Premier's chief-of-staff takes stand in lawsuit
Mark Rosner — along with the NDP and its candidate Trudy Schroeder — is being sued for defamation in civil court by Patrick Allard, an outspoken opponent of COVID-19 public health restrictions.
Allard was an independent in the March 2022 Fort Whyte byelection that was won by Obby Khan, who was recently selected as Tory party leader.
In the news release, the NDP described Allard as having used 'racist rhetoric.' Allard filed the lawsuit in December 2022.
Rosner, who was NDP leader Wab Kinew's chief of staff and was on the party's byelection committee, was cross-examined by Allard's lawyer, Scott Cannon, on Thursday.
Rosner told Court of King's Bench Justice Shane Perlmutter he stands by that description and believes it to be a fact.
'The choice of words was deliberate,' said Rosner, when asked by Cannon whether the intent was to infer Allard was a racist.
The news release was issued on behalf of Schroeder after Liberal candidate Willard Reaves called for an all-candidates forum that would include Allard. A Free Press request for comment on Reaves' proposal prompted the release.
The release quoted a campaign spokesperson as saying the proposal would give 'Allard a platform to spout his anti-vaccination and racist rhetoric' and the party declined to participate. Rosner had written that section of the release.
Rosner told court he was aware of Allard's opposition to COVID-19 restrictions and his commentary on the matter at the time, including the comparison of reporting violators of health orders with people who reported 'attic-hiding Jews' in Nazi Germany.
Rosner said he believes that comment trivialized the Holocaust and contributed to a diminished appreciation of the wrongs and the truth of the genocide in which six million Jews were killed by Nazis.
'That rhetoric, that argument, is racist in character,' said Rosner. 'The government did not murder people in Manitoba.'
Earlier this week, Abram Silver, lawyer for the NDP, questioned Allard about social media posts in which he compared the two, which Silver alleged were clearly racist.
'Make sure to turn in any attic-hiding Jews, while you're at it,' Allard wrote in a reply posted on Facebook in late 2021 or early 2022 and later uploaded to Reddit.
In court, Allard had said the comments were taken out of context and specifically compared the Nazi policy that encouraged citizens to turn in their Jewish neighbours to that of the Canadian government encouraging citizens to report public health violators during the pandemic.
Allard said in court he does not think those comments trivialize the Holocaust, but elevate concern about official overreach.
On Thursday, Cannon argued Rosner was not aware of those specific comments prior to when he helped write the news release. Rosner denied that.
He suggested to Rosner he was reckless when he used the term 'racist rhetoric' — which the political staffer denied.
Cannon has argued the news release was a political strategy motivated by malice to damage Allard's reputation and improve the NDP's standing in the byelection.
In August 2022, Allard was fined $34,000 for repeatedly breaching public health orders in 2020 and 2021. He was a fixture at anti-lockdown rallies in the province.
Ousted NDP MLA Mark Wasyliw briefly sat in the public gallery at Rosner's cross-examination Thursday morning. Wasyliw, a defence lawyer, sits as an independent in Fort Garry after being booted from the NDP caucus last fall.
erik.pindera@freepress.mb.ca
Erik PinderaReporter
Erik Pindera is a reporter for the Free Press, mostly focusing on crime and justice. The born-and-bred Winnipegger attended Red River College Polytechnic, wrote for the community newspaper in Kenora, Ont. and reported on television and radio in Winnipeg before joining the Free Press in 2020. Read more about Erik.
Every piece of reporting Erik produces is reviewed by an editing team before it is posted online or published in print — part of the Free Press's tradition, since 1872, of producing reliable independent journalism. Read more about Free Press's history and mandate, and learn how our newsroom operates.
Our newsroom depends on a growing audience of readers to power our journalism. If you are not a paid reader, please consider becoming a subscriber.
Our newsroom depends on its audience of readers to power our journalism. Thank you for your support.
Try Our AI Features
Explore what Daily8 AI can do for you:
Comments
No comments yet...
Related Articles
Winnipeg Free Press
5 hours ago
- Winnipeg Free Press
Reverse changes to two-tier Rent Assist: prof who helped design program
One of the designers of Manitoba's Rent Assist program a decade ago says changes made under the former Tories need to be reversed in order for the NDP government's homelessness strategy to work. The program was set up by then-NDP premier Greg Selinger in 2014 to support people transitioning from 'welfare to work,' while also increasing benefits for those who rely on government supports for their income, said University of Manitoba economics and labour studies associate professor Jesse Hajer. In the years since, changes to the program have seen benefits clawed back, which has made it more difficult for low-income Manitobans to make ends meet, Hajer said. RUTH BONNEVILLE / FREE PRESS FILES University of Manitoba economics and labour studies associate professor Jesse Hajer says changes made to Manitoba's Rent Assist program under the former Tories need to be reversed in order for the NDP government's homelessness strategy to work. RUTH BONNEVILLE / FREE PRESS FILES University of Manitoba economics and labour studies associate professor Jesse Hajer says changes made to Manitoba's Rent Assist program under the former Tories need to be reversed in order for the NDP government's homelessness strategy to work. In a report released Thursday for the Canadian Centre for Policy Alternatives, Hajer, who was on the planning and priorities committee of cabinet while Selinger was in power, noted the Rent Assist shortcomings will make it difficult for the NDP to meet its goal of ending chronic homelessness by 2031. The report calls on the province to reverse changes to Rent Assist made by the previous Progressive Conservative government that discriminated 'between the 'deserving' and 'undeserving' poor, by introducing higher benefits for those not' on social assistance. 2015 $806 2016 $852 2017 $877 2018 $912 2019 $947 2020 $982 2021 $1,000 2022 $1,030 2023 $1,080 2024 $1,149 — source: CMHC Rental Market Survey 'Rent Assist is an important benefit with a wide reach in Manitoba,' Hajer said in an interview. 'Low-income Manitobans have been hurt the most by high inflation in recent years, including rapidly increasing rents.' Manitoba's Your Way Home strategy, unveiled in January, relies on moving people from encampments into social housing, while moving those in social housing into the private market. If those being moved out of social housing cannot afford private market rent, the strategy risks housing some while creating homelessness for others, the report says. When Brian Pallister's Tories came into power after the 2016 election, they increased the proportion of net income that people were expected to pay towards rent to 30 per cent from 25 per cent. A few years later, after calls for a Rent Assist increase, the province increased the percentage of median market rent to which Rent Assist was indexed to 77 per cent for those on social assistance and 80 per cent for low-income workers, essentially creating a two-tier program. Hajer said reversing those cuts and returning to a model where maximum benefits are the same for all eligible Rent Assist recipients would help a large amount of people quickly. In Winnipeg, the median rent for a one-bedroom apartment has increased 35 per cent over the last decade, the Canada Mortgage and Housing Corporation Rental Market Survey shows. 'Until a massive amount of new social housing is built,' programs like Rent Assist are needed to keep the housing affordability crisis from getting worse, Hajer said. PC housing, homelessness and addictions critic Carrie Hiebert defended the stance of providing higher benefits to Manitobans not on social assistance. 'We are encouraging independence, resilience and empowerment,' Hiebert said in a statement. 'Our goal should always be to encourage a path forward for our families, friends and loved ones to make sure meaningful employment and secure housing are within their reach.' Housing, Addictions and Homelessness Minister Bernadette Smith was not available for an interview, but a prepared statement provided Friday said: 'Our government is investing in social housing, supporting renters, and ensuring Manitobans have safe, affordable, and dignified homes.' The statement noted the PCs cut Rent Assist while this year's provincial budget increased the program by $27.8 million. Hajer's report said in 2019, under the PCs, Rent Assist cash benefits to Manitoba's low-income renters increased to $140 million from $100 million, when the program was fully implemented by the NDP in 2016. Weekday Mornings A quick glance at the news for the upcoming day. The government said Friday that it has restored the renter's tax credit cut and blamed the PCs for selling off social housing units. (The Tories sold 387 units to for-profit companies, including 374 units at 185 Smith St. for $16.2 million and 13 units at 356 Assiniboine Ave. for $1.45 million). 'Expanding the supply of non-market housing needs to be the priority,' said Right to Housing Coalition member and University of Winnipeg chair of urban and inner-city studies Prof. Shauna MacKinnon. 'Rent assist should not be the default and it should not be expanded in the absence of strong rent regulations,' said MacKinnon. 'It is too easy for landlords to increase rates to Rent Assist levels, which we know is happening and especially problematic for the lowest income renters who end up paying ridiculous rents for substandard housing.' Rent assist report Carol SandersLegislature reporter Carol Sanders is a reporter at the Free Press legislature bureau. The former general assignment reporter and copy editor joined the paper in 1997. Read more about Carol. Every piece of reporting Carol produces is reviewed by an editing team before it is posted online or published in print — part of the Free Press's tradition, since 1872, of producing reliable independent journalism. Read more about Free Press's history and mandate, and learn how our newsroom operates. Our newsroom depends on a growing audience of readers to power our journalism. If you are not a paid reader, please consider becoming a subscriber. Our newsroom depends on its audience of readers to power our journalism. Thank you for your support.
Calgary Herald
9 hours ago
- Calgary Herald
Premier Danielle Smith squares off with tense crowd at heated Alberta Next panel in Edmonton
Article content And the exchanges veered away from the constitutional questions, as members of the audience exchanged barbs over health care, the government and the province's recent decision to change its expense disclosure policy. Article content Despite attempts by moderator Bruce McAllister, a former Wildrose MLA, to steer the conversation away from the flashpoints, Smith addressed concerns over the province's plan to require Albertans to pre-register for COVID vaccines and pay for the shots themselves. Article content She said the blame for the COVID shots lies with the feds. She said the feds 'defunded' the immunization program. Article content 'So we had to make a choice about how to best provide those services to those who needed them the most, without wasting $225 million, which is the value of COVID shots that were thrown away over the past three years,' said Smith. 'It's not bulls–t. It's true.' Article content Article content As for the expenses, she said the cabinet will be discussing the change on Tuesday. At the beginning of August, a change was made that takes away the requirement that the premier, ministers and senior staff have to disclose expenditures over $100. Article content Smith said she does not want to hide expenses from the public. She said the spirit of the change was to protect the privacy of officials who don't want the public to find out what hotels they regularly frequent when on the road. She said that she does not support the erasing the expenditures from the public record, and will work to reverse that part of the decision. Article content Moderator McAllister fanned the flames throughout the evening, equating some of the negative commenters to toddlers who don't get what they want. After a show-of-hands poll indicated the majority of those in the audience wanted Alberta to work with other provinces to push for changes to the federal constitution, McAllister said 'thank you to those who are here for the right reasons,' fully breaking the facade of impartiality. Article content Article content After several audience members questioned the motives of the Alberta Next panel, Athabasca-Barrhead-Westlock Glenn van Dijken reiterated the stance that sovereignty and separation don't mean the same thing. Article content 'This doesn't equate to separation, this equates to sovereignty within Canada,' he said. Article content This was the third of a series of Alberta Next meetings scheduled throughout the province, with more than 60,000 people tuning in to the meeting via livestream, the province estimates. The next one is set for Aug. 26 in Fort McMurray. Article content Article content 'It's really just a sham,' said Alberta Civic Integrity Project member Matilda Johnson. 'She (Premier Smith) just does stuff to look like she's getting input, but she also ignores the input when it's given. Obviously, most people don't agree with the idea of an Alberta pension plan, but she's still pushing it.'
CTV News
9 hours ago
- CTV News
Questions remain around resignation of Sask. Marshal after redacted documents provided
WATCH: The NDP are accusing the government of hiding the reason why a Sask. Marshal resigned earlier this year. Wayne Mantyka has more. The NDP's search for information about alleged misconduct by a Saskatchewan Marsal has come up blank after their request for documents came back with heavy redactions. 'Instead of releasing any information, the government completely redacted 290 pages of emails and documents. That's this,' NDP MLA Nicole Sarauer said on Thursday, holding the stack of documents. The inquiry was sparked by an allegation of misconduct made earlier this year against a provincial marshal. The NDP believe the incident took place in Saskatoon. 'You know, people in Saskatchewan talk. I have heard a lot of rumours about what this individual did. I don't know whether or not what I have heard is true but if what I've heard is true, it's not appropriate for me to say in front of a camera,' Sarauer said. The investigation was concluded with no release of information to the public. 'I am here today calling on the Minister of Justice, Policing, Corrections and Public Safety Tim McLeod and Legislative Secretary Michael Weger who will address media in Prince Albert later today to be transparent with the people of Saskatchewan and release the documents,' Sarauer continued. 'This pattern of secrecy and lack of public transparency is deeply troubling.' In response, the government said the Public Complaint Commission doesn't normally release that information. 'They do their internal investigation and report back to the agency responsible and they would have reported back to the head of the Sasktchewan Marshals which is Chief Marshal Rob Cameron,' Michael Weger, legislative secretary for Corrections, Policing, and Public Safety stated. They do their internal investigation and report back to the agency responsible and they would have reported back to the head of the Sasktchewan Marshals which is Chief Marshal Rob Cameron." The NDP Freedom of Information request was about incidents over the years involving the Marshal Service. Given the large volume of blank pages received, the Opposition is questioning whether it's dealing with one incident or many.
