
Germany's Israel policy is changing — Friedrich Merz's support for Palestinians' right to statehood is proof
In a move that could surprise many observers of German foreign policy, Chancellor Friedrich Merz has openly criticised Israel's military strategy in Gaza. Speaking at his annual summer press conference on Friday, Merz said Israel's approach to the war in Gaza was 'no longer acceptable', marking the second time in a single week that he has publicly questioned the conduct of Israel's war. Days earlier, in an interview with a German media outlet, Merz reaffirmed the Palestinians' right to statehood and expressed concern over Israel's actions in Gaza.
While the remarks stop short of a fundamental policy reversal, they reflect a shift in tonality. Germany has long been one of Israel's staunchest allies, with its support rooted not just in strategic alignment but in the moral reckoning of its history. Germany's post-Holocaust relationship with Israel has always been layered with moral weight and historical obligation. Since the end of World War II, successive German governments across the political spectrum have enshrined a doctrine of 'Staatsräson' (reason of state), wherein the security of Israel is seen as part of Germany's national responsibility.
Against this backdrop, Merz's remarks are noteworthy. The shift is not in Germany's foundational support for Israel's right to exist or defend itself; Merz and his government have continued to reiterate that support. What might seem to be changing, however, is Germany's willingness to draw public lines around how Israel exercises that right, particularly when civilian suffering in Gaza is mounting and prospects for peace seem increasingly remote. It is worth noting that the previous government has also attempted to persuade Israel to adopt a different approach to the war in Gaza.
As chancellor, Merz might be attempting to address several audiences simultaneously: The German public, the Israeli government and his EU allies. Domestically, the comments allow him to extend a mild rapprochement, if any, to the pro-Palestinian Germans who have found themselves on the wrong end of the baton since October 7. They also act as an overall response to increasing criticism that Germany has disregarded humanitarian suffering in Gaza. Internationally, they align Germany more closely with the emerging consensus for recognising Palestinian statehood and conditioning future ties with Israel on meaningful progress toward a two-state solution.
This move also furthered a broader European frustration with Israeli Prime Minister Benjamin Netanyahu's hardline policies. EU leaders have time and again grown wary of Netanyahu's rejection of a Palestinian state, his expansion of settlements in the West Bank, and the absence of a long-term political vision beyond military operations. Just a day before Merz's statement, Giorgia Meloni of Italy called the Israeli attack on the church in Gaza 'unacceptable', furthering her call from May urging Israel to respect international law in its military operation in Gaza. With this context, Merz's statement seems like an attempt to restore moral and diplomatic balance to Germany's Israel policy, one that still upholds Israeli security but not at the cost of Palestinian rights or EU credibility.
Merz's remarks also draw attention to a deeper tension in Germany's foreign policy of upholding a consistent, values-based stance across different global crises. Since the Russian invasion of Ukraine in 2022, Berlin has presented itself as a moral actor championing territorial sovereignty, international law, and civilian protection. Former Chancellor Olaf Scholz had, in 2022, written in an op-ed that Germany would be 'doing everything it can' to foster an international order based on democracy, security, and prosperity. Berlin's leadership within the EU on sanctions against Russia, military aid to Ukraine, and the defence of democratic values has reinforced this image.
Yet, Germany's relatively muted criticism of Israel's actions in Gaza has exposed accusations of double standards. Why is Russia condemned as a violator of international norms for targeting civilians in Ukraine, while Israel is shielded from similar scrutiny despite comparable devastation in Gaza? The perceived inconsistency in the German 'values' has undermined their credibility in the Global South and has fuelled the call for Western hypocrisy. Merz's recent intervention can then be seen as an effort to close that values gap and demonstrate his and Germany's commitment to humanitarian principles that apply universally.
While Merz's comment is important and rare, caution should prevail. The immediate impact of this on German-Israeli relations is likely to be limited. Israel remains one of Germany's closest allies outside of Europe, and both countries share deep economic, cultural, and security ties. Thus, a shift in political and strategic mood is a distant thought, but what is potentially shifting is the rhetorical mood. As the humanitarian crisis in Gaza persists and intensifies, Germany can be expected to make stronger statements. But will that lead to any actions, such as backing UN resolutions, supporting aid initiatives over Israeli objections, or even pausing certain arms exports? Unlikely.
Within the European Union, Merz's statement could act as a bridge between the more pro-Israel northern European bloc (Germany, Austria, the Czech Republic) and southern states more vocal about Palestinian rights (Spain, Ireland, Portugal). Germany has often played a mediating role in EU foreign policy, and Merz may now be positioning Germany and, by extension, himself as a voice for restraint, humanitarianism, and diplomacy.
What Merz's remarks ultimately reflect is a growing realisation that unwavering support for Israel's security cannot be a blank cheque. If Germany wants to remain a credible voice in global affairs, particularly in the Middle East, and strengthen its global south outreach, it must grapple with the contradictions of supporting a military campaign that many view as disproportionate, while also championing human rights and international law.
The writer is a political analyst and German Chancellor Fellow (2023–24), based between New Delhi and Berlin. He writes on foreign policy, electoral trends, and domestic politics

Try Our AI Features
Explore what Daily8 AI can do for you:
Comments
No comments yet...
Related Articles


Time of India
an hour ago
- Time of India
India cannot ‘switch off its economy', says envoy to UK on Russian oil imports
India's high commissioner to the UK Vikram Doraiswami has dismissed the western criticism of New Delhi's oil imports from Russia and said a country can't "switch off its economy". Doraiswami said many of India's European partners are also continuing to buy rare earth and other energy products from the same countries that they're "refusing to let us buy from". He was speaking to British radio station, Times Radio, last week after the PM's visit to London. "Don't you think that that seems a little odd?" Doraiswami said. When asked about India's "closeness" with Russia and President Vladimir Putin, he said New Delhi's relationship is based on a number of metrics. "One of these is our long-standing security relationship that goes back to an era in which some of our western partners would not sell us weapons but would sell them to countries in our neighbourhood that use them only to attack us," the high commissioner said in an indirect reference to US-Pakistan military ties from the Cold War era. He said India has an "energy relationship" with Russia, which is the result of "everybody else buying energy from sources that we used to buy from earlier". "So we've been displaced out of the energy market largely, and the costs have gone up. We are the third-largest consumer of energy in the world. We import over 80% of our product. What would you have us do? Switch off our economy," Doraiswami said. "We also see around us relationships that other countries maintain for their own convenience with countries that are a source of difficulty for us. Do we ask you to come up with a little test of loyalty?" he said. India has called EU sanctions on Rosneft refinery in India as unilateral to which it does not subscribe. On the Russia-Ukraine conflict, he said Prime Minister Narendra Modi has repeatedly said that "this isn't an era of war". "He's made that point repeatedly, including with the president of Russia and with the president of Ukraine," he said. "We are very keen for this terrible conflict to stop, as we are keen for conflicts across the world to stop," Doraiswami added.


News18
an hour ago
- News18
Important matters listed before Supreme Court on Wednesday
Important matters listed before the Supreme Court on Wednesday (July 30): * SC to hear plea of Allahabad High Court Judge Yashwant Varma challenging findings of an in-house inquiry panel report against him over the incident of cash discovery from his official residence. * SC to hear pleas related to prosecution of Tamil Nadu former minister V Senthil Balaji. * SC to hear plea of former Union minister Lalu Prasad Yadav seeking stay of trial in land for job scam. * SC to hear a batch of pleas alleging authorities used Israeli military grade spyware to snoop on various personalities including politicians, activists and journalists. *SC to hear plea of NGO alleging Indiabulls Housing Finance Limited (IHFL) disbursed dubious loans to corporate entities. view comments First Published: July 30, 2025, 09:00 IST Disclaimer: Comments reflect users' views, not News18's. Please keep discussions respectful and constructive. Abusive, defamatory, or illegal comments will be removed. News18 may disable any comment at its discretion. By posting, you agree to our Terms of Use and Privacy Policy.


News18
an hour ago
- News18
At UN, India Seeks 'Purposeful Dialogue, Diplomacy' For Two-State Solution To End Israel-Palestine War
Last Updated: Ambassador Parvathaneni Harish said humanitarian assistance is vital in sustaining life and must remain outside the realm of politics or conflict India has pushed for 'purposeful dialogue and diplomacy" to bring a 'two-state solution' for the ongoing Israel-Palestine war which has led to an unprecedented humanitarian crisis in the Gaza Strip, including the risk of a famine. Ambassador Parvathaneni Harish, India's Permanent Representative to the United Nations, while speaking at the UN's High-Level International Conference on 'The Peaceful Settlement of the Question of Palestine and the Implementation of The Two-State Solution" said: 'Our efforts must now focus on how to bring about a two-state solution through purposeful dialogue and diplomacy, and bringing the parties to the conflict to engage directly with each other." Noting that the human suffering in Gaza 'continues unabated", Harish said: 'Tens of thousands have been killed, and many more injured. Several medical facilities have been damaged or destroyed. Children have been deprived of schooling for more than 20 months. Humanitarian aid needs to flow without impediments." 'Humanitarian assistance is vital in sustaining life and must remain outside the realm of politics or conflict," he said, adding that Palestinians in Gaza must have access to food, fuel and other basic necessities 'without hindrance". He added: 'Lasting solutions are required to achieve this. Certain action points are emerging from the Conference. Following up on them is the key. Let us not be content with paper solutions but strive to achieve practical solutions that actually make a tangible difference in the daily lives of our Palestinian brothers and sisters. India expresses its complete readiness to contribute to this noble endeavour." India had also voted in favour of a UNGA resolution last year that announced an international summit in June 2025 to discuss the 'two state' formula. On the Gaza issue, India has skillfully balanced its growing and strategic relationship with Israel while maintaining its traditional support for the Palestinian cause, including the two-state solution. While firmly upholding Israel's right to defend itself against Hamas attacks, the Indian government has also called on Israel to respect international law and avoid harming civilians. 'India shares historic and strong ties with our Palestinian brothers and sisters. We have always stood by them and our commitment towards the Palestinian cause is unwavering," said Harish earlier. The Ministry of External Affairs also reaffirmed India's position in Parliament on Friday, stating that India has consistently advocated for a negotiated two-state solution, aimed at establishing a sovereign, independent, and viable State of Palestine within secure and internationally recognised borders, coexisting peacefully alongside Israel. First Published: July 30, 2025, 08:56 IST Disclaimer: Comments reflect users' views, not News18's. Please keep discussions respectful and constructive. Abusive, defamatory, or illegal comments will be removed. News18 may disable any comment at its discretion. By posting, you agree to our Terms of Use and Privacy Policy.