Samsung wins interim licence in UK patent fight with ZTE
Samsung
Electronics on Wednesday won a ruling from London's High Court in its attempt to get an interim licence to use
ZTE
's patents, in the English leg of the firms' global licensing dispute over
mobile phone patents
.
English courts have recently permitted parties to pursue short-term patent licences pending trial, including in Amazon's dispute with Nokia and Lenovo's battle with Ericsson, before both ultimately settled.
Wednesday's ruling, though, is the first time in England that a court of first instance - the initial court where a case is heard - has made such an interim licence declaration.
Disputes over the fair, reasonable, and non-discriminatory (FRAND) terms of a patent licence have frequently led to global legal battles in the telecom industry.
English courts can set global FRAND terms, following a landmark 2020 UK Supreme Court ruling, as can courts in China.
Samsung sued ZTE in London in December 2024 seeking a determination of FRAND terms, with ZTE bringing parallel lawsuits against Samsung in China, Germany and Brazil.
In London, Samsung sought a declaration that a willing licensor in ZTE's position would agree to an interim licence until FRAND terms were decided by the court.
Both Samsung and ZTE had made competing offers for an interim licence, with ZTE's licence requiring FRAND terms to be those determined by a court in China.
London's High Court ruled in Samsung's favour on Wednesday, with Judge James Mellor saying that "ZTE have acted in bad faith with their wave of unnecessary injunctive proceedings".
The judge added that "ZTE's terms are designed to render this action (in London) pointless, so that Samsung effectively has to abandon it" in favour of accepting the outcome of ZTE's lawsuit in Chongqing in southwestern China.
Samsung and ZTE did not immediately respond to a request for comment.
Try Our AI Features
Explore what Daily8 AI can do for you:
Comments
No comments yet...
Related Articles
&w=3840&q=100)
Business Standard
an hour ago
- Business Standard
Ease of doing biz, lower costs to aid Raj's growth: Rathore at BS Samriddhi
Rajasthan's journey towards becoming a ₹30 trillion economy in the next three and a half years will be guided by the twin principles of ease of doing business and lowering the cost of doing business, said Col (retd) Rajyavardhan Rathore, the state's industry & commerce minister, in a fireside chat at the Business Standard Samriddhi event on Wednesday. Rathore, who earlier launched Business Standard 's Jaipur edition in Hindi and English at the event here, said that for ease of doing business the state had announced nine policies in key sectors. These include policies on export promotion, logistics, apparel, cluster development, One District One Product (ODOP), data centres, and a forthcoming policy on artificial intelligence. With the launch of the Jaipur edition, Business Standard is now published simultaneously across 14 cities in English and seven in Hindi. The minister, who holds five portfolios, including information technology & communications, and skill development & entrepreneurship, said that as part of its effort to reduce the cost of doing business, the state government had adopted a policy of direct land allotment instead of the previous system of auction. The fixing of price for such land, he said, was carried out transparently by a committee that determines rates based on factors like the plot's distance from a city. 'Ink an MoU (memorandum of understanding), go to the Riico (Rajasthan State Industrial Development & Investment Corporation) website, pick a plot, and we will allot it to you. The website has details of available plots in all the 419 Riico industrial parks,' he said. Rathore also spoke of the government's vision to build a land bank and an IT city near Delhi, on the lines of IT cities in Hyderabad and Bengaluru. He lauded Prime Minister Narendra Modi's vision to ink free-trade agreements with different countries, and said the PM believes that India's market is its strength, while the previous government thought of it as its weakness. 'I would point to the India-EFTA (European Free Trade Association) trade pact. Under the free-trade agreement, for the first time, there is a binding commitment on the European nations to not only transfer to us technology but invest $100 billion. Similarly, we have an energy treaty with the United Arab Emirates and a trade pact with Singapore. The national government has created an environment of development within India,' Rathore said. On how Rajasthan is pulling investments, Rathore said in the Rising Rajasthan Summit, the state had not merely inked MoUs, but was handholding businesses as well. 'We are hiring consultants so that all the file movement is not done by entrepreneurs but by the government of Rajasthan. It is literally like a door-to-door service,' he said. The minister said that the state was pursuing the PM's mantra of reform, perform, and transform to the hilt. 'We are reforming, our government is performing and we are transforming Rajasthan from a ₹15 trillion economy to a ₹30 trillion economy in the next three and a half years,' he said. The minister said Rajasthan would play a big role in the PM's call for 'swadeshi' and 'aatmanirbharta'. He pointed out that there were as many as 56 minerals found in Rajasthan, and in some, such as zinc, the state is the largest producer. 'We have plenty of land. Our industrial corridor and expressway network is good,' Rathore said, adding that Rajasthan is a goldmine of possibilities. Later, the launch event was followed by two high-intensity panel discussions, attended by leading industrialists, bureaucrats and policymakers.
&w=3840&q=100)
Business Standard
2 hours ago
- Business Standard
BS Samriddhi: Rajasthan's solar sector doesn't need incentives to grow
The sunrise solar sector in Rajasthan does not need incentives to survive and grow, on the contrary, incentives and subsidies breed bureaucratic bottlenecks and delay execution, said panelists at a panel discussion on 'Energy: The Surging Renewables Sector'. The discussion was held as part of Business Standard Samriddhi-Rajasthan 2025. Business Standard launched its 14th English and 7th Hindi edition from Jaipur on Wednesday. The panel discussion was attended by Sunil Bansal, president of Rajasthan Solar Association; its CEO Nitin Agarwal; and Rahul Gupta, founder managing director and chief executive officer (MD&CEO) of Rays Power Experts Ltd. 'The structure of the incentives and their disbursement also need to be transparent, quick, and smooth,' Bansal said. He said that today Rajasthan has become a preferred destination for solar projects, and is now known as the 'Solar capital of India'. 'But beyond the hype, we should also understand that the full potential of the sector is not being harnessed to the hilt,' he added. This is because though Rajasthan is leading in terms of production of solar energy at 32 Gw, yet when it comes to manufacturing of equipment that go into making a solar project, it lags far behind states like Gujarat. 'Rajasthan today has just two major solar equipment manufacturing companies while Surat has more than 50. When Rajasthan had just one, Surat too had one unit. So, in short, other states have come a long way when it comes to setting up a base for solar equipment manufacturing but we in Rajasthan are lagging in this,' Bansal said. Gupta said that the reason why manufacturing for the solar sector has not picked up in Rajasthan in the same way as it has done in Gujarat is that the state started open access way back in 2012-13 while in Rajasthan it was started in 2017 onwards. 'Overall, the industrial scenario in Gujarat was ahead of Rajasthan by five-seven years, and their producers were able to price the power themselves which is now starting in Rajasthan,' Gupta said. He said though solar equipment manufacturing in Rajasthan has been lower than states such as Gujarat, yet it is picking up in sectors such as battery storage. With power prices going down in the state, a lot of investment will come in manufacturing as well, he added. Agarwal said India has a total solar target of 500 Gw by 2030, of which Rajasthan's share is 125 Gw (that is around 25 per cent). The state at present has installed solar capacity of 38 Gw, which means that by 2030, this installed capacity needs to be tripled. All the 125 Gw solar projects to come on stream would mean a cumulative investment of almost ₹5 trillion in the state, he added. Agarwal said of the ₹30 trillion of investments signed in recent 'Investors Meet' in the state, almost ₹28 trillion has come in the renewables sector alone. 'Rajasthan alone has the potential to generate 300 Gw of solar energy. This potential is huge and it needs to be tapped fully,' Agarwal said. He said battery storage is challenging for the solar sector but here too Rajasthan is leading the way, with the central government allocating 10,000 Mw of battery storage capacity, which is the highest in the country. Of the 10,000 Mw, tenders have been floated for 2,000 Mw. Bansal said that tariff is a big issue in the solar sector. The government needs to understand tariff fixation has to be transparent and industry-friendly. It should not think of recovering its incidental costs through tariffs. Gupta said that from the producers' side, tariffs are not a problem, and due to certainty in policy, disputes between distribution companies (discoms) and power producers have come down. Agarwal said that one big factor that stops the growth of the household solar sector is that 'we give lots of free power to consumers' but don't want to incentivise the sector. 'We conducted a study and found that Rajasthan has 11 million power connections, of which almost 8 million pay zero bill. This needs to stop. We can use the money saved through this for incentivising solar power, which is clean and green as well,' he said.
&w=3840&q=100)
Business Standard
2 hours ago
- Business Standard
Mission ₹30 trillion: Push for startups, thrust on AI, EVs need of the hour
Rajasthan's main attraction for investors is not the incentives that it gives, nor the infrastructure it has built but the peace, harmony and relationship it provides to them, said Subodh Agarwal, chairman and managing director of Rajasthan Financial Corporation. He added that each one of Rajasthan's Investment Promotion Scheme is an improvement over the other starting from Rajasthan Investment Promotion Scheme (RIPS) 2014 but what is more important is that people come to Rajasthan for investment for the value system it provides. The panel discussion was held as part of Business Standard Samriddhi-Rajasthan 2025. Business Standard launched its 14th English and 7th Hindi edition from Jaipur on Thursday. Business Standard's Ashok Kumar Bhattacharya moderated the panel discussion. Ajay Data, managing director of Data Group of Industries, and Digvijay Dhabriya, chairman of PHDCCI (Rajasthan chapter), were other panelists in the discussion. 'Rajasthan is growing with every step and one of its main strengths is its natural resources,' Agarwal said. Data said the state needs to move more aggressively in promoting startups and foster innovation. 'For Rajasthan to become a ₹30 trillion economy over the next three years from almost ₹15 trillion, it has to move towards setting up more startups,' Data said. He said presently, the state has around 5,000 startups, which is just 5 per cent of the total startups in the country. This needs to scale up to at least 100,000 over the next three years. 'One startup employs a minimum of 15 people, which means that once 100,000 start-ups come into operation, it will create around 1.5 million new jobs for the youths of the state,' Data said. He said there are few more areas where the Rajasthan government should immediately focus on a part of the startup ecosystem. These are attracting top technological talent in artificial intelligence (AI) and in electric vehicles (EVs). 'We need to aggressively look into these sectors to become big and leading players in all over the country,' Data said. He said the state also needs to remove the friction that occurs at all levels or else it creates hurdles in growth. Digvijay Dhabriya, chairman of PHDCCI (Rajasthan chapter) said that Rajasthan needs to focus more on ease of doing business and reducing the cost of doing business. He said for ease of doing business, the state needs to reduce the cost of land acquisition. On whether the new system of land acquisition launched by the state government of fixed price payment and offering land from a pool is a more viable method than the previous system of auctioning of land, Dhabriya said both the systems have their pluses and minuses. 'To me, the best method is the China model where the industry gets the opportunity to purchase land and then change its usage as per its needs,' Dhabriya said. He said whether the present system of land acquisition developed by the state is fruitful or not will be known once industries, which have entered into pacts with the state government, get their land. Dhabriya also said the state needs to develop more satellite townships on the lines of Gurugram. 'Rajasthan has lots of opportunities but several challenges as well which need to be ironed out,' Dhabriya said.
