Is England's most exciting generation still to emerge?
"It is just unfair to the rest of the U21s in the world." That was how one social media post summed up the excitement around the quality of the England Under-21 squad for their March camp.Littered with talent from some of Europe's biggest clubs, the estimated transfer value of Lee Carsley's current Under-21 side surpasses £500m.That calculation makes this group of Young Lions even more valuable than the side who won the European Championship in 2023. Phrases such as "the new golden generation" and "the most exciting youngsters ever" have been thrown around a lot with young England sides.The positive response to Friday's Under-21 squad announcement also contrasted with some of the noise and negativity around Thomas Tuchel's recall of Jordan Henderson and Marcus Rashford to the senior side.BBC Sport takes a closer look.
'We want them to be better than the last group' - Carsley
The England Under-21 side of 2023 was a special one – but Carsley has challenged his new-look 2025 side to be even better."It's difficult to compare [2023 and 2025] at the minute," Carsley told BBC Sport reporter Alex Howell on Wednesday."We are looking at the last squad knowing what they did. To win six games and not concede any goals [in the entire tournament], I think that will be very hard to recreate. But it's a goal and it's a target. "That's the challenge we have put down for these players – we want them to be better than the last group, so hopefully they can be."Only four players from the Euro 2023 winners' group were in the squad selected by Carsley last week: Jarrad Branthwaite, Taylor Harwood-Bellis, Charlie Cresswell and Harvey Elliott.
The Under-21 Euro-winning squad of 2023
The Under-21 squad of 2025
How they compare
The 2023 Under-21 European champions (23-man squad) stats at the start of that tournament:Games played in all competitions - 2,378 (average per player 103)Premier League appearances - 702 (average per player 31)Premier League starts - 430 (average per player 19)Aston Villa's Jacob Ramsey had the most Premier League appearances with 91Current Under-21 team (25-man squad):Games played in all competitions - 2,442 (average per player 98)Premier League appearances - 573 (average per player 23 )Premier League starts - 355 (average per player 14)Liverpool's Harvey Elliott has the most Premier League appearances with 87
How this Under-21 crop compares to senior team
There were strong feelings on Friday after Thomas Tuchel revealed his first senior team, three hours prior to Carsley's Under-21 announcement.Football writer Henry Winter described as "bizarre" the recall of the experienced Jordan Henderson, who didn't make the squad for Euro 2024, while Troy Deeney questioned, external the return of Marcus Rashford, who has made one Premier League start since his move to Aston Villa.There were a number of "Tuchel out" texts sent in during the day's live text on the BBC Sport website and app, albeit tongue-in-cheek.The reveal of Carsley's side, on the other hand, was met with much more positivity."Admin, you've accidentally posted the first team squad" and "this is genuinely better than the first team" were just two of many replies to the announcement of the U21 squad on England's X page.But how do the two sides shape up as a whole, creatively?U21 (25-man squad):Goals - 91Assists - 34Total goal involvements - 125 (average per player: 5)Senior team (27-man squad):Goals - 139Assists - 105Total goal involvements - 244 (average per player: 9)Midfielders in the U21 squad:38 goal involvementsAn average of 4.4 per playerBorussia Dortmund's Jamie Gittens has the highest (14)Midfielders in the senior squad:115 goal involvementsAn average of 14.7 per playerJude Bellingham has the highest (22)*Including Morgan Gibbs-White who was later added
What is the current U21 squad worth?
According to the website Football Transfers' 'Estimated Transfer Value' algorithm, the current Under-21 squad is valued at £516.9m, almost double that of the group who won Euro 2023 (£280m at the start of that tournament).Champions League, Premier League and full international appearances, along with current contract status at club level, all contribute to the ETV rating that Football Transfers give to a player - and it is different to the market value players may be sold and bought for.The worth of the current team is boosted by many playing prominent roles at big clubs in the Premier League and across Europe.For example, the top three players with the highest values: Borussia Dortmund's Jamie Gittens (£59.7m), Manchester City's Rico Lewis (£53.6m) and Liverpool's Harvey Elliott (£40.2m).Crystal Palace midfielder Adam Wharton, 21, bucks that trend slightly, coming in as the fourth-most expensive player at £40.1m - but being part of the senior squad at Euro 2024 has significantly helped his value.Another big hitter, Arsenal's Ethan Nwaneri, is valued slightly lower at £28.2m because of his limited appearances and shorter contract status - but has a value that is expected to grow rapidly.It's worth noting that, the overall value of the Euro 2023 team has risen hugely, going from £280m in 2023 to £626m in 2025.Should this current 2025 squad see such a percentage increase, we will be looking at a set of young England players with a combined value of well over £1bn.
'Experience and a fresh introduction of talent'
BBC Sport's Alex Howell followed England's Euro 2023 U21 tournament in Georgia: "Carsley went into the 2023 tournament without a recognised centre-forward and - after losing Flo Balogun to the USA - played Anthony Gordon as his main striker."This time there are no such issues and in Liam Delap, he has many people's pick as senior captain and record goalscorer Harry Kane's successor."Newcastle United's Lewis Hall and Manchester City's Rico Lewis were left out of the last tournament and are still eligible for the whole qualifying campaign this time, but Hall now looks set to be the England senior team's first-choice left-back."The squad that won the competition in Georgia was accepted as being the best in a generation and the fact that they lifted the trophy cemented that."Ethan Nwaneri is having a breakthrough season at Arsenal and has been accelerated into the Under-21s and is joined in a midfield including Jobe Bellingham and Elliot Anderson, who is starring for Champions League-chasing Nottingham Forest."Adam Wharton, Jarrad Branthwaite, Taylor Harwood-Bellis and Lewis have dropped down after a taste of football with the senior squad."There are still four members of the group that won the Under-21 Euros in 2023 and with that experience, a fresh introduction of talent, it looks as this squad could be just as exciting."
Have your say - poll and comments
Jarell Quansah, Morgan Rogers, James Trafford and Myles Lewis-Skelly were all included in Tuchel's initial England squad but could all move back down into Carsley's group, as senior players return from injury.Trent Alexander-Arnold, Bukayo Saka, Cole Palmer and John Stones are among the names you'd expect to be involved in Tuchel's plans.So which squad excites you more?
Hashtags
Try Our AI Features
Explore what Daily8 AI can do for you:
Comments
No comments yet...
Related Articles
Scottish Sun
10 minutes ago
- Scottish Sun
Transfer news LIVE: Liverpool make £113m Wirtz offer, Inter inquire about Hojlund, Spurs target Frank as new manager
Tottenham released a lengthy statement explaining their decision to dismiss manager Ange Postecoglou: FOLLOWING a review of performances and after significant reflection, the Club can announce that Ange Postecoglou has been relieved of his duties. Ange joined us from Celtic in the summer of 2023 and oversaw a period of change on the pitch, returning us to the attacking brand of football that has traditionally been associated with the Club, while writing a new chapter in our history by leading us to UEFA Europa League glory in Bilbao last month - an achievement that will live with us all forever. We are extremely grateful to Ange for his commitment and contribution during his two years at the Club. Ange will always be remembered as only the third manager in our history to deliver a European trophy, alongside legendary figures Bill Nicholson and Keith Burkinshaw. However, the Board has unanimously concluded that it is in the best interests of the Club for a change to take place. Following a positive start in the 2023/24 Premier League (PL) season, we recorded 78 points from the last 66 PL games. This culminated in our worst-ever PL finish last season. At times there were extenuating circumstances - injuries and then a decision to prioritise our European campaign. Whilst winning the Europa League this season ranks as one of the Club's greatest moments, we cannot base our decision on emotions aligned to this triumph. It is crucial that we are able to compete on multiple fronts and believe a change of approach will give us the strongest chance for the coming season and beyond. This has been one of the toughest decisions we have had to make and is not a decision that we have taken lightly, nor one we have rushed to conclude. We have made what we believe is the right decision to give us the best chance of success going forward, not the easy decision. We have a talented, young squad and Ange has given us a great platform to build upon. We should like to express our gratitude to him. We wish him well for the future - he will always be welcome back at our home. News on the appointment of a new Head Coach will be announced in due course.
The Sun
10 minutes ago
- The Sun
Arsenal transfer news LIVE: Gunners ‘make contact' with Rogers, Rodrygo wage demands revealed, Martinelli exit possible
Isak tipped for Arsenal Jamie O'Hara has claimed that Arsenal should sign Newcastle star Aleksander Isak over Viktor Gyokeres or Benjamin Sesko. He told Grosvenor Sport: 'The obvious position to strengthen for Arsenal is a striker – they need to get one in. 'They need someone big and strong who can get them 20 goals a season. For me, Kai Havertz just isn't the man for the job. 'Alexander Isak, Viktor Gyokeres or Benjamin Sesko are the obvious choices in the striker department for them. However, the trouble with strikers who come over from other leagues is that they fail to hit the ground running – particularly players from the Bundesliga and Liga Portugal. There's a massive difference between playing there and in the Premier League. 'I think clubs should be buying Premier League proven players who have been doing it week in, week out already. That's why I think Manchester United have been quite clever by signing Bryan Mbuemo and Matheus Cunha – we all know they're going to work for them. 'With that in mind, if I were Arsenal, I'd go and get Isak. I know it will be hard because Newcastle are in the Champions League, but Arsenal are a bigger club than Newcastle and could definitely tempt him.'
The National
10 minutes ago
- The National
Who's going to step up and replace Scotland's golden generation?
The youthfulness of Steve Clarke's squad for the friendly internationals against Iceland and Liechtenstein this month has, what with Connor Barron, Kieron Bowie, Tommy Conway, Josh Doig, Billy Gilmour, Max Johnston, Lennon Miller, Nathan Patterson and James Wilson all receiving call ups, certainly been heartening. The members of that nonet have an average age of just 21. Every one of them has a huge amount to offer their country at international level for many seasons to come. They have numerous qualifying campaigns left in them and hopefully a few finals too. The same is true of the injured duo Ben Doak, the Liverpool winger, and Aaron Hickey, the Brentford full-back. It was also encouraging to see the SFA roll out their Cooperation System – which will see up to three Scotland-qualified prospects under the age of 21 move freely between Premiership and Championship parent clubs and lower league outfits on loan from the 2025/26 season onwards – this week. Read more: Similar agreements already exist in Austria, Belgium, Croatia, Hungary and Serbia. Hopefully the long overdue scheme will enable our best prospects, who have often been prevented from gaining much-needed competitive game time in the senior ranks simply because their presence is needed to satisfy homegrown player quotas in European competition, to make the difficult transition from the age-group ranks. That initiative was one of the main recommendations contained within the Transition Phase paper which was co-authored by Andy Gould, the SFA's chief football officer, and Chris Docherty, the governing body's head of men's elite strategy and was published last year. That report contained many worrying revelations, damning findings and stark conclusions about how poorly Scotland is doing in comparison with other countries of a similar size across Europe when it comes to producing talented young footballers who are capable of flourishing in the paid ranks. But if anybody needed reminding just how few professionals are emerging, Brown Ferguson, the former Alloa, Hamilton and Partick Thistle midfielder and the current Stenhousemuir assistant manager who is also the assistant regional performance manager at sportscotland and the high performance manager to Scottish Golf, took to X (formerly Twitter) to tell us. He posted a series of alarming statistics about the Premiership last season. Here are a few of the most startling. Just 31.46 per cent of players to start games in the top flight were Scottish. That is down from 45 per cent three years ago. On average, just 3.23 per cent of players kicking off on a Saturday are under 21, just four out of 132. No fewer than 20 team selections failed to contain a single Scot. Aberdeen and Celtic didn't start an under-21 player in the 2024/25 campaign. The SFA have identified these major problems and are endeavouring to address them. The SPFL clubs, who in the past have shown they are more concerned with self-interest than the greater good, have endorsed and embraced their plans. But is it too little too late? Our leading clubs face a raft of challenges running academies and bringing through youngsters who are capable of representing their first teams every year. The issues which Brexit and raids on their age-group squads by their wealthier English rivals have presented in recent years have been well documented in these pages. Far fewer footballers who are good enough are emerging. These are pretty exciting times in Scottish football with Brighton owner Tony Bloom buying a major stake in Hearts and a consortium comprising American billionaire Andrew Cavenagh and the San Francisco 49ers taking over Rangers. With Hibernian a far more formidable force than they were and Aberdeen lifted by their epic Scottish Cup triumph, next season promises to be a belter. Read more: But the focus in recent weeks has very much been on how much money every club will spend and who will be brought in this summer. The new powerbrokers seem unconcerned about doing their bit to help our national game by rearing homegrown heroes. Sure, wanting to promote youth has been mentioned in passing. It appears, though, fairly far down their list of priorities. Such is the money mad modern game. There is, with Barron, Bowie, Conway, Doig, Gilmour, Johnston, Miller, Patterson and Wilson as well as Lewis Ferguson, Jack Hendry, George Hirst, Andy Irving, Scott McKenna, Scott McTominay and John Souttar all in the current Scotland squad, no reason for Tartan Army footsoldiers to panic. (Image: Craig Williamson - SNS Group) Yet, the World Cup qualifying campaign which will get underway with away games against Denmark and Belarus in September may well prove to be the last that Che Adams, Stuart Armstrong, Ryan Christie, Lyndon Dykes, Craig Gordon, Grant Hanley, John McGinn, Kenny McLean, Andy Robertson, Lawrence Shankland and Kieran Tierney are involved in. Some will retire after it, others will stay on. But we are witnessing the last hurrah of a golden generation. Will those who come after that aforementioned group grace, as many of their predecessors did, the Premier League and the Champions League? The majority of them still have some way to go to scale the same heights as their compatriots. A few will manage it, but many won't. Clarke lamented how few goalkeepers he had to choose from when he announced his squad last month. He, or his successor, may be left bemoaning the lack of centre-backs, full-backs, holding midfielders, playmakers, wingers and strikers going forward. There must be a concerted collective effort from club owners and managers or qualification for the finals of major tournaments will be a thing of the past.
