logo
Federal judges temporarily block Education Department from enforcing DEI orders

Federal judges temporarily block Education Department from enforcing DEI orders

Politico24-04-2025

Federal judges on Thursday dealt three separate blows to the Education Department's plans to enforce sweeping bans on diversity, equity and inclusion efforts in the nation's K-12 schools, in decisions that declare Trump administration policies — or the way they were enacted — likely violate the law.
The rulings stem from lawsuits brought by the country's largest teacher unions and civil rights groups in separate jurisdictions. But each court decision carries national implications that temporarily block the administration from carrying out this month's
directive that school systems
comply with its interpretation of federal anti-discrimination law or risk sanctions.
Despite the impact of each court ruling, states and schools may still face challenges to determine how the decisions apply locally — and whether educational institutions should delay or reverse policies they may already have implemented in response to the Trump administration's demands.
A
ruling in favor of a preliminary injunction
requested by the National Education Association from Landya McCafferty, a New Hampshire federal judge appointed by former president Barack Obama, stopped short of issuing a nationwide order that halts the Education Department from enforcing its orders for schools.
But McCafferty's ruling does apply to entities receiving federal funding that employ or contract with the NEA or its members — a key nuance that gives her decision considerable effect across much of the country where the largest U.S. labor union has a presence.
The second court ruling
from Stephanie Gallagher, a Maryland judge appointed by President Donald Trump, in a case brought by organizations including the American Federation of Teachers, delayed the enactment of a
Feb. 14 department letter
that asserts federal law prohibits schools from using race in decisions pertaining to all aspects of education.
'This Court takes no view as to whether the policies at issue here are good or bad, prudent or foolish, fair or unfair,' Gallagher wrote in her decision.
'But this Court is constitutionally required to closely scrutinize whether the government went about creating and implementing them in the manner the law requires,' she added. 'The government did not.'
A third ruling
issued in the District of Columbia
by Judge Dabney Friedrich, a Trump appointee, further blocked the department from demanding schools certify their compliance with the Trump administration. The government's threats, the judge said, likely violate the Constitution.
The Education Department did not respond to a request for comment.
Education Secretary Linda McMahon's agency this month
directed state school systems
to quickly sign onto a Trump administration interpretation of federal anti-discrimination law or risk potential lawsuits, civil penalties and the loss of hundreds of millions of dollars in federal funds. The agency later agreed to delay enforcing its orders until today's hearing, as part of a temporary agreement in the New Hampshire case.
The NAACP filed a lawsuit to challenge that directive in mid-April, and won a swift ruling that granted part of its request for a preliminary injunction after today's hearing in the District of Columbia, according to court records.
'Our fight is far from over, but today's decision is a victory for Black and Brown students across the country, whose right to an equal education has been directly threatened by this Administration's corrosive actions and misinterpretations of civil rights law,' NAACP CEO Derrick Johnson said
in a statement
.
The National Education Association, its New Hampshire affiliate and civil rights organizations
sued the department
in federal court last month to challenge agency guidance that directed schools to end their diversity, equity and inclusion programs. The American Federation of Teachers joined the American Sociological Association and an Oregon school district in its lawsuit, in conjunction with the Democracy Forward legal services organization.
'Today's ruling allows educators and schools to continue to be guided by what's best for students, not by the threat of illegal restrictions and punishment,' NEA President Becky Pringle said in a statement on the New Hampshire case.
'The court agreed that this vague and clearly unconstitutional requirement is a grave attack on students, our profession, honest history, and knowledge itself,' American Federation of Teachers President Randi Weingarten said of the Maryland case.
Thursday's rulings are not final decisions on the merits of the lawsuits, though they block the department from enforcing its orders while each case awaits further rulings. Each ruling, though, said each lawsuit was likely to succeed on at least some of their respective claims.
The department's
'Dear Colleague' letter
from February that asserts federal law prohibits schools from using race in decisions pertaining to all aspects of education is 'unconstitutionally vague,' McCafferty's 82-page ruling said, adding that the letter likely exceeds the department's statutory authority.
That letter and a department
'End DEI' federal tip line
'raise the specter of a public 'witch hunt' that will sow fear and doubt among teachers lest they be publicly branded as peddlers of 'divisive ideologies' based on the Department's — or even private parties' — subjective assessments,' the New Hampshire judge said.
'While it may be true that a line must be drawn somewhere between the Department's lawful prerogative to enforce anti-discrimination law and its prohibition from controlling curriculum, the Letter and its associated documents do not toe that line,' McCafferty wrote.

Orange background

Try Our AI Features

Explore what Daily8 AI can do for you:

Comments

No comments yet...

Related Articles

Donald Trump Stumbles On Air Force One Steps, Social Media Trolls Him With Old Man Jokes
Donald Trump Stumbles On Air Force One Steps, Social Media Trolls Him With Old Man Jokes

Black America Web

time6 minutes ago

  • Black America Web

Donald Trump Stumbles On Air Force One Steps, Social Media Trolls Him With Old Man Jokes

Source: SAUL LOEB / Getty President Donald Trump's having a pretty stressful week. First, he had a very public spat with his former best friend, Elon Musk, on social media, and now he has fanned the flames of Los Angeles' immigration policy protests by deploying the National Guard. But if there's one thing he despises above all, weakness is probably up there, and nearly falling in public falls under that umbrella. It came after he faced a bunch of questions from the media about the Los Angeles uprising. He said that while there's no need to invoke the Insurrection Act currently, there are 'violent people,' a nd 'We are not going to let them get away with it.' He added, 'We are not going to let our country be torn apart like it was under Biden.' Ironically, the comment was made moments before his near tumble, as former President Joe Biden's steadiness on his feet was also a constant issue. Trump was in Hagerstown, Maryland, boarding Air Force One heading to Camp David, and while climbing the steps, he tripped and caught himself before falling over. Seconds later, Secretary of State Marco Rubio tripped while going up the steps, too. Biden's mental acuity was questioned due to his balance issues, brain fog, and being the eldest president ever at 82, and Trump used it against him, even nicknaming him sleepy Joe. 'Could we take a vote, please? Who wants to call him crooked Joe? Who wants to call him sleepy Joe? That's my problem, they work like the same,' Trump said at a National Republican Congressional Committee (NRCC) fundraising event in April. ' Joe had one ability that I didn't have. He could sit down on a beach and he could fall asleep. Who the hell could do that? I could never fall asleep under these circumstances, I would be very conscious of my body.' But now, the tables have turned, and 78-year-old Trump's mentions have been flooded with old jokes. See the reactions below. Donald Trump Stumbles On Air Force One Steps, Social Media Trolls Him With Old Man Jokes was originally published on Black America Web Featured Video CLOSE

Marines arrive in LA under Trump orders as protests spread to other cities
Marines arrive in LA under Trump orders as protests spread to other cities

Yahoo

time6 minutes ago

  • Yahoo

Marines arrive in LA under Trump orders as protests spread to other cities

By Brad Brooks, Jorge Garcia, Phil Stewart and Idrees Ali LOS ANGELES (Reuters) -Hundreds of U.S. Marines arrived in Los Angeles overnight and more were expected on Tuesday under orders from President Donald Trump, who has also activated 4,000 National Guard troops to quell protests despite objections from California Governor Gavin Newsom and other local leaders. The city has seen days of public outrage since the Trump administration launched a series of immigration raids on Friday, though local officials said the demonstrations on Monday were largely peaceful. About half of the roughly 700 Marines that Trump ordered to Los Angeles arrived on Monday night, and the remaining troops will enter the city on Tuesday, a U.S. official told Reuters. The U.S. military did not immediately respond to a request for comment. Los Angeles Mayor Karen Bass told KABC that more than 100 people had been arrested on Monday but that the majority of protesters were nonviolent. Over the weekend, protesters threw rocks and other objects at officers and vehicles and set several cars ablaze. Police responded by firing projectiles like pepper balls as well as flash bang grenades and tear gas. Trump has justified his decision to deploy active military troops to Los Angeles by describing the protests as a violent occupation of the city, a characterization that Newsom and Bass have said is grossly exaggerated. Newsom said that Trump's deployment of National Guard troops has only inflamed the situation and made it more difficult for local law enforcement to respond to the demonstrations. In a statement on Monday, Los Angeles Police Chief Jim McDonnell said the department had not been notified that any Marines were traveling to the city and that their possible arrival "presents a significant logistical and operational challenge" for police. Trump's decision to mobilize 700 Marines based in Southern California escalated his confrontation with Newsom, who filed a lawsuit on Monday asserting that Trump's deployment of Guard troops without the governor's consent was illegal. The Guard deployment was the first time in decades that a president activated the Guard absent a request from a sitting governor. While the Marines are only tasked with guarding federal property temporarily until the full contingent of 4,000 Guard troops arrives, the use of active military to respond to civil disturbances is extremely rare. "This isn't about public safety," Newsom wrote on X on Monday. "It's about stroking a dangerous President's ego." The top Democrat on the Senate Armed Services Committee, Senator Jack Reed, said he was "gravely troubled" by Trump's deployment of active-duty Marines. "Since our nation's founding, the American people have been perfectly clear: we do not want the military conducting law enforcement on U.S. soil," he said. In a post on Tuesday morning on Truth Social, Trump claimed Los Angeles would be "burning to the ground right now" if he had not deployed troops to the city. DEMONSTRATIONS AND ARRESTS The raids are part of Trump's sweeping immigration crackdown, which Democrats and immigrant advocates have said are indiscriminately breaking up families. U.S. Homeland Security Secretary Kristi Noem pledged on Monday to carry out more operations to round up suspected immigration violators. Trump officials have branded the protests as lawless and blamed state and local Democrats for protecting undocumented immigrants with sanctuary cities. Hundreds of demonstrators gathered on Monday outside a federal detention center in downtown Los Angeles where immigrants have been held, chanting "free them all" and waving Mexican and Central American flags. National Guard forces formed a human barricade to keep people out of the building, and late on Monday, police began dispersing the crowd using gas canisters and arrested some protesters. At dusk, officers had running confrontations with protesters who had scattered into the Little Tokyo section of the city. As people watched from apartment patios above street level and as tourists huddled inside hotels, a large contingent of LAPD and officers and sheriff's deputies fired several flash bangs that boomed through side streets along with tear gas. Protests spread to neighboring Orange County on Monday night after immigration raids there, with demonstrators gathering at the Santa Ana Federal building, according to local officials and news reports. Protests also sprang up in at least nine other U.S. cities on Monday, including New York, Philadelphia and San Francisco, according to local news reports. In Austin, Texas, police fired non-lethal munitions and detained several people as they clashed with a crowd of several hundred protesters.

Doechii Slams Trump Administration In Powerful BET Awards Acceptance Speech
Doechii Slams Trump Administration In Powerful BET Awards Acceptance Speech

Black America Web

time6 minutes ago

  • Black America Web

Doechii Slams Trump Administration In Powerful BET Awards Acceptance Speech

Source: Kevin Winter / Getty Doechii was all smiles as she accepted the 2025 BET Awards for 'Best Female Hip Hop Artist.' After all, it's the 'Anxiety' artist's first BET Award. But instead of a traditional acceptance speech, she used her platform to bring awareness to the peaceful protest outside the Peacock Theater, which is being forcefully interrupted by authorities. 'I do want to address what's happening right now, outside the building,' she said passionately.'These are ruthless attacks that are creating fear and chaos in our communities. In the name of law and order, Trump is using military forces to stop a protest, and I want you all to consider what kind of government it appears to be — when every time we exercise our democratic right to protest, the military is deployed against us.' Dozens of people have been detained and taken into custody during raids by Immigration and Customs Enforcement, prompting protests in the DTLA area, NBC News reports. 'People are being swept up and torn from their families, and I feel it is my responsibility as an artist to use this moment to speak up for all oppressed people,' she added. Per AP, an initial 2,000 Guard troops ordered by Trump started arriving Sunday, which saw the most violence during three days of protests driven by anger over Trump's stepped-up enforcement of immigration laws that critics say are breaking apart migrant families. These attacks on our civil liberties is more evidence of the Trump Administration's failure to the people. 'This isn't about public safety,' Gov. Gavin Newsom said. 'It's about stroking a dangerous President's ego.' SEE ALSO Doechii Slams Trump Administration In Powerful BET Awards Acceptance Speech was originally published on Black America Web Featured Video CLOSE

DOWNLOAD THE APP

Get Started Now: Download the App

Ready to dive into the world of global news and events? Download our app today from your preferred app store and start exploring.
app-storeplay-store