Booze protest costs small price to pay to send Trump a message
Apparently, this is the cost of sticking to our collective guns.
A freedom of information request filed by a former leader of the Manitoba Green party found out Manitoba Liquor and Lotteries is in possession of $3.4 million in unsold wine, spirits and beer from the United States.
The booze — which includes product pulled from Liquor Mart shelves and product that was ordered and on the way here — marks the front line in Manitoba's war with U.S. President Donald Trump.
Canadian whisky is advertised at a Liquor Mart in March while black plastic covers the U.S. whiskey section. The Manitoba government ordered American products removed from Liquor Marts in response to tariffs imposed by U.S. President Donald Trump. (Tim Smith / The Brandon Sun files)
Most government-owned liquor stores and some private wine and spirit companies across the country rushed to pull U.S. alcohol off its shelves in February after Trump threatened us with crippling tariffs and mused one too many times about bringing Canada into the union as the 51st state.
The cost of this protest was never discussed with the public. The premiers who ordered the alcohol to be removed — including Manitoba's Wab Kinew and Ontario's Doug Ford — hardly stopped to discuss the fiscal implications while they were gleefully ordering government liquor commission workers to strip the shelves of Jack Daniel's bourbon and Napa Valley wines. But we all had to know there was a cost.
In Manitoba, the up-front cost is $3.4 million. That is, of course, just a fraction of the retail value.
For example, Manitoba marks up wine by 95 per cent. So, $1 million in wine represents nearly $2 million in lost sales, and significant tax revenue. Remember, all net profits from the Manitoba Liquor and Lottery Corporation go directly into the province's general revenue. In the 2023-24 fiscal year, that added up to a whopping $732 million.
Based on the total transfer — which also includes profits from lottery and gaming — you could easily dismiss the loss of $3 million as chump change. But it's still lost revenue.
The only remaining question is — is $3.4 million a fair price to pay for the political dividends derived from hauling U.S. alcohol off Manitoba shelves?
To date, the answer is absoposilutely.
The fact is that Canadians started looking for ways to avoid buying American products well before Canadian politicians got in on the action. The militant Shop Canadian campaign was organic and extremely effective. So much so that just about every good and service in this country that can lay tenuous claim to being Canadian has engaged in concerted red washing, draping their offerings with Canadian flags and slogans.
How committed are we to continuing the various boycotts? Depends on which boycott you're talking about.
Government liquor stores are boycotting U.S. booze, it appears that private stores never started.
A quick and totally unscientific survey of Winnipeg wine stores shows that most are still selling a wide variety of U.S. wines online. And if they're selling it, it's likely because many of us are still buying it. That suggests that the longer it goes on, the more we will find a way of sneaking a bottle of American Pinot Noir now and again.
Other aspects of the Canadian 'elbows up' protest movement seem to show no signs of weakening.
A Manitoba Liquor Mart shelf encouraging Canadian alternatives to U.S. liquor. (Chris Kitching / Free Press files)
On the travel front, Canadians have sent Trump a very strong message. More than a quarter of all tourist visits to the U.S. come from Canada, and last year, we spent more than $20 billion south of the border. Trump's new-age manifest destiny and his tariff threats have driven down road-trip visits by nearly 40 per cent, and air travel by about a quarter. The industry estimates that every 10 per cent loss in visits by Canadians translates into $2 billion less revenue for hospitality businesses.
What does the future hold for the channels of the boycott?
Boycotts of food and alcohol will eventually lose their bite. The bigger concern for U.S. producers is whether Canadians learn to drink wine from other regions of the world and simply do not want or need to go back to American products.
The food boycott seems headed in the same direction. Don't be surprised if, come December, we drop our elbows long enough to stuff some California strawberries into our berry holes.
Tuesdays
A weekly look at politics close to home and around the world.
On travel, there are signs the boycott will continue longer, and have longer-lasting impacts. Discovering new places and new ways of getting there could very easily curb our appetite for U.S. visits. At least, until the U.S. industry starts offering travel deals that Canadians simply cannot refuse. (Are you listening Walt Disney Co.?)
Which brings us back to $3.4 million in unsold alcohol in Manitoba.
In the midst of a still-simmering trade war with the U.S., should we be fretting the government's decision to pull that much booze from Manitoba shelves? The quick answer is 'no.'
Very little of this product will go bad. Which means, like good wine and whiskey, it's a protest that will only get better with age.
dan.lett@freepress.mb.ca
Dan LettColumnist
Dan Lett is a columnist for the Free Press, providing opinion and commentary on politics in Winnipeg and beyond. Born and raised in Toronto, Dan joined the Free Press in 1986. Read more about Dan.
Dan's columns are built on facts and reactions, but offer his personal views through arguments and analysis. The Free Press' editing team reviews Dan's columns before they are posted online or published in print — part of the our tradition, since 1872, of producing reliable independent journalism. Read more about Free Press's history and mandate, and learn how our newsroom operates.
Our newsroom depends on a growing audience of readers to power our journalism. If you are not a paid reader, please consider becoming a subscriber.
Our newsroom depends on its audience of readers to power our journalism. Thank you for your support.
Hashtags
Try Our AI Features
Explore what Daily8 AI can do for you:
Comments
No comments yet...
Related Articles
Global News
4 minutes ago
- Global News
Police chiefs throw their weight behind Liberals' border and crime bill
Canada's 'top cops' are calling on Parliament to quickly pass the federal Liberal government's package of reforms to the Criminal Code, aimed at stiffening border security and expanding police powers. Police chiefs from across the country wrapped their four-day annual summit in Victoria on Tuesday, where they threw full support behind Prime Minister Mark Carney's proposed Bill C-2. Association of Chiefs of Police president Thomas Carrique told reporters that Canadian police are dealing with modern and international threats with 'tools and authorities built for a different era, guided by outdated and inadequate legislation.' 3:02 'Canada must be secure': New border bill gives new powers to CBSA officers, police, postal workers, Health Canada 'It's a public safety imperative. Geopolitical instability fuels transnational organized crime, whether it's human smuggling as well as illicit exportation and importation of drugs, precursors, and firearms,' he said. Story continues below advertisement 'Organized crime groups are taking advantage of systematic blind spots, outdated statutes, and digital platforms to victimize Canadians. And when these gaps go unaddressed, it is police who are left to manage the consequences.' Bill C-2, also known as the Strong Borders Act, proposes sweeping changes to Canada's immigration system, tightening timelines for migrants to make asylum applications and giving the government the power to suspend new applications and the processing of existing claims. The bill would also remove barriers that prevent police from searching mail to advance a criminal investigation, where authorized to do so under the law, and expand Canada Post's inspection authority to open mail. Get breaking National news For news impacting Canada and around the world, sign up for breaking news alerts delivered directly to you when they happen. Sign up for breaking National newsletter Sign Up By providing your email address, you have read and agree to Global News' Terms and Conditions and Privacy Policy The legislation would also make it easier for authorities to access information about internet subscribers, enable the health minister to more rapidly control precursor chemicals that can be used to produce illicit drugs and introduce new restrictions on large cash transactions. And ports of entry, transporters and warehouse operators will be required to allow Canada Border Services Agency (CBSA) officials to conduct export inspections, matching existing requirements for import inspections. 1:34 Coalition of civil society organizations call for government to scrap Bill C-2 The Canadian Civil Liberties Association joined 39 other organizations in July calling on Ottawa to withdraw the legislation. Story continues below advertisement 'The Bill's privacy eroding elements include a power to demand revealing information without independent authorization from any service provider, could pave the way to expanded international information-sharing agreements, and will empower the government to significantly expand the amount of data police and security agencies can access by compelling digital services to redesign their services,' the coalition said. The coalition says the legislation would allow public officials including police, CSIS and others to demand information from companies without judicial oversight and little proof. 'The government argues this information is innocuous and only includes general details about the nature of the services a company is providing. But in practice law enforcement officials will be able to extract highly revealing information about people with these demands, including whether they've purchased something at any company, interacted with any website, or stayed at any hotel,' the group said. Carrique downplayed those critiques on Tuesday. 'Police are not asking for nor will C-2 provide us with any authorities that we didn't have in a pre-digital world. So we are simply looking to ensure that we have legislation that aligns with technology today, so we can legally with judicial authorization require electronic evidence that has gone beyond our reach right now,' he said. 0:25 Anandasangaree introduces bill aimed at tightening border security, immigration system He further argued that police looking for fentanyl precursor chemicals and 3D printed gun parts are currently handcuffed by legal loopholes that prevent them from getting judicial authorization to search and seize mail sent through Canada Post. Story continues below advertisement Police chiefs Tuesday also called on Ottawa to go further with changes to the bail system. The association said it wants to see the Criminal Code changed to allow for the prolonged detention of chronic offenders who repeatedly commit petty crimes, in addition to similar changes for violent offenders. Outgoing Victoria Police Chief Del Manak said officers are frustrated with repeatedly arresting the same people only to see them released on conditions to offend again while on bail. 'What we're really asking for here is the criminal justice system needs to be strengthened, there must be consequences and a deterrence for those that are carrying out criminal activity every single day,' he said. 'And that's the confidence that we want to give to every citizen, and they deserve that.' In that message, the chiefs have added their voices to a growing chorus that includes B.C.'s own premier and attorney general, along with provincial and federal opposition politicians and numerous mayors. The earliest changes to the Criminal Code could come is the fall legislative sitting.
Vancouver Sun
34 minutes ago
- Vancouver Sun
Canada's laws ‘outdated and inadequate' to fight cross-border crime, head of police chiefs group says
VICTORIA — The head of the Canada's police chiefs association says they are guided by 'outdated and inadequate' laws that were never designed to take on the current criminal landscape that no longer respects international borders. Thomas Carrique, president of the Association of Chiefs of Police, said police would have been in a better place to 'disrupt' transnational crime, if the federal government had listened to his group in 2001, when it last proposed legislative changes. 'Across Canada, police are confronting the domestic fallout of international disorder, but we are being asked to do so using tools, and authorities built for a different era, guided by outdated and inadequate legislation that was never designed to address today's criminal landscape,' he said on Tuesday. Start your day with a roundup of B.C.-focused news and opinion. By signing up you consent to receive the above newsletter from Postmedia Network Inc. A welcome email is on its way. If you don't see it, please check your junk folder. The next issue of Sunrise will soon be in your inbox. Please try again Interested in more newsletters? Browse here. Carrique said 'geopolitical instability and social unrest' around the world are driving what he called 'a new wave of public safety threats' as Canadian police confront transnational organized crime, extremism, drug trafficking and exploitation through the internet. 'Whether it's human smuggling as well as illicit exportation and importation of drugs, precursors, and firearms, organized crime groups are taking advantage of systematic blind spots, outdated statues, and digital platforms to victimize Canadians,' he said. While geopolitics and social unrest might be beyond the control of Canadians and their government, their level of preparation and response is not, he said. The current Strong Borders Act legislation proposed by the federal governments gives police many — but not all necessary _ tools to confront globalized crime, he said. The government said the bill would help authorities combat transnational organized crime, stop the flow of fentanyl, crack down on money laundering and bolster police response to criminal networks. Carrique, who's the commissioner of Ontario Provincial Police, made the comments during a news conference in Victoria, where the association is holding its annual conference. He said the federal government's legislation aligns closely with several resolutions the group has passed during the conference this week. Carrique said there are a 'number of loopholes' that must be closed to reflect the realities of 21st century crime, such as the inability of police to get a search warrant for any Canada Post package under 500 grams. 'So, a judge cannot even issue a search warrant for a package of that size that may contain enough fentanyl to kill a number of people.' Carrique also repeated calls for bail reform. 'The federal government has promised a crime bill this fall, introducing tougher bail sentencing provisions,' he said. 'This will be critical.' Victoria Police Chief Del Manak agreed on the need for tougher release conditions. Manak said police made 16 arrests during a two-day-long project to disrupt disorder in the city's downtown core. 'But what was telling was the number of rearrests that we made,' he said. An individual arrested in one block was re-arrested the next day not far from his first arrest following his release on conditions, Manak added. 'What we're really asking for here is the criminal justice system to be strengthened,' Manak said. 'There must be consequences, and a deterrence for those that are carrying out criminal activity every single day,' Manak said. Carrique acknowledged 2024 statistics that show crime rates trending down. The Crime Severity Index, for example, dropped by 4.1 per cent in 2024. 'We attribute that to some amazing work being done by police officers across the country, as well as other social services,' Carrique said. 'But we need to balance that against … the perception of crime, and it doesn't do us any good as police leaders in building trust, and confidence, or legitimacy, when we simply cite statistics to say, 'property crimes are down five per cent, or the homicide rate dropped 10 per cent,' because there are still people being victimized,' he said. Our website is the place for the latest breaking news, exclusive scoops, longreads and provocative commentary. Please bookmark and sign up for our daily newsletter, Posted, here .
Winnipeg Free Press
34 minutes ago
- Winnipeg Free Press
Defence minister celebrates military raises during CFB Winnipeg tour
Defence Minister David McGuinty toured Canadian Forces Base Winnipeg for the first time Tuesday to meet officials and tout the federal government's pay increase for military members. After the tour, which wasn't open to media, McGuinty expressed hopes that the pay bump will help bolster the Canadian Armed Forces' ranks, add to members' sense of purpose and make life more affordable for them. 'We are hopeful that this pay package, which has been long, long overdue, will help with the recruitment and retention, and the incredible service in the forces,' he told reporters outside the base. JOHN WOODS / FREE PRESS Lieutenant-General Jamie Speiser-Blanchet, commander and chief of the Royal Canadian Air Force (RCAF), and David McGuinty, minister of national defence, speak to media outside Canadian Forces Base 17 Wing Winnipeg Tuesday. Prime Minister Mark Carney announced pay increases and new or improved allowances last week. The package includes entry-level increases for privates (20 per cent for the regular force members and 13 per cent for reservists). New recruits will receive an annual salary of just over $52,000, up from $43,368. Other members will receive eight or 13 per cent raises, retroactive to April 1. McGuinty, who became the federal Liberal government's defence minister in May, is visiting CAF bases across Canada this summer. He was joined in Winnipeg by Lt.-Gen. Jamie Speiser-Blanchet, who recently became commander of the Royal Canadian Air Force. Wednesdays Sent weekly from the heart of Turtle Island, an exploration of Indigenous voices, perspectives and experiences. Speiser-Blanchet said the RCAF is about 2,000 personnel short of the 'established strength' that it intends to be, but there has been a 'net increase' in recruits in the last two years. McGuinty described CFB Winnipeg as a major economic generator for Manitoba, while citing plans to put money into housing and other projects in the future. JOHN WOODS / FREE PRESS Lieutenant-General Jamie Speiser-Blanchet, left, commander and chief of the Royal Canadian Air Force (RCAF), said the RCAF is about 2,000 personnel short of the 'established strength' that it intends to be, but there has been a 'net increase' in recruits in the last two years. He said housing, infrastructure, child care and spousal employment opportunities were discussed during Tuesday's meetings. McGuinty said he received a detailed briefing about the North American Aerospace Defense Command. The Canadian NORAD region is headquartered in Winnipeg. Chris KitchingReporter Chris Kitching is a general assignment reporter at the Free Press. He began his newspaper career in 2001, with stops in Winnipeg, Toronto and London, England, along the way. After returning to Winnipeg, he joined the Free Press in 2021, and now covers a little bit of everything for the newspaper. Read more about Chris. Every piece of reporting Chris produces is reviewed by an editing team before it is posted online or published in print — part of the Free Press's tradition, since 1872, of producing reliable independent journalism. Read more about Free Press's history and mandate, and learn how our newsroom operates. Our newsroom depends on a growing audience of readers to power our journalism. If you are not a paid reader, please consider becoming a subscriber. Our newsroom depends on its audience of readers to power our journalism. Thank you for your support.
