Mahmoud Khalil's bid for freedom denied as federal judge sides with Trump administration
Judge Michael Farbiarz denied a request from Khalil's lawyers calling for his immediate release after the government declined to appeal a ruling Farbiarz issued Wednesday that found the main reason cited for jailing and seeking to deport Khalil was unconstitutional.
Until Friday, Trump administration lawyers had primarily argued the lawful permanent resident should be detained and deported based on a determination by Secretary of State Marco Rubio that his pro-Palestinian advocacy could compromise a 'compelling' U.S. foreign policy interest, meaning U.S. support for Israel.
When Farbiarz said Khalil could no longer be detained on that basis, government lawyers were expected to appeal before his order went into effect on Friday at 9:30 a.m. That didn't happen, prompting Khalil's lawyers to call for his instant release.
But lawyers for the federal government later in the day said they did not interpret Farbiarz's opinion as ordering them to release Khalil because they had a backup reason for keeping him in lockup — alleged omissions on his immigration forms about his work experience.
'Khalil is now detained based on that other charge of removability,' Trump admin lawyers wrote.
Farbiarz said Khalil could make a bid for bail to the judge presiding over his separate immigration case in Louisiana.
The 30-year-old grad student, a legal permanent resident, has been detained in Jena, Louisiana, since March 9, a day after agents from the Department of Homeland Security took him into custody at his Columbia-owned apartment. He played a prominent role in campus protests against Israeli military activity in Gaza and the West Bank and Columbia's financial ties to Israel, acting as a mediator between students and the school administration.
In the weeks that followed, the government cited an obscure provision in a 1952 immigration law that says the office of the secretary of state can order someone deported if their beliefs or activities could unfavorably impact U.S. foreign relations, namely, the government's policy of combating antisemitism.
Khalil, a Palestinian who grew up in a Syrian refugee camp, rejects that his advocacy for civilians in war-torn Gaza and the West Bank is based on bigotry. His lawyers have pointed to public comments he made well before his arrest condemning antisemitism.
Farbiarz's Wednesday opinion and order found the basis provided by the government was so vague as to be unconstitutional and said Khalil's ongoing detention was jeopardizing his professional reputation and right to free speech, amounting to irreparable harm.
As of Friday's back and forth, the government's reason for detaining Khalil is now based on its allegations that when he applied for lawful permanent residency in 2024, he didn't disclose membership in the United Nations Relief and Works Agency for Palestine Refugees (UNRWA), that he'd worked for the British Embassy in Beirut after 2022, or that he was a member of Columbia University Apartheid Divest (CUAD).
Though he accepted the government's position Friday, Farbiarz on Wednesday appeared skeptical that the alleged omissions warranted his detention, noting that the government 'virtually never [detains]' people on such allegations and that Khalil's jailing was, by all accounts, driven by Rubio's unconstitutional policy.
Khalil, whose U.S. citizen wife, Dr. Noor Abdalla, accepted his diploma from Columbia on his behalf last month, is fighting his detention and deportation in a habeas corpus case filed in New Jersey, where he was swiftly transferred after being taken into custody.
Separately, he's faced immigration proceedings in Louisiana, where Judge Jamee Comans has sided with the government in ordering him deported. Before a hearing in that matter last month, where Khalil and other witnesses sought to convince Comans that his deportation could result in his death, he met his 1-month-old son, Deen, for the first time, who was born weeks after he was detained.
At that hearing, according to court papers, the government did not appear to bolster its allegations about Khalil's lawful residency forms.
The immigration judge dismissed the claim about the British embassy. Khalil testified he was never employed by UNRWA or a member or a leader of CUAD, and government lawyers didn't cross-examine him. The government did not mention the UNRWA or CUAD membership allegations in written closing arguments.
Spokespeople for the Department of Homeland Security and the Justice Department did not immediately respond to the Daily News's queries. Khalil's lawyers could not immediately be reached following Farbiarz's order late Friday.
'The deadline has come and gone and Mahmoud Khalil must be released immediately,' the attorneys said in a statement earlier Friday. 'Anything further is an attempt to prolong his unconstitutional, arbitrary, and cruel detention.'
-----------
Hashtags
Try Our AI Features
Explore what Daily8 AI can do for you:
Comments
No comments yet...
Related Articles
Epoch Times
an hour ago
- Epoch Times
JD Vance Visits National Guard in DC; Israeli Forces Begin First Phase of Gaza City Takeover Plan
Vice President JD Vance visits National Guard troops deployed in the nation's capital, where he gives some of the latest stats on the city's crackdown on crime. Our White House correspondent shares her first-hand experience with crime in the city. Israeli forces begin the first phase of their plan to take over Gaza City. Meanwh...
San Francisco Chronicle
an hour ago
- San Francisco Chronicle
Former UC Berkeley professor sues, says she was denied job because she is Israeli
A former UC Berkeley professor and dance researcher accused the university on Wednesday of refusing to rehire her because she is from Israel, alleging the administration caved to a campus backlash against Israel after the start of the Gaza war in 2023. In a lawsuit in Alameda County Superior Court, Yael Nativ said she started teaching a course on 'Intersectional Perspective on Contemporary Dance in Israel' as a visiting professor at Berkeley in January 2022. The class went well, and in July 2023 Nativ was asked by the school's Helen Diller Institute for Jewish Law and Israel Studies to apply to teach another course the following spring, the suit said. The invitation expressed 'gratitude for her prior work,' and Nativ was 'thrilled' to receive it, her lawyers said. But they said the atmosphere, and the university's position, changed drastically after the Hamas attack on Israel in October 2023, followed by Israel's counterattack. In November 2023, the suit said, SanSan Kwan, chair of the Department of Theater, Dance and Performance Studies, told Nativ she would not be rehired. 'Things are very hot here right now and many of our grad students are angry,' Kwan said in a message on WhatsApp, according to the lawsuit. 'I would be putting the dept and you in a terrible position if you taught here.' Kwan did not mention Israel, but the suit said it was a clear message that Nativ was being rejected because of her origins. Rebecca Golbert, executive director of the Helen Diller Institute, also understood the decision to be based on Nativ's Israeli birthplace and considered the rejection to be 'misguided,' the suit said. Nativ has a college degree from the Sorbonne Institute in Paris, a master of arts degree in creative arts education from San Francisco State University, and a Ph.D. in Sociology of Education from Hebrew University in Jerusalem. She has taught at colleges in Israel and is chairwoman of the Israeli Choreographers Association. UC Berkeley deprived her of 'an employment and educational opportunity that would have significantly benefited her career' and violated California laws against discrimination based on national origin, the suit said. Nativ seeks damages for lost income and emotional distress and a ban on such discrimination in the future, but she does not directly demand that she be rehired. UC Berkeley spokesperson Dan Mogulof said Wednesday he was not allowed to comment on 'personnel matters' such as the lawsuit. But he said the university 'is committed to confronting harassment and discrimination of all types' and to complying with the law. Golbert, of the Helen Diller Institute, could not be reached for comment. Several of Nativ's lawyers are from the Louis D. Brandeis Center for Human Rights Under Law, an organization that has filed other cases accusing universities of antisemitism. One suit in November 2023 accused UC Berkeley of promoting antisemitism by allowing some student groups to bar Zionists as speakers at their meetings. A federal judge refused to dismiss the suit this April. Another suit last month accused Stanford University of fostering prejudice against a Jewish insulin researcher who was allegedly forced to resign by harassment from coworkers and supervisors.
UPI
an hour ago
- UPI
Vance, Hegseth, Miller laud Guard troops, denounce capital protesters
A Humvee is parked in front of Union Station in Washington as members of the National Guard patrol on Monday after President Donald Trump last week deployed the National Guard to assist in crime prevention. Photo by Bonnie Cash/UPI | License Photo Aug. 20 (UPI) -- As protesters chanted nearby, U.S. Vice President JD Vance, Defense Secretary Pete Hegseth and White House Deputy Chief of Staff Stephen Miller visited National Guardsmen in Washington, D.C., on Wednesday amid what the Trump administration says is a crime crackdown. The three Trump administration officials greeted National Guard troops at the capital's Union Station while positioned near a table containing hamburgers for the troops, PBS News reported. "In just the past nine days, we've seen a 35% reduction in violent crime," Vance told those in attendance. "We've seen over a 50% reduction in robberies," he added. "We're seeing really substantial effects because these guys are busting their a*****." Vance said he wanted to thank the National Guard troops in person and hand out some hamburgers to show his appreciation for their efforts. Hegseth said the National Guard deployments in Washington are needed to ensure residents, visitors and those who work in the capital are safe. "The American people, the residents of D.C., deserve a safe and beautiful city," Hegseth said. "That's our mission." He called the National Guard troops "patriots who serve the country" and want to make Washington a "beautiful, safe capital." The National Guard troops are "proud of this mission" and making sure "law and order is established here in the capital," Hegseth added. He said the Defense Department is providing the resources that the troops need and working with law enforcement partners to ensure safety in Washington. Pro-Palestinian protesters gathered and chanted near Union Station, which drew a rebuke from Vance. He said the protesters "hate the idea that Americans can enjoy their communities," according to PBS News. Vance said he went to Union Station with Hegseth and Miller because criminal activity was very high there, which local officials deny. Miller added to Vance's criticism of the protesters by calling them "stupid white hippies" and said they do not represent Washington, D.C.'s residents, The Hill reported. "We are not going to let the communists destroy a great American city, let alone the nation's capital," Miller said. "All these demonstrators you've seen out here in recent days, all these elderly white hippies, they're not part of the city and never have been," Miller said. "We're going to ignore these stupid white hippies that all need to go home and take a nap because they're all over 90 years old," he added. Trump last week put the federal government in control of Washington's Metropolitan Police Department, which has been accused of falsifying crime data. Though Trump administration officials have characterized crime in the city as out of control, in actuality, crime in the district has fallen in recent years or remained flat. An agreement on Friday put the police department under local control, but Trump sought and received National Guard deployments from West Virginia, South Carolina, Mississippi, Ohio, Tennessee and Louisiana. About 1,200 National Guard troops are slated for deployment in the capital, in addition to 800 Washington National Guard troops who already are there, according to The Washington Post.
