Inspecting claim Melania Trump improperly came to US on EB-1 'Einstein' visa
In June 2025, U.S. Rep. Jasmine Crockett, a Democrat from Texas, expressed doubt that first lady Melania Trump had legitimately qualified for a so-called "Einstein visa" — as employment-based visas for people with extraordinary abilities are known — to become a permanent resident, and then a citizen, of the U.S.
"The math ain't mathin'," Crockett said during a June 25 congressional hearing as she explained that the first lady had arrived in the U.S. on such an EB-1 visa. Footage from the hearing was available on YouTube:
Starting around the 1:48 mark in the video, Crockett said:
Let me remind y'all that Melania the first lady, a model — and when I say model, I'm not talking about Tyra Banks, Cindy Crawford or Naomi Campbell-level — applied for and was given an EB-1 visa. And what that stands for is an Einstein visa.
Now y'all that don't know, let me tell you how you receive an Einstein visa: You're supposed to have some sort of significant achievement like being awarded a Nobel Peace Prize or a Pulitzer, being an Olympic medalist or having other sustained extraordinary abilities and success in sciences, arts, education, business or athletics. Last time I checked, the first lady had none of those accolades under her belt. It doesn't take an Einstein to see that the math ain't mathin' here.
Several Facebook posts relayed Crockett's claim.
Indeed, in 2018, The Washington Post reported that Melania Trump, then Melania Knauss, had petitioned the government for a "green card" — permanent residency in the U.S. — under the highly coveted EB-1 visa in 2000. Knauss was then a model who had completed a few high-profile jobs, including a large advertisement for cigarettes in Times Square and a photograph of her in a bikini with an inflatable whale for Sports Illustrated. Her visa was approved and she was then able to sponsor her parents for permanent residency in the country, according to the Post.
Snopes was not able to independently obtain confirmation that Trump had indeed obtained this visa or to secure information about the specific decision process behind her reportedly successful application for one. Therefore, we have left the claim unrated. We contacted her then-lawyer, Michael Wildes — who was mayor of Englewood, New Jersey, from 2004 to 2010 and was elected mayor again in 2018 — asking for confirmation that Trump immigrated on the EB-1 visa, and we will update this report should he respond.
The website for the U.S. Citizenship and Immigration Services says that three categories of people are eligible for the EB-1 visa: people with extraordinary abilities, outstanding professors and researchers and certain multinational managers or executives. Trump belonged to neither of the latter two categories, so if she obtained an EB-1 visa, it was under the first category: people with extraordinary abilities.
In fact, models can qualify for this visa under certain conditions. The EB-1 immigrant visa is by no means the only visa a model or performer can apply for to work in the U.S. Others are the O-1A or O-1B visas, which are nonimmigrant visas valid for three years. For example, the comedian John Oliver came to the U.S. on an O-1 visa, which he had to renew several times before obtaining permanent residency. The former Playboy model Shera Bechard also obtained this temporary "genius" visa.
Both the EB-1 and the O-1 visas require the applicant to demonstrate extraordinary abilities.
The EB-1 does not require the applicant to receive a job offer, but the criteria are hard to meet and few such visas are granted each year. However, this does not preclude successful models from obtaining them. Models who enjoy a certain level of recognition and celebrity, with substantial incomes can qualify for this path to residency and possibly citizenship, according to several experts interviewed by The New York Times.
Ultimately, however, everything indicates that there is a degree of arbitrariness in the decision to approve EB-1 visas, and much rests on the immigration officer who makes that decision, which can result in lawsuits.
In sum, it is not improbable that a working model might have received the right to permanently reside in the U.S. based on her extraordinary abilities.
This is not the first rumor about Melania Trump that Snopes has investigated. For more, see our collection of 23 rumors about the first lady.
Admin User. "District Court Rules in College's Favor in EB-1 Case - Miller Mayer Law Firm." Miller Mayer Law Firm, 19 Dec. 2023, millermayer.com/district-court-rules-in-colleges-favor-in-eb-1-case/. Accessed 2 July 2025.
"Employment-Based Immigration: First Preference EB-1 | USCIS." Www.uscis.gov, 23 Nov. 2020, www.uscis.gov/working-in-the-united-states/permanent-workers/employment-based-immigration-first-preference-eb-1. Accessed 2 July 2025.
Jordan, Mary. "Questions Linger about How Melania Trump, a Slovenian Model, Scored 'the Einstein Visa.'" The Washington Post, Mar. 2018, www.washingtonpost.com/politics/questions-linger-about-how-melania-trump-a-slovenian-model-scored-the-einstein-visa/2018/02/28/d307ddb2-1b35-11e8-ae5a-16e60e4605f3_story.html. Accessed 2 July 2025.
Jordan, Miriam. "Did Melania Trump Merit an 'Einstein Visa'? Probably, Immigration Lawyers Say." The New York Times, 4 Mar. 2018, www.nytimes.com/2018/03/04/us/melania-trump-einstein-visa.html. Accessed 2 July 2025.
Martinelli, Marissa. "John Oliver Breaks down the Four Major Paths to Legal U.S. Immigration, Including His Own." Slate Magazine, Slate, 16 Sept. 2019, slate.com/culture/2019/09/john-oliver-immigration-trump-last-week-tonight.html. Accessed 2 July 2025.
McBride, Sarah. "Should Playboy Playmate Have Received 'Genius' Visa?" NBC News, 29 June 2012, www.nbcnews.com/id/wbna48009735. Accessed 2 July 2025.
"O-1 Visa: Individuals with Extraordinary Ability or Achievement | USCIS." Www.uscis.gov, 29 May 2020, www.uscis.gov/working-in-the-united-states/temporary-workers/o-1-visa-individuals-with-extraordinary-ability-or-achievement. Accessed 2 July 2025.
"Rep. Jasmine Crockett: Visas, Hypocrisy, and the Einstein Math That Ain't Mathin'." Youtu.be, 25 June 2025, youtu.be/dW2n75FQx64. Accessed 2 July 2025.
Shore, Rebecca. #TBT to That Time Donald Trump's Future Wife Cozied up to an Inflatable Killer Whale. 23 Oct. 2014, archive.is/EdzxB. Accessed 2 July 2025.
"Staff Directory • Michael Wildes." Cityofenglewood.org, 2018, www.cityofenglewood.org/directory.aspx?eid=51. Accessed 2 July 2025.
Solve the daily Crossword
Hashtags
Try Our AI Features
Explore what Daily8 AI can do for you:
Comments
No comments yet...
Related Articles
Yahoo
30 minutes ago
- Yahoo
Britain's shameful past holds a vital message about immigration culture today
'East of Aldgate one walks into a foreign town', foreigners 'swamping whole areas once populated by English people'. The 'substitution of a foreign for an English population' has created 'increasing bitterness of feeling'. No, not Robert Jenrick or Nigel Farage, but William Evans-Gordon, the Tory MP for Stepney, fulminating in 1903 against the arrival of Jewish refugees fleeing pogroms in eastern Europe. 'Not a day passes but English families are ruthlessly turned out to make room for the foreign invaders,' he told parliament. Evans-Gordon was a founder of the British Brothers' League (BBL), a powerful anti-immigration movement with the slogan 'England for the English', and the driving force behind the 1905 Aliens Act, designed to keep out Jewish refugees. Where previous arrivals had 'merged in the population', Evans-Gordon wrote in The Alien Immigrant, 'the Hebrew colony' formed a 'permanently distinct block – a race apart', refusing to 'assimilate' but coming 'like an army of locusts, eating up the English inhabitants or driving them out'. They brought with them 'colonies of foreign crime". In certain courts in London, 'English was hardly heard'. According to Evans-Gordon: 'The proportion of aliens who live by vice is inordinately high'. They indulged in 'depraved' sexual crimes, 'which, but for them, would hardly be known in this country'. Evans-Gordon's themes echo across the century. Arguments about populations being replaced, denunciations of asylum seekers as 'invaders', the insistence that migrants are unassimilable, accusations of mass criminality and depravity, are all wearily familiar. One can even hear in Evans-Gordon the contempt for what many now call the 'liberal elite'. The 'wholesale displacement of our people,' he wrote, 'is regarded with much philosophic calm by their fellow countrymen who live at a distance, whose homes have not been invaded, and who are not subjected to the daily terror of being turned into the streets.' That might have been Matthew Goodwin. It is not difficult to recognise today how this portrayal of unassimilable Jews draws on deep-rooted antisemitic tropes. It draws also upon ideas of cultural homogeneity and difference still in play today. Across the century, critics have always portrayed immigrants as destructive of local culture. Cultures, though, are not sealed containers containing a fixed essence that migrants pollute. They are porous vessels, internally conflicted, and changing over time. Nor are individuals fixed by their cultural inheritance, but can also develop and change. The Taliban has imposed upon Afghanistan deeply reactionary norms, including about the treatment of women, that draw upon one strand of Afghan culture, but which is contested by those for whom Afghan culture means something very different. Half a century ago, Afghanistan was far more liberal than it is today. It is why so many resisted the Taliban and why so many now seek to flee. British culture was far more conservative half a century ago than it is today. The social views of conservative Muslims would have, ironically, been closer to that of the British mainstream in the 1970s. Even commentators who now rail against liberalism have absorbed the liberal transformation of the past few decades and, indeed, deploy it as a weapon against migrants from conservative cultures. Cultures are not sealed containers. They are porous vessels, internally conflicted and changing over time For many critics, African and Asian migrants, and Muslims in particular, cannot be accommodated within the 'Judeo-Christian' tradition that defines the west. Yet, as Evans-Gordon's screed reveals, barely a century ago Jewish beliefs and practices were seen as being as incompatible with British values as many now deem Muslims to be. The idea of the 'Judeo-Christian' tradition is of recent vintage. It became deployed in the 1930s, particularly in America, by those attempting to build public support for the struggle against Nazism, suggesting as it did a common civilisation between Christians and Jews. From the 1950s it was repurposed as a weapon in the cold war, President Eisenhower describing 'Judeo-Christian civilisation' as the 'fundamental concept' separating America from the atheist Soviet Union. In the 21st century, especially after 9/11, the use of the concept changed again, becoming primarily a means of depicting Islam as standing outside the western tradition and, more recently, of gaining support for Israel in its war in Gaza. Jewish thought has unquestionably played an important role in the shaping of what we now call the western tradition. That was denied for much of the past 2,000 years. When finally acknowledged, it was in a distorted form, to buttress particular political projects. And both the denial and the acknowledgement became means of defining certain immigrants, previously Jews, now Muslims, as not belonging. Like many contemporary critics, Evans-Gordon elided his deprecation of immigrant culture with claims that they deprived British workers of basic material needs, from housing to jobs. Again, from today's vantage point, we can recognise the falsity of such arguments. The material deprivation Evans-Gordon described was real, but its root cause lay not with Jewish refugees but with exploitative bosses, unscrupulous landlords and indifferent politicians. What transformed working-class lives in the early 20th century was not restrictions on Jewish immigration but the growth of trade unions, an upsurge of collective action and the development of political parties and movements that challenged inequalities. Jewish workers, particularly in east London, were at the heart of these organisations and movements, helping forge solidarity across sectarian divides and in so doing renewing working-class culture. Today, as a new generation of Evans-Gordons try to colonise our attention, that is the most important message to echo across the century. Photograph by Jewish Chronicle/Heritage Images/Getty
Yahoo
38 minutes ago
- Yahoo
US cancels India trade talks scheduled for August, NDTV Profit says
(Reuters) -A planned visit by U.S. trade negotiators to New Delhi from August 25-29 has been canceled, delaying talks on a proposed bilateral trade agreement, Indian business and financial news network NDTV Profit reported on Saturday, citing people familiar with the matter. The current round of negotiations for the proposed bilateral trade agreement is now likely to be deferred to another date, the report said, dashing hopes of some relief before the Aug. 27 deadline for the additional tariff on Indian goods kicks in. Reuters could not immediately verify the report. Earlier this month, U.S. President Donald Trump imposed an additional 25% tariff on Indian goods, citing New Delhi's continued imports of Russian oil in a move that sharply escalated tensions between the two nations. The new import tax, which will come into effect from Aug 27, will raise duties on some Indian exports to as high as 50% - among the highest levied on any U.S. trading partner. Trade talks between New Delhi and Washington collapsed after five rounds of negotiations over disagreement on opening India's vast farm and dairy sectors and stopping Russian oil purchases. India's Foreign Ministry has said the country is being unfairly singled out for buying Russian oil while the United States and European Union continue to purchase goods from Russia. Melden Sie sich an, um Ihr Portfolio aufzurufen.
Yahoo
an hour ago
- Yahoo
Hundreds gather at Lake Merritt to protest Texas congressional gerrymandering
The Brief Hundreds gathered at Lake Merritt on Saturday to protest the proposed redrawing of Texas' congressional districts. Texas lawmakers are attempting to gerrymander their state, to send more Republicans to Washington ahead of the 2026 election. Gov. Gavin Newsom has proposed similarly redistricting California to offset the additional Texas Republicans. OAKLAND, Calif. - Hundreds of Bay Area residents gathered in Oakland on Saturday to push back against President Trump's attempt to gerrymander Texas. Multiple elected officials, including Oakland Mayor Barbara Lee, Congresswoman Lateefah Simon assembled at the Lake Merritt Amphitheater, and Alameda County Supervisor Nikki Fortunato Bas, spoke to the crowd of nearly 400 people. "Trump and his Republican allies are trying to steal the 2026 election by redrawing districts in their favor and attacking our voting rights," Bas said at the event. "This attack on our democracy may have started in Texas, but without immediate action, it can sweep dangerously across our country." The event featured a 15-foot-tall inflatable chicken with orange hair, meant to represent President Trump, as well as several large, cardboard rotten eggs with the names of Texas politicians — including Senator Ted Cruz and Governor Greg Abbott — involved in the push to redraw the state's maps. "This unparalleled attack on democracy would not be possible without the Texas Republicans who are answering not to the people, but to one man: Donald Trump," Keith Brown of the Alameda Labor Council said. "California will not sit back and watch the erosion of our democracy." Indeed, California has responded to the Lone Star State's redrawn congressional map. Governor Gavin Newsom on Saturday released a map that showed the proposed redistricting of California's congressional districts. If approved, the map would add more democratic congressional seats to balance those that would be eliminated by the redrawn Texas map. Pushing back The backstory Texas' lawmakers are considering a new map that would help them send five more Republicans to Washington, but Democrats have so far halted that effort by leaving the state to prevent their GOP colleagues from meeting Trump's demands. "We can't stand back and watch this democracy disappear district by district, all across this country," Newsom said at a Los Angeles press conference on Thursday. "Not just in Texas, but in Missouri, where J.D. Vance went just a week ago, in Indiana, in places like Ohio and places like Florida. We need to stand up, not just in California. Other blue states need to stand up." There are 435 seats in the U.S. House. Of those, Republicans currently hold a 219-212 majority, with four vacancies. New maps are typically drawn once a decade, after the census is conducted. Proposed changes By the numbers Many states give legislators the power to draw maps but some, including California, rely on an independent, non-partisan commission. The redrawn map is consistent with the criteria laid out by the California's Citizen Redistricting Commission, and keeps district more compact than the current map, which helps to keep more communities and neighborhoods in the same district. The new map splits fewer cities than the current map — 57 in the submitted map versus 60 in the current map. The proposed redistricting would leave eight districts untouched and would, in 20 districts, impact fewer than 10% of residents. The new map will be put forth to voters in a special election, with the California legislature set to take up the issue next week, to call for a vote on Nov. 4.
