UK's system for verifying drivers' eyesight 'unsafe', coroner rules after four people killed
Dr James Adeley, senior coroner for Lancashire, made the remark at the inquests of four people killed by motorists whose vision was failing.
He said Britain's licensing system was the "laxest in Europe" - and one of only three to allow eyesight conditions to be self-reported.
He also said it was concerning that the UK was the only European country to issue licences without any checks up to the age of 70.
Dr Adeley presided over the inquests in Preston of Marie Cunningham, 79, Grace Foulds, 85, Peter Westwell, 80, and Anne Ferguson, 75.
Mrs Cunningham and Mrs Foulds, who were friends, were struck by Glyn Jones, 68, in his Audi A3 as they crossed the road in Southport, Merseyside, in November 2021.
Jones was told by both his optician and GP on several occasions that his eyesight was well below the standard required for driving a vehicle after he was diagnosed with a severe eye condition.
But he ignored the warnings and did not inform the DVLA or insurers.
He was sentenced to seven years and four months in jail in January last year.
Mr Westwell was hit by Neil Pemberton, 81, as he crossed the road in Langho, near Blackburn, on 17 March 2022.
Mrs Ferguson died when she was struck by a van driven by Vernon Law, 72, in Whitworth, Rochdale, on 11 July 2023.
Dr Adeley said: "The four fatalities shared the same feature that the driver's sight was well below the standard required to drive a car.
"The current system for 'ensuring' drivers meet the visual legal standards is ineffective, unsafe and unfit to meet the needs of society as evidenced by the deaths of [the four victims] where the DVLA continued to provide licences to drivers who had failed to meet the legal sight requirements."
He added: "Self-reporting of visual conditions permits drivers to lie about their current driving status to those performing an ophthalmic assessment and avoid warnings not to drive.
"Drivers may also admit they drive but then ignore instructions not to drive and fail to notify the DVLA."
Failure to tell the licensing agency of a new or worsening eyesight condition from the age of 70 is a criminal offence punishable by a fine of up to £1,000 but the coroner pointed out: "However, as the DVLA have never referred a case to the police where a condition was not disclosed for consideration for a prosecution, this appears to be a sanction without teeth."
Terry Wilcox, of Hudgell Solicitors, representing the families of Mrs Cunningham, Mrs Foulds and Mr Westwell, said: "People ignore what they are told when it doesn't suit their lifestyle, and in reality there is nothing in place to stop selfish people putting others at risk by getting back behind the wheel.
"Best estimates are that around 2% of drivers would fail the driving eyesight test - which would equate to around 750,000 drivers and 4,250 journeys every day on the M25.
"It is quite frankly frightening.
"Essentially, the only proof of suitable eyesight drivers have to provide is on the day of their driving test, when a number plate has to be read from 20 metres away.
"If you pass your test at 17, you are not asked to provide real evidence or proof of your eyesight ability ever again."
The Department for Transport said it would consider the coroner's report once received.
Try Our AI Features
Explore what Daily8 AI can do for you:
Comments
No comments yet...
Related Articles
ITV News
3 hours ago
- ITV News
Tributes paid to 'beautiful boy' following fatal crash in Cornwall
A man who died following a collision at Treburley in Cornwall has been described as "deeply loved" by his relatives. Bradley Gidney, 27, from Launceston, died at the scene of the accident on Sunday 10 August. Emergency services were called at 3.30am after a black Audi A3 left the road. In a tribute, his family said: 'We are completely and utterly devastated at coming to terms with the loss of our beautiful boy. 'Bradley was a big hearted, beautiful, generous, and loving son to Michelle and Shaun and a wonderfully dependable older brother to Elizabeth and Timothy. 'Bradley was extremely family oriented and will always be deeply loved by us and our extended family, the void he has left will never be filled. 'Bradley adored his work as a farm contractor and had just returned home from three weeks of harvesting for lifelong farming friends in Aston Clinton, Buckinghamshire, where he grew up and his love of farming was born. 'We all had a wonderful last night together at his sister's wedding celebration where Bradley stole the show on the dance floor! 'Bradley's loss will be felt by us forevermore and the stars will shine a little brighter. 'I would like to add that we are overwhelmed at the outpouring of love for Bradley in both Bucks and Devon and Cornwall, it means so much to us.' The A388 was closed for more than nine hours while specialist forensic investigators worked at the scene. Roads policing officers are investigating the circumstances surrounding the collision and appealing for any witnesses or motorists with relevant dashcam footage to get in touch. Information can be submitted online or by calling 101, quoting reference 50250206871.
Daily Mirror
7 hours ago
- Daily Mirror
Meet Alexander Isak's controversial agent who FIFA investigated and brokered Chelsea deals
Alexander Isak is being advised by an agent who's found himself at the heart of several controversies in European football since the early 2000s, with Newcastle being his latest battle Vlado Lemic has once again proved he's not afraid to throw the cat amongst the pigeons this summer. Alexander Isak 's agent has stirred up one of the biggest transfer controversies in recent memory ahead of the new Premier League season. The Newcastle United striker is now reportedly refusing to play for the club for which he's scored 62 goals in 109 games as he looks to force through a move to Liverpool before the window slams shut. His decision-making, particularly the timing of it, has raised plenty of eyebrows. But the picture grows clearer when turning the attention to one of the representatives who's been advising him over the past few weeks, Lemic. The world of football agency involves making political power moves and playing off parties against each other. Those are skills that the Serbian, 59, has fine tuned having worked in the field for over a quarter of a century. What started as primarily helping players from his home country make moves to the Netherlands has snowballed into one of the biggest agencies in the world as part of Unverisal Twenty Two, who also boast the likes of Emi Martinez and Luka Modric on their books. It was during his early work for PSV in the 2000s that Lemic first came under fire. He was accused of financial misconduct, claims which went unproven but saw him banned from the club's training ground regardless. Four years later in 2012, FIFA opened an investigation into his role in the transfer of Croatian midfielder Milan Badelj from Dinamo Zagreb to Hamburg. The involved parties were all contacted by the world governing body after Lemic was alleged to have benefited financially from the deal via an inflated fee. But they closed the investigation in February 2013, saying at the time: 'After an investigation by FIFA TMS (Transfer Management System) into the allegations, it appears that there was no substantial involvement by Vlado Lemic in this transfer." All the while, Lemic had been working his way up the football food chain. Having previously brokered a partnership between PSV and Chelsea that saw the Dutch side loan the Blues' signings until they could get a British work permit, he became increasingly involved with Roman Abramovich. He was said to be behind the transfers of Branislav Ivanovic and Nemanja Matic to Stamford Bridge in 2008 and 2009, respectively. His network of contacts was growing exponentially across Europe, including at Real Madrid, who with his help inserted a £387million release clause in Luka Modric's contract when he joined from Tottenham in 2012. In more recent years, Lemic helped broker several deals for Ajax, who have since supposedly followed PSV's lead and banned him. Swedish side AIK are also said to have similarly cut ties with his agency. Universal Twenty Two agency have been approached for comment. The kicker is that Lemic isn't officially a licensed player agent, but rather considers himself an adviser. He works closely with his brother Zoran, who is licensed by FIFA, and several other partners like Sven Mislintat, through whom official communication is usually made with clubs. Gonzalo Gaitan, for example, has been dealing with most of Isak's back-and-forth. Ultimately, it's clear Lemic is a man who usually gets what he wants, one way or another, earning money along the way for his advisory services. That's being pushed to the extreme with Isak, whose threat to strike permanently appears misguided given Newcastle are under no obligation to sell this summer, particularly with their search for a replacement striker hitting multiple roadblocks. Whether the tactics will pay off and Liverpool can improve on their opening £110m bid remains to be seen.
Glasgow Times
9 hours ago
- Glasgow Times
David Coote given eight-week ban over Jurgen Klopp comments
Coote was charged by the Football Association in June after the comments about Klopp came to light in a video circulated on social media last November. The FA said he had subsequently admitted the charge. Coote's misconduct was defined as an aggravated breach under the FA's rules because there was a reference to Klopp's nationality. An independent Regulatory Commission has imposed an eight-week suspension and mandatory face-to-face education programme on David Coote for a breach of FA Rule E3. Full statement and written reasons: — FA Spokesperson (@FAspokesperson) August 12, 2025 Coote was sacked by Professional Game Match Officials Limited (PGMOL) last December, a month after the video filmed in July 2020 came to light. PGMOL said in confirming Coote's dismissal last December that his position had become 'untenable'. In it, Coote is heard saying it had been 's***' to be fourth official at a Liverpool match in the summer of 2020, describing Klopp as a 'German c***'. He also said Klopp was 'f****** arrogant'. When the FA charged him over the Klopp comments in June, the governing body said Coote would face no further action in regard to separate allegations of gambling misconduct, which he had strenuously denied. The FA said those allegations had been fully investigated. Coote was sacked by PGMOL last December (Richard Sellers/PA) Coote was banned by European football's governing body UEFA in February until June 30, 2026 after a different video emerged of him snorting a white powder through a bank note while in Germany for last summer's Euros. In January, Coote came out as gay in an interview with The Sun and said that a lifelong struggle to hide his sexuality had contributed to the rant about Klopp, and to his drug use. 'My sexuality isn't the only reason that led me to be in that position. But I'm not telling an authentic story if I don't say that I'm gay and that I've had real struggles with hiding that,' he said. 'I hid my emotions as a young ref and I hid my sexuality as well — a good quality as a referee but a terrible quality as a human being. And that's led me to a whole course of behaviours.' Coote's formal response to the FA charge was detailed in the regulatory commission's written reasons which were published alongside the confirmation of the sanctions imposed. He accepted his words about Klopp were 'crass, inappropriate and unworthy of the role that he held within the game' and asked the commission to accept that his decision not to attend the hearing was not made out of avoidance, but due to his mental state. Coote said the words did not respect his true view of Klopp, for whom he had always had a deep professional respect. The panel wrote: 'DC (Coote) stated that he felt an immense sense of shame. He had lost a career that formed the very core of his identity. He had lost all his income and the media attention had deepened his sense of humiliation and despair. 'He was trying to piece his life back together, from a place of near total collapse.'
