B.C. NDP ex-minister urges Eby to walk back ‘astounding and disheartening' Bill 15
VICTORIA — Former British Columbia minister Melanie Mark is accusing Premier David Eby and his cabinet of 'turning their backs' on First Nations, local governments and environmentalists by passing controversial bills to fast-track infrastructure projects.
Mark, the first First Nations woman elected to B.C.'s legislature and a former cabinet colleague of Eby, says it's 'astounding and disheartening' behaviour by the government.
Both bills passed in the legislature Wednesday night, with Bill 15 that fast-tracks public and private infrastructure projects getting through thanks to a rare tiebreaking vote by Speaker Raj Chouhan.
Bill 14, which would speed up renewable energy projects and transmission lines, passed by four votes.
Critics say the bill undermines environmental standards and constitutional obligations to consult First Nations.
Mark says the government should reconsider the bills, saying in a statement that the province has walked back plans in the past.
She pointed to a controversial $789-million plan to rebuild the Royal B.C. Museum under former premier John Horgan, which the government ultimately suspended after intense criticism.
'It didn't go over as planned but former premier John Horgan had the fortitude to recalibrate, pause the project and mandate more meaningful consultation,' Mark says in a statement issued as the legislature was sitting to vote Wednesday night.
Mark says Eby can do the same in this situation, which would show the government honours the Crown's duty to consult with Indigenous people.
'Politics should not stand in the way of progressive policies. Trampling on Indigenous rights just ends up getting reversed in the highest courts — taxpayers will end up paying for this oversight,' Mark says in the statement.
'It's never too late to do the right thing.'
This report by The Canadian Press was first published May 29, 2025.
Hashtags
Try Our AI Features
Explore what Daily8 AI can do for you:
Comments
No comments yet...
Related Articles
CBC
28 minutes ago
- CBC
Some housing projects in limbo after N.S. rejection of Halifax's regional plan, mayor says
Halifax Mayor Andy Fillmore said Tuesday that the Nova Scotia government's rejection of the city's regional plan has paused some housing projects. "We've got projects, a significant number of units that have foundations poured or floors framed up that needed the regional plan amendments in the new version of the plan to be adopted in order to finish the project," Fillmore told reporters ahead of a staff presentation on the plan. "So we have a situation of limbo." Halifax's new plan to guide growth in the region was passed by council in June and would have changed a slew of bylaws and land-use planning documents across Halifax Regional Municipality, updating the 2014 regional plan that was last amended in May. But last week, Nova Scotia Municipal Affairs Minister John Lohr rejected it, saying certain environmental rules would stall development. Thousands of units impacted During the staff presentation Tuesday evening, Halifax planning director Jacqueline Hamilton told council the province's rejection of the plan impacts thousands of housing units. Hamilton said in just one category, the delay affects 12 projects creating 2,000 housing units. "That's sort of the order of magnitude … it's in the thousands of units certainly that are impacted. That's sort of what we know today, that's the caveat. There would be folks who wouldn't even be talking to us yet that would be awaiting that. I'm sure that's only the tip of the iceberg." Some councillors expressed disappointment that the province rejected the regional plan, which took five years to create. 'I think the baby went out with the bathwater' "I think the baby went out with the bathwater here, very clearly, in terms of housing over the sake of setbacks around lakes and EV chargers," said Coun. Sam Austin. "We could have amended those rather than rejecting the whole thing and creating this level of chaos. I don't think this was helpful or productive." Lohr said he was specifically concerned with two items in the plan: expanding development setbacks around watercourses to 30 metres from 20 and requiring electric vehicle parking spaces in new homes and apartments. "We felt that the focus of the plan needed to be building up density and building affordability in — and those were two examples of things that were not doing that," Lohr told CBC News on Monday. Coun. Tony Mancini said he took issue with the province's objection to the 30-metre setback. "Coun. Austin and I represent the City of Lakes. As Dartmouthians, to hear that, that's just a kick in the teeth that they don't care. It's the protection of our lakes," Mancini said. "Our lakes are stressed. They're stressed because of two things: climate change, and they're stressed because of development." Fillmore said he is working with the provincial government to try to understand its objections to the plan. He's hoping council can make changes that will make the plan "palatable" to the province. Construction group wants consultation In a letter to the municipality on Aug. 5, three days before Lohr's rejection, the Construction Association of Nova Scotia raised the same issues that the minister addressed. The group told CBC News those changes could drive up housing costs and said it wants to be consulted moving forward. "It's always unfortunate when you see one government level having to kind of delve into the business of another government. Having said that, you know, the plan that was put forward really had no consultation with industry in terms of broad-based consultation," Duncan Williams, president and CEO of the association, said Monday. Williams said he doesn't necessarily object to the new regional plan, but he has questions about how it would be implemented, how appeals would be processed and how the public would be informed about cost implications of the changes. Mayor optimistic, hoping to improve regional plan "There's an opportunity here to set up a working group that has industry professionals at the table so that we could properly give input [and] guide the process. We can't continue to build plans in a vacuum. And that's really what it feels like," he said. Fillmore said he's optimistic about conversations he's had with provincial ministers about getting the regional plan approved and getting homes built. The mayor said Halifax has to be able to accommodate growth up to one million people while protecting the environment and making sure homes can be built. "The truth is, we need to be building 8,000 homes a year for the next number of years, as many as five or six years. Last year, we barely cracked 3,000," Fillmore said. He said he still believes in the regional plan, but that he's always interested in improving a plan. He said his goal is to "get it done as quickly as possible." Hamilton said staff will come back to council once they get direction from the province on next steps. Fillmore said he hopes to have a revised plan to the province before the Christmas holiday recess.
CBC
28 minutes ago
- CBC
P.E.I. Humane Society is over its capacity, though most of the animals are not up for adoption
Fewer than 25 animals are up for adoption at the P.E.I. Humane Society, but the shelter is asking for the public to be patient because it's straining to care for more than 200. As CBC's Sheehan Desjardins reports, some are waiting to enter the adoption program… but others never will.
CBC
28 minutes ago
- CBC
The Avon River overpass was supposed to be done in 2023. Why isn't it finished?
The twinning project between Three Mile Plains and Falmouth was supposed to be completed almost two years ago. The CBC's Michael Gorman explains why, after so many delays, officials feel an end could be in sight.
