Aptness of civilians to bear arms is real issue
Assam Chief Minister Himanta Biswa Sarma recently announced that the State's 'original inhabitants and indigenous communities' can get licences to buy firearms to protect themselves in the face of insecurity over infiltration and life threats in areas bordering Bangladesh where government presence is minimal. The Opposition has pointed out that the decision would show the security infrastructure along the international border in a poor light and even give a fillip to gun culture. In communally sensitive Assam, where Assembly elections are due early next year, the announcement has sparked a debate.
The policy raises some eyebrows. The government did not say if it had first considered strengthening border forces before announcing the policy. Protecting people's lives is a core function of the State, and the policy could be misinterpreted as ineffective governance and policing in the border areas. Secondly, vetting licence seekers to exclude the unoriginal and the non-indigenous could fuel fresh confusion in Assam amid official attempts to weed out illegal Bangladeshi immigrants. Thirdly, the stringent police verification process for granting licences to 'genuine' citizens could raise allegations of discrimination. Fourthly, many people in these areas still struggle to access basic amenities, and it's unrealistic to expect them to afford an expensive firearm, undergo training, and acquire the cognitive skills necessary to understand the rules of self-defence. The well-off among them would easily bear arms, even creating an 'armed elite' within society.
Try Our AI Features
Explore what Daily8 AI can do for you:
Comments
No comments yet...
Related Articles
News18
an hour ago
- News18
What Is Dhaka's ‘Mini Pakistan'? Home To Bangladesh's Stranded Pakistanis
Last Updated: A viral video has reignited focus on the forgotten lives of Bangladesh's "Stranded Pakistanis". Tucked away in Dhaka's Mohammadpur area is a densely packed settlement known locally as 'Mini Pakistan'. It is a reference to the Geneva Camp, home to thousands of Urdu-speaking Muslims and Muhajir or Bihari Muslim settlements. A video of the camp shot by influencer RK Sohan went viral bringing attention to the deplorable conditions of the camp. The camp consists of many Urdu-speaking Muslims from Bihar and other parts of India moved to East Pakistan (now Bangladesh). They are referred to as 'Stranded Pakistanis" or 'Biharis' by Bangladesh government. A recent report by Bangladesh's Daily Star reported that the settlement now sees regular clashes between armed gangs. These gangs have reportedly stolen guns from police during the recent regime change and clashes that erupted across the country between protesters and police. The protests which led to the regime change was partly hijacked by Islamists who continue to take advantage of the fragile law and order situation of the country. Why Is Geneva Camp Called Mini Pakistan? During the 1971 Bangladesh Liberation War, most Biharis supported West Pakistan. This made them targets of hostility during and after the war. When Bangladesh became independent, these communities were left stateless and were rejected by both Pakistan and Bangladesh. The Geneva Camp was established by the Red Cross after the war to house these displaced people. It remains one of the most densely populated and underdeveloped urban slums in the city. Locals and outsiders colloquially call it 'Mini Pakistan" because of the population's cultural affinity to Pakistan, especially language (Urdu), food and dress, and due to their historical loyalty to Pakistan. What Is The Legal Status Of Its Residents? For decades, the residents were stateless. In 2008, the Bangladesh High Court ruled that those born in the country after 1971 are Bangladeshi citizens and can vote. Despite this, many still live in limbo as they lack proper documentation, economic opportunities and social integration. The term 'Mini Pakistan" is sometimes used derogatorily, especially by Bangladeshi nationalists. Residents of Geneva Camp often feel marginalized and excluded, though a new generation identifies more with Bangladesh. Pakistan has been largely reluctant to take them back, despite initial promises post-1971. First Published: June 03, 2025, 18:57 IST
India.com
2 hours ago
- India.com
What If China Stops Brahmaputra Water To India?: After Chickens Neck, Assam CM Sarma Counters Pakistan-China Threat
What If China Stops Brahmaputra? When it comes to blunt replies, Assam Chief Minister Himanta Biswa Sarma leaves many politicians behind. He is known for expressing his views very clearly, without considering any ramification. When Bangladesh raised the Chicken's Neck - Siliguri corridor issue, Sarma hit back by sharing a map of two chicken necks that Dhaka should be worrying about. Now, Sarma has reacted to Pakistan-China's joint threat related to the Brahmaputra river. Notably, India has suspended the Indus Water Treaty following the Pakistan-backed Pahalgam terror attack. Since then, Pakistanis have been raising the Brahmaputra river issue. Reacting to Pakistan's claim, CM Himanta Biswa Sarma took to social media to counter myths with facts. "What If China Stops Brahmaputra Water to India? A Response to Pakistan's New Scare Narrative. After India decisively moved away from the outdated Indus Waters Treaty, Pakistan is now spinning another manufactured threat: What if China stops the Brahmaputra's water to India?' said Sarma highlighting the question. He further said, "Let's dismantle this myth — not with fear, but with facts and national clarity. Brahmaputra: A River That Grows in India — Not Shrinks. China contributes only ~30–35% of the Brahmaputra's total flow — mostly through glacial melt and limited Tibetan rainfall." Sarma said that the remaining 65–70% of Brahmaputra water is generated within India, thanks to torrential monsoon rainfall in Arunachal Pradesh, Assam, Nagaland, and Meghalaya; major tributaries like Subansiri, Lohit, Kameng, Manas, Dhansiri, Jia-Bharali, Kopili and additional inflows from the Khasi, Garo, and Jaintia Hills via rivers such as Krishnai, Digaru, and Kulsi. "At the Indo-China border (Tuting): Flow is ~2,000–3,000 m³/s. In Assam plains (e.g., Guwahati): Flow swells to 15,000–20,000 m³/s during monsoon. The Brahmaputra is not a river India depends on upstream — it is a rain-fed Indian river system, strengthened after entering Indian territory," said the Assam CM. Responding to Pakistan, Sarma said, "Even if China were to reduce water flow (unlikely as China has never threatened or indicated in any official forum), it may actually help India mitigate the annual floods in Assam, which displace lakhs and destroy livelihoods every year. Meanwhile, Pakistan — which has exploited 74 years of preferential water access under the Indus Waters Treaty — now panics as India rightfully reclaims its sovereign rights." Sarma said that Pakistan must not forget that Brahmaputra is not controlled by a single source and is powered by the country's geography, monsoon, and civilisational resilience. Chairman of the Brahmaputra Board, Dr Ranbir Singh, pointed out that the Brahmaputra Basin is the only water-surplus river basin in India, with the rest being water-deficient. "With this dam in China, are we looking at a water-deficient Brahmaputra river basin?" he wondered.
NDTV
2 hours ago
- NDTV
Bangladesh's Muhammad Yunus Has A New Social Media Strategy To Counter Critics
Dhaka: The chief adviser of the interim government in Bangladesh has been busy. From official trips abroad to meetings with political parties that are putting pressure on him to hold elections, Muhammad Yunus finds himself increasingly cornered as he runs a government without a political mandate derived from free and fair elections - the cornerstone of a democracy. But a glance at this X timeline reveals how his office has been busy countering news publications on the functioning of his government or the situation in Bangladesh including the security situation. On Tuesday morning the X handle of Bangladesh's chief adviser posted an article about a column published in an Indian publication that opined on how Bangladesh has effectively fallen under the control of Islamist extremists who use Muhammad Yunus's international reputation to cover up their actions. Mr Yunus's response - The op-ed "contains multiple false and unsubstantiated narrative." The office of the Chief Adviser has, over the last few days, publicly denied multiple reports that have been published mostly in India. On reports of actions of Islamic extremists and radicals, subservience to the Pakistani Army and speculation that he may flee Bangladesh, Muhammad Yunus says, "Such claims are entirely false and unsubstantiated or based on opinion rather than verified facts." Muhammad Yunus has been focusing on denying news reports from abroad as concerns remain about the situation in Bangladesh where terror accused have been released, and hardline and Islamic radicals have been emboldened. Indian author M.D. Nalapat penned an Op-ed "Meltdown in Bangladesh Gaining Speed," published in The Sunday Guardian Live on June 1, 2025, which contain multiple false and unsubstantiated narrative. Nalapat suggests that Bangladesh has effectively fallen under the control of… — Chief Adviser of the Government of Bangladesh (@ChiefAdviserGoB) June 3, 2025 Muhammad Yunus's X handle has also been clarifying on reports about Bangladesh on social media. "Some social media accounts falsely claim that 20,000 Bangladeshi militants have joined the Arakan Army, recruited through a US-backed network and supplied with weapons and training. They allege funding comes from Jamaat-linked NGOs and foreign-owned garment companies in Bangladesh," Muhammad Yunus said. "However, these claims are entirely false and politically motivated to spread fear and confusion. There are no credible reports, evidence, or official statements supporting the existence of such a large militant recruitment," Yunus said. Some social media accounts falsely claim that 20,000 Bangladeshi militants have joined the Arakan Army, recruited through a U.S.-backed network and supplied with weapons and training. They allege funding comes from Jamaat-linked NGOs and foreign-owned garment companies in… — Chief Adviser of the Government of Bangladesh (@ChiefAdviserGoB) June 3, 2025 Muhammad Yunus also seems to be keeping a close eye on columns being written about the political plays being made in Bangladesh especially when it comes to pieces about him or statements that link him to foreign powers. "...these allegations are entirely unfounded and appear carefully crafted to propagate the narrative of the fallen Awami League. The facts tell a very different story: Dr. Yunus is by no means a pawn of foreign powers. There is no credible evidence to suggest that the interim government is serving foreign interests, and the article's author fails to present any proof. Bangladesh continues to maintain friendly diplomatic relations worldwide while firmly safeguarding its sovereignty and dignity," Mr Yunus said in yet another post on social media while defending his regime's actions. "Contrary to claims that Dr. Yunus is facilitating attacks on minorities, the interim cabinet has acted decisively to contain communal unrest, rather than incite it. After Sheikh Hasina's ouster, the interim government publicly condemned sectarian violence and instructed security forces to protect all communities with maximum restraint. The July movement itself was not a CIA-ISI conspiracy but a spontaneous outpouring of anger by students and ordinary citizens against Sheikh Hasina's brutal, authoritarian rule, which had suppressed democracy and led to widespread violence," Mr Yunus said in the post. On May 30, Indian columnist Omer Ghazi published a highly controversial and propagandistic article in First Post, targeting Bangladesh's Chief Adviser, Dr. Muhammad Yunus. Ghazi accused Dr. Yunus of surrendering to foreign powers and accused him of being responsible for… — Chief Adviser of the Government of Bangladesh (@ChiefAdviserGoB) June 1, 2025 Keeping with the practice of denying or dismissing news reports as false, in a post on May 28, Muhammad Yunus said, "Recently, several social media accounts have falsely claimed that Myanmar declared Bangladesh's Ambassador, Md. Monowar Hossain, 'Persona Non-Grata' and ordered him to leave the country immediately. These posts also allege that Myanmar's Ministry of Foreign Affairs issued a statement accusing the ambassador of repeated "interference in internal affairs" and engaging in "activities inconsistent with diplomatic norms." In this case Muhammad Yunus blamed the Awami League and "some individuals of Indian origin". Investigation into the origin of these rumours reveals connections to deposed Awami League activists and some individuals of Indian origin spreading misinformation. We urge everyone to verify information carefully and be cautious before sharing unverified rumours," Yunus said in the social media post. False Claim: Myanmar Has Not Declared Bangladesh Ambassador 'Persona Non-Grata' Recently, several social media accounts have falsely claimed that Myanmar declared Bangladesh's Ambassador, Md. Monowar Hossain, 'Persona Non-Grata' and ordered him to leave the country immediately.… — Chief Adviser of the Government of Bangladesh (@ChiefAdviserGoB) May 28, 2025 A day earlier, Mr Yunus again turned his focus on Indian mainstream media outlets, saying "Recently, several Indian mainstream media outlets have been persistently spreading false and misleading propaganda involving the Bangladesh Army and the Chief Advisor of the interim government. This disinformation campaign has also proliferated widely on social media platforms, especially X (formerly Twitter). These fabricated stories rely heavily on anonymous sources and lack any credible evidence or verifiable attribution." Recently, several Indian mainstream media outlets have been persistently spreading false and misleading propaganda involving the Bangladesh Army and the Chief Advisor of the interim government. This disinformation campaign has also proliferated widely on social media platforms,… — Chief Adviser of the Government of Bangladesh (@ChiefAdviserGoB) May 27, 2025 Bangladesh's interim government led by Muhammad Yunus has been criticised over exceeding its mandate and overreach. While the interim government was installed with the mandate of reforms and elections to ensure a democratically elected government is able to take charge, it has been involved in major foreign policy shifts, economic affairs and even issues like a Rohingya corridor which has long term implications for Bangladesh's security. As critics question the radical shifts being introduced by the interim government without having a mandate, the interim government led by Yunus seems keen on responding to the news reports, going to extent of tagging the authors and publications in the posts.
