Students must be more critical, discerning: Experts weigh in on online peer-tutoring channels, Singapore News
Mohammed Danie Dahlan is one such student.
The 18-year-old started a Telegram channel named socialstudieslovers in October 2023 after completing his GCE N-levels, where he shares Social Studies notes and exam strategies.
A check by AsiaOne on Wednesday (June 10) showed that the channel has about 1,620 subscribers.
While such online platforms can be an effective means to reinforce learning, experts say that students must continue to practice critical thinking and discernment while utilising them.
Dr Lee Ai Noi, senior lecturer at the National Institute of Education's (NIE) Psychology and Child & Human Development department, told AsiaOne that peer tutoring can be highly effective when thoughtfully organised.
She added that online peer tutoring initiatives, such as student-led groups on platforms like Telegram, offer convenience and immediacy, allowing students to share notes, clarify doubts, and support each other in real time.
However, in the absence of teacher supervision or formal quality checks, the reliability and depth of shared content can vary significantly.
Pointing out that students at the Primary and Secondary level might not have the ability to assess whether the information they receive is accurate or appropriate, Dr Lee said: "Informal online peer tutoring is most effective when supported by some level of oversight, structure, or moderation.
"These elements can help safeguard learning quality and ensure a positive, balanced experience for all participants." Such platforms a 'natural response'
Associate Professor Gregory Arief D Liem, a lecturer in the same department, echoed similar views to Dr Lee.
"These (services) call for students to be more critical, more discerning and take personal responsibility in terms of to what extent they should engage," he told AsiaOne.
He also stated that such online communities and platforms are "a natural response" given the importance placed on academic performance in Singapore and the digital era we are in.
"It is understandable that this phenomenon is arising because of the strong motivation for Singaporean students to do well in their studies," he said.
Dr Rebecca Chan, also from NIE's Psychology and Child & Human Development department, described the sustainability of such peer tutoring initiatives as a "two-way street".
Speaking to AsiaOne, she said: "Teaching is only sustainable when the 'teacher' keeps learning and remains curious about the subject matter to stay current and relevant.
"It is a two-way street where student peers raise questions that challenge the tutor... who is motivated and curious enough to delve deeper into areas that initially baffled them in search of answers."
"Even if it is not sustainable, it is still a cause for celebration — our youth have initiated and learnt to harness social media for learning and teaching." Managing such channels not easy: Students
Speaking to AsiaOne, Danie said that managing his channel is hard work as he has to ensure that it remains active, answer students' questions in a timely manner and ensure that the content he puts out is on-par with the syllabus taught in schools.
Despite this, the first-year Polytechnic student said he enjoys juggling multiple responsibilities and thrives in fast-paced environments.
To keep himself on task, Danie sets goals such as posting minimally once a week to remind students to revise certain topics or improve their understanding of the subject as a whole.
He also began offering tutoring services over Zoom between August and October last year, charging $5 per hour.
He has coached around 20 students taking their O and N-level examinations to date.
Raina Nafisa, 17, started The Muggers in July last year before her O-level English Oral examination.
The channel consolidates study tips, notes, and helpful resources across subjects from various sources in Singapore.
Speaking to AsiaOne, the student said that she would manage most matters pertaining to the channel with the help of a few friends.
But after a few months of doing so, Raina felt she is dedicating too much time to the initiative.
She then decided to hand over the reins of the channel to her friend, Kara Wee, who was already helping to facilitate Zoom sessions, shortly after their O-levels.
"I feel that she is more proficient than I was; from finding resources to talking with people...or just managing her time in general," Raina said.
Wee, a Year 5 student at St Joseph's Institution, told AsiaOne: "While hosting all the zoom lectures, I developed a profound sense of accomplishment knowing that I was able to help so many of my peers with their academics."
She added that many students have even approached and thanked her personally since she took ownership of The Muggers.
When asked if the two have any future plans for the channel, they mentioned discussions about turning it into a tuition centre.
Otherwise, it will continue to be a network of resources for future students to use, they added.
[[nid:718488]]
bhavya.rawat@asiaone.com
Try Our AI Features
Explore what Daily8 AI can do for you:
Comments
No comments yet...
Related Articles
Independent Singapore
3 days ago
- Independent Singapore
'Too young for a flat, too broke for rent — where do you go when you're homeless in your own country?'
SINGAPORE: In the muted corner of Reddit, a Singaporean user posted a plain question: 'Does anyone have any experience as to where to sleep and maintain basic hygiene without a permanent roof and without seeking help from agencies?' While the post was brief, the story it implied was profound and complex. The original poster—a local citizen under 35—is in a risky spot. Jobless, with no family support to rely upon, and unqualified for public housing because of age limitations. In addition, acquiring private property is improbable and out of reach, and with rent becoming too expensive, he's now facing a life without a permanent living accommodation. What ensued was a wave of lived experiences, not expressions of pity or shame, only practical advice and sympathetic words of reassurance from fellow Singaporeans, some of whom had walked the same path. Sleeping under the radar One commenter shared a recollection from childhood – poor and dispossessed, 'taking showers at public swimming pool facilities, and sleeping at Changi Airport,' a real shelter for many in moments of silent desperation. The airport, with its 24/7 lights and comparatively harmless setting, has long been a viable option, a last resort for the homeless. Another shared a more mature version of that narrative: 'six months living inside a rented car, parking close to the workplace or public grounds, sleeping in the steamy uneasiness of a parked vehicle, and taking a bath at community swimming pools or workplace amenities when possible.' East Coast Park was a vital location—free public baths and virtual inconspicuousness, but sleep was elusive. 'Sometimes cannot sleep and the next day have to work—damn difficult.' Working for shelter One response provided another possible lifeline — consider 'working at Resorts World Sentosa (RWS), particularly in F&B roles.' A former casino server narrated how part-time staff got not only salaries (occasionally paid every day) but also food. It was tough work, but for someone who needs fast cash and nourishment, it could bridge the gap. Platforms like FastJobs list short-range and daily-paid gigs, critical for someone with no monetary safeguards. The key, another Redditor pointed out, was flexibility. Keeping one's head above water necessitates readiness to take whatever work comes and making acts of survival a routine. The reluctance to seek help What stood out in the original post was an inaudible struggle to ask for help, not out of pride, but the anxiety to burden others. However, one commenter gently pushed back: 'If the only reason you don't want to reach out to social services is because you don't want to bother anyone, I suggest you just do it. They exist for a reason.' Singapore has agencies, interventions, and facilities for rough sleepers, even if they're not always visible. One such option is the Safe Sound Sleeping Places (S3P) system, set up all over the island. These are nominated accommodations supervised by community groups and charitable organisations. They often have shower facilities, offer meals, and most importantly, safety. Some of these living quarters are faith-based, but anyone can avail of their services. The objective isn't conversion, but compassion. It's available, without judgment. Dignity in hard times For most, homelessness isn't a choice; it's a condition that occurs, often slowly, until unexpectedly one is already navigating where to sleep at night and how to stay clean. Yet, in these online threads, there's a sense of resilience. A certainty that even in one of the world's well-heeled cities, one can survive and endure without disappearing into gloom and desperation, provided that one adapts, accepts help, and holds on to some hope. 'Use your imagination and compromise where you can,' one former homeless netizen wrote. 'That's how I survived.' To the original poster—and others in similar situations—help exists, even if you have to reach a little further than you're used to, and if you're reading this from a place of ease, maybe you now know a little more about those who aren't—and what it takes to get through another night.
AsiaOne
3 days ago
- AsiaOne
Tanjong Katong sinkhole: Both directions of road open, bus services 36 and 48 resume , Singapore News
Nine days after a sinkhole formed on Tanjong Katong Road South, towards East Coast Parkway (ECP), road repairs and reinstatement works have been completed. Just before 5am on Monday (Aug 4), workers removed barricades facing Mountbatten Road and Tanjong Katong Road, allowing motorists to pass. Bus services 36 and 48 also resumed their west-bound routing. East-bound bus services and the bound of Tanjong Katong Road South, towards Mountbatten Road, resumed at noon last Saturday (Aug 2). Residents whom AsiaOne spoke to in the first week were concerned with inconvenience and safety. Many of them use the road frequently, some even within the hour before the sinkhole formed. Said Mr Ho, 70, who lives 500m away at a property along Amber Gardens Road: "Work has been ongoing at the PUB construction site for many months. Of course I am concerned to hear the news (of the sinkhole). Hopefully, PUB and the relevant agencies will check other worksites for safety before this repeats." Other residents told AsiaOne that both bounds of the road are heavily used by motorists and commuters in Marine Parade to get to and from ECP — connecting them to the airport, city, and western parts of Singapore (via the Marina Coastal Expressway). MP for Marine Parade-Braddell Heights GRC Goh Pei Ming, who made twice-daily visits to the site in the days following the incident, and authorities urged patience so that thorough assessment and tests could be carried out to certify the roads are safe for use. During a visit to the site on July 29, Sustainability and Environment Minister Grace Fu said that the incident was serious and should not have happened. She apologised to the driver of the vehicle, members of public and residents in the vicinity and affected motorists and commuters. Rigorous tests to ensure safety: LTA After the car was lifted out of the sinkhole on Sunday (July 27), national water agency PUB, which coordinated and led the recovery works, commenced backfilling the sinkhole with liquified stabilised soil (LSS). LSS is made of cement, soil and water, and is used to fill cavities in the soil. It also provides the strength needed for road construction. The authorities then carried out "a series of rigorous tests" to assess the ground condition, to ensure that the road was safe for reinstatement and reopening. Both the Land Transport Authority (LTA) and national water agency PUB said that ground-penetrating radar (GPR), physical probes, and seismic sensors were deployed for checks and scans. Timeline, what's next? A two-lane wide sinkhole formed on Tanjong Katong Road South, just after the slip road from Mountbatten Road, on Saturday (July 26). Adjacent to the sinkhole is a PUB worksite where a 16m-deep shaft connecting three sewer lines was being constructed. PUB said that a concrete component in the shaft, known as a caisson ring, failed at around 5.50pm. It is not known yet what caused the caisson ring to fail. A car, which had turned into Tanjong Katong Road South (from Mountbatten Road), fell into the sinkhole as the roads collapsed. The female driver was able to escape from the car before water filled up, and she was rescued by quick-thinking migrant workers and taken to hospital. That night, BCA conducted preliminary checks on the nearby One Amber condominium and landed houses in the vicinity. It later said that the buildings were not affected by the incident. On July 27, following overnight checks on the integrity of adjacent roadways, the sinkhole was drained and the stricken car hoisted out at around 2pm. That evening, PUB said it had called for a safety time-out to review and assess sewer construction works similar to the Tanjong Katong incident. Backfilling works, which commenced after the car was lifted out, was completed on Monday (July 28). The same day, the Building and Construction Authority (BCA) said it was commencing an independent investigation into the sinkhole incident. BCA said that the investigation will "examine the circumstances leading to the formation of the sinkhole, identify the root causes, and take the necessary actions against any non-compliance under the Building Control Act". During her site visit on Tuesday (July 29), Sustainability and Environment Minister Grace Fu also announced the formation of an internal investigation panel within the Ministry of Sustainability and Environment (MSE) to probe the cause of the incident, and how to prevent similar incidents. Recovery work at Tanjong Katong Road South may have been completed, but investigation into the incident has just begun. According to BCA and MSE it could take months due to the complexity and the need for geophysical tests. [[nid:720879]] editor@
Independent Singapore
4 days ago
- Independent Singapore
‘I'm done with S'pore! I wanna move to M'sia…' — S'porean man earning S$100K/year feels ‘jaded with life in SG; KL feels sweet place to be'
SINGAPORE: When a Singaporean earning a cool S$100,000 a year starts eyeing Kuala Lumpur as his personal Eden, the internet listens but starts to debate. In a viral post on the r/Malaysia subreddit, a 35-year-old Singaporean man, husband and father of three, poured his heart out because he's completely burnt out, and now he hears KL is calling… 'Of late, I have been feeling very jaded with life in SG and have been fantasizing of leaving,' he wrote. 'KL feels like a sweet place to be, with opportunities likely far greater than anywhere else in Malaysia.' Done with SG. Wanna move to Msia. byu/serstay inmalaysia He added that while his job in Singapore's education sector is stable, and he's close to his extended family, he's dreaming of a reboot across the Causeway. Notably, he's unsure where or how to begin the transition, and was hoping Malaysian Redditors could shed some light. Grass is greener on the other side, or just different? The replies ranged from 'please think twice' to 'you're not alone.' But one theme stood out like a neon sign on Jalan Bukit Bintang: it's complicated. 'Mate, I'm sorry to burst your bubble,' one Malaysian bluntly said, reminding the Singaporean that 'There's a reason plenty of Malaysians are seeking opportunities in Singapore.' Another Redditor, who worked in both Malaysian and Australian schools, urged the man not to oversimplify the move. 'Don't narrow it down to country. Narrow it down to the specific school… and what their values are.' See also S377A: "Doing the right thing" - or killing the Opposition softly? A few Singaporeans chimed in as well, some sympathising. One candidly admitted: 'If you struggle with S$100K and three kids in Singapore, you're gonna cry if you go to Malaysia and try to live on RM100K.' 'You need about RM180K/year in KL…' At current exchange rates, S$100K is roughly RM330K — a salary only a small percentage of Malaysians earn. While KL might offer a lower cost of living on some fronts, Redditors were quick to point out hidden pitfalls: Housing: A good 3-bedroom condo would cost close to RM2,000/month A good 3-bedroom condo would cost close to RM2,000/month Transportation: You'll need a car, as public transport is not quite like that in Singapore You'll need a car, as public transport is not quite like that in Singapore Schooling: International schools are the go-to for expats, but come with a hefty price tag International schools are the go-to for expats, but come with a hefty price tag F&B & Groceries: Hawker food and local stuff may be cheaper, but fast food and other items, not necessarily. One Malaysian explained: 'To maintain the same lifestyle as S$100K in SG, you need about RM180K/year [in KL]. [That's] around RM16K/month.' Not easy unless you're in a niche or leadership role. 'Sounds like you just need a vacation…' Many suggested a softer landing, like taking a sabbatical or long break before calling the movers. 'Sounds like you just need a vacation,' one advised. 'Rent a long-term Airbnb, take the kids on a road trip, breathe. Then decide,' another added. See also Crime and punishment: Where is the debate? A few even floated hybrid options: 'Keep earning SGD with a remote job while living in JB or KL. That's the best of both worlds.' Maybe look to Europe? A major concern for the Singaporean was the pressure cooker of Singapore's education system. One commenter agreed with him: 'I increasingly feel bad for the kids. I can live with a lower income if it means a more holistic learning environment for them.' But others warned Malaysia might not be the promised land for this. 'If you want growth mindset education, maybe look to Europe,' said one. 'Most people on this subreddit want to leave Malaysia…' Not all Malaysians were keen to sell their country. One local Redditor pointed out, 'Most people on this subreddit want to leave Malaysia,' to hint to the Singaporean that he's basically going against traffic. Another added a reality check: 'KL is just Singapore 2.0 — with worse walkability,' additionally warning him that the traffic jams could make him rethink his life. And then there were those who saw the appeal in collectively saying that though Malaysia isn't perfect, if he and his wife can earn five digits each and keep expectations grounded, they'll be okay. Life here can be calm, exciting, and less intense — if they find the right setup. See also What Is Retirement Like for You in Singapore? 'You're thinking too much…' In perhaps the most Singaporean reply of all, one commenter captured the tension with a touché: 'You got too much money, that's making you think too much. Give me some, and you'll know how important your job is,' he wrote. Verdict: Lion City or KL City? So, should this jaded Singaporean ditch the Lion City for KL's nasi lemak or roti canai mornings at a slower pace? Reddit's collective answer: not unless he has a concrete job lined up, realistic expectations, and a serious heart-to-heart with his family. Because sometimes, the grass isn't greener. It's just a different turf — and it might require a 7-year car loan and international school fees. But if you're really tired of SG's rat race, a short escape across the border never hurt. Just remember: don't pump RON95! Meanwhile, in other news, a 28-year-old Malaysian woman poured her heart out in a heartfelt post about working in Malaysia just won't do for her mum and dad, because to them, even earning RM7K/month is still not 'good enough'. You can read more about her story over here: 28 y/o Malaysian woman laments because her parents keep forcing her to work in Singapore to earn more
