Premier League awards 2025: PST chooses its Best XI of the 2024-25 PL season
A decisive champion does not make a dominant one, and the Premier League's Best XI is unlikely to look like it has in recent seasons when Man City or Liverpool take up most of the positions on nearly every ballot.
Yes, it's a difficult one. And the advanced stats don't make it easier, as some of the season's most impressive individual performances came from stars living in the bottom half of the table. Bruno Fernandes, Matheus Cunha, Eberechi Eze were among the magnificent talents who did not qualify for Europe through the league route.
Then the injuries — superstars Erling Haaland and Bukayo Saka were very good this season but missed significant stretches.
MORE — Premier League Golden Boot race
So, it makes sense that our three staff writers — Joe Prince-Wright, Andy Edwards, and Nick Mendola — had different looking Best XIs as we asked them to assemble one after Week 36 of the 2024-25 Premier League season.
There were 33 spots to be awarded between our trio of writers, and 18 different players were selected for the honors.
Liverpool, to no one surprise, had the most players spread between the teams. Virgil van Dijk, Ryan Gravenberch, and Mohammed Salah were unanimous, while Alexis Mac Allister slid onto Prince-Wright's list.
Man City may well finish third or even second on the table, but Pep Guardiola's team only had one player named by one writer — Mendola picked Josko Gvardiol in his back three.
MORE — Goodison Park final game details
Arsenal's William Saliba was unanimous call but the only Gunner named by our panel. Chelsea also only had one player selected, as Nick picked Enzo Fernandez.
Newcastle United's Alexander Isak was also unanimous, and Edwards nabbed Bruno Guimaraes to give the Magpies a second representative.
Nottingham Forest goalkeeper Matz Sels made two squads, and he was joined by Murillo on JPW's Best XI.
Bournemouth's Milos Kerkez and Kepa Arrizabalaga made the cut, while Fulham, Aston Villa, Crystal Palace, and Brentford saw players named at least once.
Let's take a look at the XIs.
Nicholas Mendola's 2024-25 Premier League Best XI
Kepa Arrizabalaga
William Saliba, Virgil van Dijk, Josko Gvardiol
Daniel Munoz, Ryan Gravenberch, Enzo Fernandez, Antonee Robinson
Mohammed Salah, Alexander Isak, Bryan Mbeumo
Andy Edwards' 2024-25 Premier League Best XI
Matz Sels
Daniel Muñoz, William Saliba, Virgil van Dijk, Antonee Robinson
Ryan Gravenberch, Bruno Guimaraes, Youri Tielemans
Joe Prince-Wright's 2024-25 Premier League Best XI
William Saliba, Virgil van Dijk, Murillo
Daniel Munoz, Ryan Gravenberch, Alexis Mac Allister, Milos Kerkez
Mohammed Salah, Matheus Cunha
Alexander Isak
Newcastle get back on level terms thanks to Alexander Isak's second goal of the season to make it 1-1 against Chelsea at Stamford Bridge.
The Bees are buzzing thanks to Bryan Mbeumo's left-footed curler into the bottom corner of the net to put Brentford 1-0 ahead of Crystal Palace at the Gtech.
Liverpool take the lead thanks to Alexis Mac Allister's glancing header to make it 1-0 over 10-men Wolves at Anfield.
Hashtags
Try Our AI Features
Explore what Daily8 AI can do for you:
Comments
No comments yet...
Related Articles
Yahoo
an hour ago
- Yahoo
Report: Newcastle Chasing Premier League Winger Again
Newcastle Eyeing Anthony Elanga in Fresh Transfer Move Newcastle United have reignited their interest in Nottingham Forest winger Anthony Elanga, according to recent reports from Sky Sports. With Eddie Howe keen on bolstering his attacking options, the Magpies have reportedly made initial contact with Forest over the possibility of securing Elanga's services this summer. Photo IMAGO Renewed Interest from Eddie Howe Eddie Howe's admiration for Elanga is well-documented. Sky Sports journalists Keith Downie and Lyall Thomas confirmed that the Newcastle manager had previously attempted to bring the winger to St James' Park on Deadline Day last summer. Although a deal failed to materialise then, Howe clearly sees Elanga as a pivotal part of his attacking plans. Impressive Season at Forest Elanga proved instrumental for Nottingham Forest during the last campaign. His six goals and 11 assists in 38 Premier League appearances highlight his significance in Forest's commendable run, ultimately securing them qualification for the UEFA Europa Conference League. With three years left on his current contract, Forest will not let the 23-year-old leave easily, especially given his contributions since joining from Manchester United in July 2023. Transfer Competition and Strategy Elanga is among four top winger targets identified by Newcastle. Securing his signature, however, could be complicated, as Forest will undoubtedly demand a substantial fee given his recent performances and contractual situation. The pursuit indicates Newcastle's intent to continue strengthening their squad after recent investments and improvements under Howe's guidance. Newcastle's Ambitions Clear The renewed attempt to sign Elanga sends a clear message about Newcastle's ambitions for the upcoming season. Adding a talent like Elanga, who offers pace, creativity, and consistent attacking threat, would considerably boost their chances of competing at higher levels domestically and possibly in Europe in the near future. Advertisement As negotiations potentially unfold, Newcastle supporters will hope the club's persistence pays off. Anthony Elanga could be exactly the kind of exciting, young talent to further elevate the Magpies. Our View – EPL Index Analysis As a Newcastle supporter, hearing about our renewed interest in Anthony Elanga is genuinely exciting. Eddie Howe clearly values players with energy, speed, and versatility, and Elanga ticks all these boxes. He showed immense promise at Forest last season, helping them clinch European football—something Newcastle fans desperately want to see return to St James' Park regularly. While Elanga might not be the biggest name in the Premier League, his consistent assists and goals tally demonstrate the potential we urgently need in wide areas. Moreover, signing a player who excelled at a club like Forest sends a positive message about our ambition. It shows we're not just interested in star names but focused on effective, quality signings who can immediately enhance the squad. However, it's crucial we act decisively this time. Missing out on him last summer was frustrating, and Newcastle must now show they're serious contenders in the market. Elanga's ability to thrive under pressure at Forest suggests he'd handle the expectations at Newcastle well. Let's hope our management secures this promising talent swiftly, reinforcing our squad ahead of what promises to be a thrilling season.
Yahoo
an hour ago
- Yahoo
Bayern Munich Ponder €80M Raid for Man Utd, Liverpool Target With PSG Sell-on Clause
PSG sold Xavi Simons to RB Leipzig earlier this year, resulting in Liverpool and Manchester United showing serious interest in the Dutch midfielder. Moreover, the deal included a sell-on clause, meaning PSG could cash in again if Leipzig decides to move him on. According to Fabrizio Romano, Leipzig paid €80 million total—€55 million up front—and Simons signed a deal through June 2027. Still, there's no certainty he'll see out that contract in Germany. Advertisement With the summer transfer window approaching, speculation around Simons' future is heating up. CaughtOffside reports that Manchester United may have the upper hand over City in the chase to land him. Could Bayern Munich beat Liverpool for former PSG ace?Fichajes reports that Bayern Munich view Xavi Simons as a strong fit for their plans, but RB Leipzig's asking price could be a major hurdle. The Red Bull-owned club, facing the setback of missing out on European competition, has already made Simons available for transfer. Leipzig are reportedly demanding around €80 million, which has forced Bayern Munich to think carefully about whether they're ready to commit to such a significant investment. Advertisement Simons' camp is reportedly watching Bayern Munich's next steps. While the interest from the Bavarian side is serious, any deal will likely hinge on potential departures from the squad—and whether deeper-pocketed clubs decide to make a move for the talented Dutchman. Empire of the Kop recently reported that Liverpool are preparing an opening bid of around €60 million ($67.8 million) for the Netherlands international playmaker, as Arne Slot aims to boost his attack for next season. However, despite Slot's desire to make this player his first summer signing, the offer will likely fall short. RB Leipzig are reportedly holding out for closer to €80 million ($90.4 million).
Yahoo
an hour ago
- Yahoo
Barcelona turn down Chelsea's Nkunku-Lopez swap deal
Barcelona have rejected a potential swap deal with Chelsea involving Christopher Nkunku and Fermin Lopez, according to Mundo Deportivo. Chelsea manager Enzo Maresca admires Lopez and wants him at Stamford Bridge, but Barca are not interested in an exchange deal for their La Masia graduate. Advertisement Lopez caught the eye this season, coming on from the bench to provide creativity and energy. The Spanish attacking midfielder also has a keen eye for goal. Lopez bagged eight goals and 10 assists in 46 appearances for the Catalans as they clinched the domestic treble and reached the UEFA Champions League semi-final. His performances have caught the eye of Chelsea, but Barca are not willing to part with their prized asset, especially if the offer on the table is taking Nkunku. The Frenchman has endured two injury-riddled campaigns in West London and is keen to move away. Nkunku managed 14 goals and five assists, but the consensus is that it was an underwhelming season. Advertisement Barca are too focused on signing Luis Diaz, and except Lopez asks for a move away, they will not be at the negotiating table with Chelsea. Chelsea should not be afraid to cough up the funds for Lopez – View Firstly, Lopez brings one quality Chelsea desperately need – intensity. He is a vivacious attacker who executes his actions with quickness and works hard off the ball. Cole Palmer and Enzo Fernandez are quality in the Chelsea engine room, but they play at their own pace. Lopez injects electricity into matches. Additionally, he can cover several positions, and the Blues need that versatility when they eventually sell Nkunku. Advertisement He can provide the same cutting edge in attack and does not rest on his laurels defensively. If Chelsea can get Lopez at a fair price, he would be a steal. However, Barcelona will likely demand a massive fee to part ways with the 22-year-old, who is a stud.
