Australia regulator and YouTube spar over under-16s social media ban, World News
SYDNEY — Australia's internet watchdog and YouTube exchanged barbs on Tuesday (June 24) after the regulator urged the government to reverse a planned exemption for the Alphabet-owned video-sharing platform from its world-first teen social media ban.
The quarrel adds an element of uncertainty to the December rollout of a law being watched by governments and tech leaders around the world as Australia seeks to become the first country to fine social media firms if they fail to block users aged under 16.
The centre-left Labour government of Anthony Albanese has previously said it would give YouTube a waiver, citing the platform's use for education and health. Other social media companies such as Meta's Facebook and Instagram, Snapchat, and TikTok have argued such an exemption would be unfair.
eSafety Commissioner Julie Inman Grant said she wrote to the government last week to say there should be no exemptions when the law takes effect. She added that the regulator's research found 37 per cent of children aged 10 to 15 reported seeing harmful content on YouTube - the most of any social media site.
"This is not a fair fight where our kids are concerned, vis-a-vis social media sites," Inman Grant told the National Press Club in Sydney.
She said social media companies deployed "persuasive design features" like recommendation-based algorithms and notifications to keep users online and "YouTube has mastered those, opaque algorithms driving users down rabbit holes they're powerless to fight against".
YouTube, in a blog post, accused Inman Grant of giving inconsistent and contradictory advice, which discounted the government's own research which found 69 per cent of parents considered the video platform suitable for people under 15.
"The eSafety commissioner chose to ignore this data, the decision of the Australian Government and other clear evidence from teachers and parents that YouTube is suitable for younger users," wrote Rachel Lord, YouTube's public policy manager for Australia and New Zealand.
Inman Grant, asked about surveys supporting a YouTube exemption, said she was more concerned "about the safety of children and that's always going to surpass any concerns I have about politics or being liked or bringing the public onside".
A spokesperson for Communications Minister Anika Wells said the minister was considering the online regulator's advice and her "top priority is making sure the draft rules fulfil the objective of the Act and protect children from the harms of social media".
[[nid:719327]]
Hashtags
Try Our AI Features
Explore what Daily8 AI can do for you:
Comments
No comments yet...
Related Articles
Straits Times
an hour ago
- Straits Times
WP wants to be ‘insurance' for S'pore should PAP suffer ‘major malfunction': Pritam
Mr Pritam Singh (centre) on the popular Malaysian political podcast Keluar Sekejap, which translates to 'out for a moment', hosted by Mr Khairy Jamaluddin (left) and Mr Shahril Hamdan. PHOTO: PRITAMSINGH76/INSTAGRAM WP wants to be 'insurance' for S'pore should PAP suffer 'major malfunction': Pritam SINGAPORE – The Workers' Party wants to get to a position where it is ready to step in and govern, should the ruling PAP suffer a 'major malfunction', said Leader of the Opposition Pritam Singh. 'You want to be in a position where you can say: 'Look, we're ready because we've got these years of experience under our belt,'', he added. This would be a 'great insurance for Singapore', said Mr Singh, who has been party chief since 2018. 'I'm not saying me and my colleagues today will be in that position, but we certainly want to put the party in that position,' he added. Mr Singh, who was making his first podcast appearance, was responding to a question by former Malaysian health minister Khairy Jamaluddin on whether he could see a Singapore without the PAP at the helm. Mr Khairy and Mr Shahril Hamdan, former UMNO information chief, are hosts of popular Malaysian political podcast Keluar Sekejap, which translates to 'out for a moment'. In an almost two-hour-long session uploaded to YouTube on June 24, Mr Singh also said he would not want to be prime minister of Singapore. 'I think my role is to normalise the idea of an opposition in Singapore,' he said. He hopes to bring more like-minded people on board to achieve a 'functioning and effective' parliamentary democracy. His comments – filmed during a family holiday to Malaysia – come about two months after the 2025 general election held on May 3. In that outing, his party held on to their 10 seats in Aljunied, Hougang and Sengkang. It also picked up two Non-Constituency MP seats for its Jalan Kayu and Tampines GRC candidates, following close fights in those constituencies. They form the WP's largest contingent in Parliament, after the party fielded 26 candidates in eight constituencies out of the 97 seats and 33 constituencies available. The podcast covered a wide range of topics, including Mr Singh's background and motivation to join politics, the party's strategy at the recent election and its role in Singapore's political landscape. Throughout the podcast, Mr Singh reiterated his view of WP's role as a check and balance to the ruling party, given the appetite of Singapore voters today. This came through in his response to comments referenced by Mr Khairy, that suggested Mr Singh's strategy in the general election showed a 'lack of ambition' – for instance, by not contesting outside the 'bunker' of Aljunied GRC where he has been since 2011. Mt Khairy also asked if the party should pivot away from Mr Singh's medium-term goal, set in 2019, of contesting and winning one-third of the seats in Parliament. The one-third goal is tied to Singapore's laws, which state that constitutional amendments require two-thirds majority support in the House. Mr Singh said he has to understand what Singaporeans want and how they respond to language which reflects ambition. 'I have to have a good finger on the pulse of Singaporeans... If that language is not in sync with their broad understanding of what they want out of politics in Singapore, then ambition can be a death knell for any politician in Singapore,' he said. 'If we accept that Singaporeans are pragmatic and there's no demand for a change of government, then going out there, flying a flag which says 'I'm your Prime Minister-in-waiting' is probably, with respect, an act of foolishness.' The party's strategy is determined by its sense of the pulse of Singaporeans, he said. If the public has an appetite for something else, the party should be sensitive to it. 'If not, it's a gamble and gambles don't work very well in Singapore politics,' he added. But the party did have a 'complete change' of strategy as compared to 2020 – in Tampines and Punggol GRCs and Jalan Kayu in particular, where the party presented strong cases, said Mr Singh, who did not elaborate on the change. Those three constituencies were the WP's closest losses. Mr Singh said this sense of what Singaporeans want is also why much of the party's work is done at the margins – to bring the voices of people who fall between the cracks to Parliament – rather than to present a radically different vision of Singapore. He added that on a day-to-day level, Singapore is a decent place to live, thrive, grow and raise a family, 'and that's not what we are trying to destroy'. 'But in spite of all that, there is a desire amongst many Singaporeans for political balance, and we know that, and we try and tap into that.' Mr Shahril pointed to other opposition political parties in Singapore that appear to have a different view of the opposition's job, as they offer policy ideas that are 'more radical than the WP', which has sometimes been described as a half step to the left. Mr Singh acknowledged those views, but said that while everyone wants a successful Singapore, the question is how to get there. 'Utimately, one view will prevail, and I think that's the view that the public can relate to most naturally. And hence, in comparison to the other opposition parties, we present this particular vision for this moment in time,' said Mr Singh. If that view changes, the WP wants to be in a position to pivot very quickly. But the party cannot pivot or talk about change if it does not have a position in Parliament, he added. Mr Shahril asked if WP had 'missed the trick of trying to get into the emotional register' as opposed to being managerial and technocratic, by not raising issues of discontent among Singaporeans such as the cost of living. Mr Singh said the party had talked about cost of living and housing during the election, but 'the PAP didn't take the bait'. The PAP ran a 'very, very tight campaign' where there were no gaffes, and the strategy was not to talk about the pain points, he said. 'The Singaporean voter is very sophisticated, and accordingly, we have to align our politics in a way which can ensure that the opposition continues to grow and thrive in the Singapore context,' he added. Mr Singh was also asked about how he dealt with his court case, where he was fined in February for lying to a parliamentary committee during its 2021 inquiry into former WP MP Raeesah Khan's conduct. He has appealed his conviction and sentence. He said: 'When your conscience is clear and you do not agree with what has been done to you, there's a certain clarity of mind, clarity of thought, clarity of purpose, that keeps you focused on what you are in this for, and that really has been my lodestar.' He pointed to a BBC report that said the case had almost no impact during the elections, adding that 'without going into details, I did fairly respectably in my constituency'. Mr Singh was also asked about how Singapore manages multiracialism and multiculturalism. The ruling government in Singapore takes this very seriously, said Mr Singh. 'I cannot think of any other way to manage a society with different races than telling all of them that all of you are important and everybody has a place at the table.' While it is not perfect, the fundamental building block of any society is to respect one another, he said. Asked if he would do it any differently, he said: 'I wouldn't, because I am passionately race neutral about things'. This does not mean he ignores reality, but being race neutral is how he views Singapore and aspires the country to be, he added. Multiracialism is something Singapore continues to work at, and 'as an opposition member, I want to be part of the solution in that', he said. Asked if there was data to show electoral support by ethnic groups, Mr Singh said that as residential areas have a mix of people, 'you can't really tell which community voted in which particular direction'. Whether one is a member of the Singapore government or an opposition politician, the approach to race is that it is not something to be brought into the political realm – not something to score political points on, added Mr Singh. Goh Yan Han is political correspondent at The Straits Times. She writes Unpacked, a weekly newsletter on Singapore politics and policy. Join ST's WhatsApp Channel and get the latest news and must-reads.
Business Times
5 hours ago
- Business Times
Civmec set to acquire ship manufacturer Luerssen Australia for A$20 million
[SINGAPORE] Construction and engineering services provider Civmec will purchase Luerssen Australia from Naval Vessels Lurssen (NVL) Australia for A$20 million (S$16 million) in cash, the company said on Thursday (Jun 26). Civmec will take ownership of the whole business, including assets, employees and licences. The deal will be funded by the group's existing cash reserves. The assets, plant and equipment, were valued at A$3.6 million. No external valuation was conducted for the acquisition. The aim of the deal is to solidify Australia's sovereign shipbuilding capability by consolidating design, construction and operational expertise under a single, locally owned entity, in a bid to enhance national resilience and support long-term defence industry growth, said the Australian shipbuilder. Luerssen Australia, a subsidiary of NVL, is an independent, privately owned group of German shipyards and related companies. The organisation was formerly known as Lurssen Defence. It specialises in the design, manufacture and servicing of yachts, naval and coastguard vessels. The company supports Australia's national sovereign shipbuilding strategy and operates from the Australian Marine Complex in Henderson, Western Australia. BT in your inbox Start and end each day with the latest news stories and analyses delivered straight to your inbox. Sign Up Sign Up The acquisition has a target completion date of Jul 1. A pre-agreed level of working capital will be retained within Luerssen Australia at completion to support post-completion operations as well, Civmec said. Earlier on Oct 15, 2024, Civmec had signed a non-binding heads of agreement with the German shipbuilder for the transfer of ownership of Luerssen Australia. This, in particular, was to ensure the 'uninterrupted design and build' of six offshore patrol vessels for the Royal Australian Navy under an existing contract with the Australian Department of Defence – the NVL subsidiary's sole business, executed at a shipyard in South Australia and a Civmec-owned facility in Western Australia. Shares of Civmec closed 1.2 per cent or S$0.01 higher at S$0.86 on Wednesday.
Straits Times
5 hours ago
- Straits Times
Work on hawker centre, polyclinic in Bishan town centre to start in this term of govt: Chee Hong Tat
Artist impression of pedestrian mall linking future developments and community facilities within the Bishan Sub-Regional Centre. PHOTO: URA Work on hawker centre, polyclinic in Bishan town centre to start in this term of govt: Chee Hong Tat SINGAPORE - Work on the new hawker centre, polyclinic and revamped bus interchange in the Bishan town centre will start within the current term of government and take several years to complete, said National Development Minister Chee Hong Tat. About 200,000 sqm of new office space could also be built in the town centre, matching the scale of that in Paya Lebar Central, Mr Chee said in a Facebook post on June 26. The Government is studying plans to develop Bishan into a new business hub as part of the Urban Redevelopment Authority's (URA) 2025 draft masterplan, which was unveiled on June 25. Several government agencies are exploring the feasibility of relocating their offices to the area, to jump-start the development of this business district, URA said earlier. Plans are afoot to develop Bishan into a sub-regional centre. Such areas are business hubs, such as those in Paya Lebar and Serangoon, that bring jobs closer to homes. They are smaller than the regional centres in Woodlands, Jurong East and Tampines. Efforts to improve connectivity in Bishan will make it easier for residents to move around the town and access neighbouring facilities, Mr Chee said. For instance , cycling paths in the Bishan town centre will allow residents to cycle to upcoming recreational spaces such as the North-South Corridor and Kallang River. Bishan Place – a road behind Junction 8 shopping centre – will be transformed into a pedestrian mall and be linked to transport hubs and facilities, he added. There are also plans for a walking and cycling street along the developments in Bishan Road that will be connected to Bishan-Ang Mo Kio Park. These plans are on top of that for the Toa Payoh Integrated Development on the site of the former Toa Payoh Sport Centre in Lorong 6 Toa Payoh , which will be completed within this term of government, said Mr Chee. The integrated development will have an improved sports centre, an upgraded polyclinic, a bigger library and a rejuvenated town park. It will have sheltered linkways to Toa Payoh MRT station and bus interchange. The Draft Master Plan 2025 includes plans to continue driving Singapore's economic growth by strengthening its economic gateways and business districts, rejuvenating key precincts and supporting innovation. The exhibition for the draft masterplan will be displayed at the HDB Hub in Toa Payoh from Aug 9 to 17. Join ST's WhatsApp Channel and get the latest news and must-reads.
