Letters: I am disturbed by what happened on Oct. 7 and what's happening in Gaza
I have done a great deal of soul-searching and am trying to better educate myself about the long-standing Israeli-Palestinian conflict. That a well-planned pogrom could have laid siege on Israeli citizens under the watchful eye of the Israeli government was a shock.
But in the ensuing months and now years, I am deeply disturbed by the evisceration of the Gazan people through bombs, starvation, lack of medical care and a litany of other horrors. On both sides of the conflict, the death tolls are gut-wrenching, but comparing them seems flawed.
There are still Israeli hostages being held in Gaza. Prime Minister Benjamin Netanyahu continues to relentlessly attack the region, and to what end, leaves me shuddering. While participating recently in a Run For Their Lives walk, which advocates for the hostages held by Hamas, I was waging an internal battle about the multifaceted tragedy of the conflict. The perhaps dozen or so of us on this walk were dogged by a driver shouting pro-Palestinian phrases at us and at one point spitting on one of the participants. I did not think that individual was antisemitic so much as misinformed, angry and seeking a voice.
In the current and deafening climate of Immigration and Customs Enforcement raids, immigration protests and military intervention, how is it possible to hear one another?
Interestingly, I was given a 'Run for Their Lives' sign to carry during the walk. Scrawled on the other side was, 'Bibi it's time to resign.'
Several of us on the Run For Their Lives walk could not agree more.Regarding the op-ed 'The phrase 'Free Palestine' is freeing no one, but it is killing some of us' (June 10): The phrase 'Free Palestine' is killing nobody.
If we don't live in a world where basic human rights are valued pertaining to religious affiliation, ethnicity or color of skin, the phrase 'Free Palestine' shouldn't need pondering, since we all know what is freedom, especially when we are deprived of it, such as what is happening to the Palestinians.
Therefore, the phrase 'Free Palestine' is not a 'license to kill' Jews or Zionists, as Jay Tcath, president of the Jewish United Fund, writes.
However, Israelis and Americans have said these things: 'We are fighting human animals' (Defense Minister Yoav Gallant); 'There are no innocent civilians' in Gaza (hostage Mia Schem); 'We nuked the Japanese twice. … That needs to be the same here' (U.S. Rep. Randy Fine). Tcath doesn't condemn those words but tries to criminalize the 'Free Palestine' call for freedom.
For those of us who are not Palestinian, 'Free Palestine' is a demand to end the apartheid in the only democracy in Middle East. 'Free Palestine' is our plea for forgiveness from the innocent kids of Gaza who have been killed, maimed or starved to death with the use of U.S. taxpayer money.
'Free Palestine' begs the divine for mercy; we beg to be set free from the burden we can't continue to carry watching the demise of humanity in Gaza.
Free, free Palestine!Regarding the op-ed 'You can't separate anti-Zionism from antisemitism. Stop pretending you can' (June 12): In condemning violence against innocent Jewish people, my alderman, Brendan Reilly, equates anti-Zionism with antisemitism. In the same Tribune issue, I read the article 'Health officials: Palestinian death toll in war tops 55,000.'
Surely, there is a disconnect here. The violence against innocent people, whether Jews or Palestinians, whether in this nation or the Middle East, surely needs to cease.
To protest the oppressive and alienating policies of the present administration of Israel is to stand with many of my Jewish friends and neighbors, not to mention the Jewish members of my family.
For a path forward, I'm convinced that anti-Zionism, in its totalitarian and exclusionist form, must be distinguished from antisemitism and be held to account.Andy Shaw's op-ed should be required reading for all Chicagoans as well as the politicians he calls out ('Public officials must cut the fat before begging for taxpayer bailouts,' June 6). Shaw rightly calls out the bad players and their complete lack of integrity when dealing with their unsustainable bloated budgets.
Shaw should also include the majority of roughly 7,000 governmental bodies in Illinois; the state has unfathomable pension debt.
Additionally, we need an investigation into how much the lawsuits Illinois and Chicago are filing against the federal government are costing taxpayers. Gov. JB Pritzker and Mayor Brandon Johnson's complete lack of accountability and their smug statements regarding their broken budgets are just more disregard for their constituents. They need to stop pointing the finger at others and start governing; state lawmakers and aldermen need to do that as well.
All Illinoisans must wake up. Nothing is free, and we will all pay if drastic action is not taken now.
Can we all write in Shaw for governor or mayor?Andy Shaw's opinion piece could not be more on point.
Our mayor and governor try to scapegoat the president's policies for the financial disasters that decades of fiscal incompetence and mismanagement on the part of City Hall and Springfield have placed in the lap of taxpayers.
Elected officials in City Hall and Springfield have no compunction about spending the hard-earned wages of the citizenry however they see fit. But they don't need to worry; their personal financial futures are secured by the bloated pension system they have awarded themselves.
As in Washington, pork, waste, mismanagement, abuse and even outright fraud are too much a way of life that our elected officials have either created or turned a blind eye to. Too many are more interested in personal wealth and status than of actually serving the interests of the voting public.
Less than 20% of Chicago voters approve of Mayor Brandon Johnson, yet he is spending Chicagoans into an abyss that we may never escape from. Gov. JB Pritzker is increasingly politically divisive in a divided state where the interests of Chicago too often trump those of the rest of Illinois.
It's time for the electorate wake up. Voters should force the state and the city to enact term limits and recall measures to enable us to throw the bums out. That likely will never happen since those elected officials control the agenda, not the voters whom they should be serving.
Hashtags
Try Our AI Features
Explore what Daily8 AI can do for you:
Comments
No comments yet...
Related Articles
The Hill
30 minutes ago
- The Hill
ICE director says he'll ‘flood' Boston after Mayor Wu refuses to comply with feds
Acting Immigration and Customs Enforcement (ICE) Director Todd Lyons said on Wednesday that the federal law enforcement agency will 'flood the zone' with immigration agents in Boston after Mayor Michelle Wu (D) fired back at President Trump's administration over the city's sanctuary policies. 'We're definitely going to, as you've heard the saying, flood the zone, especially in sanctuary jurisdictions,' Lyons said in an interview on 'The Howie Carr Show.' 'Boston and Massachusetts decided to say that they wanted to stay [a] sanctuary. Sanctuary does not mean safer streets. It means more criminal aliens out and about the neighborhood. But 100 percent, you will see a larger ICE presence,' the acting ICE director told host Howie Carr. Wu said on Tuesday that Boston will not 'bow down to unconstitutional threats or unlawful coercion' from the federal government. 'The U.S. Attorney General asked for a response by today, so here it is: stop attacking our cities to hide your administration's failures,' the Boston mayor said. Her comments came after Attorney General Pam Bondi sent out letters to 32 state and local governments last week, known as 'sanctuary jurisdictions,' including Boston, saying they could have their federal funding dismissed or face legal action if they do not cooperate with the administration's immigration crackdown. Bondi set the deadline for a response from the city for Tuesday this week. 'We did Operation Patriot March, which yielded over 1,000 arrests, and now you're going to see more ICE agents come to Boston to make sure that we take these public threats out that she wants to let go back in the communities,' Lyons said. 'We're going to keep making America safe.' Boston enacted the Boston Trust Act in 2014, which bars local law enforcement from cooperating with federal immigration enforcement agents, particularly around arresting migrants in the country illegally who are on civil warrants.
CNN
an hour ago
- CNN
Netanyahu orders ‘immediate negotiations' to release hostages as Israel advances Gaza City operation
Israeli Prime Minister Benjamin Netanyahu says he has ordered negotiations for the release of all hostages and an end to the war in Gaza 'on terms acceptable to Israel.' The Israel military still intends to advance plans to take control of Gaza City, Netanyahu said. The Israeli leader's remarks came in a video recorded on Thursday, ahead of a high-level security meeting Netanyahu convened with defense chiefs and cabinet ministers focused on approving the operational plans to take Gaza City and 'decisively defeat Hamas.' Netanyahu stressed that Israel is now at a critical juncture. 'We are at the decisive stage,' he said, underlining that 'defeating Hamas and securing the release of all hostages go hand in hand.' This is the first time Netanyahu has publicly addressed the Gaza war ceasefire talks since Hamas responded positively earlier this week to the latest proposal put forth by mediators from Qatar and Egypt. Still, the Israeli prime minister did not say to whom he had given the order to start immediate negotiations and avoided referring to the current proposal framework, which begins with a 60-day ceasefire during which half of the remaining Israeli hostages are to be released. Israeli officials believe that 50 hostages remain in Gaza, at least 20 of whom are thought to be alive. In his recent public statements and official briefings, Netanyahu has emphasized that Israel is seeking a comprehensive agreement that would secure the release of all hostages and meet Israel's conditions for ending the war. He continues to push forward plans for a massive assault on Gaza City, and on Wednesday instructed the military to shorten the timeline of the operation – despite concern from residents of Gaza City, who have described Israel's plans as the 'beginning of a new war.' Israel has called up tens of thousands of reservists to take part in the impending military operation. The Israeli military is already on the outskirts of Gaza City, according to an Israel Defense Forces (IDF) spokesman. 'We are at the stage of decision,' Netanyahu said in a video address. 'Today I came to the Gaza Division to approve the plans that the (Israel Defense Forces) presented to me and to the minister of defense for taking control of Gaza City and defeating Hamas.' At the same time, Netanyahu refrained from making any official reference to the mediators' proposal, leaving open the possibility of a partial agreement. Two Israeli sources say that Netanyahu is managing the developments under tight secrecy and confidentiality.
Yahoo
an hour ago
- Yahoo
Netanyahu says he will push ahead with Gaza City takeover and renewed ceasefire talks
APTOPIX Israel Palestinians Gaza DEIR AL-BALAH, Gaza Strip (AP) — Israeli Prime Minister Benjamin Netanyahu said Thursday he will give final approval for the takeover of Gaza City while also restarting negotiations with Hamas aimed at returning all the remaining hostages and ending the war on Israel's terms. The wide-scale operation in Gaza City could start within days. Netanyahu's approval was expected during a meeting with senior security officials late Thursday, but no decision was announced before midnight in Jerusalem. Hamas said earlier this week that it had agreed to a ceasefire proposal from Arab mediators, which — if accepted by Israel — could forestall the offensive. The Israeli military has begun calling medical officials and international organizations in the northern Gaza Strip to encourage them to evacuate to the south ahead of the expanded operation. The military plans to call up 60,000 reservists and extend the service of 20,000 more. Israeli strikes, meanwhile, killed at least 36 Palestinians Thursday across Gaza, according to local hospitals. A renewed offensive could bring even more casualties and displacement to the territory, where the war has already killed tens of thousands and where experts have warned of imminent famine. Many Israelis fear the operation could also doom the remaining 20 or so living hostages taken by Hamas-led militants in the Oct. 7, 2023, attack that ignited the war. Gaza City operation could begin in days During a visit to the military's Gaza command in southern Israel, Netanyahu said he would approve the army's plans to retake Gaza City and had instructed officials 'to begin immediate negotiations' for the release of all hostages "and an end to the war on terms acceptable to Israel.' "These two things — defeating Hamas and releasing all our hostages — go hand in hand," he said. It appeared to mark Israel's first public response to the latest ceasefire proposal drawn up by Egypt and Qatar. Egyptian and Hamas officials say it is almost identical to an earlier one that Israel accepted before the talks stalled last month. The proposal would include the release of some of the hostages in exchange for Palestinians imprisoned by Israel, a pullback of Israeli forces and negotiations over a more lasting ceasefire. Israeli troops have already begun more limited operations in Gaza City's Zeitoun neighborhood and the built-up Jabaliya refugee camp, areas where they have carried out several previous large-scale raids over the course of the war, only to see militants later regroup. The military says it plans to operate in areas where ground troops have not yet entered and where it says Hamas still has military and governing capabilities. So far, there has been little sign of Palestinians fleeing en masse, as they did when Israel carried out an earlier offensive in Gaza City in the opening weeks of the war. The military says it controls around 75% of Gaza, and residents say nowhere in the territory feels safe. Protests in Israel and Gaza Hundreds gathered Thursday for a rare protest in Gaza City against the war and Israel's plans to support the mass relocation of Palestinians to other countries. Women and children held placards reading 'Save Gaza' and 'Stop the war, stop the savage attack, save us,' against a backdrop of destroyed buildings as Palestinian music played. Unlike in previous protests, there were no expressions of opposition to Hamas. 'We want the war on Gaza to stop. We don't want to migrate. Twenty-two months … it's enough. Enough death. Enough destruction,' said Bisan Ghazal, a woman displaced from Gaza City. In Israel, protesters marched Thursday night in Tel Aviv holding banners that read 'The people will bring back the hostages' and 'How much blood will be spilled?' Among the demonstrators was Dudu Dotan, who said Netanyahu is endangering the remaining hostages by moving forward with the planned Gaza City offensive. Of the 50 still being held in Gaza, Israel believes about 20 hostages are still alive. 'This way will not bring the hostages back,' Dotan said. "Every hostage he brought back, he brought back through deals. And every time he tried to bring them back with military force, he caused the hostages to be killed.' Plans for widening the offensive have also sparked international outrage, with many of Israel's closest Western allies — but not the United States — calling on it to end the war. Dozens killed across Gaza At least 36 Palestinians were killed Thursday by Israeli fire across the Gaza Strip, including 14 who were seeking humanitarian aid, according to local hospitals. The military says it only targets militants and blames civilian deaths on Hamas because it operates in densely populated areas. The Israeli military said it killed several armed militants in the Morag Corridor, a military zone where people seeking aid have repeatedly come under fire in recent weeks, according to witnesses and health officials. Nasser Hospital in southern Gaza had earlier reported that six people were killed in that area while seeking aid on Thursday. It was not possible to reconcile the two accounts. The Media Freedom Coalition, which promotes press freedoms worldwide, called Thursday for Israel to allow independent foreign news organizations access to Gaza. Aside from rare guided tours, Israel has barred international media during the war, in which at least 184 Palestinian journalists and media workers have been killed. 'Journalists and media workers play an essential role in putting the spotlight on the devastating reality of war,' said a statement signed by 27 of the coalition's member countries. Israeli strikes destroy evacuated tent camp Israeli airstrikes also destroyed a tent camp in Deir al-Balah, the only city in Gaza that has been relatively unscathed in the war and where many have sought refuge. Residents said the Israeli military warned them to flee shortly before the strikes set the camp ablaze, and there were no reports of casualties. Families, many with children, could later be seen sifting through the ashes for the belongings they had managed to take with them during earlier evacuations. Mohammad Kahlout, who had been displaced from northern Gaza, said they were given just five minutes to gather what they could and evacuate. 'We are civilians, not terrorists. What did we do, and what did our children do, to be displaced again?" The Gaza Health Ministry said Thursday that at least 62,192 Palestinians have been killed in the war. Another two people have died from malnutrition-related causes, bringing the total number of such deaths to 271, including 112 children, the Health Ministry said. The ministry is part of the Hamas-run government and staffed by medical professionals. It does not say whether those killed by Israeli fire are civilians or combatants, but it says around half were women and children. The U.N. and many independent experts consider its figures to be the most reliable estimate of wartime casualties. Israel disputes its toll but has not provided its own. Hamas-led militants started the war when they attacked Israel on Oct. 7, 2023, killing some 1,200 people, mostly civilians, and abducting 251. Most of the hostages have been released in ceasefires or other deals. Hamas says it will only free the rest in exchange for a lasting ceasefire and an Israeli withdrawal. ___ Abou Aljoud reported from Beirut, and Lidman reported from Jerusalem. Associated Press Writer Mari Yamaguchi contributed from Tokyo. ___ Follow AP's war coverage at
