Pityana prepares for another legal showdown with Absa and SA Reserve Bank
Former Absa board member Sipho Pityana is bracing for another bruising battle with the bank as well as the South African Reserve Bank (Sarb) in the court of law in his fight for reform in the banking sector.
This comes as Absa and the Sarb's Prudential Authority (PA) both filed applications for leave to appeal the Pretoria High Court ruling last month that vindicated Pityana in his claim that the PA broke the law in interfering with his possible nomination as Absa chair in 2021.
The PA controversially consulted with third parties regarding his suitability for the chairperson role, particularly following inquiries into his resignation from AngloGold Ashanti amid allegations of sexual harassment - claims he firmly denies.
The court found that the PA acted unlawfully by adopting an informal process to review Pityana's nomination, as prescribed by the regulations in place under the Banks Act.
Pityana's legal battle began when he sought a declaratory order against the PA, claiming they had operated outside the legal framework established for such considerations. He did not seek any relief against Absa.
However, Absa said it would take the judgment on review.
'After careful consideration of the 13 June 2025 High Court judgement, Absa will respectfully seek leave to appeal. It should be noted that the Court made no findings against Absa, save to order that it was jointly liable with the Prudential Authority for the applicant's costs,' Absa told Business Report on Monday.
The court's judgment, delivered by Judge Flatela Luleka last month, established that the PA had indeed overstepped its bounds by failing to follow established protocols, thus denying Pityana the opportunity to contest objections to his appointment.
'The [PA] acted unlawfully and in excess of its power per the Banks Act 94 of 1990 by engaging in an informal process with the [Absa Group] and [Absa Bank] in connection with the nomination of [Pityana] as chairperson of the [Absa Group] and [Absa Bank's] board of directors, and in particular by notifying the [Absa Group] and [Absa Bank] of its objection, alternative intention to object to [Pityana's] nomination,' read the judgment.
PA spokesperson, Thoraya Pandy, also confirmed on Monday that the PA is going back to court on the matter.
'Yes you are right, we have lodged an appeal. The documents are in the public domain and you can reach out to the courts for it, as we do not share it directly to anyone,' Panday said.
Speaking with Business Report last month, Pityana said the case had raised serious concerns regarding the independence of the Sarb and also urged for a formal investigation into what he describes as "cosy relationships" between key figures in the banking sector.
He said the judgement raised a number of new questions in terms of transparency, good governance and ethical conduct in the financial sector's regulatory environment, as well as accountability when laws are broken.
On Monday, Pityana said there was nothing really surprising about these applications for leave to appeal.
'The more curious one is why Absa is appealing the judgement when no finding is made against them. Indeed, why are they spending so much resources on a case in which they are cited only as an interested party. It already speaks to collusive behaviour,' Pityana said.
Pityana's legal battle extends beyond this ruling; he is also contesting his removal from the Absa board through separate legal proceedings.
BUSINESS REPORT
Try Our AI Features
Explore what Daily8 AI can do for you:
Comments
No comments yet...
Related Articles
Daily Maverick
an hour ago
- Daily Maverick
Kenny Kunene remains in office while Joburg mayor ‘still getting briefings'
Johannesburg Mayor Dada Morero is still applying his mind to the fate of Mayoral Committee Member (MMC) for Transport Kenny Kunene, who remains in office more than 48 hours after police found him at the Sandton house of a man accused of being a criminal mastermind. Morero is under pressure to act on Kunene after his party, the Patriotic Alliance (PA), suspended him from party activities for 30 days and has 'removed' him from the MMC position. The party, however, cannot remove Kunene from his post as only the mayor has the prerogative to remove or replace MMCs, which he can do at any time and without council approval, according to Section 60 of the Municipal Systems Act. The PA can, however, recall him as a councillor, which it hasn't done. Morero also faces pressure from opposition parties in the city, which argue that keeping Kunene in the position undermines the credibility of Johannesburg's executive. Morero has several options, including appointing someone in an acting capacity, selecting a new candidate or asking Kunene to take leave of absence – all of which have different implications, especially if Kunene is ultimately cleared by his party's internal investigation. Morero's spokesperson, Chris Vondo, said the mayor had not made a decision, but was still consulting various stakeholders. 'No final decision has been made. The mayor is still getting briefings from various parties,' he said. Daily Maverick understands from various council sources that Kunene remains in his position. Morero, through his office, has not sent any internal communication on the steps he will take. This is further complicated by the fact that the office of the speaker, to whom political parties send letters recalling councillors, has also not received any communication from the PA about Kunene's suspension. The PA's spokesperson, Steve Motale, insisted: 'He [Kunene] has been placed on a 30-day leave of absence from both positions.' He was referring to both Kunene's positions as a Joburg MMC and deputy leader of the PA. It is understood that the party is still weighing its options before it informs the speaker and Morero. A meeting with coalition partners is scheduled to take place soon. Kunene is most likely to be removed as an MMC and remain an ordinary council member, if history is anything to go by. In November 2024, Kabelo Gwamanda was dismissed from his role as MMC for Community Development following his arrest for alleged involvement in a fraudulent funeral insurance scheme. Found at the scene Kunene was suspended by the PA after a visit, details of which remain unclear, to the home of Katiso 'KT' Molefe, who was arrested in connection with a 2022 drive-by shooting that killed Oupa Sefoka, better known as DJ Sumbody. Sefoka and his bodyguard died after their vehicle was riddled with bullets in Woodmead, Johannesburg. Police have also fingered Molefe for the killing of Armand Swart, an engineer from Vereeniging. Swart was murdered after his company reportedly raised red flags about price gouging related to a Transnet tender. Speaking to journalists on the sidelines of the National Assembly vote on the Appropriation Bill on Wednesday, McKenzie commended the police for arresting the 'dangerous' Molefe, whom he believes has no relationship with Kunene. McKeznie believes Kunene was set up, although he has provided no evidence to back this up. 'He doesn't believe he was set up; he says it was pure coincidence. I have no proof, but I just have a gut feeling that he was set up…' he told journalists. On the decision to place Kunene on suspension while an internal investigation was being conducted, McKenzie said it was important to set a precedent and position the party for the 2026 local government and 2029 general elections. 'We are showing people what type of government they will get in 2029 when they vote for us.' McKenzie has insisted that as early as Friday, a credible team of lawyers will be appointed to look into the matter. Although McKenzie believed in Kunene's innocence, he said what happened was 'really unfortunate' and that leaders should be mindful of the people whose company they kept. 'We, as the party, believe his version of events. We know the character of the man, but we have to do the right thing, no matter how hard it is. 'People must understand that we have worked very hard to rebuild our reputations, coming from jail, and I am speaking for Mr Kunene as well…' A day after Kunene was interrogated about links with Molefe, he was spotted walking out of the Hawks' offices in Germiston. Asked about this, McKenzie said: 'I think it is totally unrelated to this matter.' McKenzie was so sure of Kunene's innocence that he even suggested that if they were both accused of murder, he would be the more likely suspect. 'If there is a murder that happened and there were two suspects, me and Kenny, I would be the main suspect. Kenny Kunene can't hurt a fly. That guy is such a soft character. The mistake with him is that he is too accessible.' Opposition pressure The Democratic Alliance in the city has since written to Morero, asking that he immediately remove Kunene, in line with Section 60 of the Municipal Structures Act. 'The position of MMC is one of public trust and responsibility. Regardless of whether criminal charges are eventually brought against Mr Kunene, his conduct in this matter has already compromised the integrity of the Mayoral Committee and brought the city into disrepute,' said DA caucus leader Belinda Kayser-Echeozonjoku. Kayser-Echeozonjoku wanted the mayor to apply the same standard to Kunene as had been the case with Gwamanda. ActionSA has echoed similar sentiments, adding that public representatives ought to uphold the highest standards of integrity both in their official capacity and private conduct. 'When such standards are brought into question, the legitimacy and credibility of the broader administration are inevitably placed at risk,' said Lebo Mokoka, the party's regional secretary. The UDM's Yongama Zigebe said Kunene's suspension was a step in the right direction as it set a precedent that public representatives had to be held to account. While the city was yet to act, the UDM said: 'Our interest is in the restoration and protection of public confidence in leadership. We trust that the relevant authorities, including the City of Johannesburg and law enforcement, will act in the best interest of transparency, justice, and institutional integrity.' Kunene was appointed transport MMC in the City of Gold in February 2023, and has also acted as executive mayor, filling in for both former mayor Gwamanda and current mayor Morero. Despite his short tenure, he positioned himself as a proactive leader by conducting site visits to depots, roadworks and bus infrastructure hubs, and notably leading raids on hijacked buildings and illegal connections, often a thorny issue. His past includes a criminal conviction. In 1997, he was sentenced to six years in prison for fraud after being found guilty of running a Ponzi scheme. At the time, he worked as an English teacher, but became involved in criminal activity while selling alcohol after hours. Speaking to SABC News about the visit to Molefe's home, he said he was there in his capacity as the owner of the online publication African News Global. Kunene told the broadcaster he was in the company of an unnamed journalist who had arranged the meeting with Molefe. Kunene claimed he had never previously met or interacted with Molefe, with whom the journalist was set to conduct an exclusive interview.
IOL News
4 hours ago
- IOL News
Steinhoff forfeits R6. 3bn to settle long-standing battle with SARB
The South African Reserve Bank's (SARB's) seven-year probe into now-defunct Steinhoff's alleged breach of Exchange Control Regulations has finally been concluded with an agreement that what is now Ibex Group will no longer try to recoup a previously forfeited R6.3 billion. In a statement released on Thursday, the central bank said that it and Ibex Group had resolved all the disputes between the two parties in a 'comprehensive settlement'. 'Both SARB and the Ibex Group consider the settlement reasonable, proportionate and justifiable in light of the complex and competing interests,' the central bank's statement said. 'SARB and the Ibex Group consider this final settlement to be in the best interests of South Africa." SARB said that the deal followed it having taken legal advice, considered the public interest, its mandate in terms of forex, investor confidence in South Africa, and promoting regulatory certainty by allowing the Ibex Group to settle its contractual obligations to its foreign financial creditors, it had agreed to settle the matter. The deal allows Ibex to settle SARB's enforcement action by ceasing litigation over R6.3 billion – plus interest – of funds that had already been forfeited to the state. At the same time, SARB has granted permissions for Ibex to implement its Dutch court-approved winding down of the remaining Steinhoff business units that it did not take over.
IOL News
8 hours ago
- IOL News
This is what June's inflation results mean for your pocket and trolley
June's inflation data revealed a rise to 3.0%, up from 2.8% in April and May, signalling a shift that could hit both consumers and portfolios. While fuel prices are easing, grocery bills are climbing fast, with food inflation at a 15-month high of 5.1%. Image: Squirrel photos/Pixabay After maintaining stability at 2.8% in April and May, South African inflation experienced a notable rise in June, aligning with projections from economists and signalling new considerations for the SA Reserve Bank ahead of its upcoming interest rate review. What does it mean? Your grocery basket is more expensive – Meat, fruit, and vegetables are driving food inflation – Meat, fruit, and vegetables are driving food inflation Fuel relief is real – but might not last – Prices are down now, but oil market risks loom – Prices are down now, but oil market risks loom Interest rate outlook in question – SARB's next move could affect loan repayments, mortgages, and household budgets – SARB's next move could affect loan repayments, mortgages, and household budgets Trade wars and tariffs could make things worse – Global instability could hit SA's agricultural and automotive sectors The annual consumer price inflation recorded a 3.0% increase, while the Consumer Price Index (CPI) rose by 0.3% month-on-month, reflecting the complex dynamics within the nation's economy. Despite remaining close to the lower threshold of the South African Reserve Bank's (SARB) inflation target range of 3% to 6%, the increased rate raises concerns. The heightened inflation is now driven primarily by the food and non-alcoholic beverages sector, which saw its annual rate soar to a 15-month high of 5.1% in June. Within this category, meat, particularly beef, emerged as a significant contributor to the food inflation spike, alongside other unprocessed food items. This upward trend is compounded by fruits and nuts, and vegetables maintaining double-digit inflation rates for the second consecutive month. Interestingly, while food costs escalated, fuel prices have continued their decline, marking a fourth month of reduced prices. The cost of fuel is currently on average 11.2% lower than it was a year ago, providing some respite amid rising food costs. Delving deeper, the annual inflation rate for goods surged to 2.3%, an increase from 1.8% in May, whereas the service sector received a slight boost as its inflation rose to 3.7% from 3.6% the previous month. South African Reserve Bank chief Lesetja Kganyago has expressed concerns regarding external factors, most notably the depreciation of the US dollar due to potential tariffs and deflationary pressures emanating from China. These challenges pose significant risks to the local inflation landscape and broader economic activity. Kganyago highlighted that if tariffs are imposed, sectors such as agriculture and automotive could suffer, further stressing South Africa's economic framework. Video Player is loading. Play Video Play Unmute Current Time 0:00 / Duration -:- Loaded : 0% Stream Type LIVE Seek to live, currently behind live LIVE Remaining Time - 0:00 This is a modal window. Beginning of dialog window. Escape will cancel and close the window. Text Color White Black Red Green Blue Yellow Magenta Cyan Transparency Opaque Semi-Transparent Background Color Black White Red Green Blue Yellow Magenta Cyan Transparency Opaque Semi-Transparent Transparent Window Color Black White Red Green Blue Yellow Magenta Cyan Transparency Transparent Semi-Transparent Opaque Font Size 50% 75% 100% 125% 150% 175% 200% 300% 400% Text Edge Style None Raised Depressed Uniform Dropshadow Font Family Proportional Sans-Serif Monospace Sans-Serif Proportional Serif Monospace Serif Casual Script Small Caps Reset restore all settings to the default values Done Close Modal Dialog End of dialog window. Advertisement Video Player is loading. Play Video Play Unmute Current Time 0:00 / Duration -:- Loaded : 0% Stream Type LIVE Seek to live, currently behind live LIVE Remaining Time - 0:00 This is a modal window. Beginning of dialog window. Escape will cancel and close the window. Text Color White Black Red Green Blue Yellow Magenta Cyan Transparency Opaque Semi-Transparent Background Color Black White Red Green Blue Yellow Magenta Cyan Transparency Opaque Semi-Transparent Transparent Window Color Black White Red Green Blue Yellow Magenta Cyan Transparency Transparent Semi-Transparent Opaque Font Size 50% 75% 100% 125% 150% 175% 200% 300% 400% Text Edge Style None Raised Depressed Uniform Dropshadow Font Family Proportional Sans-Serif Monospace Sans-Serif Proportional Serif Monospace Serif Casual Script Small Caps Reset restore all settings to the default values Done Close Modal Dialog End of dialog window. Next Stay Close ✕ The prevailing uncertainty in the economic landscape has resulted in mixed expectations among economists concerning the decisions of South Africa's Monetary Policy Committee (MPC) during its upcoming rate-setting meeting. Earlier this year, the bank has already implemented two cuts to the repo rate, the latest occurring in May. While some analysts advocate for the continuation of this easing cycle, arguing that inflation has remained consistently low, others believe the committee may choose to maintain the current rates in light of potential volatility. IOL
