This week will haunt the prime minister after his most damaging U-turn yet
Why you can trust Sky News
It has been a painful week to watch.
A U-turn in slow motion, culminating in a midnight climbdown as Number 10 agreed to concede to defiant MPs on Thursday night.
The concessions are considerable. They mean, among other compromises, that existing claimants of personal independence payments (PIP) and the health aspect of Universal Credit will be protected from welfare reforms.
Some MPs, like Diane Abbott and Nadia Whittome, remain unconvinced, but they were never high on the list of rebels the government expected to persuade.
Ministers now hope that with the backing of MPs like Dame Meg Hillier, the chair of the Treasury Select Committee, the bill will pass the Commons.
Their problems won't end there, though.
Firstly, there is the question of money. The Resolution Foundation estimates the concessions will cost £3bn of the £5bn the chancellor hoped to save from the welfare reforms.
The prime minister 's spokesperson says the changes will be fully funded in the budget and there will be no permanent increase in borrowing. They won't comment on any potential tax rises to plug the gap in Rachel Reeves' finances.
The bigger cost, though, is the political one.
A year ago, when Sir Keir Starmer strode into Downing Street with a thumping majority, few could have imagined how the last few days would play out.
More than 120 MPs, nearly a third of the parliamentary Labour party and more than the total number of Tory MPs, publicly prepared to rebel on a flagship policy.
How did it come to this? How did the prime minister, and the people around him, not see a rebellion coming when there had been signs MPs weren't happy for weeks?
Those are the questions being asked by senior Labour figures behind the scenes.
Sir Keir's spokesperson says the prime minister consistently engages with colleagues, and parliamentary engagement takes many forms.
But a lack of engagement with backbenchers has led to the prime minister's most damaging U-turn yet, and this week will haunt the prime minister beyond Tuesday's crunch vote.
Hashtags
Try Our AI Features
Explore what Daily8 AI can do for you:
Comments
No comments yet...
Related Articles
BBC News
12 minutes ago
- BBC News
Hampshire Post Office victim 'still at war' as she gets OBE
A victim of the Post Office computer scandal has said she will continue to fight for compensation for colleagues, as she received an OBE at Buckingham Hamilton, 68, was falsely prosecuted in 2006 for a £36,000 shortfall at her branch in South Warnborough, accepted a financial settlement in 2024, but said it was "wicked" that 138 former sub-postmasters were still battling for Department for Business and Trade (DBT) said it had paid more than £1bn so far. Mrs Hamilton, who received her honour for services to justice on Thursday, said: "Personally my claim's been settled but I cannot, cannot stop fighting until the rest of the group get paid. "We fought in the High Court in 2019 and it took years to even get it to court... 138 of those people are still fighting. One hundred are dead."And I just find the whole thing wicked that they cannot be fair with people."On Friday, police said seven suspects had been identified in connection with the criminal trial might be not be held until 2028, detectives Hamilton said the DBT had claimed that there was little money for compensation, although it had employed an "army of lawyers" to "grind us into submission".She added: "Basically the Business Department owned the Post Office and they prosecuted us and destroyed us and they're now in charge of the compensation."It really is the fox in charge of the henhouse."It should go to an independent body to be fair and they'd stop spending hundreds of millions they've spent on lawyers, which is obscene."The Horizon IT system, which began operating in 1999, falsely created shortfalls in Post Office branches for which sub-postmasters were held than 900 people were prosecuted and some went to prison. In a statement, DBT said: "We pay tribute to all the postmasters including Jo who have suffered from the Horizon scandal."We have quadrupled the total amount paid to victims with more than £1bn paid to thousands of postmasters across the UK and anyone unhappy with their offer can have their case reviewed by an independent panel of experts." You can follow BBC Hampshire & Isle of Wight on Facebook, X (Twitter), or Instagram.
BBC News
16 minutes ago
- BBC News
How Staffordshire pottery sector reacted to industrial strategy
"Pathetic", "a missed opportunity", "a four out of 10 at best" – these were some of the phrases used by the pottery industry to describe the government's industrial 10-year plan announced on Monday confirmed 7,000 businesses would see electricity bills slashed by up to 25% from 2027, while 500 firms would get a 90% cut in network charges from 2026 under the British Industry Supercharger some in Stoke-on-Trent and Staffordshire – the heart of the UK ceramics industry – cautiously welcomed it as a "start", many have been left Secretary Jonathan Reynolds said the sector was "foundational" to the UK and would benefit from the measures. Three firms in Stoke-on-Trent have collapsed since the start of 2025 – Royal Stafford, Heraldic Pottery and Moorcroft, though the latter was recently bought by the founder's companies, workers and unions have been calling on the government to support the industry, which has become beset by rising energy prices and falling sales. After the spending review came and went, ministers including Ed Miliband said support would be revealed in the Industrial following its announcement, many questioned why ceramics was barely mentioned in the document and wondered where the actions were regarding the cost of gas – the dominant energy source in the association Ceramics UK accused the government of misleading and misunderstanding the UK chief executive Rob Flello said: "This represents a missed opportunity to back one of the UK's most enduring and strategically important manufacturing industries."Fifth-generation ceramicist Emily Johnson, owner of Barlaston-based 1882 Ltd, had previously described the industry as being "on its knees".On the industrial strategy, she said: "Pathetic, is a word. I think that we've been let down again."But you know what, Stoke is resilient and we are not going to get the support that we need from them so we're just going to have to do it ourselves." Beverley Berry was one of the 57 workers at Moorcroft who lost her job, and she has been campaigning for government help ever said she was left "disappointed" by the strategy and questioned whether it was all worth it."I feel quite pessimistic about it. When I first heard the news and thought it was imminent that we were going to help, I thought it wasn't all in vain," she Laver, CEO of Staffordshire Chamber of Commerce, gave the strategy a "four out of 10 at best" and said businesses needed support "now"."Stoke-on-Trent is only mentioned once on page 41 – that's it," she said. "If we were the steel industry, I think we would have had much more support thrown at us and we don't want to see more businesses go to the wall." There were those who were cautiously optimistic, including Portmeirion boss Mike Raybould, who said the measures were "a start" but called for faster action."It's good that they're recognising and finally talking about the UK ceramics industry," he told BBC Radio Stoke."But we need to see the detail, we need to see faster action and I suspect we probably need to see more support as well."While the support with electricity bills was welcome, Mr Raybould said firms wanted to see support with gas prices too, describing it as the more "dominant" form of energy in the new owner Will Moorcroft, grandson of founder William Moorcroft, also said the measures were "a start" but were unlikely to make a huge difference."There's still a lot of work to be done and, without getting political, there could be quicker decisions that could be made to help business, whether it's national insurance or business rates," he said. 'Foundational sector' In his statement in the House of Commons, Reynolds said ceramics was "recognised as a foundational sector" in the strategy,"Its principal request is about energy prices. There are some ceramics businesses - I accept not that many - that get the supercharger [discount] and will get the more generous rate."He said, however, the costs of a lot of those businesses did not match the intensity test the supercharger discount was based on."That is exactly why the British industrial competitiveness scheme has been designed in such a way that they will benefit from it, and that will be a game-changer for them," he gas prices, he said they were projected to fall "from the very significant level that they have been at" in future financial years. Follow BBC Stoke & Staffordshire on BBC Sounds, Facebook, X and Instagram.
BBC News
16 minutes ago
- BBC News
Sir Keir Starmer says Eluned Morgan right to raise concerns
The prime minister has played down divisions within his party after weeks of public criticism of him from Welsh Labour leader Eluned Keir Starmer told BBC Wales the Welsh first minister was "right to raise concerns" and promised to "deliver on those as far as we can".He spoke ahead of his Welsh Labour conference speech in Llandudno, where he will allege Plaid Cymru would be willing to form a "backroom stitch-up" with Reform and the Tories after the next which has strongly ruled out working with Reform in any form, accused Sir Keir of "peddling fiction". In her conference speech First Minister Eluned Morgan will say Reform would "rip" up the May, Morgan used an event in Cardiff Bay's Norwegian Church to set out a series of criticisms and demands of the UK her "Red Welsh Way", Morgan said she would "not stay silent" if Sir Keir's government took decisions "we think will harm Welsh communities".She complained about the UK government's plans for benefits and winter fuel payments, and demanded Wales benefit from wind power via the Crown Estate. The UK government has since U-turned on both winter fuel payments and disability benefits - the latter after a huge rebellion threatened Sir Keir's government. Speaking at a visit to RAF Valley on Anglesey, Sir Keir said the Westminster and Welsh governments "work very well together".He said the UK government had given Welsh ministers their largest financial settlement since devolution Keir said there was a "good relationship" and argued the spending review - which saw £445m for rail including new stations and £118m for coal tip safety - showed there was "a lot of really important delivery for Wales"."She quite rightly raises the issues of concern and I'd expect her to do so. And I work with her to deliver on those as far as we can." In a conference speech on Saturday, Sir Keir will make the case that having two Labour governments in London and Cardiff is delivering for Wales."This is the party that has got wages rising faster in the first 10 months than the Tories managed in 10 is the government that is cutting bills and creating jobs," he will will warn abandoning Labour could risk a "return to the chaos and division of the last decade" with a "backroom stitch-up between the Tories, Reform and Plaid".Plaid Cymru has firmly ruled out working with Nigel Farage's Reform UK, with leader Rhun ap Iorwerth saying in March there was "no way to see any co-operation at all between two parties who are so fundamentally different".He also told PA Media in May he could not see a "formal relationship" with the Conservatives "after 14 years of destruction".But he said "co-operation can take many, many forms. It can be informal. It can be issue by issue". The next Senedd election will see the partial-first past the post and proportional voting system used since 1999 replaced with elections that aim to better reflect how people will make it very hard for any party to win a majority or govern alone, and parties will face questions about who they may be prepared to work response, a Plaid Cymru spokesperson said: "If this is Labour's big pitch to the people of Wales, then frankly, they're scraping the barrel. Instead of offering hope, they're peddling fiction about imaginary coalitions involving parties that agree on virtually nothing."Welsh Conservative Senedd leader Darren Millar has said he would work with "anybody" to unseat the Welsh Labour government in Cardiff said: "It is in the national interest to kick Labour out of office so we can get to grips with these challenges and fix Wales. The Welsh Conservatives will do everything we can to secure that outcome." 'Moment of reckoning' In her conference speech, First Minister Morgan will say the next Senedd election will be a "moment of reckoning".In a bid to mobile the party's membership, Morgan will say: "Reform are rising. Plaid are mobilising."This is not a moment to look away. This is the moment to look forward - a moment of maximum opportunity and, yes, also of serious threat."She will say Reform want to "dismantle" the NHS and "rip it up" for a "privatised, profit-driven" system.A Reform UK Wales spokesperson said: "Wales now has the worst health service and health outcomes in the entire UK. Baroness Morgan is a former health minister herself – her record speaks for itself." Jo Stevens, Welsh Secretary, will announce a £11m fund for businesses in Port includes £6.78m from the UK government and £5m from Tata Steel and will support firms that offer skilled, well-paid employment will say: "This new fund is a powerful example of what can be achieved when Labour governments, trade unions and business work together to deliver for communities."
