SC raps Samay Raina, 4 others over remarks on disabled persons
The Supreme Court on Monday summoned five social media influencers and stand-up comics including Samay Raina over offensive and derogatory remarks made against persons with disabilities, even as it stressed that any speech that demeans a community or class of persons will be curtailed.
The court considered the issue in a petition filed by Cure SMA Foundation working for the welfare of disabled persons, that produced as evidence, videos where comedian Raina and four others were seen making fun of persons with disabilities.
Issuing notice on the petition to the Centre and Maharashtra government, the court directed the Mumbai Police Commissioner to ensure the presence of the five in court on the next date failing which the bench threatened to order coercive steps to secure their presence. Besides Raina, the other persons summoned by the court are Vipul Goyal, Balraj Paramjit Singh Ghai, Sonali Thakkar, and Nishant Jagdish Tanwar.
Raina is no stranger to controversy; he hosted India's Got Latent, the show in which podcaster and influencer Ranveer Allahbadia made distasteful and obnoxious comments
The bench headed by justice Surya Kant took strong objection to 'irresponsible statements' made by the five: 'There are people who seek fundamental right of free speech. If there is such freedom, then we will curtail any speech which demeans another community.'
The order said, 'The Commissioner of Police, Mumbai is directed to serve notice on the respondents (Raina and others) to ensure their presence in court failing which coercive steps will be taken to secure their presence.'
The petition argued by senior advocate Aparajita Singh said that while the foundation is a votary of free speech, such speech should respect other communities as the effect of making such statements has a very damaging effect on persons with disabilities and their families. According to her, the offensive expressions used to mock at disabled persons amounts to 'hate speech' which does not deserve any protection under right to free speech, a constitutionally guaranteed right under Article 19(1)(a).
The bench, also comprising justice N Kotiswar Singh, said, 'On one hand, through judicial and legislative measures, we want to integrate such persons into the society, and you damage it by passing such statements.'
The court said that it was keen to lay down guidelines, both punitive and preventive, to ensure persons indulging in such speech are not spared. 'We would like to lay down some guidelines to prevent such persons from indulging in irresponsible behaviour. We need to think about having remedial and punitive steps which can be preventive in nature, that can be taken against such persons,' the bench observed.
The court requested Attorney General R Venkatramani to assist the court on the next date 'having regard to the sensitivity and importance of the issue' and permitted the Union government, state of Maharashtra, and Aparajita Singh to make suggestions in this regard.
The petitioner initially filed an application before the top court last month in a case where Allahbadia approached the court to club criminal cases against him pending in Assam and Maharashtra after he made some offensive comments on a show 'India's Got Latent'.
SMA Foundation said that in the same show, Raina made fun of a blind and cross-eyed persons and upon deeper probe, the organisation came across multiple instances where persons with disabilities were ridiculed and humiliated on this show.
The petitioner attached video clips of statements made by the other four persons 'denigrating' persons with disabilities.
The petition sought a two-fold relief - guidelines to regulate the broadcast of such online content which violates the right to life and dignity of the persons with disabilities, and a positive obligation on the government and private entities to adopt a unique standard of representation of persons with disability in the online domain.
Although there is a regulatory framework governing the broadcasting of online content, under the Information Technology (Intermediary Guidelines and Digital Media Ethics Code) Rules, 2021, the Code of Conduct and the Programme Code provided under Rule 6 of the Cable Television Network Rules, 1994, the petition pointed out that such instances point to the yawning gap between the existence of regulations and their implementation.
Try Our AI Features
Explore what Daily8 AI can do for you:
Comments
No comments yet...
Related Articles
Hans India
13 minutes ago
- Hans India
India aiming for net zero emissions at major ports by 2047: Sarbananda Sonowal
New Delhi: Sustainability is at the heart of our maritime policy, and we are committed to achieving net zero emissions at major ports by 2047, said Union Minister of Ports, Shipping and Waterways, Sarbananda Sonowal on Saturday. During an interaction with students of the Blue MBA Executive Programme at Copenhagen Business School (CBS), Sonowal outlined India's strategy to transform its maritime infrastructure through flagship initiatives like the Sagarmala Programme and Maritime Amrit Kaal Vision 2047. 'These efforts aim to build modern, multimodal logistics systems while prioritising clean energy, digital shipping and green port development,' the Minister added. He described India as a 'compelling story of inclusive, innovative, and sustainable growth,' and said that the country's vision is to become the global epicentre for green shipping and clean trade corridors. 'The discussion also covered India's ambitious goals for maritime decarbonisation, including the use of green hydrogen and cutting-edge digital solutions,' the Union Minister stated. Highlighting the growing cooperation between India and Denmark in green maritime technologies, Sonowal praised Denmark for its global leadership in energy efficiency and digital shipping. He said India, under the leadership of Prime Minister Narendra Modi, is modernising its maritime sector through policy reform, infrastructure investment, and international collaboration. 'India's vast coastline and heavy reliance on sea trade -- over 90 per cent of its volume -- make the maritime sector a central pillar of its economic strategy,' the minister noted. He also shared the government's plans to scale up maritime education and workforce, aiming to increase India's maritime professionals from 7.86 million to nearly 40 million by 2047. He highlighted a sharp rise in women seafarers, from just 1,699 in 2014 to over 7,000 in 2024, as a sign of the country's focus on diversity and inclusion. His visit was marked by a detailed conversation with maritime professionals and faculty members, focusing on India's commitment to sustainable development and economic growth. The event underlined India's deepening ties with Denmark and its increasing engagement with global academic and professional institutions in the maritime field.
Time of India
19 minutes ago
- Time of India
Amit Shah felicitates Chhattisgarh police officers for historic success in anti-Naxal operation
RAIPUR: Union Home Minister Amit Shah on Saturday met with Chhattisgarh's senior police and intelligence officers who played a pivotal role in recent anti-Naxal operations in LWE affected regions. Shah felicitated Chhattisgarh Director General of Police Arun Dev Gautam, Vivekananda Sinha, additional DG (Anti-Naxal ops), P Sundarraj, Bastar range inspector general of police and three SPs. The meeting took place in New Delhi, where Shah personally congratulated the team on what is being hailed as one of the most significant counter-insurgency successes ever in the fight against Left-Wing Extremism. Chhattisgarh chief minister Vishnu Deo Sai and deputy CM Vijay Sharma were present during the meeting. In a post on social media platform X, Shah wrote, 'Met the officers who played a crucial role in the recent anti-Naxal operations and congratulated them on the historic success of these operations. I am eager to meet the brave jawans who made these operations successful with their courage and will soon visit Chhattisgarh to meet them. Modi government is committed to freeing India from the menace of Naxalism.' Shah's remarks come in the wake of a major operation conducted from May 18-21 in Abujhmarh region — one of the most remote and challenging terrains in central India. In a critical encounter on May 21, security forces gunned down 27 Maoists, including the CPI (Maoist) General Secretary and Polit Bureau member Basavaraju alias Gaganna. He was one of the most wanted Maoist leaders in the country. A substantial cache of arms and ammunition was also recovered. Security forces involved in the operation included District Reserve Guard (DRG) units from Narayanpur, Dantewada, Kondagaon, and Bijapur districts, working in coordination under the leadership of top police officials. During the felicitation event, Shah also honoured Prabhat Kumar, SP Narayanpur, Jitendra Yadav, Bijapurand Shalabh Sinha, SP Bastar, in presence of CM Sai, state home minister Sharma, Union Home Secretary Govind Mohan, Director of Intelligence Bureau Tapan Deka, and several senior officers from the Centre and state security apparatus. Chief Minister Vishnu Deo Sai in a message to Shah said, 'It is due to your strong resolve and inspiring leadership that historic success is becoming possible in the fight against Naxalism in Chhattisgarh. This battle to end red terror is at a decisive turning point, and by March 2026, the complete eradication of Maoism from both the state and the nation is certain. Our officers and brave personnel of the security forces are engaged in the mission to make the country free of Naxalism with unmatched courage and valour.
The Print
34 minutes ago
- The Print
Preventive detention extraordinary power of state that must be used sparingly: SC
'Therefore, the order of detention dated June 20, 2024, and the impugned judgment dated September 4, 2024, passed by the High Court of Kerala at Ernakulam are hereby set aside. In the attending facts and circumstances of this case, the appeal is allowed,' the bench said in its order passed on Friday. A bench of justices Sanjay Karol and Manmohan said the circumstances pointed out in the order by the detaining authority may be ground enough for the state to approach the competent courts for cancellation of bail in cases against him, but it cannot be said that the same warranted his preventive detention. New Delhi, Jun 7 (PTI) Preventive detention is an extraordinary power in the hands of the state that must be used sparingly, said the Supreme Court as it set aside an order to detain a man indulging in money lending in Kerala. Noting that the power of preventive detention finds recognition in the Constitution under Article 22(3)(b), the bench said, 'The provision for preventive detention is an extraordinary power in the hands of the state that must be used sparingly. It curtails the liberty of an individual in anticipation of the commission of further offence(s), and therefore, must not be used in the ordinary course of nature.' The bench said the contention of the detaining authority that the detainee, Rajesh, who used to run a private financing company called 'Rithika Finance', was violating the conditions of bail imposed upon him in the cases that have been considered for passing the order of detention. It said that pertinently, no application has been filed by the respondent in any of the four cases, alleging violation of such conditions, if any, and moreover, have not even been spelt out during the hearing of the case filed by his wife against the Kerala High Court order, which affirmed the preventive detention order of the Palakkad district magistrate. 'Keeping in view the above expositions of law, we have no doubt that the order of detention cannot be sustained. The circumstances pointed out in the order by the detaining authority may be ground enough for the state to approach the competent courts for cancellation of bail, but it cannot be said that the same warranted his preventive detention. 'We clarify that if such an application for cancellation of the detainee's bail is made by the respondent – state, the same must be decided uninfluenced by the observations made hereinabove,' the bench noted. It referred to the provisions of the Kerala Anti-Social Activities (Prevention) Act, 2007, and said that the object of the statute was to provide for effective prevention of certain anti-social activities in the state. The bench said Section 2(j) of the state law defines 'goonda' as a person who indulges in activities that are harmful to the maintenance of public order, either directly or indirectly, and includes persons who are bootleggers, counterfeiters, drug offenders, and loan sharks, among others. The bench also said that under Section 3 of the Act, the district magistrate so authorised or the government may pass an order directing detention of a 'known goonda' to prevent commission of antisocial activities within the state of Kerala. 'Coming to the attending facts and circumstances, we are of the considered view that the exercise of power under Section 3 of the Act was not justified in law,' the top court said, as it noted four cases lodged under the Kerala Money Lenders Act, 1958, cited by the police for recommending preventive detention to the district magistrate. The police stated that the detainee was a 'notorious goonda' in the district and a threat to the society at large. Aggrieved by the order of his detention dated June 20, 2024, Rajesh's wife filed a writ petition before the Kerala High Court assailing the order and praying for a writ of habeas corpus to the state against the 'illegal' detention of her husband. The high court on September 4 last year affirmed the order of preventive detention. Aggrieved by the order, the detainee's wife moved the top court challenging the decision. On December 10, 2024, the top court ordered the detainee to be released as his maximum period of detention under the Act was over. PTI MNL ARI This report is auto-generated from PTI news service. ThePrint holds no responsibility for its content.
