logo
Court hears nurse raised concerns that flow of oxygen at low level for first 11 minutes of baby's life

Court hears nurse raised concerns that flow of oxygen at low level for first 11 minutes of baby's life

Irish Times02-07-2025
A nurse who was involved in the resuscitation of a baby who died five days later has said she was 'extremely concerned' after finding that oxygen flow through respiratory equipment used was initially at a low level.
A sitting of Dublin District Coroner's Court heard on Wednesday that nurse Elaine Sheehy raised concerns that the flow of oxygen was at a low level for the first 11 minutes of Aaron Cullen's life.
Ms Sheehy, who resigned from her post at the Midland Regional Hospital Portlaoise in October 2016 and took up a post elsewhere, was on duty at the Special Care Baby Unit when she was asked to urgently attend resuscitation efforts.
Aaron had been born by emergency Caesarean section on May 4th, 2016, at 35 weeks gestation. The inquest heard he was 'extraordinarily' unwell after his birth and was 'gasping' for breath, witnesses said.
READ MORE
He suffered from severe persistent pulmonary hypertension, a condition in which a baby fails to transition from antenatal circulation.
Two attempts to intubate him after birth by a paediatric registrar were unsuccessful. Between attempts, a Neopuff resuscitator was used in an effort to pump his lungs.
Aaron was 11 minutes old by the time Ms Sheehy arrived, she said, recalling the mask being used to ventilate him being too large, as it was for full-term babies.
It was then switched to a preterm mask, which was readily available in the room, to ensure an airtight seal so no gas could escape.
Ms Sheehy further recalled being 'extremely upset and concerned' at the fact that she had to increase the oxygen flow of the Neopuff used during resuscitation.
Although she could not be certain, she said she either had to turn on the flow of gas providing oxygen entirely or she at least needed to it turn up to recommended levels.
Ms Sheehy, who became visibly upset while giving evidence, said she found the fact that she had to adjust the flow 'very upsetting'.
While Prof Colm O'Donnell, a consultant neonatologist and expert witness who reviewed the case for the coroner, said he could not definitively say whether or not the Neopuff gas flow was turned on, it was his opinion that it was.
He cited several staff being in attendance before Ms Sheehy arrived, saying they reported checking the equipment before Aaron's delivery.
He also noted that although Aaron did not breathe spontaneously, his heart rate increased from less than 60bpm to over 100bpm, which indicated the machine had some effect.
Prof O'Donnell said Aaron's lungs were 'very poorly compliant', adding that it would have been 'extremely difficult' to aerate his lungs during mask ventilation as opposed to intubation, which the inquest heard was not achieved until 21 minutes after his birth.
While sooner intubation would have allowed for an immediate and better supply of oxygen, he did not believe this, or a proper fitting mask from the beginning, would have changed the outcome.
Ms Sheehy disclosed concerns to the hospital's interim director of midwifery, Maureen Revilles, after learning of Aaron's death, which took place at the Coombe hospital on May 9th.
Ms Revilles, who said she expected Ms Sheehy to be a witness at Aaron's initial inquest due to the disclosure, insisted that she said she had to turn on the machine.
This was later 'revised' to her having to turn up the flow, she said.
Evidence concerning Ms Sheehy's concerns was not made available to coroner Dr Myra Cullinane at the time of the original inquest, which returned a narrative verdict.
The evidence was secured by his mother, Claire Cullen, through Freedom of Information requests, prompting a fresh inquiry.
An inquest verdict is due to be returned on Thursday.
Orange background

Try Our AI Features

Explore what Daily8 AI can do for you:

Comments

No comments yet...

Related Articles

Food company at centre of listeriosis outbreak was hit with two prohibition orders in recent weeks
Food company at centre of listeriosis outbreak was hit with two prohibition orders in recent weeks

The Journal

time7 hours ago

  • The Journal

Food company at centre of listeriosis outbreak was hit with two prohibition orders in recent weeks

BALLYMAGUIRE FOODS WAS served with two prohibition orders in the weeks leading up to a mass recall of ready meals and side dishes that it produces. These prohibition orders were part of the same investigation that ultimately led to the recall of over 140 food items this week. A prohibition order serves to prohibit the sale of an impacted product, either temporarily or permanently. Following these prohibition orders on 30 June and 18 July, a recall notice was issued to consumers and retailers. These recall notices were also listed on the FSAI website and an alert was sent to the media. Food items are often removed from shelves due to recall notices issued by the FSAI, but such notices tend to involve only certain batches. In a statement today, Ballymaguire Foods said that all of its products have been withdrawn and that the company has suspended all production. The company added that production at the affected facility 'will only recommence once the relevant authorities are satisfied'. The move comes after a total of 142 different ready-made meals and side dishes which are made and distributed by Dublin-based Ballymaguire Foods and sold in major supermarkets across Ireland were recalled due to the possible presence of bacteria called Listeria monocytogenes. Medical professionals are currently investigating the death of an adult with confirmed listeriosis. Nine cases of listeriosis had been confirmed as of Tuesday. Previous recall notices On 30 June , the FSAI issued recall notices on various branded Bacon & Cabbage Dinners produced by Ballymaguire Foods due to the possible presence of Listeria monocytogenes. These included meals produced for SuperValu, Tesco, and Centra. A HSE inspector was of the opinion that the various Bacon & Cabbage meals were 'injurious to health and unfit for human consumption' and directed that the ready meals be recalled. Advertisement Close to three weeks later, on 18 July , Ballymaguire Foods was again served a prohibition, with a recall notice being issued for various pre-packaged 'Turkey and Ham Dinners', which were sold in Centra and Supervalu. In a statement to The Journal , the FSAI said these two recall notices are 'part of the same investigation that is underway and which has resulted' in the recall of over 140 food items this week. A spokesperson for the FSAI added: 'As this is an on-going investigation no further details can be released.' 'Corrective actions' In a statement today, Ballymaguire Foods said it has appointed a public health expert to lead its response and that it is 'treating it with the utmost seriousness'. The spokesperson said the company is 'committed to doing everything necessary to responsibly and transparently address this, in full collaboration with the public health authorities'. As a precautionary measure, all Ballymaguire Food products have been withdrawn and it has suspended all production. The spokesperson said the company has 'taken corrective actions, including a full pharmaceutical-grade clean-down of the site' and that 'production at the affected facility 'will only recommence once the relevant authorities are satisfied'. It has also appointed Dr. Patrick Wall—former Chief Executive of the FSAI and former Professor of Public Health at University College Dublin—to lead its response team and review, including the implementation of any necessary enhanced procedures. 'We sincerely apologise for the concern this may cause,' said the spokesperson. 'Incidents of this nature are exceptionally rare and we are treating this with the utmost seriousness. 'We are acting decisively and transparently to protect public health which is of paramount importance to us.' Symptoms Listeriosis arises from an infection from Listeria monocytogenes bacteria. Symptoms can include mild flu-like symptoms, or gastrointestinal symptoms such as nausea, vomiting and diarrhoea. In rare cases, the infection can be more severe, causing serious complications. Some people are more vulnerable to Listeria monocytogenes infections, including pregnant women, babies, and people with weakened immune systems, including the elderly. The incubation period (time between initial infection and first symptoms appearing) is on average three weeks but can range between three and 70 days. Readers like you are keeping these stories free for everyone... A mix of advertising and supporting contributions helps keep paywalls away from valuable information like this article. Over 5,000 readers like you have already stepped up and support us with a monthly payment or a once-off donation. Learn More Support The Journal

Listeriosis outbreak ‘unusual' as ready meals must be cooked, and bacteria is sensitive to heat, professor says
Listeriosis outbreak ‘unusual' as ready meals must be cooked, and bacteria is sensitive to heat, professor says

Irish Times

time11 hours ago

  • Irish Times

Listeriosis outbreak ‘unusual' as ready meals must be cooked, and bacteria is sensitive to heat, professor says

The outbreak of a rare bacterial infection, listeriosis, in Ireland is 'unusual' in that it relates to food that should be reheated or cooked, a professor in microbiology has said. Experts have called on members of the public to ensure they heat pre-prepared food products 'thoroughly' to reduce the risk of further infection. On Wednesday, the Food Safety Authority of Ireland (FSAI) confirmed an adult with listeriosis has died , and the watchdog is investigating an 'extensive outbreak' of the disease. Nine cases of listeriosis have been identified as of July 22nd, it said, and there has been a 'voluntary precautionary recall' of 141 ready-made products 'due to a link with the outbreak'. READ MORE The affected meals include chicken curries, lasagnes, bolognaises, pasta bakes, cottage pies and chow meins. Affected side dishes include ready-made mashed potatoes, carrots and peas, green cabbage and pilau rice. Listeriosis generally causes flu-like symptoms. However, pregnant women, babies, older people and those who are immunocompromised are more vulnerable to severe infections. Prof Catherine Rees, professor of microbiology at the University of Nottingham, said the bacteria that causes listeriosis – Listeria monocytogenes – is 'sensitive to heat' and usually associated with soft cheese, pâté or smoked salmon. 'So this outbreak is unusual because the list of recalled products includes dishes that should be reheated or cooked,' she said. 'If the source of the outbreak has been identified, that will help control this outbreak, but symptoms can take some time to develop, so more cases may be reported as time goes on. She added: 'To help reduce the risk of further infections the public should be reminded to always heat pre-prepared food products thoroughly.' Dr Ricardo Calderón González, a research fellow at the school of medicine, dentistry and biomedical sciences at Queen's University Belfast, said the incidence of this disease is low in Ireland. 'But there are two important things to take in consideration: these numbers don't include the number of miscarriages caused by Listeria, and despite the low incidence, mortality rate can be quite high in those that develop the disease, around 20 per cent of those hospitalised,' he said. The implicated products are produced by food manufacturer Ballymaguire Foods, which specialises in the production of freshly prepared meals. All batches and all best-before dates are included. In an updated statement on Thursday, the company said it suspended all production and has 'taken corrective actions, including a full pharmaceutical-grade clean-down of the site'. The company said it has appointed Dr Patrick Wall, a former chief executive of the FSAI and former chairman of the European Food Safety Authority, to lead a response team. 'The team has a singular focus: to fully and effectively resolve this matter. It is doing so in close collaboration with the relevant public health authorities. Production at the affected facility will only recommence once the relevant authorities are satisfied,' it added.

Ballymaguire Foods appoints public health expert after listeria-linked meal recall
Ballymaguire Foods appoints public health expert after listeria-linked meal recall

Irish Examiner

time11 hours ago

  • Irish Examiner

Ballymaguire Foods appoints public health expert after listeria-linked meal recall

Ballymaguire Foods, which produced more than 170 prepared meals and side dishes recalled due to the possible presence of Listeria monocytogenes, has appointed a public health expert to lead its response to the situation. On Wednesday, the Food Safety Authority of Ireland (FSAI) said its National Control Team was investigating an outbreak of listeriosis linked to the recall of over 170 ready meals sold in supermarkets nationwide. On Thursday, Ballymaguire Foods confirmed it had appointed Dr Patrick Wall, former Chief Executive of the FSAI and former Chairperson of the European Food Safety Authority, to lead its response team. The company said it was treating the matter with "the utmost seriousness." It stated that its priority has been "a swift, responsible, health-led response, and remains so," adding that, as a precaution, all products have been withdrawn and clear consumer information has been shared with its retail partners. "We suspended all production and have taken corrective actions, including a full pharmaceutical-grade clean-down of the site." A company spokesperson added: "The team has a singular focus: to fully and effectively resolve this matter. It is doing so in close collaboration with the relevant public health authorities. Production at the affected facility will only recommence once the relevant authorities are satisfied." Nine cases have been linked to the outbreak so far, and one adult has died with a confirmed case of the rare bacterial infection. Earlier on Wednesday, the FSAI issued an expanded recall of over 170 ready meals and side dishes sold at Tesco, SuperValu, Aldi, and Centra due to the possible presence of Listeria monocytogenes. The meals were produced by Dublin-based Ballymaguire Foods. Affected products include pasta bakes, curries, lasagne, turkey and ham dinners, pasta Bolognese, beef stroganoff, and some vegetarian dishes. The recalled items include several sold under Tesco's 'Irish Classics', 'Classic Kitchen', and 'Finest' labels, SuperValu's 'Freshly Prepared' and 'Signature Tastes' labels, and Aldi's 'Specially Selected' and 'Inspired Cuisine' labels. Some own-brand items from Tesco, SuperValu, and Centra are also included in the recall, as are products from The Happy Pear, Clean Cut Meals, and From the Farm. A full list of all the items recalled can be found here. Consumers have been advised not to eat any of the affected products and to check their fridges and freezers for implicated items and dispose of them. Ballymaguire Foods said it understands the public has questions and would continue to address them "openly and responsibly." "Where appropriate, we are referring queries to the relevant authorities. We recognise the vital role of the FSAI as the primary body in addressing public queries and its guidance to consumers on food safety and best practice. "The FSAI continues to advise the public that anyone with queries should contact it on info@ the spokesperson said. The company also apologised for the concern the recall may cause. "As we have stated, incidents of this nature are exceptionally rare and we are treating this with the utmost seriousness," the spokesperson added. "We are acting decisively and transparently to protect public health which is of paramount importance to us."

DOWNLOAD THE APP

Get Started Now: Download the App

Ready to dive into a world of global content with local flavor? Download Daily8 app today from your preferred app store and start exploring.
app-storeplay-store