Ireland needs to tackle ‘stark gap' between ‘rhetoric and reality' of children's rights, says child protection rapporteur
A specialist children's legal service could contribute to closing the 'stark gap' between the 'rhetoric and reality' of children's rights here,
Ireland
's child protection rapporteur has said.
Rights should be more than 'lofty principles on paper', they must be 'practical and effective', said
Caoilfhoinn Gallagher
.
She was addressing an event in
Dublin
marking the publication of a new report by independent law centre Community Law & Mediation, which analysed the legal needs of children and young people and set out recommendations on how best to achieve those.
Several State and non-State stakeholders, including the Ombudsman for Children's Office, Legal Aid Board and Children's Rights Alliance, were among those consulted for the report.
READ MORE
It particularly prioritised consultations with children and young people who had first-hand experience of legal issues. The difficulties they highlighted included school and family problems, bullying, discrimination, stigma based on 'being from a place that everyone thinks the worst of', mental health and having supports cut off after the age of 18
The report's key recommendation is for the establishment of a specialist children's legal service here with a particular focus on the practice and promotion of child-friendly justice.
It recommends that priorities within the Child Poverty Unit of the Department of the Taoiseach and in the National Policy Framework Young Ireland should be reviewed to ensure commitments in relation to children's rights include an access to justice component.
In her address, Ms Gallagher said former taoiseach Leo Varadkar had said he wanted Ireland to be the best country in Europe to be a child and the government's 2019 children and youth policy was aimed at improving outcomes for children and young people.
That 'ambitious vision' is to be welcomed, she said, adding that she acknowledged and supported many key steps taken in recent years to improve systems, frameworks and outcomes for children.
However, she said there remain 'significant and persistent and grave' concerns about child protection and the realisation of child rights in several areas.
The aspiration to make Ireland the best place in the world to be a child was likely 'to ring hollow' for many, including the family of teenager Daniel McAnaspie, who was in the care of the State when he was stabbed to death in 2010.
An inquest jury last month found he was unlawfully killed and his family have called for a State apology for systemic failures in his care.
It was, she suspected, also likely to ring hollow for High Court judge John Jordan who presides weekly over the secure care list and recently described the continual failure of Tusla to provide enough beds for at risk children as 'an affront to the rule of law'.
The United Nations Committee on the Rights of the Child had in 2023 set out six areas where Ireland should take 'urgent' steps, including non-discrimination, violence against children and mental health, she noted.
The CLM report is a 'vital' contribution to the important discussion about the gap between rhetoric and reality and how to close that gap, she said.
Law professor and child rights expert Conor O'Mahony said litigation has limits and is not normally the place where people want to start when it comes to children's rights but it is 'sometimes the only way to get things done'.
He said the 2012 'quite timid' children's rights amendment to the Constitution created a charter under which the courts might do 'interesting things' in relation to children's rights but the courts had 'not really embraced that licence' in the years since.
Nothing in the Constitution states that the separation of powers between the legislature and the judiciary is more important than the rights of children but the courts have tended to prioritise the former over the latter, he said.
Hashtags
Try Our AI Features
Explore what Daily8 AI can do for you:
Comments
No comments yet...
Related Articles
Irish Times
an hour ago
- Irish Times
‘A roof over your head is seen as a luxury': Hundreds attend housing protest outside Dáil
Hundreds of people gathered outside the Dáil this evening as part of a demonstration urging the Government to take 'urgent action' to address the housing crisis . Sínead Scully and Luke Murphy attended the Raise the Roof protest as they feel locked out of the housing market. Nearing their 30s, the couple moved in with Mr Murphy's parents after two and half years renting in order to save for a mortgage deposit. With a master's degree and a PhD between them, Mr Murphy said they have another year or two of 'hard saving' before they can move out. 'We're both in very secure jobs and we're in a position to save but we're still not able to afford property in Dublin,' Ms Scully said. READ MORE They don't believe the Government is advocating on their behalf. 'I think they think they're doing a good job, but clearly they aren't,' Ms Scully said, adding that programmes such as the Help To Buy scheme don't have the intended effect when property prices are so high. 'I think it's years and years of successive Fianna Fáil and Fine Gael governments … applying bandaid solutions to long term problems," Mr Murphy said. Protestors at The Raise the Roof rally outside Leinster House. Photograph: Alan Betson / The Irish Times Mother and son Ger Nolan and Evan Sheridan have always regarded housing as a pressing issue for the younger generation. 'It wasn't a worry I had at 16 or 18, but that's the reality nowadays,' Ms Nolan said. 'Housing is where everything stems from. You need people to run services in the country and if they can't afford to pay rent in Dublin, the city doesn't function any more,' she added. Mr Sheridan said 'housing is a basic human right, it's crazy how something as basic as a roof over your head is either too expensive or is seen as a luxury, and for many young people is a luxury'. He believes the Government is making housing out 'to be a lot more complicated than it actually is', citing the €14 billion windfall tax from Apple last year as a reason why 'funding is not an issue'. Photograph: Alan Betson/The Irish Times Bernard Joyce, a representative of the Irish Traveller Movement, said 'it's really important that we're all here together today'. Mr Joye said Irish Traveller women and children are disproportionately homeless, and called for 'culturally appropriate accommodation which meets their community's needs'. Among the speakers were Sinn Féin leader Mary Lou McDonald, Labour leader Ivana Bacik, Rory Hearne of the Social Democrats and People Before Profit's Paul Murphy. There was a considerable presence of their supporters at the demonstration. The speakers often emphasised what they see as the interconnected nature of social issues such as the housing crisis, economic inequality, and discrimination against migrants. The demonstration was organised by Raise the Roof, a broad coalition of trade unions, advocacy groups, NGOs, political parties and homelessness agencies. It coincided with a Bill in the Dáil tabled by Sinn Féin, Labour, the Social Democrats, People Before Profit-Solidarity and the Green Party, as well as some left-wing independent TDs. The Bill seeks to implement freezes and caps on rent prices, reintroduce a ban on no-fault evictions, and increase taxes on vacant and/or derelict properties and funding for homelessness agencies.
Irish Times
3 hours ago
- Irish Times
Syrian refugees say they are homeless after resettlement flights to Ireland from Lebanon cancelled
Syrian refugees due to fly to Ireland from Lebanon this week under a resettlement scheme say they have been left homeless and terrified after their flights were cancelled due to the Israel-Iran attacks. 'This flight was like a lottery ticket for us in order to start a new life,' said Delivan Hassan Mohammed (37), who was due to leave on Thursday with her husband and 14-year-old daughter. She said they were given the travel information one month ago under a resettlement scheme that has already been beset by lengthy delays. 'We were looking forward to leaving but we were disappointed. I already left my house, left my job, sold everything,' she said. READ MORE 'All we want to know is a date so we can plan our life and put things in motion so we can survive until we can be taken outside this country.' Another man, who did not want to be named, said everyone started crying when they were informed about the cancellation. He was due to travel with his children and wife. 'Everything we owned, we sold it. We bought clothes for travelling and now we're left without money, without jobs, without a home ... We gave up everything because of the journey,' he said. His wife said her daughters were terrified by bombings during the Israeli bombardment of Lebanon last year. 'They don't want to be in Lebanon or Syria; they feel unsafe in all of them. They had the hope of leaving this area. They wanted to escape and today was their last glimpse of hope,' she said. Like others, she is terrified that the war between Israel and Iran will spread. Missiles have been visible in the night sky from Lebanon since last Friday, when the Israeli attacks on Iran began and Iran started retaliating. 'We want to leave as soon as possible. We feel like nobody is helping us,' the woman said. The Department of Justice, which is responsible for the refugee resettlement programme, did not respond to a request for comment. Neither did the International Organisation for Migration, which organises the travel. The Irish Times understands that 26 Syrians were due to travel on Thursday. About 375 Syrian refugees were chosen for resettlement following an Irish delegation's visit to Lebanon in November 2022, including 185 who were under the age of 18 at the time. They were given a document saying they could expect to travel by the end of 2023, but many are now waiting more than 2½ years. 'It is a very difficult situation,' said Rudy Haider Sharaf, who still has no idea when he will travel with his wife and three children. 'I am afraid of war. My children are very afraid.' The family were displaced by bombing in Lebanon last year. Despite a ceasefire last November, Israel continues to carry out regular air strikes in south Lebanon where they live. Another Syrian woman, who is also waiting to travel with her family, said they were 'living in fear and disappointment with the ongoing delays and postponements as we wait for our flight to Ireland to be scheduled. 'Life has come to a complete standstill for us,' she said. One three-year-old girl, who was among those waiting, died last year. Her father – who lived for a long time in a tent in northern Lebanon with his wife and children – said he believes she might have survived if she had access to proper medical care. 'I made every effort to treat her or travel with her to your country, but death was faster,' said Zuhair Al-Ashqar, who has since reached Ireland with his wife and young son.
Irish Times
4 hours ago
- Irish Times
Ireland needs to tackle ‘stark gap' between ‘rhetoric and reality' of children's rights, says child protection rapporteur
A specialist children's legal service could contribute to closing the 'stark gap' between the 'rhetoric and reality' of children's rights here, Ireland 's child protection rapporteur has said. Rights should be more than 'lofty principles on paper', they must be 'practical and effective', said Caoilfhoinn Gallagher . She was addressing an event in Dublin marking the publication of a new report by independent law centre Community Law & Mediation, which analysed the legal needs of children and young people and set out recommendations on how best to achieve those. Several State and non-State stakeholders, including the Ombudsman for Children's Office, Legal Aid Board and Children's Rights Alliance, were among those consulted for the report. READ MORE It particularly prioritised consultations with children and young people who had first-hand experience of legal issues. The difficulties they highlighted included school and family problems, bullying, discrimination, stigma based on 'being from a place that everyone thinks the worst of', mental health and having supports cut off after the age of 18 The report's key recommendation is for the establishment of a specialist children's legal service here with a particular focus on the practice and promotion of child-friendly justice. It recommends that priorities within the Child Poverty Unit of the Department of the Taoiseach and in the National Policy Framework Young Ireland should be reviewed to ensure commitments in relation to children's rights include an access to justice component. In her address, Ms Gallagher said former taoiseach Leo Varadkar had said he wanted Ireland to be the best country in Europe to be a child and the government's 2019 children and youth policy was aimed at improving outcomes for children and young people. That 'ambitious vision' is to be welcomed, she said, adding that she acknowledged and supported many key steps taken in recent years to improve systems, frameworks and outcomes for children. However, she said there remain 'significant and persistent and grave' concerns about child protection and the realisation of child rights in several areas. The aspiration to make Ireland the best place in the world to be a child was likely 'to ring hollow' for many, including the family of teenager Daniel McAnaspie, who was in the care of the State when he was stabbed to death in 2010. An inquest jury last month found he was unlawfully killed and his family have called for a State apology for systemic failures in his care. It was, she suspected, also likely to ring hollow for High Court judge John Jordan who presides weekly over the secure care list and recently described the continual failure of Tusla to provide enough beds for at risk children as 'an affront to the rule of law'. The United Nations Committee on the Rights of the Child had in 2023 set out six areas where Ireland should take 'urgent' steps, including non-discrimination, violence against children and mental health, she noted. The CLM report is a 'vital' contribution to the important discussion about the gap between rhetoric and reality and how to close that gap, she said. Law professor and child rights expert Conor O'Mahony said litigation has limits and is not normally the place where people want to start when it comes to children's rights but it is 'sometimes the only way to get things done'. He said the 2012 'quite timid' children's rights amendment to the Constitution created a charter under which the courts might do 'interesting things' in relation to children's rights but the courts had 'not really embraced that licence' in the years since. Nothing in the Constitution states that the separation of powers between the legislature and the judiciary is more important than the rights of children but the courts have tended to prioritise the former over the latter, he said.
