‘All for nothing': Hong Kong workers complain of losing jobs to imported labour
After being forced to quit, Har Cheng* went to the Hong Kong food stall she had worked at for almost two decades, only to find out she had been replaced by imported labourers from mainland China.
Advertisement
Feeling angry and mistreated, Cheng, 67, who helped wash dishes, clean tables and sell beers at the traditional dai pai dong, said her loyalty over the years had all been 'for nothing'.
'I thought I just had a few more years to work before retirement, and the stall had at least 28 workers … How could I expect I would be the first to be targeted?' Cheng said.
Over the past six months, Cheng and 200 other restaurant workers have
reported being sacked and replaced by labourers who came to the city via an import scheme, according to the Eating Establishment Employees General Union.
Unionists and human rights advocacy group the Society for Community Organisation raised concerns about the impact of the scheme ahead of Labour Day on May 1, saying they had heard and received reports from local workers who were replaced by imported labourers.
The government said in 2023 that authorities would ensure city jobseekers were given priority in employment. Photo: Jelly Tse
To combat the city's manpower shortage, the government in September 2023 allowed employers to bring in unlimited unskilled or low-skilled workers from the mainland for 26 new job types, including waiters, junior chefs, and hospitality and sales staff in catering.
Hashtags
Try Our AI Features
Explore what Daily8 AI can do for you:
Comments
No comments yet...
Related Articles
RTHK
2 days ago
- RTHK
'All MPF schemes to be onboarded to eMPF this year'
'All MPF schemes to be onboarded to eMPF this year' The managing director of the MPFA Cheng Yan-chee says the platform is expected to save administration costs of up to HK$40 billion over 10 years. Photo: RTHK The managing director of the Mandatory Provident Fund Schemes Authority (MPFA), Cheng Yan-chee, on Saturday said the authority aims to transfer all MPF accounts to the eMPF Platform within this year. The one-stop platform, which came into operation in June last year, aims to streamline and automate the administrative work of MPF schemes. Speaking on a radio programme, Cheng said the authority is undergoing the second phase of onboarding schemes to the platform, and all MPF accounts can be viewed on the site within this year. "We had our first phase of onboarding from June to October last year, involving small-scale trustees. They have fewer employee and employer accounts. They account for two percent of the total number of accounts in the city," he said. "The second phase is from March to August, dealing with midsize trustees who have more accounts. After this phase, one-fourth of all accounts will be onboarded to the platform." The director said he expects the platform to help reduce administration costs and save up to HK$40 billion in the coming 10 years. Meanwhile, Cheng said the authority is reviewing the maximum and minimum levels of MPF contributions, considering factors such as the socioeconomic situation and income distribution, and will hand in a report to the government next year.
HKFP
22-05-2025
- HKFP
Hong Kong press union says gov't made ‘mistakes,' ‘unreasonable claims' in independent news sector tax audits
The Hong Kong Journalists Association (HKJA) has said that the government's tax authority made errors and 'strange, unreasonable claims' when auditing independent media outlets and issuing additional demands. 'We've noticed that the Inland Revenue Department (IRD) made numerous mistakes while reviewing the tax [records of media outlets and reporters],' Selina Cheng, the chairperson of the union, said in Cantonese on Wednesday. facing simultaneous tax audits and backdated demands. At least six independent outlets and 20 individuals, including the heads of media outlets and their spouses, have received notification of audits and additional tax demands since November 2023, Cheng said. The outlets include InMedia,The Witness, ReNews, Boomhead, HKFP, and one that did not wish to be named. The financial years being probed span the full six or seven years allowable under the IRD's remit. Those inspected usually receive a notice of assessment of additional tax first, the press union chief said. Then, they are requested to pay a provisional tax demand before the investigation into any alleged underpayment is complete. Cheng said an individual who did not run any companies received a notice from the IRD with a company Business Registration (BR) number, and was asked to pay tax for the firm. The union searched the number and found that it did not exist. 'That journalist was asked to pay profits tax even though they didn't conduct any business,' she alleged. Another media outlet had its tax audited for a financial year before the company was even established, Cheng added. 'We noted that the IRD had some kind of strange, or unreasonable claims with details that we noted that didn't make any sense,' Cheng has said. In some other cases, Cheng said the IRD had calculated individuals' taxable income as double the actual amount. Cheng told HKFP on Thursday that the union was undecided as to whether they would approach the government watchdog, the Ombudsman, about the apparent errors. In response to HKFP about the journalist group's claims, the IRD said on Wednesday that the authority 'has established procedures' to review the information provided by taxpayers and to verify the amount of tax payable. 'If there is any information showing that any person may have breached the provisions of the Inland Revenue Ordinance (IRO), the IRD will follow up the case in accordance with the IRO,' the IRD said. Statement: HKFP, which was 'randomly selected' for an audit in 2024, has always met its tax obligations, paid demands immediately, and ensured meticulous record-keeping. Donor data was withheld in paper submissions to Inland Revenue, with all 'hold' demands reduced to HK$0.… — Hong Kong Free Press HKFP (@hkfp) May 21, 2025 It added that the 'industry or background of a taxpayer has no bearing on such reviews.' In a statement on Wednesday, HKFP said it has been cooperating fully with its tax audit, having 'always met its tax obligations, paid IRD demands immediately, and ensured meticulous record-keeping since our 2015 inception.' The HKJA itself has also faced a probe. In January, it said the IRD demanded HK$400,000 from the group after reviewing its 2017-2018 accounts. 'Additional time and energy' According to the HKJA, the total amount demanded from the six media outlets and other related organisations was around HK$700,000, while the total amount demanded from individuals was around HK$1 million. Companies and individuals have a month to raise objections, according to IRD procedures. Cheng said all the media outlets, individuals and the HKJA raised objections and most of them saw the requested payment of provisional tax suspended. However, being subject to such audits burdens the independent media sector, which often has limited resources and manpower. 'They have to budget for additional audits, additional legal fees, additional time and energy seeking professional advice,' she said. Reports of government scrutiny come as the state of press freedom in Hong Kong remains in the spotlight. In the annual Reporters Without Borders (RSF) Press Freedom Index, released last month, Hong Kong tumbled five spots to enter the 'red zone' – meaning a 'very serious' situation – for the first time, alongside China. Since the Beijing-imposed national security law came into effect in 2020, dozens of civil society groups have shuttered. Two of Hong Kong's biggest independent media outlets – Apple Daily and Stand News – also saw their offices raided and their top staff arrested. Apple Daily's founder Jimmy Lai, who has been remanded since December 2020, has been charged with two counts of conspiring to collude with foreign forces under the Beijing-imposed national security law, and a third count of conspiring to publish seditious materials under colonial-era legislation.
HKFP
21-05-2025
- HKFP
Hong Kong's independent news sector – inc. companies, staff and family members – face tax audits and demands
Hong Kong's independent news sector, including companies, staff and family members, are facing simultaneous tax audits and backdated demands, the Hong Kong Journalists Association (HKJA) said on Wednesday. The situation reflected a worsening press freedom environment, they said. Head of the HKJA Selina Cheng said at a press conference that at least six news outlets – including InMedia, The Witness, ReNews, Boomhead, Hong Kong Free Press and an outlet that declined to be named – had been receiving government tax demands since November 2023 as part of Inland Revenue Department (IRD) inspections. Meanwhile, a total of 20 individuals linked to the independent media industry are also facing similar probes and tax demands, Cheng said: 'Journalists in Hong Kong do not have a very high income. Other than having to pay these claims of taxes, they also need to spend money, time and energy to prove in reverse that they were innocent.' According to the press union, 12 of them are heads, board members or shareholders of the news outlets concerned. Also under inspection are two freelance journalists, two spouses of news outlet heads, an employee of a media outlet, and both parents of the HKJA chief. The financial years being probed span the full six or seven years allowable under the IRD's remit. Those inspected usually receive a notice of assessment of additional tax first, the press union chief said. Then, they are requested to pay a provisional tax demand before the investigation into any alleged underpayment is complete. 'Usually, taxpayers will be required to pay a holding amount of tax for the coming year,' Cheng said. 'Usually, that kind of tax assessment is based on current income, but we're highlighting cases against media outlets and reporters who already paid their taxes in full six or seven years ago – and now the Hong Kong tax authority is coming to ask them to pay [an] even higher amount based on assessments that are made without evidence.' 'The IRD's audit of media and reporters was not based on sufficient evidence – or reasonable grounds, we believe – when they made such assessment of income shortfall, or requirement to pay their tax even before the audit is complete.' 'We think if the IRD thinks that there were taxpayers who neglected to pay their taxes in full, they should give sufficient and correct evidence before making these claims.' The total amount demanded from six media outlets and other organisations involves HK$700,000 so far, whilst the total amount demanded from individuals is around HK$1 million, according to the HKJA. Cheng faces an IRD probe into her salary tax dating back to 2017-18 when she was a reporter with local outlet HK01. The IRD also inspected Cheng's parents' salary taxes, profit taxes and rates. 'I was earning a monthly salary of HK$18,000 at that time and IRD assessed my taxable income [to be] HK$231,000. But recently, IRD said my taxable income was HK$631,000, and requested to tax me for the 'underreported' HK$400,000,' Cheng said, adding that the IRD did not provide evidence as to why it suspected there had been more taxable income. According to IRD procedures, companies and individuals can raise objections against assessments within a month of any notice. Cheng said all the media outlets, individuals and the HKJA raised objections and most of them saw the requested payment of provisional tax suspended. In a response to HKFP's enquiries on Wednesday, an IRD spokesperson said that it had established procedures to verify taxpayer information and follows the Inland Revenue Ordinance: '[T]he IRD will follow up the case in accordance with the IRO. The industry or background of a taxpayer has no bearing on such reviews,' it said, adding that it cannot comment on individual cases. It did not respond as to how companies were 'randomly selected' for audits. HKFP has submitted a Code on Access to Information request to better understand the procedure. 'Significant strain' When asked by an HKFP reporter about the impact of IRD inspection on press freedom, Cheng said she believed the audits hampered media outlets' daily operations and their sustainability. 'They have to budget for additional audits, additional legal fees, additional time and energy seeking professional advice,' she said. 'I think, to small organisations and to individuals, that's a significant strain.' 'If a number of media outlets or dramas are coming under financial duress created by unwarranted audits, then it does affect our ability to work continually,' Cheng added. HKFP 'always met its tax obligations' In a statement on Wednesday, HKFP said it has been cooperating fully with its tax audit, having 'always met its tax obligations, paid IRD demands immediately, and ensured meticulous record-keeping since our 2015 inception.' It added that it had obfuscated donors' personal data in paper submissions to the IRD and that IRD demands made ahead of the probe were reduced to HK$0 upon HKFP's appeal. The statement said that recent government scrutiny had diverted resources, manpower and funds away from journalism amid a years-long financial deficit: 'The delays involved, and wide scope of these inspections, raise questions about the burden on the taxpayer and tax office resources.' Statement: HKFP, which was 'randomly selected' for an audit in 2024, has always met its tax obligations, paid demands immediately, and ensured meticulous record-keeping. Donor data was withheld in paper submissions to Inland Revenue, with all 'hold' demands reduced to HK$0.… — Hong Kong Free Press HKFP (@hkfp) May 21, 2025 'HKFP nevertheless understands our case will shortly be concluded, just as all recent cases involving the Companies Registry, the Food and Environmental Hygiene Department, and the Agriculture, Fisheries and Conservation Department over the past year were closed.' Press freedom in Hong Kong Reports of government scrutiny come as the state of press freedom in Hong Kong remains in the spotlight. In the annual Reporters Without Borders (RSF) Press Freedom Index, released last month, Hong Kong tumbled five spots to enter the 'red zone' – meaning a 'very serious' situation – for the first time, alongside China. Since the Beijing-imposed national security law came into effect in 2020, dozens of civil society groups have shuttered. Two of Hong Kong's biggest independent media outlets – Apple Daily and Stand News – also saw their offices raided and their top staff arrested. Apple Daily's founder Jimmy Lai, who has been remanded since December 2020, has been charged with two counts of conspiring to collude with foreign forces under the Beijing-imposed national security law, and a third count of conspiring to publish seditious materials under colonial-era legislation. Last year, the HKJA said there was a 'systematic and organised attack' upon the city's media sector, after receiving reports from journalists from at least 13 media outlets saying they or their family members had received anonymous harassment letters. Cheng said the HKJA was not aware of how those behind the campaign obtained journalists' personal information, adding it was concerned about apparent and potentially unlawful leaks from the government or private databases. During the press conference on Wednesday, Cheng said the media outlets inspected by IRD partly overlapped with those facing harassment last year.
