Judge strikes down key parts of Florida law that led to removal of books from school libraries
U.S. District Judge Carlos Mendoza in Orlando said in Wednesday's ruling that the statute's prohibition on material that described sexual conduct was overbroad.
Mendoza, who was appointed by President Barack Obama, also said that the state's interpretation of the 2023 law was unconstitutional.
Among the books that had been removed from central Florida schools were classics like Margaret Atwood's 'The Handmaid's Tale,' Richard Wright's 'Native Son' and Kurt Vonnegut's 'Slaughterhouse-Five.'
'Historically, librarians curate their collections based on their sound discretion not based on decrees from on high,' the judge said. 'There is also evidence that the statute has swept up more non-obscene books than just the ones referenced here."
After the Republican-controlled Florida Legislature passed the law, school officials worried that any sexual content was questionable, a belief that was enforced by new state training that urged librarians to err on the side of caution. Last year, Florida led the nation with 4,500 removals of school books.
Under the judge's ruling, schools should revert back to a U.S. Supreme Court precedent in which the test is whether an average person would find the work prurient as a whole; whether it depicts sexual content in an offensive way; and whether the work lacks literary, artistic, political or scientific value.
The lawsuit was brought by some of the nation's largest book publishers and some of the authors whose books had been removed from central Florida school libraries, as well as the parents of schoolchildren who tried to access books that were removed.
The author plaintiffs included Angie Thomas, author of 'The Hate U Give"; Jodi Picoult, author of 'My Sister's Keeper"; John Green, author of 'The Fault in Our Stars"; and Julia Alvarez, author of 'How the Garcia Girls Lost Their Accents.' The publisher plaintiffs included Penguin Random House, Hachette Book Group, HarperCollins Publishers, Macmillan Publishing and Simon and Schuster.
Hashtags
Try Our AI Features
Explore what Daily8 AI can do for you:
Comments
No comments yet...
Related Articles
Daily Mail
25 minutes ago
- Daily Mail
Historic red state town with Victorian charm faces population boom
Once celebrated for its historic Victorian architecture and small-town charm, Clarksville, Tennessee , is now grappling with the growing pains of being one of the fastest-expanding cities in America. The population of the military town that sits close to Fort Campbell on the border with Kentucky has soared past 186,000. This is a jump of nearly 20,000 in just four years - but the housing market hasn't kept pace, driving prices sky-high and leaving many locals struggling to find a place to live. A new housing study warns that the shortage spans both rental and for-sale properties, with limited supply and a lack of variety in available homes. The squeeze is forcing some residents to spend a disproportionate share of their income on housing, cutting into local spending and threatening long-term economic stability. City officials acknowledge the problem, but the scale of Clarksville's growth has left them scrambling to balance development with infrastructure needs while preserving the historic charm that draws people here in the first place. Council member Deanna McLaughlin called the situation 'urgent', pointing to a severe five-year housing gap of more than 15,000 units - including 8,595 for-sale homes and 6,598 rentals across all price points - and noted that both affordable and market-rate rentals are nearly at full occupancy. 'Limited options and rising costs are creating a significant cost burden for residents,' she said. 'We're seeing 43.6 percent of renters and 20 percent of homeowners spending more than 30 percent of their income on housing, which is above the state average. Incomes simply aren't keeping pace with the cost of living .' Local real estate agent Tyler Forte, who services Clarksville from his base in Nashville, says the city has undergone a dramatic transformation in just a few years. 'Even three years ago, Clarksville was kind of Nashville's stepsister - known mainly for the military base and university, with a lot of farmland and a small-town feel,' Forte said. 'Since COVID, it's just absolutely taken off. They're building a ton of homes and commercial projects, new grocery stores, and even two new hospitals. It's gone from being an afterthought to a major city in Tennessee.' Much of that growth, Forte says, has been driven by both out-of-state buyers and Nashville residents seeking a lower cost of living. 'As Nashville prices have climbed, I've had a lot of clients who've moved to Clarksville for more affordable housing,' he explained. Forte notes that new construction dominates the market, which can be a double-edged sword. 'Most of the homes I see in Clarksville are brand new - even something built in 2015 is considered old. Builders are offering big incentives, like interest rate buy-downs through their preferred lenders. One client just locked in a 3.99 percent rate through Lennar's in-house lending program - a huge drop from the 6.5-7 percent you'd see with a typical lender. 'Because the builder owns the lender, they can offer aggressive financing deals that make new construction especially attractive,' he said. While bidding wars aren't as common as they once were, Forte says competition still exists for certain properties. 'If a home is unique, move-in ready, and priced right, it can still spark multiple offers. But out of the 80 homes I sold in the past year, only about three had bidding wars.' Some parts of the city remain hotter than others. 'The Sango area in the south is the most competitive,' Forte said. 'It's closer to Nashville, has a strong school district, and that combination is always going to drive demand.' However, Forte doesn't believe the real shortage is in housing stock. 'They're building as fast as they possibly can,' he said. 'The bigger issue is infrastructure. This was mostly farmland 10 years ago, and the public systems just aren't built to handle this kind of population growth so quickly.' Although the boom has brought new businesses and job opportunities, it has also fueled concerns about traffic congestion, rezoning battles, and environmental impacts in a city where Victorian-era streets and landmarks now sit in the shadow of sprawling new subdivisions. McLaughlin said younger residents and first-time buyers are especially hard-hit, with many unable to qualify for mortgages and a shortage of smaller 'starter' homes in the market. She warned that building quickly without careful planning could worsen traffic congestion, strain public services, and erode the character of historic neighborhoods. 'If the housing shortage persists, the most pressing concerns would be an increase in the number of cost-burdened residents, particularly those in lower- and middle-income brackets,' she said. 'That could lead to the departure of essential workers and drive prices even higher,' she added. Patrick Bowen, president of Bowen National Research, led the assessment that laid bare Clarksville's housing shortage - and its wider economic consequences. 'Whether it's rental or for-sale housing, there's not much available,' Bowen told local FOX affiliate WZTV Nashville. 'And what you do have is really not affordable for many low- to moderate-income households.' He warned that rising housing costs don't just hit residents - they ripple through the local economy. 'When you've got people spending exorbitant amounts on housing, that's less money going back into the local economy. It has an impact on employers, too; the workforce can't afford to stay in the market, or afford the rent they're paying.' Bowen says the newly compiled data can help Clarksville plan smarter: 'Now you have data to look to, so when you're setting priorities and goals, you have something that gives you structure, to say, we need to focus on this type of housing or this population.' He also stressed that rushing development could make matters worse. 'Yes, housing is needed quickly, but that doesn't mean it should be rushed. You want to make sure you're building the right kind of housing, in the right places, with the right infrastructure in place.'
Reuters
an hour ago
- Reuters
Trump-Putin talks produced enough movement to justify Ukraine meeting, Rubio says
Aug 17 (Reuters) - Talks between U.S. President Donald Trump and Russian leader Vladimir Putin produced enough movement to justify a meeting with Ukrainian and European leaders, U.S. Secretary of State Marco Rubio told CBS on Sunday. Rubio also said both Russia and Ukraine would have to make concessions to end the war, adding that the United States might not be able to produce a scenario guaranteeing peace. European leaders will accompany Ukrainian President Volodymyr Zelenskiy to meet Trump in Washington on Monday, seeking to bolster him as the president presses Ukraine to accept a quick peace deal after meeting Putin on Friday. "I'm not saying we're on the verge of a peace deal, but I am saying that we saw movement, enough movement to justify a follow-up meeting with Zelenskiy and the Europeans," Rubio told the "Face the Nation" show. Rubio's comments were among the first by senior U.S. officials present at the talks with Putin. In a social media post, Trump wrote, "BIG PROGRESS ON RUSSIA. STAY TUNED!" he gave no details Speaking separately to Fox News' "Sunday Morning Futures" program, Rubio said the talks had narrowed down the key issues. These included drawing borders, long-term security guarantees for Kyiv, and which military alliances Ukraine could have, he said, adding "there's a lot of work that remains." Putin has ruled out Ukraine becoming a member of NATO. Article 5 of the alliance's charter is a mutual defence pact obliging allies to defend a member from attacks. Steve Witkoff, Trump's special envoy to Russia, told CNN that the U.S. side had won "the concession that the United States could offer Article Five-like protection." Pressed for details, he said, "the United States is potentially prepared to be able to give Article Five security guarantees, but not from NATO, directly from the United States, and other European countries." This would be one of the topics for discussion on Monday, he said. According to sources, Trump and Putin discussed proposals for Russia to relinquish tiny pockets of occupied Ukraine in exchange for Ukraine ceding a swathe of fortified land in the east and freezing the front lines elsewhere. "We may not like it, it may not be pleasant, it may be distasteful, but in order for there to be an end of the war, there are things Russia wants that it cannot get, and there are things Ukraine wants that it's not going to get," said Rubio. In a separate interview with ABC, Rubio said if a deal could not be reached to end the war, existing U.S. sanctions on Russia would continue, and more could be added. When Zelenskiy visited the White House in February, the meeting ended in a shouting match. Rubio, speaking to CBS, dismissed the idea that the European leaders were coming to Washington to protect Zelenskiy. "They're not coming here tomorrow to keep Zelenskiy from being bullied. They're coming here tomorrow because we've been working with the Europeans," he said. "We invited them to come."
Daily Mail
an hour ago
- Daily Mail
Vladimir Putin's surprising lunch menu for meeting with Donald Trump is revealed - despite never getting a chance to eat it after cutting talks short
Donald Trump and Vladimir Putin were due to dine on halibut and steak in Alaska before their lunch was cancelled, sensitive documents revealed today. The US President and Russian leader held crunch talks at Joint Base Elmendorf-Richardson in Anchorage on Friday and were expected to eat together. The menu - revealed among papers relating to the summit found in a hotel printer - shows they would have had a starter of 'green salad with champagne vinaigrette'. The main course was a 'duet of filet mignon with brady peppercorn sauce and halibut Olympia served with buttery whipped potatoes and roasted asparagus'. But the summit ended early and the lunch at the US military base - which would have concluded with a dessert of 'crème brûlée' - never took place. The document found at Hotel Captain Cook also stated that the meal was 'in honour of His Excellency Vladimir Putin, President of the Russian Federation'. Halibut Olympia is a local dish where halibut fillets are smothered in a creamy sauce then topped with buttery breadcrumbs on top of a base of caramelised onions. Sensitive documents revealed Mr Trump and Mr Putin were due to dine on halibut and steak Jeremy Pataky, an editor of Edible Alaska magazine, told the New York Times: 'It has the vibe of being homey and comforting and mildly retro, but palatable. 'I would not characterise it as haute cuisine. To see that on the menu for an extremely high-level state dinner felt a bit surprising.' He added: 'In our culinary Venn diagram of what's possible to harvest at sea between Alaska and Russia, I mean certainly we have halibut, so there's that.' President Trump's chief of protocol has been facing questions after the menu was among sensitive documents relating to the Russia-US summit that were discovered. Monica Crowley, who was in charge of creating the programme for Russian leader Vladimir Putin's visit, was left red-faced after eight pages including precise locations, meeting times and private phone numbers of government employees were found. The documents also told US officials how to pronounce their Russian counterparts' names, including, 'Mr President POO-tihn'. Hotel Captain Cook is 20 minutes from the Joint Base Elmendorf-Richardson, where the historic meeting took place. The documents told US officials how to pronounce names, including, 'Mr President POO-tihn' Ms Crowley, 56, is a former Fox news presenter who is said to be 'extremely close' to Mr Trump and his wife Melania. She was photographed on Friday warmly greeting President Putin when he arrived at the military base and again at the airport as he prepared to fly home to Russia. The documents were given to US public broadcaster NPR which has seen its funding slashed by Mr Trump. The broadcaster claimed the papers were found in a printer on Friday morning by three hotel guests. Jon Michaels, a professor of law at UCLA and national security expert, said that the documents revealed 'a lapse in professional judgement'. He said: 'It strikes me as further evidence of the sloppiness and the incompetence of the administration. You just don't leave things in printers. It's that simple.' But White House deputy press secretary Anna Kelly dismissed the papers as 'a multi-page lunch menu' and claimed that no security breach had occurred. She told the Daily Mail: 'It's hilarious that NPR is publishing a multi-page lunch menu and calling it a 'security breach'. 'This type of self-proclaimed 'investigative journalism' is why no one takes them seriously and they are no longer taxpayer-funded thanks to President Trump.'
