logo
'How can we cope?': Doctors and nurses speak out on system at breaking point

'How can we cope?': Doctors and nurses speak out on system at breaking point

KUALA LUMPUR: Severe staff shortage caused by the migration of healthcare workers and burnout among existing staff have pushed nurses to the brink of despair and helplessness, said medical frontliners.
A staff nurse who only wanted to be known as Nini, 42, said she started her nursing career at a hospital in Johor in 2005 and was transferred to Kuala Lumpur in 2010.
She said the work culture in Kuala Lumpur was different and she hardly had any time for breaks. She is now a senior and is on duty at wards where she has to take care of eight to 12 patients at a time.
"Although the World Health Organisation recommends one nurse for every four patients in a general ward, we are doing double the amount and more sometimes when a nurse calls in sick."
She said staffing levels had dropped steadily in her ward over the past five years.
"This is not new. But these past years, the situation has worsened as more colleagues leave for greener pastures in."
Nini now manages her shift with fewer nurses, saying it has caused burnout among her colleagues, especially if there are demanding superiors.
"An ex-colleague joined a hospital in Dubai, where she works eight-hour shifts, earns RM12,000 monthly and gets free housing.
Two more moved to Singapore and another is in Perth now. They were senior staff. Losing them is a big blow. We're trying to hold the fort, but we are not sure how long we can do it.
Patients sometimes blame us when they do not get the care they deserve, but that is not because we don't care. It's because we just physically cannot keep up."
In a hospital in Kota Kinabalu, an emergency medical officer who only wanted to be known as Dr Mohamad, 42, said the emergency department was running at almost 200 per cent capacity on some days with fewer than 10 doctors on duty.
"We should have at least five medical officers per shift.
Some nights, we're down to just three. Imagine one stroke victim, one asthma patient and one road traffic victim.
How can we manage? You can't be everywhere. We used to spend 10 to 15 minutes with each patient.
Now, it's sometimes three minutes, just enough time to prescribe and move on. We're not proud of it, but this is the reality.
I've had three of my closest colleagues leave in the last 12 months.
Two to Australia and one to a telehealth firm in the United Kingdom that pays more than double of what he used to earn here.
They left because their applications to be relocated to the peninsula were rejected several times."
He said doctors wanted to remain in Malaysia, but the Health Ministry must improve the perks, salary and incentives.
According to statistics from the Malaysian Medical Association, more than 4,000 healthcare workers, including more than 1,500 nurses and 900 doctors, migrated or entered private practice between 2021 and 2024.
The Health Ministry has acknowledged a nationwide shortage of 20,000 nurses and 8,000 doctors, including specialists. And this gap is expected to widen as more resign or retire.
A specialist from Klang, Dr Menon, 48, said her unit delivered up to 20 babies a day with increasingly junior and overstretched staff on some days.
"We need at least six medical officers per 24-hour cycle to handle these cases safely.
Some days, we barely have three medical officers. I'm in the operating theatre for hours, then straight to clinic or ward rounds with no break. One of my best registrars left for Dubai.
She told me, 'In one shift, I deliver five babies and get to eat lunch. Here, I would have to deliver 10 babies before I could even go to the toilet'."
Dr Menon said one of her most dependable nurses resigned after a decade of service recently. "She went to Singapore.
She sent me a voice note last month and said, 'Cikgu, I finally feel like a normal human again'. It broke my heart." She said the workload was not only overwhelming,
it was affecting quality of care for patients as well as staff morale. "The system is bleeding and we're using our hands to plug the holes."
Asked why she chose to stay despite getting offers abroad, she said her elderly parents and in-laws kept her here. "I'm more concerned about the new generation as it is getting harder to convince the younger ones to stay.
They don't see a future here. And without a strong pipeline, we're heading towards collapse." Dr Menon believed that better pay, structured career paths and more specialist training slots could slow down the collapse.
Orange background

Try Our AI Features

Explore what Daily8 AI can do for you:

Comments

No comments yet...

Related Articles

MMA urges halt to Poisons (Amendment) Bill, wants govt to engage healthcare stakeholders
MMA urges halt to Poisons (Amendment) Bill, wants govt to engage healthcare stakeholders

The Star

time3 hours ago

  • The Star

MMA urges halt to Poisons (Amendment) Bill, wants govt to engage healthcare stakeholders

PETALING JAYA: The Malaysian Medical Association (MMA) has voiced strong concern to the Poisons (Amendment) Bill 2025, urging the government to halt its progress in Parliament until proper engagement is conducted with stakeholders in the healthcare sector. Its president Datuk Dr Kalwinder Singh Khaira ( pic ) said the association, along with other medical professional bodies, was deeply concerned that the Bill was tabled without prior consultation with key stakeholders, including the MMA itself. 'We acknowledge the government's intention to strengthen enforcement, possibly in response to serious cross-border threats such as drug smuggling or maritime trafficking. 'However, if this is indeed the rationale, it must be clearly stated and the scope of the amendments appropriately defined in the legislation,' he said in a statement on Friday (July 25) night. Dr Kalwinder said the language of the Bill was overly broad and raised red flags regarding enforcement powers and the implications for private healthcare services. He pointed specifically to Clause 2, which designates all police officers as authorised officers under the Act, and the proposed Section 31A, which grants the Health Minister power to appoint 'any person' without specifying qualifications. 'These provisions raise serious concerns about unchecked enforcement authority and the potential disruption to legitimate private healthcare services, such as GP clinics, mobile services and charity-based health initiatives,' he said. He added that the MMA also took issue with the expanded definition of 'premises' in the Bill, saying it could group licensed medical facilities together with non-healthcare-related or even criminal operations under the same enforcement scope. 'This risks not only operational disruption, but also potential violations of patient confidentiality and public trust,' Dr Kalwinder said. He added that the absence of engagement with the medical fraternity represented a major procedural lapse, especially since the proposed changes would significantly impact the daily operations of thousands of healthcare practitioners nationwide. 'These are not peripheral changes,' he said, adding that the Health Ministry and MPs delay any further readings of the Bill until a comprehensive consultation is held with the medical profession. Dr Kalwinder said the Act must make a clear distinction between enforcement aimed at criminal activity and regulation of clinical practice. He noted that private healthcare providers are already regulated under the Private Healthcare Facilities and Services Act 1998 (Act 586), with oversight from the Health Ministry. 'This arrangement should remain as it is,' he said, warning against overlapping or excessive enforcement that could disrupt healthcare delivery. Dr Kalwinder reiterated that the MMA stands ready to engage in constructive dialogue to ensure public safety is upheld without compromising the integrity and autonomy of the medical profession.

Promoting baby-friendly private hospitals
Promoting baby-friendly private hospitals

The Star

time4 hours ago

  • The Star

Promoting baby-friendly private hospitals

SEREMBAN: The Health Ministry, through the National Lactation Centre, has launched the Madani private hospital Baby-Friendly Hospital Initiative (BFHI) 2025 to promote breastfeeding and reduce the prevalence of diet-related non-communicable diseases. Its deputy minister Datuk Lukanisman Awang said partnership between the public and private sectors to implement the initiative and support nursing mothers with confidence and respect was a shared responsibility. 'The core objectives of this tour, which is in line with the National Nutrition Policy, include expanding BFHI promotion, ensuring more private hospitals join the movement of nursing mothers, strengthening community support so that nursing mothers do not feel isolated and can confidently nurse their children,' he said at the launch of the initiative here yesterday, Bernama reported. Such inclusive efforts would ensure the health of both mother and child, and allow more Malaysians to support breastfeeding, he said, adding that 31 private hospitals are participating in the initiative. 'Currently, 31 out of 180 private hospitals have been accredited as BFHI. Congratulations to 20 KPJ Healthcare hospitals for being the hospital consortium with the most accredited hospitals,' he said. Lukanisman said there are 15 hospitals being in the final stage of training by the National Lactation Centre together with the state Health Department to receive BFHI accreditation while 65 hospitals are in the process of initial training.

Wawa not dismissing ‘evil eye' for health woes
Wawa not dismissing ‘evil eye' for health woes

The Star

time4 hours ago

  • The Star

Wawa not dismissing ‘evil eye' for health woes

ACTRESS Wawa Zainal, who has been battling a series of health issues since last year, has apologised to her fans, suggesting that her misfortune may be linked to the cultural belief in the evil eye (penyakit ain), Utusan Malaysia reported. Wawa, whose full name is Nur Hawa Zainal Abidin, said that she had taken several steps to address her health, including undergoing a full body check-up, taking supplements and carefully monitoring her diet. 'I've been falling sick constantly since last year. It could be due to my age or a weakened immune system, which may be affecting my overall health,' she said. The actress, married to actor Aeril Zafril, also mentioned that she might need to increase her vitamin intake as it had previously been uncommon for her to fall ill. 'Thankfully, whenever I get sick, Aeril always takes me to the hospital for a check-up. 'I've also stopped consuming carbonated drinks, sweets and dairy products,' she added. When asked if her health issues could be related to the evil eye, the cultural belief that bad luck or illness can be caused by the ill-wishing of others, Wawa did not dismiss the possibility. 'I even consulted some experts to ensure that everything is all right. 'But I haven't resorted to alternative treatments. I rely solely on the Quran for protection,' she said. Wawa also expressed regret, saying: 'If I have ever hurt or mistreated anyone, whether intentionally or unintentionally, I sincerely apologise.' > A family of eight in Kuala Nerus, Terengganu, who reside in an abandoned building once used as a swiftlet house, has received assistance from the authorities, Kosmo! reported. Rural and Regional Development Ministry Terengganu director Md Razi Md Lazim said the family had stayed in the building as they could not afford to pay the monthly rent of RM550. Md Razi expressed his sympathy towards Mohd Nazarudin Muhamat, 50, his wife Nur Nadiatul Asyikin Muhammad Nasir, 36, and their six children. 'The site is in a dilapidated condition and it is not safe for anyone to stay there,' he said. Md Razi said that repair works will be done to turn the place into a proper home. Nur Nadiatul Asyikin said she used to work in Kuala Lumpur but decided to go back to their hometown during the Covid-19 pandemic due to the high cost of living. 'My mother allowed us to stay here temporarily. 'We tried to make some adjustments but there is no toilet, so we go to the nearest petrol station,' she added. Her husband works as a mechanic while she sells ice cream. They have a combined income of about RM1,000 a month. (The above articles are compiled from the vernacular newspapers (Bahasa Malaysia, Chinese and Tamil dailies). As such, stories are grouped according to the respective language/medium. Where a paragraph begins with a >, it denotes a separate news item.)

DOWNLOAD THE APP

Get Started Now: Download the App

Ready to dive into a world of global content with local flavor? Download Daily8 app today from your preferred app store and start exploring.
app-storeplay-store