If you think Neymar's career is a disappointment, it says a lot about unrealistic expectations
Most of the time when a player scores direct from a corner — an 'olimpico' — they're not necessarily trying to score. Stick it in the right area to cause some chaos, sure. If it happens to go in, great. But actively aiming for the opposite top corner? Not so much.
Then there's Neymar. Brazil's record goalscorer has recently returned to his boyhood club, Santos, after a fairly calamitous spell in Saudi Arabia. Inevitably, he has been on the receiving end of some lively treatment from the stands, most recently from fans of Internacional de Limeira when Santos faced them in the Paulista Championship last weekend.
After receiving some choice feedback while taking a corner, Neymar encouraged those fans to ramp up the abuse. They did. Neymar took the corner. You know what happened next.
UGASUAGSDUASGDUAGSUDGA O NEYMAR METEU UM GOL OLÍMPICO! O ADM TÁ COMPLETAMENTE MALUCO! NíO É POSSÍVEL! KKKKKKKKKKKKKK #Paulistão2025 pic.twitter.com/8S3vby2Npk
— TNT Sports BR (@TNTSportsBR) February 23, 2025
Neymar's return to Santos has not been treated by some as a glorious homecoming, but rather as a symbol of disappointment, another piece of evidence to support the idea that his career has been… if not a failure, certainly a bit of a letdown.
It's not an unreasonable charge. Some things haven't gone to plan. He hasn't won the Ballon d'Or, he hasn't won the World Cup, Brazil won their only Copa America since he made his international debut when he was injured, he went to Saudi Arabia aged 31 when he could have enjoyed another few years playing at the highest level.
Advertisement
But it feels wrong to write him off as a disappointment. And if he has been, that says more about the expectation than it does about him.
Because most of Neymar's career has been played under the weight of crushing expectation. He made his senior debut for Santos in 2009, aged 17, by which time the hype machine was well underway. He had already visited Europe for trials with Real Madrid, courted by Zinedine Zidane and the rest. His father, Neymar Snr, was merrily teeing up endorsement deals, the start of what would eventually become Neymar Inc, a whole industry that trades on his image that has also meant Jnr and Snr haven't had a real father-son relationship for the better part of two decades. Kids would approach him and ask in hushed tones, 'Are you really better than Messi?'
He was almost immediately marked out as the next great hero of Brazilian football. Pele advocated for him to be part of Dunga's squad at the 2010 World Cup when he was barely 18. In 2011 he scored the goal that brought him to the worldwide consciousness, an astonishing solo effort for Santos against Flamengo that would win him the Puskas Award. That same year, he led his team to the Copa Libertadores title, their first since the 1960s, the only one they have won without Pele in the team.
UGASUAGSDUASGDUAGSUDGA O NEYMAR METEU UM GOL OLÍMPICO! O ADM TÁ COMPLETAMENTE MALUCO! NíO É POSSÍVEL! KKKKKKKKKKKKKK #Paulistão2025 pic.twitter.com/8S3vby2Npk
— TNT Sports BR (@TNTSportsBR) February 23, 2025
The following years were consumed by a combination of speculation about when he would move to one of Europe's giants, and how he would become Brazil's talisman, the player to lead them to glory and redemption at their home World Cup in 2014.
It's easy to forget how crazy things were around Neymar at that tournament. He was 22 years old and the most historically successful football nation in the world was asking him to carry them on his back. When that back was fractured, by Colombia defender Juan Zuniga's knee, his team-mates held up his shirt in tribute, as if he had passed away tragically. He was still alive, but without him they had essentially admitted their hopes weren't.
Advertisement
After that, it was a cinch. All he was expected to do was become the best player in the world, measure up to Lionel Messi at Barcelona, then lead Paris Saint-Germain to their first-ever Champions League title.
He had the misfortune to emerge as a brilliant, thrilling young footballer at a time when Brazilian football was at a low ebb, when they needed a figurehead to pin all their hopes on.
People will also judge him because he couldn't do what previous greats have, which is to inspire his nation to winning the World Cup. But the idea that this should necessarily take too much shine off a player's legacy has always been a silly one. Would we think less of Messi if Lautaro Martinez and Gonzalo Montiel and Paulo Dybala had missed those penalties in 2022? Messi winning the World Cup is a great story, and provides a satisfying and complete end to his narrative, but he wouldn't be any less of a player if he hadn't. Just as Cristiano Ronaldo or Johan Cruyff or Alfredo Di Stefano aren't any less great.
But if this is a game of 'show us your medals', Neymar has a decent collection: league titles in four countries, a Copa Libertadores, a Champions League, an Olympic gold. He's also his country's all-time leading goalscorer, more than Pele, Ronaldo, Vava, Garrincha, Ronaldinho and the rest.
And then there are the intangibles. It's perfectly understandable if you don't really like Neymar: the diving, the brattish attitude, the array of stupid haircuts. But if you've watched Neymar and there haven't been dozens of moments where he made you feel joy, or remind you why you watch football, it's possible you're letting your personal distaste cloud your judgement.
Neymar did invite some of this colossal expectation on himself. He's rarely been shy about self-promotion. By leaving Barcelona for PSG in 2017, he was actively saying he wanted to be The Guy, rather than The Guy Just to the Left of the Guy. He very publicly set himself some aims that he hasn't achieved. He has been held back by injuries, scandal and bad decisions.
Advertisement
But to judge him harshly by those standards ignores basically everything else that has happened in his career, or life. From when he was a boy, people expected him to become a god, Pele Mk II. All they got was a genius.
And if that's a disappointment, if Neymar's career has not lived up to the expectations we have placed upon him, that's our problem, not his.
Hashtags
Try Our AI Features
Explore what Daily8 AI can do for you:
Comments
No comments yet...
Related Articles
New York Post
2 hours ago
- New York Post
USMNT coach talking World Cup after loss to Turkey, the team's third straight defeat
A third straight loss didn't prevent Mauricio Pochettino from thinking big. 'We need to believe. We need to compete like today and for sure we're going to have the possibility to win the World Cup,' the U.S. coach said after the Americans lost their third straight game, wasting an early lead in a 2-1 defeat to Turkey in a friendly on Saturday. Jack McGlynn scored 59 seconds in for the U.S., which was missing many regulars as Pochettino revamped his roster following a dismal performance at the CONCACAF Nations League final four in March. Advertisement 5 Jack McGlynn (6) misses a shot on goal during the USA's 2-1 loss to Turkey at Pratt & Whitney Stadium at Rentschler Field on June 7, 2025. David Butler II-Imagn Images Turkey took advantage of a sloppy defense as Arda Güler and Kerem Aktürkoğlu scored in a 2-minute, 20-second span midway through the first half. While the U.S. had 60% possession and outshot Turkey 13-11, the Americans dropped to 5-4 under Pochettino, who took over after first-round elimination at last year's Copa America led the U.S. Soccer Federation to fire coach Gregg Berhalter. Advertisement They have lost three straight for the second time in a year. 'Today, who is going to tell me, oh, we showed lack of, we showed lack of — lack of what today?' said Pochettino, a 53-year-old from Argentina who coached Tottenham, Paris Saint-Germain and Chelsea. 'The team showed what (it) needed to show. … Playing in this way, they are going to win most of the games.' 5 United States head coach Mauricio Pochettino encourages his team during the first half their loss to Turkey in a friendly. AP Coaching a nation that hasn't reached the World Cup semifinals since 1930 or the quarterfinals since 2022, Pochettino changed eight starters from the Nations League loss to Canada in March and kept only left back Max Arfsten, winger Diego Luna and forward Patrick Agyemang. Advertisement 'Some guys that are coming in — and they're not thinking twice about taking someone on. It's not playing safe. It's like, let's take risks and try to go after this thing,' said midfielder Tyler Adams, who entered at the start of the second half. 'I think having fresh faces, guys that aren't fearless, young guys, that's going to help us.' With a year to go before co-hosting the World Cup, the U.S. plays Switzerland on Tuesday at Nashville, Tennessee, in another friendly, then opens the CONCACAF Gold Cup against Trinidad and Tobago on June 15. 5 Team USA celebrates after its first-half goal in their loss to Turkey. David Butler II-Imagn Images 'I am really sad because I think this group of players are working so hard and I think we deserve (a) better result today,' Pochettino said. 'I think we performed well. I think we're brave enough. I think the attitude was: Go and press, match in every single aspect a team like Turkey that is one of the best teams in the last year in Europe.' Advertisement Defender Alex Freeman, a 20-year-old son of former NFL All-Pro receiver Antonio Freeman, started in his U.S. debut. Matt Freese, a starter at Major League Soccer's New York City, made his debut in goal. Matt Turner, the usual starter since 2022, didn't play for Crystal Palace after March 1. 5 USA midfielder Luca de la Torre gives a frustrated reaction after a missed in the tea's loss to Turkey. David Butler II-Imagn Images Midfielder Quinn Sullivan and defender Nathan Harriel made debuts as 65th-minute substitutes. McGlynn scored when he ran onto a pass from Malik Tilman, took several touches, cut inside and curled a left-footed shot from just outside the penalty area inside the far post for his second goal in five international appearances. It was the earliest U.S. goal since Shaq Moore scored 20 seconds in against Canada during the 2021 CONCACAF Gold Cup. 5 Jack McGlynn (6) and teammates warm up before Team USA's loss to Turkey. David Butler II-Imagn Images Turkey tied it in the 24th minute when Freese tapped the ball to Johnny Cardoso, whose pass ricocheted off a leg and past Freese for Güler's fifth international goal. Advertisement Then in the 27th, Miles Robinson tried to clear Oğuz Aydın's shot and the ball went to Aktürkoğlu, who one-timed a bouncing shot past Freese for his 12th international goal and sixth in eight games. 'Of the goals that we concede, that created a big mess on the team,' Pochettino said.
Washington Post
2 hours ago
- Washington Post
US coach Mauricio Pochettino says 'We're going to have the possibility to win the World Cup'
EAST HARTFORD, Conn. — A third straight loss didn't prevent Mauricio Pochettino from thinking big. 'We need to believe. We need to compete like today and for sure we're going to have the possibility to win the World Cup,' the U.S. coach said after the Americans lost their third straight game, wasting an early lead in a 2-1 defeat to Turkey in a friendly on Saturday.
Hamilton Spectator
3 hours ago
- Hamilton Spectator
US coach Mauricio Pochettino says ‘We're going to have the possibility to win the World Cup'
EAST HARTFORD, Conn. (AP) — A third straight loss didn't prevent Mauricio Pochettino from thinking big. 'We need to believe. We need to compete like today and for sure we're going to have the possibility to win the World Cup,' the U.S. coach said after the Americans lost their third straight game, wasting an early lead in a 2-1 defeat to Turkey in a friendly on Saturday. Jack McGlynn scored 59 seconds in for the U.S., which was missing many regulars as Pochettino revamped his roster following a dismal performance at the CONCACAF Nations League final four in March . Turkey took advantage of a sloppy defense as Arda Güler and Kerem Aktürkoğlu scored in a 2-minute, 20-second span midway through the first half. While the U.S. had 60% possession and outshot Turkey 13-11, the Americans dropped to 5-4 under Pochettino , who took over after first-round elimination at last year's Copa America led the U.S. Soccer Federation to fire coach Gregg Berhalter . They have lost three straight for the second time in a year . 'Today, who is going to tell me, oh, we showed lack of, we showed lack of — lack of what today?' said Pochettino, a 53-year-old from Argentina who coached Tottenham, Paris Saint-Germain and Chelsea. 'The team showed what (it) needed to show. ... Playing in this way, they are going to win most of the games.' Coaching a nation that hasn't reached the World Cup semifinals since 1930 or the quarterfinals since 2022, Pochettino changed eight starters from the Nations League loss to Canada in March and kept only left back Max Arfsten, winger Diego Luna and forward Patrick Agyemang. 'Some guys that are coming in — and they're not thinking twice about taking someone on. It's not playing safe. It's like, let's take risks and try to go after this thing,' said midfielder Tyler Adams, who entered at the start of the second half. 'I think having fresh faces, guys that aren't fearless, young guys, that's going to help us.' With a year to go before co-hosting the World Cup, the U.S. plays Switzerland on Tuesday at Nashville, Tennessee, in another friendly, then opens the CONCACAF Gold Cup against Trinidad and Tobago on June 15. 'I am really sad because I think this group of players are working so hard and I think we deserve (a) better result today,' Pochettino said. 'I think we performed well. I think we're brave enough. I think the attitude was: Go and press, match in every single aspect a team like Turkey that is one of the best teams in the last year in Europe.' Defender Alex Freeman, a 20-year-old son of former NFL All-Pro receiver Antonio Freeman, started in his U.S. debut. Matt Freese, a starter at Major League Soccer's New York City, made his debut in goal. Matt Turner, the usual starter since 2022, didn't play for Crystal Palace after March 1. Midfielder Quinn Sullivan and defender Nathan Harriel made debuts as 65th-minute substitutes. McGlynn scored when he ran onto a pass from Malik Tilman, took several touches, cut inside and curled a left-footed shot from just outside the penalty area inside the far post for his second goal in five international appearances. It was the earliest U.S. goal since Shaq Moore scored 20 seconds in against Canada during the 2021 CONCACAF Gold Cup. Turkey tied it in the 24th minute when Freese tapped the ball to Johnny Cardoso, whose pass ricocheted off a leg and past Freese for Güler's fifth international goal. Then in the 27th, Miles Robinson tried to clear Oğuz Aydın's shot and the ball went to Aktürkoğlu, who one-timed a bouncing shot past Freese for his 12th international goal and sixth in eight games. 'Of the goals that we concede, that created a big mess on the team,' Pochettino said. ___ AP soccer:
