Blanket bans on smartphones are not the answer
nearly half of young people 'feel low' at least weekly
. Invariably, any discussion on young people's mental health moves quickly to smartphones and social media, and the conclusion that the digital lives of young people are linked to a decline in their happiness. But we may be too quick to jump to conclusions on this.
In truth, the evidence is limited. Links between the digital lives of children and adolescents and their mental wellbeing are often based on correlative data with few longitudinal or experimental studies. Studies don't always clearly separate how different types of smartphone or social media use affect young people, and they often don't distinguish between using a phone for learning versus mindlessly scrolling.
There are likely positive and negative aspects to online activities, but sweeping conclusions and reactionary policies ignore this important nuance.
A lot of the commentary around smartphone use in young people frames it as a post-pandemic problem, with increased screen time and online distractions seen as linked to lockdown-induced dependency. But this ignores digital educational policies established well before the pandemic, which encouraged the use of student-owned devices, particularly to support classroom learning.
READ MORE
Policy guidance laid important groundwork for the informal incorporation of smartphones into educational settings, particularly in schools where resources are tight and there isn't always access to 1:1 laptop or tablet schemes. Implementation often relied on devices students already owned – in most cases, this meant a smartphone. The increasing presence of smartphones in schools is less a byproduct of the pandemic and more a foreseeable consequence of earlier policy directions that were often reactive and technologically permissive.
Media coverage of smartphone use in recent years has focused on, and often celebrated, more restrictive responses. Sweden, for example, has moved towards banning smartphones in primary classrooms, aligning with broader efforts to refocus on traditional forms of learning.
Minister for Education Helen McEntee recently issued circulars requiring schools to implement a policy to restrict the use of, and access to, personal mobile phones by students for the duration of the school day at post primary level and a full ban at primary level.
In 2024, the Australian government passed a new law which introduces a mandatory minimum age of 16 for accounts on some social media platforms. Controversially, parents cannot give their consent to under-16s to use these platforms, marking a new departure in terms of parents' rights.
At a surface level, such actions offer clear, decisive action in the face of complex technological challenges, and resonate with public anxieties about youth wellbeing. But they're fraught with practical, human rights and ethical implications. Age verification systems can be circumvented and bans also risk pushing young users on to less-regulated platforms or creating generational disconnects in digital literacy.
Blanket bans on smartphones, social media access and other digital activities overlook both the complexity of the issues and the realities of young people's lives. Restrictive policies and a one-size-fits-all approach may inadvertently exacerbate inequalities.
Mobile devices and social media can serve as essential tools for safety, communication and family co-ordination, especially for older adolescents needing greater independence.
Digital tools such as the language-learning app Duolingo, interactive Stem app Brilliant and online chess have opened up access to educational and enrichment opportunities that were once limited to wealthier families. These tools can give children from lower-income households a chance to learn languages, engage in advanced problem-solving, and develop critical-thinking skills.
While regulatory efforts may form part of a broader digital policy toolkit, bans alone are a blunt instrument and probably ineffective. They do little to address the underlying needs that drive youth engagement with smartphones; the human desire for social connection, access to information and autonomy.
So what can we do? A more effective response must be holistic: combining regulation with education, digital literacy and the co-creation of safe digital spaces that support both protection and participation.
Collective action and voluntary agreements among parents of primary schoolchildren to delay children's access to smartphones can play an important role. The 'no smartphone' initiatives seen in parts of Ireland are a promising grassroots approach to addressing concerns around digital overexposure, cyberbullying and mental health. These agreements can help to reduce peer pressure and create a more uniform standard that benefits all children.
Ideally, they should begin during primary school when habits and digital behaviours are still forming. Early implementation not only delays premature exposure to potentially harmful online environments, but also lays the groundwork for more responsible and mindful smartphone use in adolescence, supported by ongoing digital literacy education and parental involvement.
Investment in education-based initiatives, such as the Webwise programme, can empower young people and their families to navigate the digital world safely. Safer Internet Day, which is held annually in more than 180 countries, presents a valuable opportunity to promote responsible online behaviour through schools and community engagement.
Acceptable use policies, widely used across educational contexts, also present significant potential as instruments for guiding responsible smartphone and social media engagement among young people and advancing digital wellbeing. Of course we need to implement stronger regulations for the technology sector, including setting quality standards for children's content, controlling data extraction and algorithms and enforcing stricter privacy laws.
But technology is part of contemporary life, and it is continuously evolving. Simply trying to ban it won't work. Policymakers must adopt a flexible approach that maximises its benefits while safeguarding young people from potential risks.
Selina McCoy is professor in Sociology at the Economic and Social Research Institute and Ann Marcus-Quinn is associate professor in Technical Communication at the University of Limerick
Hashtags
Try Our AI Features
Explore what Daily8 AI can do for you:
Comments
No comments yet...
Related Articles
Irish Times
an hour ago
- Irish Times
‘Once somebody shares the fact they are thinking about suicide, there's a connection to life'
'Silence is the real danger in suicide,' says psychotherapist Mark Herman. It leaves people alone with their thoughts. 'In my experience, once somebody shares the fact they are thinking about suicide, there's a connection to life ... and some kind of an unburdening.' Talk therapies are generally recommended as a first-line treatment option for most people struggling with mental health . However, too many men in crisis stay silent. The male predominance among deaths by suicide is an indicator of that. According to the latest provisional figures from the Central Statistics Office , there were 351 deaths by suicide in 2024, of which 289 were male and 62 female – a rate of 10.9 per 100,000 men and 2.3 per 100,000 women. A more complete set of statistics for 2021, incorporating late registrations, records 512 deaths of people by suicide in Ireland that year, unchanged from the number recorded in 2017. Over those five years, the proportion of deaths of people by suicide for males remained broadly similar, at about eight in 10, with the highest-risk age range in 2021 being 50-54 years. READ MORE Psychotherapist Mark Herman. A €2 million investment in new counselling supports for men recently announced by the Department of Health is aimed at helping to break the silence. Championed by the Minister of State with responsibility for mental health, Mary Butler , this initiative will be accompanied by a public campaign and promotion through GPs from the start of September. She has stressed that this is 'recurring funding', for measures that include more than 15,000 free counselling sessions to men each year. However, accessibility and affordability are not the only barriers to men seeking any kind of talk therapy. Butler's reference to the importance of men's 'specific needs and preferences' being taken into account when designing tailored supports acknowledges that, and there will be efforts to reduce stigma. As the health and wellbeing manager with the Irish Men's Sheds Association ( ), Rebecca McLaughlin, says: 'I wish it were as simple as the movies 'If you build it, they will come'.' A clinical psychotherapist by training, she researched the challenges and barriers to older men engaging with counselling and therapy for her master's degree. 'Even just a few generations apart, men present with very different views and perspectives, whether it's on masculinity, the male role, gender, stigma and also engagements like therapy,' she says. Yet, consistent among men both young and old is a tendency to believe that seeking help challenges their masculine identity. Men of all ages present later and with more acute symptoms to mental health services. The gender split among those attending Herman's private psychotherapy practice in north Dublin is the opposite of the national trend, with about two-thirds of his clients being male. He suggests that men may gravitate towards a male counsellor, just as women may seek a female counsellor – in which case women will have a lot more choice. A 2018 survey by the Irish Association for Counselling and Psychotherapy showed its membership to be 78 per cent female. [ Walking football: 'Look around. The lads are buzzing before we even get out on the pitch' Opens in new window ] 'I think there is some kind of a comfort in talking to a man, in way of engagement but also in understanding of men's issues,' says Herman. Yet it often still takes a woman to get a male client in the door. She may be his mother, partner, sister or, in cases of bereavement, a daughter. 'About half of my male clients seem to arrive by some kind of 'proxy',' he explains. A woman in the client's life has encouraged him, or perhaps laid down an ultimatum, to seek help. 'Maybe some of those women have been to therapy themselves. It's good; it's a moving forward of that influencing.' The woman may be the one to engage initially with Herman, who must have contact from the man before anything is set up. Tea and biscuit time at the Irish Men's Sheds Association 'I need to hear what he's looking for, and I need to make sure he's there of his own free will.' However, Herman can identify personally with this female nudging towards talk therapy. 'My wife, Maria, encouraged me to consider counselling for years, before my problems finally came to a head and I couldn't sidestep them any longer. I remember being reluctant, but also knowing I probably should give it a chance. 'Just a couple of sessions', I told myself...' Sharing with somebody who is non-judgmental brings not only relief but also clarity. A skilled listener can ask questions that will help the person move themselves forward A former tech and business manager, he still finds it hard to say exactly how counselling helped him so much. 'But I think that I got on well with my counsellor Phil, was able to trust him and that we worked well together, was the main thing.' He found it such a valuable experience that he did a degree in counselling and became, as he says himself, one of those 'wounded healers' – people whose own painful experiences inspire and, arguably, better equip them to help others. 'This has been a long, vague path for me, but shows that hard times can offer us opportunities and lead to hope of fresh new things.' Hope is a lifeline that can also be buried by silence. Yet, in general, men seem less likely than women to recognise the power of saying things about inner turmoil out loud, be that with a professional, partner or friend. Sharing with somebody who is non-judgmental brings not only relief but also clarity. A skilled listener can ask questions that will help the person move themselves forward. 'It's not just talk. It's also taking small steps,' says Herman. health and wellbeing manager Rebecca McLaughlin with a member at the Irish Men's Sheds Association In the thriving, 450-plus men's sheds on this island, McLaughlin sees older men 'upturning all the traditional negative stereotypes applied to them', such as 'men are hard to reach' and 'men don't talk'. 'What we experience is actually sharing and talking about health issues and problems,' she says. But, crucially, this is done 'shoulder to shoulder' in the course of another activity, such as woodwork, gardening or some other community project. 'Each shed is run autonomously and has its own unique mix of three ingredients: people, place and purpose. Connection is the common factor – and a kettle, of course.' [ New €1m fund for men's sheds to help with heating and insurance Opens in new window ] The predominantly 60-years-plus age group drawn to the sheds grew up in a more entrenched culture of masculine silence around emotions. There is a huge leap from that to being expected to go into a room with a stranger and open up about their feeling, McLaughlin points out. In her 'wraparound' work with men's sheds to facilitate workshops and other wellbeing initiatives, she has found that even the label 'mental' health can be off-putting. Some older men have profoundly negative associations with the word, due to social, cultural and historical conditioning. To them it suggests, 'there's something wrong with you,' she says. 'You were locked away; you were sent off; it was silence.' Yet, for instance, a programme dealing with loss, devised post-Covid in conjunction with the Irish Hospice Foundation, has proved very popular. In some cases it has prompted men to come forward to look for further support, outside the walls of the sheds. 'It's like dropping a pebble in the pool. It creates a ripple effect and it opens up a dialogue.' While welcoming Butler's move to bolster men's counselling, McLaughlin says the association would like to see more research about those in need of support who do not seek help. 'Is it around expectations? Is it about not having tailored supports for them? Is it about the language? Is it about misunderstanding of the role of the therapist? It's very, very complicated to unpick.' Echoing Herman's comments, she says there also seems to be 'quite a sensitivity to the age and gender of the therapist'. However, she adds, it's only by asking men themselves will we get nearer to the answers about what would encourage them to look for mental health support. Meanwhile, the department has promised evaluation of the impact of the new funding. Direct consultation paved the way for a new mental health programme for young Travellers , which is being rolled out with €100,000 this year from the funding announced by Butler, says John O'Brien, manager of the National Traveller Mental Health Service. This service, based in Exchange House in Dublin 1, is funded through the Health Service Executive 's National Office for Suicide Prevention. Research indicates that Traveller men are seven times more likely to die by suicide than the general population. Part of the new project will be crisis-management training for Traveller adults, delivered by peers in their own community. The other part will be a six- to eight-week mental health programme for youngsters, with boys aged 15 to 18 being the key target group Last year, among a Traveller population here of about 33,000 (based on Census 2022), 'we recorded 37 possible deaths by suicide and 32 the year previous', says O'Brien, 'the youngest being 12, right the way up to a man in his 60s'. In surveying young Travellers before the pilot project, one key finding was that they had all been exposed to suicide and death. The second was a prevalent lack of hope for their future, with a widespread sense that 'people like me' don't go to college, go into apprenticeships or get jobs. 'So that's where this programme is coming in,' says O'Brien. 'We asked the young people who would they turn to if they were worried, stressed or depressed or suicidal. Overwhelmingly they responded that they would go to their own parents or their own community, their peers. Professional support in the way of doctors or GPs, teachers, youth service workers, was way down the list.' That information was fed back to the adults through focus groups. 'There was a sense of pride within the adults that the children would go to them.' But there was also 'a real sense of despair because the capacity isn't there for them to deal with those issues'. Part of the new project will be crisis-management training for Traveller adults, delivered by peers in their own community. The other part will be a six- to eight-week mental health programme for youngsters, with boys aged 15 to 18 being the key target group. The approach contrasts with the traditional way of 'middle-class, white professionals coming in to deliver projects – and I include myself in that cohort', says O'Brien. The pilot programme was co-produced between professionals and community members and then delivered by a Traveller man and settled woman. [ Mankeeping: why it's bad for women and men Opens in new window ] Stigma has been a historical factor in fewer men than women seeking counselling and psychotherapy, says Austen Donohoe, communications and digital marketing manager of MyMind ( ), which will be funded to provide 5,000 free sessions targeted at men. Currently, two-thirds of clients using this early intervention service for mild to moderate mental health challenges are female. Last year, the breakdown was 62 per cent female, 34 per cent male, with other and undisclosed at 1 per cent each. The average age for a MyMind client is 34, and the majority attend therapy for help with anxiety and stress. Many also seek assistance with other everyday issues such as self-esteem, loneliness and work/life balance. 'It is our hope that this new HSE funding will encourage more men to seek help sooner, with the mental health benefits for both them and their communities serving to help reduce stigma.' According to MyMind's mental health professionals, specialisations such as cognitive behavioural therapy work well for men by creating structure and teaching skills for managing mental wellbeing, reports Donohoe. 'Other specialisations like art therapy offer ways of communicating without relying on words alone. These approaches, and others, make therapy for men something that can be actively engaged in as a project for self-improvement.' Samaritans – – 116 123 – jo@
Irish Times
9 hours ago
- Irish Times
Heather Humphreys and Seán Kelly presidential face-off expected as Fine Gael reopens nominations
A contest between former minister Heather Humphreys and the MEP Seán Kelly to become Fine Gael 's presidential candidate became increasingly likely on Monday night after the party's executive council decided to seek fresh nominations rather than selecting a single candidate. Nominations will open on Tuesday for two weeks. Ms Humphreys is said by former colleagues to be keen to become the candidate. Ahead of the meeting, Mr Kelly said he would be 'leaning towards contesting'. The meeting was hastily convened after the sudden announcement on Thursday by party nominee Mairead McGuinness that she was dropping out of the race for health reasons . READ MORE Ms McGuinness said she made the 'very difficult decision' after a stay in hospital and would now prioritise her health. 'I do not believe that I have the strength to give the campaign my all,' she said. Her departure has left just one confirmed candidate in the contest, the left-wing Independent TD Catherine Connolly . After deliberating for little over an hour on Monday evening, Fine Gael's executive council decided it would reopen nominations until September 2nd. Ms Humphreys had ruled herself out of the race earlier this year, saying she wanted to spend more time with her family. However, party sources have said that following the vacation of the nomination by Ms McGuinness, she has expressed strong interest in representing the party in the autumn poll. Her candidacy has been strongly backed by Tánaiste and party leader Simon Harris . Sources said that when he contacted Fine Gael ministers on Friday to tell them Ms McGuinness was standing down, he voiced strong support for former Cavan-Monaghan TD Ms Humphreys, who is a long-time ally. However, South MEP Seán Kelly has also indicated his interest. He considered contesting the nomination against Ms McGuinness earlier in summer, but he ultimately decided against it. In response to queries from The Irish Times on Monday Mr Kelly said he was in 'decision mode'. In a text sent before the executive meeting, he said that, depending on the outcome, he would 'be leaning towards contesting.' A senior party figure, when asked if the outcome of the meeting would lead to a contest between Ms Humphreys and Mr Kelly, said: 'Most likely, yes.' Mr Harris was present for the full meeting. Sources said there was a clear mood among those present that there should be a contest and a hustings. The two-week period is to allow prospective candidates to win sufficient support within the party. To be nominated, a candidate needs the named support of 20 members of the parliamentary party, 25 Fine Gael councillors and five members of the executive council.
Irish Times
11 hours ago
- Irish Times
The Irish Times view on delayed hospital discharges: a perennial problem with serious consequences
The latest figures from the HSE show that there were delays in discharging 5,500 people from acute hospital care so far this year, leading to more than 85,500 lost 'bed days' in the system. In turn, this is contributing to delays in people getting through the A&E system and in particular more time spent on trolleys. And we know that, as well as causing discomfort, this also exposes the patients to higher clinical risk. What is formally called a delayed transfer of care occurs when a person is ready to leave the acute care system but remains occupying a bed. This is a perennial problem in the Irish hospital system and is part of a wider story of a growing and ageing population putting pressure on social services. This can happen for a number of reasons but generally involves older people who are waiting for an appropriate care programme at home, a bed in a step-down facility or space in a nursing home. Homelessness can be another issue. There has been some limited progress in recent years, with the 5,548 delayed patient transfers so far this year down from 6,6610 in 2023. But despite a range of action plans from successive ministers going back more than a decade, the issue remains a serious one. As well as contributing to the ongoing unacceptably high number of people on trolleys, an unnecessarily long stay in an acute ward also opens up the patient to greater risk of infection and means they are delayed getting on with their lives in a more appropriate setting. More funding for step-down facilities and home support packages will remain needed as the population ages. The lack of joined up technology in the Irish health system remains an issue. And delays in the administration of the support schemes for nursing homes - the Fair Deal scheme- and in the provision of home care packages are also factors. READ MORE Tackling delayed discharge remains a key issue for the hospital system . And it is also vital for the support and dignity of the largely older population and their families, who are seeking the best way forward after a period of hospital care.
