Trump is right: DC has a crime problem. But he's not the one to fix it.
President Donald Trump says he will take new actions to curb the crime problems in Washington, DC. Trump and other officials have announced plans for him to take control of the Metropolitan Police Department, deploy National Guard troops and ramp up federal law enforcement in the nation's capital.
While I understand the public concern about Trump expanding his power beyond Washington, the District of Columbia is distinct from other cities governed by states, and the federal government has a unique role to play in its governance.
And I'm inclined to agree with Trump's broader points about crime and safety in Washington.
Trump is right on one thing: America deserves a safe capital. Although it's improving in terms of its crime problem, it is still far from being a safe city. While crime in the district is falling from its post-pandemic peak, and violent crime is even at a 30-year low, the violent crime rate in Washington remains relatively high compared with other states, and the homicide rate is atypically high.
Tell us: In the wake of Trump's federal DC takeover, are you worried about crime? | Opinion Forum
Americans deserve a safe capital city. DC could be safer.
Part of the problem is that many crimes are less often prosecuted in Washington. Even crimes involving weapons are charged at a rate substantially below those of other major cities. Similarly, the district has become less likely to prosecute minors and young adults, according to the Manhattan Institute, a right-wing think tank.
Still, Trump is definitely exaggerating the crime problem to give a pretext for his latest actions, and he will likely end up taking credit for declining crime rates that have already begun to take effect. But that doesn't mean his idea of a crime-free Washington is wrong. I don't think the Trump administration is all that much more capable of running the nation's capital than the city leadership is, but I don't find it offensive that White House officials would try their hand at it.
Opinion: Supreme Court could end race-based voting districts. Good. They're antiquated.
Nor is Washington just another city. It does mean something to be the nation's capital, and representatives of foreign nations who visit are not seeing America's best when they come there. The home of our federal government has no business being among the most dangerous cities in the nation.
Trump's push is more about optics than safety
While Trump's message is right, his push to ramp up federal law enforcement in Washington is more about optics than meaningfully reducing crime.
Having uniformed Drug Enforcement Administration agents patrolling the National Mall and flooding the streets with 800 National Guard personnel sounds great in theory, but Washington's violent crime is concentrated in areas away from the Mall. It's all for show.
Trump can also only take control of the local police force for up to 30 days before needing congressional approval. What he can actually accomplish over the course of a month remains to be seen, but I am skeptical of his ability to enact any lasting change in the coming weeks.
Temporary supplements from federal law enforcement and the National Guard could even help in the short term, but the problem of more than 800 police officer positions needing to be filled will remain even after those 30 days are up.
And what about filling the 15 vacancies on the Superior Court of the District of Columbia, which handles the city's criminal cases?
In the end, Trump's increased control over Washington is likely to blow over as a typical optics play, with little show in terms of results. He's overstating the problem of crimes and trying to take credit for declines that have already been happening without his intervention. It's just more smoke and mirrors.
Dace Potas is an opinion columnist for USA TODAY and a graduate of DePaul University with a degree in political science.
Hashtags
Try Our AI Features
Explore what Daily8 AI can do for you:
Comments
No comments yet...
Related Articles
NBC News
24 minutes ago
- NBC News
The CEO in chief: How Trump is getting what he wants from big business
For years, conservative groups and corporate leaders argued that the U.S. government would be better if it were run like a business. For President Donald Trump, who has controlled his own businesses for decades, that looks like taking an increasingly active role in individual corporations' affairs, from manufacturing to media to tech firms. And corporations are meeting the demands of a president who is more freely exerting his powers than he did the last time he was in office. At Trump's urging, Coca-Cola said it would produce a version of its namesake soda with U.S.-grown cane sugar. Paramount paid millions to settle allegations Trump levied against CBS' venerated '60 Minutes.' Two major semiconductor makers agreed to give the government a cut of their sales in China. The CEO of Intel met with Trump soon after the president called on him to resign. 'It's so much different than the first term,' said a Republican lobbyist whose firm represents several Fortune 500 companies, who spoke on condition of anonymity to speak candidly. 'He's just acting like a businessman. In his first term, I think he was trying to cosplay as a politician. He's more comfortable in his own skin, too. He can explain deals better.' Trump's role represents a break with past administrations that may have been unwilling or unable, politically, to bring similar pressure to bear on businesses. In the past, small-government conservatives once accused previous Democratic administrations of attempting to 'pick winners and losers' by trying to regulate industries. Trump today stands downstream of a bolder right-wing movement that calls for enhanced state intervention in corporate affairs. Trump has said the corporate concessions are intended to boost the U.S. economy. And the White House, in a statement, reinforced the idea that Trump's involved approach to private-sector dealings is a key part of his economic agenda. 'Cooled inflation, trillions in new investments, historic trade deals, and hundreds of billions in tariff revenue prove how President Trump's hands-on leadership is paving the way towards a new Golden Age for America,' White House spokesperson Kush Desai said.
NBC News
24 minutes ago
- NBC News
Los Angeles school year begins amid fears over immigration enforcement
LOS ANGELES — Los Angeles students and teachers return to class for the new academic year Thursday under a cloud of apprehension after a summer filled with immigration raids and amid worries that schools could become a target in the Trump administration's aggressive crackdown. Los Angeles Unified School District Superintendent Alberto Carvalho has urged immigration authorities not to conduct enforcement activity within a two-block radius around schools starting an hour before the school day begins and until one hour after it classes let out. 'Hungry children, children in fear, cannot learn well,' Carvalho said in a news conference. He also announced a number of measures intended to protect students and families, including adding or altering bus routes to accommodate more students. The district is to distribute a family preparedness packet that includes know-your-rights information, emergency contact updates and tips on designating a backup caregiver in case a parent is detained. The sprawling district, which covers more than two dozen cities, is the nation's second largest with more than 500,000 students. According to the teachers' union, 30,000 students are immigrants, and an estimated quarter of them are without legal status. Federal immigration enforcement near schools causes concern While immigration agents have not detained anyone inside a school, a 15-year-old boy was pulled from a car and handcuffed outside Arleta High School in northern Los Angeles on Monday, Carvalho said. He had significant disabilities and was released after a bystander intervened in the case of 'mistaken identity,' the superintendent said. 'This is the exact type of incident that traumatizes our communities; it cannot repeat itself,' he added. Administrators at two elementary schools previously denied entry to officials from the Department of Homeland Security in April, and immigration agents have been seen in vehicles outside schools. DHS did not immediately respond to an email seeking comment. Carvalho said that while staffers and district police officers cannot interfere with immigration enforcement and do not have jurisdiction beyond school property, they have had conversations with federal agents parked in front of schools that resulted in them leaving. The district is partnering with local law enforcement in some cities and forming a 'rapid response' network to disseminate information about the presence of federal agents, he said. Educators worry about attendance Teachers say they are concerned some students might not show up the first day. Lupe Carrasco Cardona, a high school social studies and English teacher at the Roybal Learning Center, said attendance saw a small dip in January when President Donald Trump took office. The raids ramped up in June right before graduations, putting a damper on ceremonies. One raid at a Home Depot near MacArthur Park, an area with many immigrant families from Central America, took place the same morning as an 8th grade graduation at a nearby middle school. 'People were crying, for the actual graduation ceremony there were hardly any parents there,' Cardona said. The next week, at her high school graduation, the school rented two buses to transport parents to the ceremony downtown. Ultimately many of the seats were empty, unlike other graduations. One 11th grader, who spoke on the condition that her last name not be published because she is in the country without legal permission and fears being targeted, said she is afraid to return to school. 'Instead of feeling excited, really what I'm feeling is concern,' said Madelyn, a 17-year-old from Central America. 'I am very, very scared, and there is a lot of pressure.' She added that she takes public transportation to school but fears being targeted on the bus by immigration agents because of her skin color. 'We are simply young people with dreams who want to study, move forward and contribute to this country as well,' she said. Madelyn joined a club that provides support and community for immigrant students and said she intends to persevere in that work. 'I plan to continue supporting other students who need it very much, even if I feel scared,' she said. 'But I have to be brave.' Some families who decide that the risk is too great to show up in-person have opted for online learning instead, according to Carvalho, with virtual enrollment up 7% this year. The district has also contacted at least 10,000 parents and visited more than 800 families over the summer to provide information about resources like transportation, legal and financial support and are deploying 1,000 workers from the district's central office on the first day of classes to 'critical areas' that have seen immigration raids. 'We want no one to stay home as a result of fears,' Carvalho said.
Washington Post
24 minutes ago
- Washington Post
Lawmakers visit Baltimore ICE site accused of ‘inhumane' conditions
Two weeks after most of Maryland's congressional delegation staged a sit-in at a controversial immigration enforcement facility in Baltimore, lawmakers returned for a guided tour on Wednesday and said they were still being stonewalled about how detainees are being treated inside. 'We leave here with more questions than we came in with,' said Rep. Kweisi Mfume (D-Maryland). Immigration Customs and Enforcement officers have been using rooms in the agency's Baltimore field office as a holding area for people arrested amid President Donald Trump's ramped-up immigration enforcement. In Maryland, where a 2021 state law bars privately run immigration detention centers, the field office functions as the agency's primary holding facility for detainees awaiting transfer out of state. Civil rights groups have filed lawsuits in three states — including Maryland — alleging the holding facilities are not equipped for days-long detentions. And as arrests have increased, so too have concerns from immigrant rights groups and Democrats about a lack of adequate facilities. In May, the Amica Center for Immigrant Rights and the National Immigration Project filed a federal lawsuit alleging 'inhumane conditions' in the Baltimore holding rooms. The lawsuit alleges detainees have been denied access to showers, blankets and medical care. In New York, a federal judge ruled in a similar case this week that the Trump administration must improve conditions in a Manhattan holding facility where a government lawyer acknowledged detainees were sleeping on the floor. Another lawsuit is pending in Los Angeles. The Trump administration has dismissed the concerns. Worries about conditions in the Baltimore holding facility and other ICE detention facilities prompted a dozen Democratic lawmakers from across the country, including Rep. Jamie Raskin (D-Maryland), to file a federal lawsuit against the Department of Homeland Security and ICE last month, saying each had been blocked from conducting oversight at federal detention facilities. That lawsuit came two days after six members of Maryland's congressional delegation tried to visit the Baltimore field office, only to be turned away. At the time, DHS spokesperson Tricia McLaughlin said that 'these Members of Congress could have just scheduled a tour; instead, they're running to court to drive clicks and fundraising emails.' Mfume said the lawmakers did request a visit in advance. Earlier this summer, DHS tightened rules for congressional oversight visits, arguing field offices — such as the one in Baltimore — fall outside congressional purview to inspect detention facilities. Three Democratic lawmakers representing Maryland — Mfume, Sen. Chris Van Hollen and Rep. Sarah Elfreth — returned Wednesday after ICE reached out and the parties scheduled a visit. During the tour, the three lawmakers said, they were able to observe three large rooms and two small ones, which held a handful of people. 'It has the kind of cold feeling that you would find in any police station,' Mfume said. The day was an unusually slow one for the Baltimore field office, Van Hollen said. That was because Maryland ICE personnel have been tasked with assisting efforts in other states and D.C., leading to less enforcement activity in Maryland in recent days, he said they were told. Lawmakers characterized their visit as lacking transparency. They said they raised about 20 to 25 issues with the ICE personnel who led the tour, including Nikita Baker, the acting director of the Baltimore field office, but did not receive immediate answers. 'We are going to continue to run those questions down,' Elfreth said. 'We're going to continue this drumbeat to make sure that ICE is transparent and accountable.' ICE did not respond to questions from The Washington Post about the living conditions in the facility, how long it is holding people there and why it turned away the members of Congress during their earlier visit. Van Hollen and Sen. Angela Alsobrooks (D-Maryland) had raised concerns about the facility with the Department of Homeland Security in an April letter, noting that it lacked a food service program and bed space, describing ICE staff members procuring emergency foil blankets and inflatable beds. Homeland Security Secretary Kristi L. Noem wrote back in June that holding people for more than 12 hours was necessary because of limitations on space as a result of restrictions in the Maryland Dignity Not Detention Act. 'ICE is committed to safe, secure, and humane environments for all of those in ICE custody and will ensure appropriate conditions for confinement,' Noem wrote. Though ICE did not answer questions about how many people have been detained at the facility since the start of Trump's second term, representatives did tell them more than 100 people had been at the facility at one time, Van Hollen said. 'This is a lot of people to cram into a relatively small space,' he said. The lawmakers were denied the opportunity to speak to any detainees, Van Hollen said. 'Clearly they don't want us talking to the people who are detained here today and in the future,' he said.
