Greenwashing is rife in Australia, but could its days be numbered?
These green premium products are marketed to us everywhere. They target eco-conscious consumers wanting to do the right thing and create the impression that by paying a premium, the carbon dioxide released into the atmosphere from flying, shipping or burning gas are neutralised or 'offset' with carbon credits.
But the settlement of a recent court case has shown not only that this kind of marketing is misleading Australian consumers; it's also a form of greenwashing. This is a practice by which a business makes its products or services seem more sustainable than they are, usually in a bid to create a positive brand image or improve their reputation.
According to a 2023 study by the Australian Competition and Consumer Commission, 57 per cent of businesses reviewed made concerning claims about their environmental credentials. This week, a case heard in the Federal Court of Australia offered us an up-close view of what this looks like in practice.
In 2023, the advocacy group Parents for Climate first filed a greenwashing case against EnergyAustralia, arguing that the company's 'Go Neutral' gas product misled the more than 400,000 Australian customers who signed up. That's because the carbon offsets purchased by the company did not prevent or undo harms caused by burning fossil fuels.
Loading
In response to case, this week EnergyAustralia apologised to its customers and acknowledged that 'offsets do not prevent or undo the harms caused by burning fossil fuels for a customer's energy use. Even with carbon offsetting, emissions released from burning fossil fuels for a customer's energy use still contribute to climate change.'
The acknowledgement from Australia's third-largest gas retailer that offsets don't neutralise pollution caused from burning gas marks a significant moment for corporate accountability. It also highlights the need for stricter rules on how companies use carbon credits and clearer guidelines around how they communicate this to customers and shareholders.
Last year, Climate Integrity also referred Qantas to the ACCC for greenwashing, arguing that its 'Fly Carbon Neutral' option, which customers purchase for an additional fee, misleads customers about the impact of flying. Red Energy has also been approached by Climate Integrity regarding its 'carbon neutral' gas product, which uses a similar marketing tactic as EnergyAustralia.
Hashtags
Try Our AI Features
Explore what Daily8 AI can do for you:
Comments
No comments yet...
Related Articles
Perth Now
29 minutes ago
- Perth Now
Qantas set for big fine after illegally sacking workers
Australia's largest airline is staring down the barrel of another nine-figure fine for illegally sacking more than 1800 workers during the COVID-19 pandemic. The Federal Court will hand down a hefty penalty to Qantas on Monday in what will be the latest court blow for the airline after a scandal-plagued recent tenure. Qantas outsourced its baggage handlers, cleaners and ground staff in 2020, in a move the court ruled was designed to curb union bargaining power in wage negotiations. It appealed the ruling to the High Court but the decision was not overturned, paving the way for Monday's penalty. The Transport Workers Union has sought the maximum penalty of $121 million, while Qantas has urged Justice Michael Lee to impose a "mid-range" penalty between $40 million and $80 million. Qantas will cop the fine on top of a $120 million compensation payment it has made to the ground staff for their economic loss, pain and suffering since their jobs were outsourced during the pandemic. It has argued the actions were a mistake, not a deliberate breach of the law. Qantas also sold tickets to cancelled flights for several years, triggering more legal turmoil and a $100 million fine after it was sued by the Australian Competition and Consumer Commission. The carrier, which was under the control of Alan Joyce at the time of the illegal sacking, lost billions of dollars during the pandemic, which decimated the aviation sector. But the former CEO did not address the scandal when he spoke at an aviation conference on Thursday, instead spruiking his ability to keep the airline afloat in unprecedented times. "But here's the real insight: resilience isn't a reaction … it's a decision made years in advance, often when it's uncomfortable, even unpopular," he said. "Qantas was the only major Australian airline not to go bankrupt during or after the pandemic … that wasn't luck. That was resilience."
Perth Now
29 minutes ago
- Perth Now
Growth can put spark into younger generations' future
Australia is failing its younger generations and the chair of the Productivity Commission believes a policymaker "growth mindset" can help. Danielle Wood says the generational bargain is in peril. "Young people today believe they won't live better lives than their parents did," the head of the nation's economic think tank will say at the National Press Club on Monday. "I'm worried too." Australians born in the 1990s were the first generation not to earn more than those in the decade before them. Now in their 30s, millennials are struggling to enter the property market "as policy choices have contributed to house prices growing much faster than incomes for the best part of three decades". This generation will also bear the brunt of climate change and the cost of decarbonisation, made worse by policymakers who have dodged the cheapest options, namely a national carbon price. Ms Wood, due to speak before the federal government's economic reform roundtable on Tuesday, says the challenges facing younger generations amount to productivity problems. About squeezing more from less, productivity allows wages to grow and helps "build things better and faster", such as homes and clean energy infrastructure. The commission has already spelled out a long list of recommendations to kickstart anaemic productivity growth in five separate reports released before the roundtable. Suggestions include reforming the corporate tax system and financial incentives for workplace training. Ms Wood will also call for an attitude shift at the highest levels of government policymaking and delivery. "This 'growth mindset' - an elevation of growth and the benefits it brings - has been missing from Australian policy for far too long," she said. She will point to the "growth of the regulatory burden" as symptomatic of a policy culture failing to prioritise growth. "Regulatory hairballs" are everywhere, she will argue, from 31-step approvals and licensing surveys for would-be Queensland cafe owners to "evermore stringent requirements for energy efficiency in the construction code". Australia's key economic stakeholders are set to gather in Canberra to propose solutions to the nation's ailing productivity as part of the government's hotly anticipated roundtable. Almost 30 groups representing farmers, pharmacies, universities and small, medium and large businesses have urged the government to reduce red tape and reform taxes without raising costs. "Australia is facing an uncertain future unless we fix the real challenges within our economy," Business Council of Australia chief executive Bran Black said. Environment groups have also urged the government to address concerns like nature law reforms. "Nature's economic role is too important to leave out of national reform conversations," Australian Land Conservation Alliance chief executive Jody Gunn said. "If we invest in the solutions it brings, we all win."
AU Financial Review
5 hours ago
- AU Financial Review
The week Chalmers can start to craft an economic legacy
The three-day Economic Reform Roundtable starting on Tuesday is Jim Chalmers' opportunity to make a fresh start on crafting an economic legacy to match the nation's great reforming treasurers. Before the 2022 election, Anthony Albanese promised Labor would seek to govern in the best reform traditions of the Hawke-Keating governments of the 1980s and 1990s. As treasurer, Paul Keating floated the Australian dollar, began winding down tariff protection, and reduced personal and company tax. As prime minister, he introduced the principle of enterprise bargaining into the industrial relations system.
