
Ban fair enough: bar owner
A Dunedin bar owner has admitted helping patrons glug "excessive" amounts of Champagne from an ice sculpture.
Vault 21 owner Andre Shi said he could not argue with the Alcohol Regulatory and Licensing Authority's decision to temporarily suspend the bar's licence, but the skulling caught on video at a sponsored event was unplanned.
The suspension of the Octagon bar and restaurant's on-licence was called for by the Dunedin City Council, a decision issued by the authority said.
Judge Robert Spear said it was alleged alcohol was promoted irresponsibly which probably encouraged people to consume it "to an excessive extent".
In November last year, as part of a sponsored Moet et Chandon event, a large ice sculpture of a "hollow oversized Champagne wine bottle" was set up on the footpath outside Vault 21.
Staff allowed alcohol to be poured freely through the vessel and was drunk by people "crouched down below the mouth of the ice sculpture", Judge Spear said.
"Three videos extracted from Facebook show that this large ice sculpture was in full view of the passing public which, of course, this being the Octagon is at the very centre of Dunedin city."
One video showed a woman "drinking directly from the ice sculpture until she could obviously drink no more".
"This was, without question, an act at a high level of irresponsibility in relation to the promotion of alcohol."
Vault 21's liquor licence was suspended for 72 hours, from 8am today until 8am Saturday, and a negative holding recorded against the licensee company, AND Hospitality Group Ltd.
If the company received a total of three negative holdings within three years, an application would be made for the cancellation of its on-licence.
Mr Shi told the Otago Daily Times yesterday, while the 72-hour suspension was "a little bit heavy", he respected the authority's decision and was "taking it on the chin".
The ice sculpture was planned for only the beginning of the event to chill drinks as they were poured into Champagne flutes.
But "some punters" had attempted to drink from the sculpture directly, after it was moved outside to be a decoration while patrons had lunch.
Mr Shi confirmed he had poured the Champagne down the sculpture and said he wanted to make sure it was controlled.
It "wasn't planned", he said. "I helped them to do it. The punter was trying to do it themselves."
But the authority deemed the amount he had poured, as captured on video, was "excessive", Mr Shi said.
"That's a decision that I can't argue with."
Two videos posted by media personality William Waiirua depicting women drinking from the sculpture had since racked up 49.3 million and 53.1 million views on social media.
People attending the event included Dunedin Mayor Jules Radich and city councillors.
A "third party" had laid a complaint after footage of the event circulated online, Mr Shi said.
Judge Spear said the initial explanation was the promotion only involved Champagne being poured down the ice sculpture into a glass, limiting the amount available for consumption.
"However, the Facebook video posts were subsequently found that showed that the promotion was far more extreme."
tim.scott@odt.co.nz

Try Our AI Features
Explore what Daily8 AI can do for you:
Comments
No comments yet...
Related Articles


Scoop
8 hours ago
- Scoop
ComCom Prosecutes Unregistered Lender Who Targeted Vulnerable Consumers
Press Release – Commerce Commission The Commission has prioritised enforcement action against lenders who have not met their obligations under the CCCFA. The Commission is particularly focussed on lenders who provide credit to vulnerable consumers in New Zealand. The Commerce Commission has filed criminal charges in the Auckland District Court against an unregistered and uncertified lender, Ilaisaane Malupo, trading as Nane Easy Loan Finance Services NZ (Nane Loans). The Commission alleges Ms Malupo provided personal loans illegally to members of the Tongan community in South Auckland from March 2024. Associate Commissioner Joseph Liava'a says when lenders are identified operating outside of the law, the Commission will act swiftly to shutdown these operations to ensure that consumers are protected when borrowing money or buying goods on credit. Under the Financial Service Providers (Registration and Dispute Resolution) Act and the Credit Contracts and Consumer Finance Act (CCCFA), all lenders must be registered and certified in order to provide consumer credit. 'Often these kinds of lenders are a last resort for people who are struggling to borrow from reputable lenders. Many people who borrowed from Ms Malupo were already under financial pressure and on low incomes, so irresponsible lending could have had a big impact on borrowers and their families,' Mr Liava'a says. 'Some of the borrowers indicated they needed to borrow money to buy food or pay off other loans,' Mr Liava'a says. Alongside the lack of certification, the Commission alleges Ms Malupo's terms included high interest rates of up to 15 per cent charged on a weekly basis, which would double if borrowers failed to repay the loans within 28 days; and late payment fees of up to $10 per day. 'In order to keep up with payments some borrowers resorted to selling their sentimental possessions or missing rent payments,' Mr Liava'a says. Ms Malupo operated her business on social media and in some cases threatened that borrowers who failed to repay their debt would be 'named and shamed' on Facebook or other Tongan media sites until repayment was made. 'Public shaming is never ok and could put borrowers in a vulnerable position to avoid being called out for their friends and family to see,' Mr Liava'a says. The Commission has prioritised enforcement action against lenders who have not met their obligations under the CCCFA. The Commission is particularly focussed on lenders who provide credit to vulnerable consumers in New Zealand. Background The Commission launched an investigation into Ilaisaane Malupo after receiving enquiries, including from a financial mentor about Ms Malupo's lending practices which were causing harm to borrowers. Whilst the Commission is continuing its investigation into further breaches of the CCCFA which are likely to have occurred, the Commission's immediate priority was to stop Ms Malupo from entering new loans or enforcing any existing loans. Ms Malupo has been charged (4 June 2025) with: Criminal charges under section 11 of the Financial Service Providers (Registration and Dispute Resolution) Act 2008 for providing a financial service without being registered, the penalty of which is 12 months' imprisonment or a fine not exceeding $100,000; and Criminal charges under section 103(2) of the Commerce Act 1986 for attempting to deceive or knowingly mislead the Commission on any matter before it, the penalty of which is a fine not exceeding $100,000. All lenders must be certified under Part 5A of the Credit Contracts and Consumer Finance Act 2003 by the Commerce Commission. To gain certification, lenders must satisfy the Commission that those operating the business are financially sound, honest, reputable, reliable and competent to do the job.

1News
8 hours ago
- 1News
Auckland lender charged for allegedly providing illegal personal loans
An unregistered and uncertified lender has been charged after allegedly providing personal loans illegally to members of the Tongan community in South Auckland. Ilaisaane Malupo, trading as Nane Easy Loan Finance Services NZ (Nane Loans), provided loans to borrowers in South Auckland from March 2024. An investigation was launched by the commission after receiving inquiries, including from a financial mentor, about Malupo's lending practices which were allegedly causing harm to borrowers. The Commerce Commission alleges Malupo's terms including high interest rates of up to 15% charged on a weekly basis, which would double if borrowers failed to repay the loans within 28 days; and late payment fees of up to $10 per day. All lenders must be registered and certified to provide consumer credit. ADVERTISEMENT 'Often these kinds of lenders are a last resort for people who are struggling to borrow from reputable lenders," Associate Commissioner Joseph Liava'a said. "Many people who borrowed from Ms Malupo were already under financial pressure and on low incomes, so irresponsible lending could have had a big impact on borrowers and their families. 'Some of the borrowers indicated they needed to borrow money to buy food or pay off other loans.' Liava'a said some borrowers 'resorted to selling their sentimental possessions or missing rent payments' to pay off the loans. In some cases, the commission alleged Malupo – who operated her business on social media – threatened to 'name and shame' borrowers who failed to repay their debt on Facebook or Tongan media sites until repayment was made. 'Public shaming is never OK and could put borrowers in a vulnerable position to avoid being called out for their friends and family to see,' Liava'a said. The commission has filed criminal charges in the Auckland District Court. ADVERTISEMENT She has been charged with providing a financial service without being registered and for attempting to deceive or knowingly mislead the Commission on any matter before it.


Scoop
9 hours ago
- Scoop
ComCom Prosecutes Unregistered Lender Who Targeted Vulnerable Consumers
Press Release – Commerce Commission The Commission has prioritised enforcement action against lenders who have not met their obligations under the CCCFA. The Commission is particularly focussed on lenders who provide credit to vulnerable consumers in New Zealand. The Commerce Commission has filed criminal charges in the Auckland District Court against an unregistered and uncertified lender, Ilaisaane Malupo, trading as Nane Easy Loan Finance Services NZ (Nane Loans). The Commission alleges Ms Malupo provided personal loans illegally to members of the Tongan community in South Auckland from March 2024. Associate Commissioner Joseph Liava'a says when lenders are identified operating outside of the law, the Commission will act swiftly to shutdown these operations to ensure that consumers are protected when borrowing money or buying goods on credit. Under the Financial Service Providers (Registration and Dispute Resolution) Act and the Credit Contracts and Consumer Finance Act (CCCFA), all lenders must be registered and certified in order to provide consumer credit. 'Often these kinds of lenders are a last resort for people who are struggling to borrow from reputable lenders. Many people who borrowed from Ms Malupo were already under financial pressure and on low incomes, so irresponsible lending could have had a big impact on borrowers and their families,' Mr Liava'a says. 'Some of the borrowers indicated they needed to borrow money to buy food or pay off other loans,' Mr Liava'a says. Alongside the lack of certification, the Commission alleges Ms Malupo's terms included high interest rates of up to 15 per cent charged on a weekly basis, which would double if borrowers failed to repay the loans within 28 days; and late payment fees of up to $10 per day. 'In order to keep up with payments some borrowers resorted to selling their sentimental possessions or missing rent payments,' Mr Liava'a says. Ms Malupo operated her business on social media and in some cases threatened that borrowers who failed to repay their debt would be 'named and shamed' on Facebook or other Tongan media sites until repayment was made. 'Public shaming is never ok and could put borrowers in a vulnerable position to avoid being called out for their friends and family to see,' Mr Liava'a says. The Commission has prioritised enforcement action against lenders who have not met their obligations under the CCCFA. The Commission is particularly focussed on lenders who provide credit to vulnerable consumers in New Zealand. Background The Commission launched an investigation into Ilaisaane Malupo after receiving enquiries, including from a financial mentor about Ms Malupo's lending practices which were causing harm to borrowers. Whilst the Commission is continuing its investigation into further breaches of the CCCFA which are likely to have occurred, the Commission's immediate priority was to stop Ms Malupo from entering new loans or enforcing any existing loans. Ms Malupo has been charged (4 June 2025) with: Criminal charges under section 11 of the Financial Service Providers (Registration and Dispute Resolution) Act 2008 for providing a financial service without being registered, the penalty of which is 12 months' imprisonment or a fine not exceeding $100,000; and Criminal charges under section 103(2) of the Commerce Act 1986 for attempting to deceive or knowingly mislead the Commission on any matter before it, the penalty of which is a fine not exceeding $100,000. All lenders must be certified under Part 5A of the Credit Contracts and Consumer Finance Act 2003 by the Commerce Commission. To gain certification, lenders must satisfy the Commission that those operating the business are financially sound, honest, reputable, reliable and competent to do the job.