Supreme Court lawyer body slams ED notice to senior advocate
Representative image (ANI)
NEW DELHI: The Supreme Court Advocates on Record Association (SCAORA) on Monday condemned ED's notice to senior advocate Arvind Datar for his legal opinion on allotment of employee stock option plan (ESOPs) granted to Rashmi Saluja, ex-chairperson of Religare Enterprises by Care Health Insurance, which is being probed by the agency.
Datar had objected to the summons, saying a legal professional's opinion in connection with a case could not be the subject matter of probe. ED subsequently withdrew the summons. Despite its withdrawal, SCAORA, through president Vipin Nair and general secretary Nikhil Jain, issued a statement on ED's unwarranted action. tnn
Probing lawyers for legal opinion undermines rule of law: SCAORA
Despite withdrawal of summons, SC Advocates on Record Association (SCAORA) through chief Vipin Nair and general secretary Nikhil Jain issued a statement on ED's unwarranted action, saying it "reflects a disturbing trend of investigative overreach that threatens the independence of legal profession & undermine the very foundation of the rule of law".
"To summon a senior member of the Bar for discharging his professional responsibility is a misuse of authority and an affront to sanctity of role of advocates. When agencies resort to coercive measures against advocates merely for giving legal opinions, they don't just target individuals, they strike at the institutional structure that ensures justice," SCAORA said. "If advocates can be subjected to coercive measures for providing legal advice, it would paralyse the functioning of the legal system and erode public confidence in the justice delivery mechanism," it added.
by Taboola
by Taboola
Sponsored Links
Sponsored Links
Promoted Links
Promoted Links
You May Like
오스템 임플란트 받아가세요
임플란터
더 알아보기
Undo
ED had earlier sent a questionnaire to Arvind Datar and former IRDAI chairman J Hari Narayan, asking them whether they knew before giving legal opinion that IRDAI, the insurance regulator, had already rejected the offer of ESOPs to Saluja, who is under investigation for alleged financial irregularities related to Religare.
Sources said Saluja was facing a criminal probe for alleged irregularities in Religare and its subsidiary Care Health Insurance. IRDAI has not only cancelled ESOPs granted to her but imposed a penalty of Rs 1 crore for allotment of ESOPs despite IRDAI's disapproval. Saluja has already exercised Rs 40 crore worth of ESOPs before it was cancelled by IRDAI.
Datar told ED he could not respond to queries without approval of the client (Religare). However, Religare said it had no objection to ED asking Datar to explain the circumstances.
Try Our AI Features
Explore what Daily8 AI can do for you:
Comments
No comments yet...
Related Articles
Indian Express
11 minutes ago
- Indian Express
Telangana govt grants administrative sanction for Phase 2B of Hyderabad Metro
Telangana on Monday accorded administrative sanction for Phase 2B of Hyderabad Metro Rail (Phase 2B), estimated to cost Rs 19,579 crore, as a joint venture between the state government and Centre. The order in this regard from the Municipal Administration and Urban Development department, dated June 16, is applicable to three upcoming corridors. According to the order, after careful examination of the matter, the government accorded 'administrative sanction for implementation of Hyderabad Metro Rail Phase-II (B) project consisting of three corridors for a length of 86.1 km to be undertaken by Hyderabad Airport Metro Limited as a 50:50 Joint Venture (JV) project between Government of Telangana and Government of India…' The estimated cost will be funded through a JV model, adhering to the Government of India's norms and policy guidelines. While the state government will contribute Rs 5,874 crore (30%) of the total cost, the Centre will provide Rs 3,524 crore (18%). A significant portion, Rs 9,398 crore (48%), will be sourced as debt or loans from financial institutions like Japan International Cooperation Agency (JICA), Asian Development Bank (ADB), etc. Finally, a Public-Private Partnership (PPP) component will cover the remaining Rs 783 crore (4%). Under Phase 1, the state government operates three corridors covering 69 km and is the largest public-private partnership metro rail project in the world. Since 2017, the Hyderabad Metro Rail Ltd (HMRL) has been operating trains on the LB Nagar to Miyapur, Nagole to Raidurgam, and JBS to MGBS corridors. The stretch from MGBS to Falaknuma, however, has not materialised, mainly due to objections related to property acquisition and route alignment issues, and the new government has taken up the work for this stretch too along with the rest of the Phase 2 corridors. Under Phase 2A, a proposal covering five corridors (76.4 km) at an estimated cost of Rs 24,269 crore has been sent to the Union Ministry of Housing and Urban Affairs (MoHUA). Phase 2 A includes Corridor IV: Nagole – Shamshabad RGIA (Airport Corridor) stretching 36.8 km, Corridor V: Raidurg – Kokapet Neopolis covering 11.6 km, Corridor VI: MGBS – Chandrayangutta (Old City Corridor) extending 7.5 km, Corridor VII: Miyapur – Patancheru covering 13.4 km, and Corridor VIII: LB Nagar – Hayat Nagar stretching 7.1 km. The Hyderabad Airport Metro Limited (HAML) submitted proposals for Phase 2B to the government in May this year. Under Phase 2B, a 39.6-km stretch is proposed between RGIA to Future City (Skills University) as Corridor IX; a 24.5-km stretch is proposed between Jubilee Bus Station (JBS) and Medchal as Corridor X; and a 22-km stretch is proposed between JBS and Shamirpet as Corridor XI.
Hans India
24 minutes ago
- Hans India
Pune bridge collapse deaths crime of culpable homicide, says Uddhav Thackeray in Saamana
The Uddhav Thackeray's Shiv Sena on Tuesday led a scathing attack against the Mahayuti government over the death of four tourists and injuries to 51 others in the Pune bridge collapse, saying that people with cruel hearts are ruling Maharashtra and the deaths of tourists due to the government's inaction to repair the dilapidated bridge was a crime of culpable homicide. The Thackeray camp in the party's mouthpiece 'Saamana' alleged that the chief minister's move to offer condolences, announce a compensation to the heirs of the deceased and the inquiry into the incident are a sham, and the Mahayuti leaders are shedding crocodile tears. "Chief Minister's close associate and state minister of disaster management Girish Mahajan seems to be waiting for such accidents. As soon as an accident occurs, he immediately announces an assistance of Rs 5 lakh each to the families of the dead and free treatment to the injured. Girish Mahajan puts the price of the lives lost due to government negligence at Rs 5 lakh each, but why are the lives being lost? But why did these people lose their lives? Who will answer these questions?' asked the Thackeray camp. According to the editorial, the bridge on the Indrayani River has become old. The government had approved Rs 8 crore to rebuild it, but that money remained on paper. 'As all the money was spent on politically beneficial schemes, the state government's coffers are in tatters. As a result, the bridge on the Indrayani River was not repaired, and people were swept away. This is a crime of culpable homicide,' it said. The editorial further said that the Pune district Guardian Minister is Ajit Pawar, and the MLA from Maval, where this terrible accident took place, Sunil Shelke, is Ajit Pawar's close confidante. "The MLA did not see the dilapidated bridge in their village, but he himself spent over a hundred crore rupees to get elected. What exactly does Ajit Pawar do as the Guardian Minister, paying attention to the development of Pune? Builders and landlords develop, but people are swept away when the dilapidated bridge on the Indrayani River collapses," claimed the editorial. 'Maharashtra is being hit by accidents and mishaps. Several people from Maharashtra died in the Ahmedabad plane crash. A family from Akola was killed in a helicopter crash in Kedarnath. Five youths drowned in the Godavari River. Three tourists drowned in Charlotte Lake in Matheran. Only sad, disappointing news is coming from all sides," said the editorial. The editorial also referred to the cracks at the platform of the newly unveiled statue of the Chhatrapati Shivaji Maharaj at Rajkot fort in Malvan, saying it is quite worrisome. 'First, the first grand statue there collapsed last year and now the platform of the new statue has caved in. This is a failure of the Public Works Department. Here, the bridge over the Indrayani River collapsed, and there, the platform of the statue of Shivaji Maharaj has deteriorated. So, where exactly did the crores of rupees spent on this go? If you are not going to investigate this, then your announcements of investigations and checks are in vain," said the editorial. The editorial also mentioned the death of five passengers who fell from a Mumbai local train, saying that its grief and shock are disturbing the state. "Railways, rivers, roads and air transport have all become unsafe in the state. A series of such accidents is happening one after another in the country and Maharashtra. This has raised a question mark over the claims of those who call themselves Vikas Purush or survivors of the people. Accidents are happening, people are losing their lives in them, and this is largely due to the government's inaction," said Shiv Sena(UBT) in Saamana. The editorial also targeted Prime Minister Narendra Modi, saying that he left for a three-nation tour, ignoring the grief after the Ahmedabad plane crash. "The pyres of those who died in the plane crash have not been extinguished. The tears of the families have not stopped as the Prime Minister came and left Ahmedabad. The same can be said of the rulers in Maharashtra. The government, which is wasting money on unnecessary projects, does not work on the bridge over the Indrayani River and in a moment, the bridge collapses and people are swept away alive," said the Saamana editorial.
Indian Express
27 minutes ago
- Indian Express
Andhra woman tied to tree, thrashed over unpaid loan in Chandrababu Naidu's constituency; couple arrested
The police in Andhra Pradesh's Chittoor district Monday arrested a couple and their relatives after they allegedly tied up a woman to a tree and thrashed her over defaulting on a loan her husband, a daily wage labourer, had taken. The incident occurred in Narayanapuram village in Kuppam mandal, which is the constituency of Chief Minister N Chandrababu Naidu. The police said that the woman, identified as Sirisha, 28, was dragged from her house in front of her two children by S Manikappa, allegedly a Telugu Desam Party (TDP) member, on Monday. According to the police, R Timappa, the woman's husband, reportedly took a loan of Rs 80,000 from Manikappa of the same village two years ago, and has been paying it in small monthly installments. Timappa recently fled to Bengaluru, where he found work as a construction labourer, the police said, adding that he had stopped paying the money to Manikappa. 'Manikappa tied her to a tree and demanded money. His wife and sister-in-law ended up assaulting Sirisha. We have rescued Sirisha and registered a case under Bharatiya Nyaya Sanhita (BNS) sections 341, 323, 324, 606, and 34,'' said a police officer. Sirisha and her children had also allegedly fled to Bengaluru, and she returned to her village on Monday to seek school transfer certificates for them. A viral video of the incident that surfaced on Tuesday shows Manikappa's wife Munemma slapping and hitting Sirisha despite villagers trying to stop her. The police said that Manikappa and five members of his family and relatives have been arrested in the case.
