Chicago Cubs Must Improve Third Base Position; Here's How They Can Do It
Based on facts, either observed and verified firsthand by the reporter, or reported and verified from knowledgeable sources.
Newsweek AI is in beta. Translations may contain inaccuracies—please refer to the original content.
Despite having baseball's hardest schedule in April, the Chicago Cubs are going to come out of the month at least three games over .500, and they hold one of the easiest remaining schedules.
After a 3-1 loss to the Philadelphia Phillies on Sunday, Chicago sits at 17-12 atop the NL Central division. There is one thing still preventing Chicago from being a true contender in the NL, and that is third base.
CHICAGO, ILLINOIS - APRIL 18: Vidal Bruján #17 of the Chicago Cubs plays third base during a game against the Arizona Diamondbacks at Wrigley Field on April 18, 2025 in Chicago, Illinois.
CHICAGO, ILLINOIS - APRIL 18: Vidal Bruján #17 of the Chicago Cubs plays third base during a game against the Arizona Diamondbacks at Wrigley Field on April 18, 2025 in Chicago, Illinois.With their pursuit of Alex Bregman in the offseason, the Cubs clearly did not feel comfortable with what they were entering the season with at the position.
Top prospect Matt Shaw was given the starting job after his performance in spring training and Chicago hoped he would be the answer. That was not the case, and Shaw was optioned to Triple-A Iowa after just 18 games played.
Five players have spent time at third base for the Cubs already this season. That list includes Shaw, Gage Workman, Justin Turner, Jon Berti and Vidal Brujan. Those five players have given Chicago the No. 21 spot (-0.3) in Wins Above Average at the third base position.
It is not just the offensive struggles that are cause for concern, but the defensive struggles as well. Workman made two errors in just nine total chances, good for a .778 fielding percentage. Brujan made a costly mistake on Sunday that led to a Phillies run in the top of the 10th inning.
'You can argue up and back whether Bruján could have charged that ball and made a different play … He's playing way too deep to do that.'@MLBBruceLevine on the play that led to the Phillies' 2nd run in the 10th. pic.twitter.com/dJCqWsA15H — Marquee Sports Network (@WatchMarquee) April 28, 2025
It is a position that is a clear weakness that Chicago must address before it becomes too late. There are a couple of different ways that the Cubs could approach the situation.
The first would be to bring Shaw back up to the major leagues and let him work out his issues. Yes, the struggles at the plate would be tough to look past, but his defense would be levels above anyone else currently playing the position.
The second way is to explore the third base trade market. There are a few trades that Chicago could explore to make a splash and massive upgrade at the position.
Whatever the final decision is, it is important that the Cubs address the situation sooner rather than later, before it begins to cost them games and potentially even a division championship.
More MLB: Phillies Predicted to Target $8.2 Million All-Star Closer in Blockbuster Trade
Try Our AI Features
Explore what Daily8 AI can do for you:
Comments
No comments yet...
Related Articles
Yahoo
14 minutes ago
- Yahoo
The Short Porch is thinking about Pete Crow-Armstrong and pitchouts
If you are a fan of checking out leaderboards, have I got some leaderboards for you. Entering play today, 60 games into the season, your WAR leader in the National League is Pete Crow-Armstrong. That's true whether you're a fan of fWAR (3.6) or bWAR (3.8) and it doesn't take a lot of digging into the numbers to see how the Cubs centerfielder has played himself into the highly speculative early MVP conversation. He's slashing .281/.313/.562 with 15 home runs, 21 stolen bases and 51 RBI a little more than a third of the way through the season. I could talk about the bat or the glove for days, and probably will dig into both later this season. However, today I want to talk about PCA's baserunning and speed because it's contributing to circumstances I'm not sure I've ever seen on a baseball field. Take, for example, this play last night [VIDEO]. Advertisement The probability that PCA can and will head home sets up a situation where José Tena has to try and hold PCA on third, but by the time he's done that even Carson Kelly can leg out that grounder. That effectively turns an out into a baserunner because of the fear of the run. That's quite the trick if you can pull it off. But that highly improbable event happens a few times a season. And nothing prepared me for the more bizarre moment that involved PCA last night. Unfortunately this didn't make the highlight reel for a video, but I grabbed some screenshots. After PCA took a walk against former Cub Andrew Chafin to put runners at first and second with one out Carson Kelly hit a single to load the bases with Happ at third, PCA at second and Kelly at first. Michael Busch drew a walk to score Happ and keep the bases loaded. Dansby Swanson got called out on strikes on an outside pitch for the second out: Dansby is called out on a questionable strike three That set up one a play I'm not sure I've ever seen in an MLB game. Nico Hoerner, one of the best contact bats in baseball, comes to the plate with two down, the bases loaded and PCA at third. PCA knows his existence at third base is enough to cause distractions, and he decides to take advantage by dancing down the line in eyesight of Nationals reliever Cole Henry: PCA dancing down the line It looks mostly like PCA is trying to 1) take the attention of the battery while they try to get Nico out and maybe, if he's lucky, 2) induce a bad throw to cause some chaos. He's not all that far down the line even though he's moving a lot and it'd be silly to try and steal home with two outs and the righty on the mound. You can see where PCA is down the line here: PCA down the line just before the pitchout All of the above is why my eyes were not prepared for what happened next — an old school pitchout with the bases loaded and two down: Nationals pitchout with the bases loaded PItchouts are increasingly rare in today's game as you can see below: Advertisement I'm shortcutting a lot of great analysis here, but Sam Miller on his substack discussed the demise of the pitchout in 2023 and estimated each team might throw a single pitchout a season. The bottom line is that sabermetrics made a really compelling case that they weren't worth wasting a pitch that could be a strike, which makes sense. That said, even when pitchouts were much more common, I'm not sure I've ever seen a pitchout with the bases loaded because a team would only do it if you thought there were a reasonable shot at at getting a runner who was trying to steal. And with the bases loaded, the only runner who could be attempting to steal would be the guy on third. In this case, that would mean one of the fastest players in MLB taking a shot at stealing home with two outs despite the righty on the mound. Then again, maybe the combination of Nico in the box and PCA at the plate makes this a different equation. After all, if you can get the out at third, you eliminate the risk of Nico making contact with the bases loaded, which he promptly did [VIDEO]. What say you, Cubs fans? When was the last time you saw a pitchout with the bases loaded or did that play make you do a double take as well? Was it just a good risk to take given Nico's much higher than likely ability to get a hit at the plate? Or was it something else all together? Advertisement Either way, I can now definitively say I've seen a pitchout with the bases loaded. Pete Crow-Armstrong continues to be in the middle of the most unlikely things. More from
Washington Post
an hour ago
- Washington Post
Tigers scratch Carpenter against White Sox because of right hamstring tightness
CHICAGO — The major league-leading Detroit Tigers scratched right fielder Kerry Carpenter from the lineup against the Chicago White Sox on Wednesday night because of right hamstring tightness. Carpenter's hamstring has been bothering him for a few days. Manager A.J. Hinch said the Tigers were 'just being cautious' and that he was available to pinch hit. Carpenter hit a career-high three homers in a 13-1 romp over Chicago on Monday and was tied for second on the team with 13 this season. He was batting .273 with 27 RBIs.
Associated Press
an hour ago
- Associated Press
Tigers scratch Carpenter against White Sox because of right hamstring tightness
CHICAGO (AP) — The major league-leading Detroit Tigers scratched right fielder Kerry Carpenter from the lineup against the Chicago White Sox on Wednesday night because of right hamstring tightness. Carpenter's hamstring has been bothering him for a few days. Manager A.J. Hinch said the Tigers were 'just being cautious' and that he was available to pinch hit. Carpenter hit a career-high three homers in a 13-1 romp over Chicago on Monday and was tied for second on the team with 13 this season. He was batting .273 with 27 RBIs. The Tigers optioned right-hander Dylan Smith to Triple-A Toledo with Sawyer Gipson-Long returning from elbow and hip injuries that sidelined him for nearly two years. The 27-year-old right-hander made his first start since Sept. 28, 2023. Detroit also recalled right-hander Jason Foley from Toledo and placed him on the 60-day injured list while he recovers from right shoulder surgery. Detroit had the best record in the majors at 40-22 entering Wednesday's game. ___ AP MLB:
