Andrew Hastie says Israel needs to states its ‘end game,' after confirming plans to take over Gaza City
The opposing comments between senior Coalition members indicates a fissure in the opposition's response to the war, which threatens to escalate following the Israeli Security Cabinet's approval of plans to attack Gaza City.
Prior to this, Israeli Prime Minister Benjamin Netanyahu had indicated his desire to take over the entire Gaza Strip following the Israeli Defence Force's 22-month military offensive in the region.
While Mr Hastie, who is a former SAS commander and the Coalition's home affairs spokesman, supported Israel's 'right to self-defence,' and said Israeli hostages needed to be released, he also questioned: 'What end game will Israel achieve by sending an occupation force in?'
Andrew Hastie said Israel should reveal its 'end game' after it announced plans to take over Gaza City. Picture: NewsWire/ Martin Ollman
Speaking to the ABC, he said Gaza had already been 'largely destroyed' and reduced to 'rubble', and noted that the 'urban combat' nature of the attack would also result in the deaths of IDF soldiers.
'Not only, potentially, would you see more violence, you would see more IDF body bags going back to Israel as well,' he said.
'What would such an occupation achieve? I think that's a good question to ask Israel.'
Speaking about the 'humanitarian crisis in Gaza', Mr Hastie suggested the creation of a new settlement to ensure 'peace and a level of security for both sides'.
'I'm a student of Biblical history as well. Both parties have been pounding it out in the desert for the last 3500 years,' he said.
'We need to be realistic about what we can achieve in terms of a lasting peace solution.
'We need a new settlement, a new political reality that allows people on both sides to live in peace, within reason.'
Earlier, Senator Cash criticised the government's call for Israel not to proceed with its offence on Gaza, and said the 'operational tactics and the way this war is conducted on the ground … is a matter for the Israeli government'.
Israel's Security Cabinet approved plans to take over Gaza City on Friday. Picture: AP Photo/Jehad Alshrafi
However, she accused Hamas of refusing to 'properly participate in the peace negotiations,' adding that the 'Israelis are in the situation today because Hamas started this war'.
Senator Cash also accused Labor for being weak on its position that Hamas could end the war by releasing the Israeli hostages captured on October 7.
'I think what disturbs me more than anything is that so many now, but in particular Penny Wong number one as the offender, they skip over this important detail. This war could end tomorrow if Hamas released the hostages and laid down their arms,' she told Sky.
Senator Cash's comments were in response to Foreign Minister Penny Wong, who urged Israel 'not to go down this path,' warning that its plans to create the 'permanent forced displacement' of Gazans could amount a 'violation of international law'.
'Australia calls on Israel to not go down this path, which will only worsen the humanitarian catastrophe in Gaza,' she said in a statement issued on Friday.
'With international partners, Australia maintains our call for a ceasefire, the return of hostages and aid to flow unimpeded.
'A two-state solution is the only pathway to secure an enduring peace – a Palestinian state and the State of Israel, living side-by-side in peace and security within internationally-recognised borders.'
This comes as Anthony Albanese is considering whether Australia will join western allies, including Canada, the UK and France in officially recognising Palestinian statehood at the United Nations General Assembly in September.
Read related topics: Israel
Jessica Wang
NewsWire Federal Politics Reporter
Jessica Wang is a federal politics reporter for NewsWire based in the Canberra Press Gallery. She previously covered NSW state politics for the Wire and has also worked at news.com.au, and Mamamia covering breaking news, entertainment, and lifestyle.
@imjesswang_
Jessica Wang
Hashtags
Try Our AI Features
Explore what Daily8 AI can do for you:
Comments
No comments yet...
Related Articles
Perth Now
41 minutes ago
- Perth Now
Israel faces backlash over Gaza war escalation plan
PM Benjamin Netanyahu's plan to ramp up military action in Gaza has drawn international scorn. (EPA PHOTO) PM Benjamin Netanyahu's plan to ramp up military action in Gaza has drawn international scorn. (EPA PHOTO) Credit: AAP Israel's security cabinet approved a plan to take control of Gaza City, a move expanding military operations in the shattered Palestinian territory that drew strong rebukes internationally. Germany, a key European ally, announced it would halt exports of military equipment to Israel that could be used in Gaza. Britain urged Israel to reconsider its decision to escalate the Gaza military campaign. However, US President Donald Trump's ambassador to Israel, Mike Huckabee, told Reuters that some countries appeared to be putting pressure on Israel rather than on the militant group Hamas, whose deadly attack on Israel in 2023 ignited the war. In Israel, families of hostages held by militants in Gaza, and opposition leaders blasted Prime Minister Benjamin Netanyahu for a decision that they said would put hostages' lives at risk. Far-right allies in Netanyahu's coalition have been pushing for a total takeover of Gaza as part of his vow to eradicate Hamas militants, though the military has warned this could endanger the lives of remaining hostages held by militants. Opposition leader Yair Lapid called the decision to send Israeli forces into Gaza City a disaster, saying it defied the advice of military and security officials. Netanyahu told Fox News that the military intended to take control of all of Gaza. The announcement from the prime minister's office early on Friday after Thursday's security cabinet meeting said the military would take Gaza City, but did not say if Israeli forces would take all of the enclave. Israel's cabinet is expected to endorse the Gaza City plan. The military has said that it controls around 75 per cent of Gaza. Amir Avivi, a retired Israeli brigadier general, estimated that if the military did take Gaza City, it would give Israel control of about 85 per cent of the strip. "Gaza City is the heart of Gaza. It's really the centre of government. It has always been the strongest and even in the eyes of Hamas, the fall of Gaza City is pretty much the fall of Hamas," said Avivi. "Taking over Gaza City is a game changer." European Commission President Ursula von der Leyen was among foreign leaders urging Israel to reconsider its decision to advance into Gaza City. Regional power Saudi Arabia, which has said it could not normalise ties with Israel without the establishment of a Palestinian state, condemned any move to occupy Gaza. In recent weeks, Britain, Canada and France said they could recognise a Palestinian state at the UN General Assembly next month. The Hostages Families Forum, which represents many families of captives in Gaza, said the pursuit of occupying Gaza means abandoning the hostages, all while ignoring public support to immediately end the war in a deal that releases the hostages. It said in a statement that the security cabinet had chosen to "embark on another march of recklessness, on the backs of the hostages, the soldiers, and Israeli society as a whole". "I think it's a death sentence to all the hostages that are still being held there. And it's the wrong decision to do it at this time," Danny Bukovsky, a hotelier in Tel Aviv, said of the announcement that Israeli forces would move into Gaza City.
Sky News AU
3 hours ago
- Sky News AU
Hamas ‘cannot continue' to govern in Gaza
Shadow Cabinet Secretary Andrew Wallace says Hamas cannot be allowed to 'stay in power' as the ruling body of the Gaza Strip. Israeli Prime Minister Benjamin Netanyahu says Israel plans to take full military control of Gaza despite growing criticism at home and abroad over the nearly two-year war in the territory. 'I don't think that anybody wants that; the Palestinians don't want that, the only people who want that is Hamas itself,' Mr Wallace told Sky News host Danica De Giorgio. 'Western countries across the world have been clear that we cannot see a situation where Hamas have the ability to continue to govern in Gaza.'
The Australian
3 hours ago
- The Australian
Germany suspends arms exports to Israel for use in Gaza
Germany will halt the export of military equipment to Israel which could be used in the Gaza Strip, Chancellor Friedrich Merz said Friday, reacting to Israel's plan to take control of Gaza City. The arms export freeze marks a dramatic change of course for the German government, which has long been one of Israel's staunchest international allies as it has sought to atone for the Holocaust. Merz said it was "increasingly difficult to understand" how the latest Israeli military plan would help achieve the aims of disarming Hamas and freeing the remaining Israeli hostages held in Gaza. "Under these circumstances, the German government will not authorise any exports of military equipment that could be used in the Gaza Strip until further notice," he said in a statement. Merz added that Berlin "remains deeply concerned about the ongoing suffering of the civilian population in the Gaza Strip". Israel has until recently enjoyed broad support across the political spectrum in Germany, a country still seeking to atone for the World War II murder of more than six million Jews. In the period since the Hamas attack of October 7, 2023 started the Gaza war until May this year, Germany approved defence exports worth at least 485 million euros ($565 million) to Israel. The deliveries included firearms, ammunition, weapons parts, special equipment for the army and navy, electronic equipment, and special armoured vehicles, the government said in June in response to a parliamentary request. Merz again stressed that "Israel has the right to defend itself against Hamas' terror" and said that "the release of the hostages and determined negotiations on a ceasefire are our top priority". "The disarmament of Hamas is essential. Hamas must not play a role in the future of Gaza." But he added that "the even tougher military action by the Israeli army in the Gaza Strip, which was decided on by the Israeli cabinet last night, makes it increasingly difficult, from the German government's point of view, to understand how these goals are to be achieved". - West Bank warning - The decision marks a dramatic step for Germany, where Merz's tone towards Israel has been sharpening in recent months as the dire humanitarian situation in Gaza further deteriorated. The conservative leader has also been under pressure from some within his own coalition government to increase pressure on Israel, particularly from members of the centre-left Social Democrats. However, while often voicing concern, Germany had so far refrained from taking major concrete steps. Germany has so far avoided following France, the United Kingdom and Canada, who have announced plans to recognise a Palestinian state in September. On a visit to Israel last week, German Foreign Minister Johann Wadephul maintained Berlin's long-standing position that recognition could come only after a process of negotiation between Israel and the Palestinians but added that the process "must begin soon". Berlin has also opposed the suspension or termination of the EU-Israel Association Agreement, which had been under review by the bloc. International concern has been growing over the suffering of Palestinians in Gaza, where a UN-backed assessment has warned that famine is unfolding. German airforce planes have in recent days joined other countries with airdrops of humanitarian aid over the war-battered coastal territory. Merz said that "with the planned offensive, the Israeli government bears even greater responsibility" for providing aid to Gaza's civilians. He reiterated Germany's call for comprehensive access to Gaza for "UN organisations and other non-governmental institutions". Merz also said that "the German government urges the Israeli government not to take any further steps toward annexing the West Bank". Last month, 71 members of Israel's 120-seat parliament, including members of Prime Minister Benjamin Netanyahu's right-wing coalition, passed a motion calling on the government to annex the West Bank. jsk/fz/rl
