
Africa needs a voice on information integrity and media freedom at G20 Summit
As leaders of the world's major economies prepare for the November G20 Johannesburg Summit, champions of South Africa's journalism industry are working to ensure that information integrity and media freedom are not overlooked.
The two issues are inextricably linked, argue Media Monitoring Africa and the South African National Editors' Forum (Sanef). Together, the two organisations are spearheading Media20 (M20) in the lead-up to the G20 talks, to highlight the issues.
The United Nations (UN) Global Principles for Information Integrity put freedom of expression, accuracy, reliability and an independent, free and pluralistic media centre-stage.
M20 highlights the blind spots in the new artificial intelligence (AI) landscape – especially how citizens receive news and fact-based information online. It warns that 'current trends foresee an increase in low-quality and false information, with increasing AI 'hallucinations' and deceptive deepfakes being produced and circulated'.
Traditional journalism is considered an antidote to such falsehoods as 'it debunks lies and exposes information operations', say M20 campaigners. It also 'contributes reliable news and informed comment into the public information ecosystem'. Yet traditional journalism is under threat, with newsrooms struggling to compete with digital platforms due to a complex mix of business, technical and content challenges.
Press freedom in G20 countries, 2015-2025
M20 is timely considering that many G20 countries exhibit reduced media freedom, driven by political and economic factors. The recent World Press Freedom Index puts major democracies, including the US and India, in the spotlight (see graph).
The defunding of media outlets and newsroom closures such as that of Voice of America, are a significant concern, given their role in highlighting international issues to a broad audience and providing a bulwark against 'fake news'.
Furthermore, the index's authors say the US is 'experiencing its first significant and prolonged decline in press freedom in modern history', with more than double the number of journalists arrested in the US than a year ago.
Likewise, the index reveals that 80% of the African news networks surveyed have seen their economic indicators 'drop'. This means their subsidies and advertising revenues have declined in the past year, leading some to 'self-censor' for fear of future funding cuts. That doesn't bode well for M20's efforts to campaign on media freedom and integrity at the G20 meetings.
At last year's G20 in Brazil, information integrity was prioritised, culminating in a ministerial declaration that without information integrity, trust in public institutions and democracy 'may be affected with negative effects on social cohesion and economic prosperity' and human rights. Many saw it as a bold move.
In contrast, under South Africa's G20 presidency, the issue has been somewhat relegated, struggling to get onto the agenda. M20 campaigners note just one 'high-level presentation' on AI-generated deepfakes at a workshop in June as part of the G20 Digital Economy Working Group.
'We do have good relations with the South African government,' says Media Monitoring Africa director William Bird, noting that Pretoria welcomed the M20 campaign. But ultimately 'we want to get information integrity formalised into one of the G20 tracks in future'. That might be a big ask given the range of economic- and development-focused topics the G20 is currently tasked with.
However, M20 has found an ally in the French mission to South Africa. Ambassador David Martinon recently hosted a dialogue with other African media policy organisations to 'place media sustainability, independent journalism and information integrity on the global agenda'. While M20 will be confined to the fringes of the heads of state meeting, the French delegation could be a useful vehicle to amplify the issue, albeit informally.
In an era of what is often dubbed 'fake news' – but which experts prefer to call 'coordinated inauthentic behaviour' – the language of the information landscape has adopted a more considered definition. It highlights not only inauthentic content but also how algorithms, hate speech and AI-generated deepfakes can pollute the information space, tinkering with content and how it's delivered to us.
Bird's efforts to raise the profile of this issue at the Johannesburg G20 are something of a placeholder – with an eye on next year's summit in the US. 'This is a way of providing a base so that work in the US can be built on this,' he says, fearful that under a US G20 presidency the issue could be downplayed or ignored.
He says the US administration's record on supporting independent media, including executive orders related to funding public service broadcasters, does not inspire confidence.
Although this year's G20 has no working group dedicated to information integrity, the digital economy working group touches on digital innovation and equitable, inclusive and just artificial intelligence.
Of course, the G20 is not the only forum to raise such issues. An inquiry by South Africa's Competition Commission identifies generative AI, digital advertising, social media and search engines as challenges to media viability in terms of running media companies and delivering public interest journalism.
Research ICT Africa provided expert testimony to that inquiry, highlighting the lack of a level playing field, which disadvantages the Global South. It speaks of big platforms like Meta, X and TikTok having 'algorithm designs that favour foreign media over local sources, subscription models over free content, and YouTube over South African broadcasters'.
This undermines local journalism and privileges values and priorities that favour the Global North over the Global South. 'What we are trying to do is future-proof our journalism,' argues Sanef's Izak Minnaar. 'We want global media development issues to focus on Africa and the Global South.'
The Competition Commission's inquiry provides leverage for some issues raised by M20. Those behind the campaign want to highlight the journalism aspect of the new media landscape – and not limit it to issues of business equity and media viability.
An M20 information integrity summit is scheduled for September in Johannesburg, and more analysis is under way on gender-based violence, online safety and child protection, and journalism as a public good.
In this context, information integrity will no doubt become an essential backdrop to the G20 Summit – one of the most important annual events on the geopolitical agenda. DM
Hashtags

Try Our AI Features
Explore what Daily8 AI can do for you:
Comments
No comments yet...
Related Articles

The Star
4 hours ago
- The Star
Trump to skip G20 Summit in South Africa, citing 'very bad policies' and violence concerns
US President Donald Trump said he will probably not attend the G20 Summit in South Africa, citing 'very bad policies' as the reason. Speaking on Air Force One on Tuesday, Trump said he will send someone else because of the 'problems' he has with South Africa. 'I think maybe I'll send somebody else because I've had a lot of problems with South Africa. They have some very bad policies,' he said. 'They have some very bad policies… A lot of people are being killed. I'd like to, but I don't think I will.' This remark reflects Trump's ongoing criticism of South Africa, particularly his repeated references to unsubstantiated claims that Pretoria has targeted white farmers—a narrative the South African government has consistently and categorically rejected. Further signalling strained diplomatic ties, US Treasury Secretary Scott Bessent did not attend the July G20 finance ministers' meeting in Durban, while Secretary of State Marco Rubio similarly opted out of a G20 foreign ministers' summit in Johannesburg earlier this year. During the early months of his second term, Trump amplified allegations of systematic discrimination against white citizens, a narrative promoted by Elon Musk, a South African-born entrepreneur and then-ally of Trump. The White House has also expressed formal concerns over South Africa's policies, notably the Black Economic Empowerment (BEE) framework and controversial land expropriation legislation, the latter of which was enacted in January 2023.


The South African
9 hours ago
- The South African
Donald Trump hints at skipping G20 summit in South Africa
US President Donald Trump has hinted that he may not attend the G20 leaders' summit in South Africa this November, citing continued dissatisfaction with the country's domestic and international policies. 'I think maybe I'll send somebody else because I've had a lot of problems with South Africa. They have some very bad policies,' Trump told reporters aboard Air Force One on Tuesday. The summit, scheduled to take place under South Africa's G20 presidency, is expected to be a key global diplomatic event. However, Trump's comments add fuel to already tense US-South Africa relations. Trump's criticism comes on the back of several contentious issues: South Africa's land reform policies : Trump has previously accused South Africa of land seizures and 'white genocide,' though these claims have been widely discredited. : Trump has previously accused South Africa of land seizures and 'white genocide,' though these claims have been widely discredited. International litigation : The US has opposed South Africa's case at the International Court of Justice (ICJ) , where Pretoria accused Israel of genocide over its actions in Gaza. : The US has opposed South Africa's case at the , where Pretoria accused over its actions in Gaza. Economic friction : In February, Trump signed an executive order slashing US financial aid to South Africa , criticising the country's Black Economic Empowerment (BEE) laws as discriminatory. : In February, Trump signed an executive order slashing , criticising the country's laws as discriminatory. Diplomatic boycotts: Earlier this year, US Secretary of State Marco Rubio boycotted a G20 foreign ministers' meeting hosted in South Africa. The ongoing Gaza conflict – which has left tens of thousands dead, displaced millions, and led to accusations of war crimes – has further divided Washington and Pretoria. South Africa continues to press its genocide case against Israel, a close US ally. South African President Cyril Ramaphosa has dismissed Trump's accusations, defending the country's land and economic policies as legitimate redress of historical injustices. He has urged Trump to attend the G20 summit, framing it as an opportunity for dialogue and diplomacy. If Trump follows through on skipping the summit, it would mark a major diplomatic snub, especially given South Africa's role as the current G20 chair. It remains to be seen who the US might send in his place. Analysts suggest Trump's decision could further deepen geopolitical divisions within the G20 and complicate discussions on global cooperation – particularly on issues of trade, security, and climate change. Let us know by leaving a comment below, or send a WhatsApp to 060 011 021 1 Subscribe to The South African website's newsletters and follow us on WhatsApp, Facebook, X and Bluesky for the latest news.

The Herald
11 hours ago
- The Herald
Trump says he may skip G20 summit in SA, cites policy disapproval
Earlier this year, secretary of state Marco Rubio boycotted a G20 foreign ministers' meeting in South Africa, which has the G20 presidency from December 2024 to November 2025. Washington, under Trump and former president Joe Biden, has complained about the case brought by South Africa at the International Court of Justice, where it accused Israel of genocide over its military assault in Gaza. Israel's assault has killed tens of thousands, caused a hunger crisis, internally displaced Gaza's entire population and also led to accusations of war crimes at the International Criminal Court. Israel denied the accusations and cast its Gaza offensive as self-defence after a deadly October 2023 Hamas attack that killed 1,200 people and in which more than 250 were taken hostage. Diplomatic relations between the US and South Africa have also been strained under Trump due to the government's BEE policies to address the legacy of centuries of racial inequality. Ramaphosa, who has urged Trump to attend the G20 summit, rejected Washington's claims that South Africa will use its land policy to arbitrarily confiscate white-owned land. Reuters