GOLDSTEIN: Questioning Canada's immigration policies is not racist
A report by The Globe and Mail that said 17,600 foreigners had their criminal convictions forgiven by the Immigration Department over 11 years, up to and including 2024 — thus removing a ban on them coming to Canada — is a case in point.
If five years have passed since a foreign criminal's conviction or completion of a sentence, the Immigration Department has the power to deem them 'rehabilitated,' meaning they can apply to enter Canada through work and study visas, as permanent residents or visitors.
Last year alone, 1,390 people had their criminal convictions forgiven, while 105 applications were refused, according to The Globe and Mail report.
There can, of course, be legitimate cases where, for example, an individual has been convicted by a dictatorial foreign government on false or trumped-up charges of criminal offences or where the convictions are for relatively minor offences.
Lax immigration vetting makes Canada prime target for Iranian infiltration, says Secure Canada
Federal minister plans to hold consultations this summer on immigration intake
But the problem is the Immigration Department won't provide any breakdown of what crimes were forgiven, other than to say that in the most serious offences the immigration minister would be involved in the decision.
As Conservative immigration critic Michelle Rempel Garner told The Globe and Mail, this lack of transparency has to end 'if the public is going to have any confidence in the immigration system's vetting process.'
(Also of note here is that since the data covers an 11-year period up to and including 2024, it means it was in place during the Harper Conservative government, which was in office up until 2015, although the bulk of the decisions would have been made under the Liberals.)
This isn't the first time Canadians have had a reason to ask legitimate questions about who is allowed into Canada and why.
Last year, in answering an order paper question by Conservative MP Laila Goodridge, which was reported by Postmedia, the Canada Border Services Agency responded that the federal government had lost track of almost 30,000 people who failed to appear for deportation proceedings.
Similarly, auditor general Karen Hogan reported in 2020 that the federal government had lost track of the whereabouts of over 34,000 foreigners ordered deported from Canada, including almost 3,000 criminal cases.
All the way back in 2003, then-auditor general Sheila Fraser reported that Ottawa had lost track of 36,000 people the federal government had ordered deported, adding that mismanagement of deportees was encouraging illegal immigration.
Obviously this is a chronic problem within the federal government that never gets resolved, but concern about losing track of foreign deportees is but one reason to be concerned about Canada's immigration system.
In 2024, for example, internal government documents obtained by The Canadian Press revealed that in announcing a significant boost to its immigration targets in 2022, the Trudeau government ignored warnings from its own public servants that doing so would increase the cost of housing and negatively impact Canada's already beleaguered health-care system.
That, of course, is exactly what happened with then-prime minister Trudeau eventually conceding the higher immigration targets had gone 'far beyond what Canada has been able to absorb' and was 'something that we need to get back under control,' which the Liberals belatedly attempted to do.
One presumes Trudeau and the Liberals didn't consider themselves to be racists in doing so.
Hashtags

Try Our AI Features
Explore what Daily8 AI can do for you:
Comments
No comments yet...
Related Articles
Yahoo
7 minutes ago
- Yahoo
TSX futures rise on US-Japan trade deal
(Reuters) -Futures tied to Canada's benchmark index rose on Wednesday, after U.S. President Donald Trump revived hopes for deals with its trading partners following an agreement with Japan. Futures on the S&P/TSX index were up 0.5% at 1,637.1 points by 06:20 a.m. ET (1020 GMT). Trump struck a trade deal with Japan, lowering tariffs on auto imports and sparing Tokyo from punishing new levies on other goods, in exchange for a $550 billion package of U.S.-bound investment and loans. Meanwhile, prospects of an EU-U.S. trade agreement improved after Trump said on Tuesday that EU representatives would come for trade negotiations on Wednesday. The news lifted market sentiment and sparked hopes of more U.S. agreements before the August 1 tariff deadline. In commodities, gold prices fell and oil prices were steady. Copper prices touched their highest in over two weeks. In corporate news, Zara founder Amancio Ortega's investment vehicle Pontegadea Inversiones has agreed to acquire a 49% stake in PD Ports from Brookfield Asset Management. In the U.S., Alphabet and Tesla will kick off the results season for the "Magnificent Seven" stocks later in the day. Canada's main stock index rose on Tuesday, led by mining shares. FOR CANADIAN MARKETS NEWS, CLICK ON CODES: TSX market report [.TO] Canadian dollar and bonds report [CAD/] [CA/] Reuters global stocks poll for Canada Canadian markets directory


Fox News
9 minutes ago
- Fox News
Fencer who went viral for protest of trans athlete reacts to Team USA following Trump's women's sports order
Women's fencer Stephanie Turner believed she was "ruining her life" when she chose to kneel in protest of a transgender competitor at a USA Fencing event in late March. But after nearly four months, a congressional hearing on the subject and, now, a revision in Team USA's transgender participation policy that surfaced Tuesday, Turner says she "absolutely" would do it all again. U.S. Olympic and Paralympic Committee (USOPC) updated its policies on Tuesday to suggest it will comply with President Donald Trump's "Keeping Men Out of Women's Sports" executive order. "This has caused so much of a hindrance to my life personally, and it's caused me so much emotional turmoil that I'm just so glad this is over and that there are a lot of women and girls out there who are very appreciative of this victory," Turner told Fox News Digital. "I just have to say thank you [to Trump]. I voted for him, and this was a huge reason why I voted for him. And to see him come through for me and for women and girls so soon into his administration, it just, I mean, that's a huge victory. I've never seen politics work in my favor immediately, effectively, efficiently. … I'm just so grateful for that executive order." Still, Turner said that the change taking as long as it did is "disappointing" to her. For Turner, a former longtime Democrat and Maryland native, Trump in 2024 was the first Republican she's voted for. She says she "shudders" to think where she'd be if she and other former Democrats didn't vote for Trump in 2024. Still, Turner and her support group are calling for further measures by the USOPC after the recent policy change. The Independent Council on Women's Sports (ICONS), the advocacy group that represents Turner, released a statement Tuesday calling for mandatory sex screening for all women's athletes to enforce Trump's executive order effectively. "The next critical step is for the USOPC to implement sex screening protocols. This will ensure that women are guaranteed equal, fair and safe opportunities in athletic competition. ICONS will not rest until every girl, at every level, in every sport has access to fair competition and privacy in locker rooms," the statement said."The U.S. has a chance to be a leader in standing up for the fair treatment of women around the world." Turner is also calling for mandatory testing. "Enforcement of this policy is going to be essential," Turner said. Turner pointed to karyotyping, a test that examines the chromosomes in a sample of cells, as a necessary form of testing. "You can't rely on documentation anymore. You can't rely on drivers license(s), you can't rely on birth certificates because those can all be edited," Turner said. Turner helped ignite an avalanche of backlash against one of the USOPC's major governing bodies, USA Fencing, when she released footage of her viral protest in April. Turner was disqualified and given a black card for her refusal to face the trans opponent, prompting backlash against USA Fencing. The controversy was then the subject of a federal hearing May 7. Turner testified against USA Fencing Chair Damien Lehfeldt at the Department of Government Efficiency (DOGE) Subcommittee's hearing, "Unfair Play: Keeping Men Out of Women's Sports." In early June, USA Fencing's Board of Directors voted to amend its previous policy that prioritized states with LGBTQ-friendly laws for host sites for competitions and a policy that may have prevented the playing of the national anthem at some events. Both of those policies were highly criticized in the aftermath of Turner's viral protest. Then, the very next week, two USA Fencing directors filed a lawsuit against the other six at-large members, alleging Lehfeldt made false statements to Congress at the May 7 hearing. The plaintiffs, Andrey Geva and Abdel Salem, each have long ties to the sport and organization, previously coaching or competing for Team USA. This week, USA Fencing became one of the first organizations to make an official announcement that referenced the USOPC's new policy. On July 18, 2025, the USOPC released new athlete safety guidelines that all national governing bodies must follow under a federal executive order issued by the president earlier this year. For Turner, her involvement in the issue began in her home state of Maryland the last weekend of March, when she was matched up against the transgender opponent, Redmond Sullivan, at the Cherry Blossom Open. When Turner knelt in front of Sullivan, she says she told Sullivan, "I have much love and respect for you, but I will not fence you." Now, as she reflects on the issue, Turner has a message she would give Sullivan after Tuesday's news. "I hope he understands that what he did was cheating, and it was not fair to women and girls. I also want him to know that I don't hate him personally. This was never about him and me. This was really about the issue and the policy at hand," Turner said. "And if I am angry at anybody, I'm angry at his enablers and the people who have allowed this policy to go on for so long."


Fox News
9 minutes ago
- Fox News
Women's fencer Stephanie Turner reacts to Team USA following Trump's order to protect women's sports
Women's fencer Stephanie Turner speaks to Fox News Digital about the change to the USOPC's policy on trans athletes nearly four months after her protest of the issue went viral.