Education minister open to eliminating Ontario school trustees
Already, Paul Calandra has appointed supervisors who have taken over five of Ontario's biggest school boards. Trustees have been shut out of their accounts, and those appointees have been tasked with making decisions to improve boards' financial situations and avoid deficits.
But Calandra has consistently told all 72 school boards in the province they are on notice and must direct money to classrooms. He has talked of more centralization and creating greater consistency from board to board.
"The ministry needs to step up to the plate moreso than it has over the last 40 years," he told hundreds of municipal politicians Tuesday in Ottawa, where he and cabinet colleagues fielded questions at the annual conference of the Association of Municipalities of Ontario.
"We have to stop downloading responsibility to trustees who neither have the authority to tax or the expertise to undertake some of the things that we're asking them to do."
CBC News asked Calandra if he would go so far as to eliminate trustees in the province, even ahead of the next school board elections. Nominations are scheduled to open next May and the votes held alongside municipal elections in October 2026.
Everything is on the table and the governance model for education is being reviewed, Calandra answered.
"If it looks like we can deliver the product better, provide better outcomes for students, better resources for teachers, and give parents certainty, and if that means eliminating trustees, then I'm going do it," he said.
5 boards under watch
Calandra assumed the education file in cabinet in March. By April, he had put the Thames Valley District School Board in southwestern Ontario under provincial control after an investigation, spurred by news trustees having taken a retreat at an expensive Toronto hotel even while the board struggled with deficits.
Then, at the end of June, he announced the results of third-party reviews of the finances at Toronto District School Board, Toronto Catholic District School Board, Dufferin-Peel Catholic District School Board and the Ottawa-Carleton District School Board (OCDSB).
They too are now under supervision. Bill 33 has been tabled at Queen's Park to make it easier for the government to take over a board without an outside review.
The report from PricewaterhouseCoopers into the Ottawa-Carleton board found "no examples of reckless or deliberate wrongdoing, lack of financial oversight or governance or actions resulting in potential reputational damage."
But trustees in Ottawa had been struggling to avoid a fifth deficit, and have consistently said boards are underfunded, without enough money to cover special education, inflation, or to pay substitutes for staff on sick leave.
The OCDSB managed to make $18 million in cuts and pass a balanced budget in June. Now that the board is under supervision, they have been locked out of their accounts.
That access to accountable local trustees is critical as families navigate the education system, says opposition education critic Chandra Pasma, the NDP member of provincial parliament for Ottawa West—Nepean.
Pasma says she is concerned that without trustees, directors of education would be accountable only to an out-of-touch education minister in Toronto. She has watched developments in Quebec and Nova Scotia, where those provinces have moved to abolish boards.
"We're talking over 175 years of democratically elected school boards in what is now Canada," said Pasma. "Unfortunately what we're seeing now with this attempt to grasp more and more power is part of a pattern with the Ford government."
Ontario has 72 school boards, including public and Catholic systems in both French and English.
The education minister has consistently told them they are all on notice and must direct spending to classrooms, even as Calandra acknowledges there are many talented and hardworking trustees at many school boards.
"But ultimately the governance structure is based on a system that is outdated and old and that needs to be modernized, and we're going to do that work," Calandra told CBC News, noting the government will also respect the constitutional rights of French-language boards and Catholic boards.
"I don't foresee a situation where governance of our public English public schools remains the same," he added.
Hashtags
Try Our AI Features
Explore what Daily8 AI can do for you:
Comments
No comments yet...
Related Articles
National Post
23 minutes ago
- National Post
Bus crash kills 79 people, including 19 children, returning to Afghanistan from Iran
A bus crash in northwestern Afghanistan killed at least 79 people returning from Iran, including 19 children, an official said. Article content Two people were also injured in the crash, Interior Ministry spokesperson Abdul Mateen Qani told The Associated Press. Article content Article content Tolo News, citing the official, said the crashed happened around 8:30 p.m. Tuesday in Herat province. The bus collided with a truck and a motorbike, causing a massive fire that killed many on the spot, the outlet reported. Article content Article content Nearly 1.8 million Afghans have been forcibly returned from Iran in the past few months. A further 184,459 were sent back from Pakistan and more than 5,000 were deported from Turkey since the beginning of the year. Additionally, nearly 10,000 Afghan prisoners have been repatriated, mostly from Pakistan. Article content Article content Article content The Taliban criticized neighboring countries in July for the mass expulsion of Afghans, as Iran and Pakistan expel foreigners who they say are living there illegally. The Ministry of Refugees and Repatriation said some 6 million Afghan refugees remain overseas. Article content Advocacy group Save the Children called on countries to ensure that returns to Afghanistan were safe and noted that forced returns of children risked further harm. Article content 'This horrific tragedy is a stark reminder of the deadly risks hundreds of thousands of Afghan children face on their journeys from Iran,' a group official, Samira Sayed Rahman, said in a statement. Article content
CBC
an hour ago
- CBC
PC, NDP candidates struggle during final debate of Spruce Woods byelection
Candidates for the Progressive Conservatives and New Democrats struggled to explain their respective positions on gender education in schools and the responsibility for the poor quality of Manitoba's health-care system on Wednesday evening, during the second and final debate leading up to the Spruce Woods provincial byelection. Six days before voters in the southwestern Manitoba constituency choose a new MLA, PC candidate Colleen Robbins, the NDP's Ray Berthelette and Liberal Stephen Reid spent 85 minutes fielding policy questions in front of about 90 people gathered at the community hall in Sprucewoods, a residential area in the RM of Cornwallis, immediately north of Canadian Forces Base Shilo. Robbins, a former nurse and longtime PC party volunteer and official, said she supported more of a role for parents versus teachers when it comes to gender education because she said she was concerned gender-affirming surgery is being performed on minors in Manitoba. "I believe a parent should be involved until a child is of adult age," Robbins said. When debate panellist Kelly Saunders, a Brandon University political science professor, informed Robbins this form of surgery is not performed on minors in Manitoba, Robbins said she has nothing against gays or lesbians and has friends within the LGBT community. The PC candidate later committed to educating herself on topics she doesn't understand well and apologized for her earlier statements — the second time Robbins issued an apology this week. The debate about "parental rights" prompted Liberal candidate Reid, a teacher, to mock the idea that educators are capable of indoctrinating students to become gay or lesbian or convince them to change genders. "If you can indoctrinate your kids, they would be wearing deodorant and showering," Reid quipped. Realtor-turned-NDP candidate Berthelette, meanwhile, was unable to state how the governing New Democrats could mitigate chronic understaffing at the Brandon Regional Health Centre and other deficiencies in health care, aside from repeatedly stating that his party cannot make significant progress after only 22 months in power. This gave Reid and Robbins the opportunity to share stories about lengthy waits for ambulances and a shortage of emergency rooms in Spruce Woods, a mostly rural constituency that encompasses the north side of Brandon, nine municipalities surrounding the city and the urban communities of Souris, Glenboro, Rivers, Wawanesa and Oak Lake. "In 2023, 90 per cent of that election was about health care the how the NDP had a plan to fix it, and I haven't seen that plan," Robbins said. Early in Wednesday's debate, Robbins faced a series of questions from the event's panellists — Saunders, Brandon Sun reporter Alex Lambert and Winnipeg Free Press columnist Deveryn Ross — over a series of now-deleted Twitter comments that prompted apologies early this week from the PC candidate. Robbins repeated her disavowal of a 2020 tweet professing hatred for unions and a 2021 tweet that displayed what she now describes as an ignorance of intended purpose of residential schools system. Meanwhile, Berthelette was asked who would represent Spruce Woods if the NDP wins the byelection — him or Wab Kinew — given there are more signs on lawns and public places featuring the premier's face than there are signs bearing the candidate's visage. "It's obvious, it's Team Wab," Berthelette said. "Wab is one of the best promoters of rural Manitoba that we have." Spruce Woods has only elected Progressive Conservative MLAs since the constituency was created in 2011. But the governing New Democrats have made an effort to be more competitive this year. The byelection was sparked by the resignation in March of former PC MLA Grant Jackson, who is now the Conservative member of Parliament for Brandon-Souris. In the four months between April's federal election and the provincial byelection call in July, Kinew or members of his cabinet made made no fewer than seven appearances in southwestern Manitoba, where they announced or re-announced at least $334 million worth of operating or capital funds. Advance voting in the Spruce Woods byelection is open until Aug. 25. The byelection itself takes place Aug. 26.
CTV News
an hour ago
- CTV News
FOI reveals compensation for Victoria's new police chief, head-hunting cost
A contract obtained through a freedom of information request lays out the compensation for Victoria's new police chief. A contract obtained through a freedom of information request lays out the compensation for Victoria's new police chief. Victoria's incoming police chief has secured a salary nearly $53,000 higher than her predecessor. CTV News Vancouver Island has learned Victoria Police Department (VicPD) Chief Fiona Wilson is earning $350,000 annually. The now-expired job posting for the role listed a salary range of $270,000 to $310,000. 'We offered a salary commensurate with the experience of the incoming chief,' Victoria and Esquimalt Police Board Chair Micayla Hayes said in an interview on Wednesday. Outgoing Chief Del Manak earns $297,250 a year, VicPD said. 'The last chief will leave thinking, 'Oh, I didn't make that much money,' but that's the name of the game,' said CTV public safety analyst Chris Lewis. While the department provided the salaries of the incoming and outgoing chiefs, it declined to share Wilson's contract and the expense receipts from the search firm that helped hire her, 'given the privacy considerations of the candidates and the incoming chief.' CTV News obtained the contract and receipts through a freedom of information request. The five-year agreement lays out compensation outside of Wilson's salary, including a $20,000 lump sum for moving expenses, seven weeks of vacation, and an unmarked vehicle that can be used in her personal time. 'It's important that the public understand where their money is going,' Lewis said. The contract says Wilson is considered to be on-duty most of the time, and is on call 24 hours a day. 'Police chiefs need to be well-paid,' said Lewis, who is a former commissioner of the Ontario Provincial Police. 'They have a huge impact on public safety and their decisions can ultimately change the face of the judicial process and government relations in the city.' Wilson is on the job with Manak until he retires on Aug. 31. She's declining interviews until the department's change of command ceremony on Aug. 28. Wilson, a former deputy at the Vancouver Police Department (VPD), is the highest-paid municipal police chief on southern Vancouver Island. Saanich's chief earns $290,572, while the chiefs in Central Saanich and Oak Bay earn $251,912 and $228,552, respectively. 'Policing is competitive at all levels. The board is thrilled to have brought in such a dynamic and well-respected chief, and we're comfortable with the salary,' Hayes said. 'There's no question in the board's mind that we made the right selection.' In 2024, Wilson's gross compensation as a Vancouver deputy totaled $370,329 according to the VPD's executive remuneration list. That includes payouts such as those for unused vacation. 'She ultimately could have been chief potentially in Vancouver and made a heck of a lot more, so why not pay her the proper amount?' Lewis said. Chief search cost $88K VicPD's board hired head-hunting firm Pinton Forrest & Madden (PFM) to conduct a national search for its next top cop. The search cost taxpayers $82,021. PFM had a base fee of $60,000 and $22,021 in food, travel, and accommodation expenses for the candidates, VicPD said. Candidate names are redacted from the expense documents, which include receipts for travel on BC Ferries, HeliJet, and mainline airlines. The candidates stayed at various hotels during the search, most of which cost roughly $300 a night.
