How are vaccines tested?
The American Academy of Pediatrics, opens new tab has said childhood vaccines are carefully studied in randomized controlled trials — including with placebos — to ensure they're safe and effective. Here is what you need to know about how vaccines are tested and approved in the United States:
What has Kennedy said about vaccine testing?
In an appearance with television personality Dr. Phil McGraw in April, Kennedy said that "the only vaccine that was ever safely tested in a clinical trial against a placebo was the COVID vaccine... None of the others were ever tested against placebo."
He repeated that claim during heated Congressional testimony on Wednesday.
What is a randomized controlled trial?
In order to receive approval from the U.S. Food and Drug Administration, most new medical treatments must be tested in large trials to confirm their effectiveness and safety.
In such trials, participants are randomly assigned to either a group receiving the new medicine or a control group. That ensures that any differences in outcomes can be attributed to the new treatment.
In many randomized trials, a new therapy is compared to an older, well established therapy. If no standard therapy already exists, the new treatment is compared to a placebo – an inert sham treatment without any therapeutic or physiological effect.
Are new vaccines always compared to placebos?
Not always. When a brand new vaccine is developed to protect against a disease that has no preventative therapy on the market, the FDA requires placebo-controlled trials to prove the vaccine is safe and effective.
Drugmakers also develop vaccines to improve upon an existing shot, either by updating an already-approved vaccine or by identifying a mechanism for defending against the virus that offers better protection and/or fewer side effects.
In those cases, the newer vaccine is compared to an existing vaccine. It is considered unethical to randomly assign volunteers to receive an inert placebo, leaving them – and the unvaccinated people they may come in contact with - vulnerable to a disease when a protective vaccine is available.
After successful testing in randomized controlled trials, all vaccines are then monitored in 'real world' studies, which usually include more diverse patient populations and reflect actual use in routine healthcare settings.
Have all childhood vaccines been tested against a placebo?
No. Childhood vaccines currently recommended for use in the United States that have been tested against placebos include Sanofi's (SASY.PA), opens new tab Daptacel, used to protect against diphtheria, tetanus, and pertussis (whooping cough), Sanofi's immunization against respiratory syncytial virus (RSV) Beyfortus, and GSK's Rotarix and Merck's (MRK.N), opens new tab RotaTeq, the two rotavirus vaccines licensed for use in the United States.
Some of the currently available vaccines were tested by comparing them to already-approved vaccines.
For example, the very first combined vaccine against measles, mumps and rubella (MMR), approved in 1971, was compared in randomized controlled trials to a measles-only vaccine and a placebo. But most subsequent MMR vaccines were not compared to placebos because that would have left study participants vulnerable to preventable diseases.
What do experts say about Kennedy's proposal?
Kennedy's proposal to require that all new vaccines undergo safety testing in placebo-controlled trials 'is ethically problematic and will slow testing down for no good reason,' Dr. Seema Shah, director of research ethics at Ann & Robert H. Lurie Children's Hospital of Chicago, said in a statement.
Hashtags
Try Our AI Features
Explore what Daily8 AI can do for you:
Comments
No comments yet...
Related Articles
The Independent
an hour ago
- The Independent
The worrying thing Covid can do to your blood revealed by new study
Covid may prematurely age blood vessels by around five years, according to a new study, increasing the risk of heart attack and stroke. Research published in the European Heart Journal revealed that a Covid infection could accelerate the ageing of blood vessels, particularly in women. Vaccinated individuals show less stiffening in their arteries and stabilised symptoms over time in comparison to those who had not been protected against Covid. Lead researcher Professor Rosa Maria Bruno, from Université Paris Cité, said: "We know that Covid can directly affect blood vessels. We believe that this may result in what we call early vascular ageing, meaning that your blood vessels are older than your chronological age and you are more susceptible to heart disease. 'If that is happening, we need to identify who is at risk at an early stage to prevent heart attacks and strokes." The new study tested nearly 2,500 people from across the world, categorising them based on whether they had Covid and whether they had been hospitalised for it, both in a general ward and in an intensive care unit. Tests were taken six months after an infection and again after 12 months. It measured each person's vascular age with a device that examines how quickly a wave of blood pressure travels between the artery in the neck and the legs. The higher the measurement meant the stiffer the blood vessels, indicating a higher vascular age. It found that all three groups of patients who had a Covid infection had stiffer arteries compared to those who hadn't been affected. The average increase in women was 0.55 meters per second for those who had mild Covid, 0.60 for those who had been hospitalised, and 1.09 for those in intensive care. According to researchers, an increase of around 0.5 meters per second is "clinically relevant" and equivalent to ageing around five years. It also increases the risk of cardiovascular disease, like heart attack, stroke or sudden cardiac arrest, in 60-year-old women by 3 per cent. The difference between men and women could come down to immune systems, Prof Bruno added. She said: 'Women mount a more rapid and robust immune response, which can protect them from infection. However, this same response can also increase damage to blood vessels after the initial infection.' She said the virus acts on specific receptors in the body that are in the lining of the blood vessels. The virus will use these receptors to enter and infect cells. Last month, it was reported that a new strain of Covid had spread across the UK, accounting for the highest proportion of cases - around 30 per cent. Experts warned the Stratus strain was resisting immunity and had a unique symptom of giving people a hoarse voice.
Reuters
5 hours ago
- Reuters
Madrid's poor neighbourhoods clamour for more trees to cool streets in deadly heatwaves
MADRID, Aug 20 (Reuters) - As Madrid sweltered at the peak of one of Spain's longest-ever heatwaves, the temperature on a street in one of its poorest neighbourhoods - Puente de Vallecas - measured 41.4 degrees Celsius (106.5 Fahrenheit) by early afternoon. A few hundred metres down the street it was 38.6 C. The difference? One section of the street was treeless while the other was shaded by a row of leafy mulberries. According to scientific studies, trees can play a key role in mitigating the often-deadly effects of heatwaves and as temperatures in Spain rise as a result of global warming they may play a crucial role in helping to regulate temperatures. However, activist groups say that Madrid has been losing tree cover, particularly in some of its poorer neighbourhoods, and are pushing the mayor to plant more. 'The difference between having or not having trees on your street has an immediate impact on your health,' said Manuel Mercadal, a member of activist group Sustainable Vallekas, which has been measuring temperature differences on Vallecas's streets to raise awareness. San Diego, a part of Puente de Vallecas, registered some of the highest temperatures in Madrid, according to a Polytechnic University of Madrid study, which identified so-called "urban heat islands" where temperatures were as much as 8 C higher than in other parts of the city, such as parks. The heat is exacerbated by a lack of air conditioning because many households can't afford it, said Pablo Chivato, a coordinator of the neighbourhood association for Puente de Vallecas. More frequent heatwaves are taking their toll on elderly patients, especially those with underlying cardiac problems, said Antonio Cabrera, a family doctor at a primary care centre in La Elipa in southeastern Madrid. "Higher mortality rates were traditionally associated with winter in European countries. Nowadays, for people aged 80–90 with multiple health conditions, this is the time of year when many of them die," Cabrera said. As temperatures rise, trees have become a political issue. Madrid's Mayor Jose Luis Martinez-Almeida has clashed with activists over trees since taking power in 2019, particularly over plans to cut down more than 1,000 trees for the extension of a metro line. Official data show that while the total number of trees has increased by 2.4% under Almeida's watch, that was mostly in the expanding middle-income districts in the city's east. All except one of the southern districts lost trees. Puente de Vallecas has lost 1,314 trees or 3% of its total tree cover since 2019. Some of the loss was caused by a heavy snowstorm in 2021 that killed 80,000 trees. But many are also felled as the city embarks on construction projects. The mayor's office didn't respond to a request for comment. Left-wing party Mas Madrid has pledged to plant 75,000 more trees so that the city has one tree every seven metres (23 feet). The law used to stipulate that felled trees must be replaced, but a recent reform means local councils in certain circumstances can create a fund into which to pay what it would have cost to plant new trees, said Lola Mendez of the environmental group Ecologists in Action. Almeida's office said it has planted nearly 40,000 trees in empty tree pits under a plan announced in 2022. Data published by the city in 2023 showed 1,318 trees were planted in Puente de Vallecas, but that 719 empty tree pits were covered over. The city hasn't published more recent data. Chivato said his neighbourhood association worked with the mayor's office to plant trees in 75% of empty tree pits in the Puente de Vallecas neighbourhood of San Diego. But many remain empty.
Press and Journal
6 hours ago
- Press and Journal
Aberdeen man thriving three years after care home's failings left him facing needless 'end of life' care
Recent failings at a troubled Aberdeen care home have stirred up painful memories for a former resident's family, whose loved one was hospitalised for severe malnourishment. Wendy Sutton spoke candidly about her family's ordeal after her brother, Michael Yeoman, was placed in Hamewith Lodge in Northfield back in 2022. She told The Press and Journal his care left him so poorly that a visiting nurse believed he was in his final days. The worried medical professional is even said to have prescribed end of life medication to ease his pain. Only when he was hospitalised did the care home's failings become clear. He made a significant recovery after being moved from Hamewith Lodge and, in new accommodation, is 'thriving' three years on from his ordeal. Wendy is clear that the home badly failed her brother, with key issues including poor nutrition and medication mismanagement — complaints that were upheld by the Care Inspectorate. She has come forward to speak out after a 2025 report outlined continued failings at Hamewith. For Wendy the issues raised by inspectors are eerily similar to those made by she and her family during her brother's time there. It was back in February 2022 that Michael, aged 67, was moved from his specialist home into Hamewith Lodge. He suffers from severe mental disabilities, with the family referring to him as 'Peter Pan' as he has the mental age of a five-year-old. He'd been in the care home just two months when it became clear his health was declining rapidly, prompting the family to demand help. A Covid outbreak at the home had forced the cancellation of family visits. But they continued to interact with him over video and Wendy could see a difference in his appearance. 'We noticed on a number of occasions, with each and every FaceTime, that Michael was deteriorating,' she said. 'He was rocking back and forth in his chair. He wasn't communicating very well. And he had black eyes and bruising on his body.' According to Wendy, the staff said her brother's appearance was simply down to Covid. But within six weeks he had lost 10kg in weight. Michael's brother Brian tried to visit him, but was told by staff that he was 'fine'. Undeterred, Brian turned up unannounced, creating what the family said was 'visible panic' among the staff. And in fact, by the end of the day, staff had attempted to administer end of life care – a move that confounded his siblings. Wendy said: 'They told us he was 'end of life' but we couldn't understand why because he had recovered from Covid, and his vitals and blood pressure were good. 'We were told we couldn't sit in with Michael because he was end of life. He was prescribed end of life drugs. 'We demanded that Michael be taken to hospital but they didn't want that. 'They said he was comfortable where he was and we were advised to leave him. 'We fought to get him into the hospital. 'At the hospital we were told that he was suffering from malnutrition and severe dehydration and they didn't know if he would pull through. 'Michael would have died if we hadn't intervened.' A spokesperson for HC-One, which operates Hamewith Lodge, told The Press and Journal: 'Mr Yeoman sadly experienced a rapid decline in his health in May 2022, which prompted colleagues to contact his GP services for additional medical advice. 'Following a consultation with an NHS advanced nurse practitioner, Mr Yeoman was placed on 'End of Life Care' and was moved to hospital soon after. 'This decision was not made by colleagues at the home and a subsequent hearing by the Nursing and Midwifery Council found no wrongdoing.' Despite that, Wendy lodged five specific complaints with the Care Inspectorate regarding Michael's situation. All were upheld. In documents made available to The P&J, the Care Inspectorate found: For Wendy, reading the 2025 report into Hamewith Lodge left her 'horrified'. She said: 'It was the same situation as before. 'The care inspector's recommendations are exactly what they said to us in 2022. 'It's now 2025 and I just think someone is going to die in that home before something is actually done.' One complaint Wendy made was that Michael was given improper doses of medication. This was echoed by inspectors in the 2025 report. She said: 'I couldn't believe how many times we had put in concerns about certain things over the few weeks that Michael was there. 'It was practically on a daily basis that there were always issues.' An HC-One spokesperson added: 'We take the feedback and findings from the Care Inspectorate very seriously. 'We acknowledge that the standard of care for Mr Yeoman fell below the level we as an organisation set ourselves and our residents expect. 'We apologise for the upset and distress caused to Mr Yeoman and want to reassure his family that everyone at the home is continually committed to raising the standards of care to an appropriate level.' Hamewith Lodge made improvements following the problems in 2022, achieving a 'very good' rating in a 2024 report. The report noted that during that time a new management team had been installed. Hamewith Lodge was also praised for being 'clean, tidy and clutter free'. However, in the nine months since that report, there has once again been a decline in standards. Following his hospital admission, Michael remained in a hospital bed for weeks as he recovered. He was then offered a chance to live at Cowdray Club Care Home, where he remains to this day. Wendy said: 'He has improved greatly since being at Cowdray Club. 'It's a wonderful end to the story, because it could have had a very different ending.'
