No truce in India-Pakistan disinformation war: Analysts
NEW DELHI: India and Pakistan have announced a ceasefire after coming close to all-out conflict, but on social media citizens on both sides are vying to control public perceptions by peddling disinformation. Platforms such as Facebook and X are still awash with misrepresented footage of the attacks that killed at least 60 people and sent thousands fleeing.
AFP fact-checkers have debunked many of the clips, which actually show the Zionist entity-Palestine war or the war in Ukraine. Indian and Pakistani media outlets have also amplified misinformation, including false or unverifiable claims of military victories that experts say have exacerbated tensions and contributed to a flood of hate speech. "It's complicated to establish the military facts because, in addition to the reality of strikes that are difficult to ascertain, there's a communication war going on," said General Dominique Trinquand, an international relations analyst and former head of the French military mission to the United Nations.
Disinformation peaked when India launched deadly air strikes on Wednesday targeting "terrorist camps" in Pakistan, two weeks after a deadly attack on the Indian-run side of disputed Kashmir. New Delhi blames Islamabad for backing the April 22 attack near the tourist town of Pahalgam, which killed 26 people — almost all of them Hindu men. Pakistan denies the claim. After the first round of Indian air strikes, the Pakistani military shared footage that had previously circulated in reports about a 2023 Zionist entity air strike on Gaza. The clip quickly appeared on television and social media but was later retracted by numerous media outlets, including AFP.
AI-generated imagery has also muddied the waters, including a video that purportedly shows a Pakistan Army general saying the country lost two of its aircraft. AFP fact-checkers found the clip was altered from a 2024 press conference. "We have seen a new wave of AI-based content in both video and still images due to increased access to deepfake tools," said Joyojeet Pal, an associate professor in the School of Information at the University of Michigan.
JAMMU: A woman temporarily displaced from her home at a border area, sits inside a room in an inn at a Gurudwara (Sikh temple), in Jammu on May 13, 2025.
Social media crackdown
Both India and Pakistan have taken advantage of the information vacuum to raise alarm bells and promote their own claims and counter-claims. Pakistan appears to have lifted a more than one-year-old ban on X the same day of the Indian strikes, according to an AFP analysis of data from the nonprofit Open Observatory of Network Interference. "In a time of crisis, the government needed its people's voice to be heard all around the world and not to be silenced anymore like it was before for domestic political purposes," said Usama Khilji, a digital rights expert and activist in Pakistan. The country's National Cyber Emergency Response Team (NCERT) on May 8 issued an alert about "increased cyberattacks and misinformation via emails, social media, QR codes, and messaging apps".
Both Pakistan's Ministry of Economic Affairs and the Karachi Port Trust later said their X accounts had been hacked. A post from the latter account said the port — one of South Asia's busiest — was attacked by the Indian military. The page was later restored and the port authority said no attack had taken place. India, meanwhile, has executed a sweeping crackdown targeting the social media accounts of Pakistani politicians, celebrities and media organizations. The government ordered X to block more than 8,000 accounts and banned more than a dozen Pakistani YouTube channels for allegedly spreading "provocative" content, including news outlets. Press Information Bureau (PIB) Fact Check, a government-run website, has also refuted more than 60 claims about the ongoing crisis, many having to do with supposed Pakistani military victories.
'Cyclical relationship'
The avalanche of disinformation online has been accompanied by a spike in hate speech offline. A report from the US-based India Hate Lab documented 64 in-person hate speech events between April 22 and May 2. Most were filmed and later shared on social media. "There is a cyclical relationship between offline hate speech and the rise of harmful online content," said Raqib Hameed Naik, executive director of the Center for the Study of Organized Hate.
He said the Pahalgam attack sparked in India a "significant surge in rallies where far-right leaders weaponized the tragedy to incite hate and violence against Muslim Indians and Kashmiris." Several clips online show people dressed in Hindu garb calling for economic boycotts of minority Muslims. Rallies in the northern Indian states of Himachal Pradesh and Uttarakhand have seen similar incendiary speeches. Now that a ceasefire has been declared, Naik warned that hate speech "will once again refocus on religious minorities." "The war machine may have paused, but the hate machinery never stops. I worry it might return with a greater force." — AFP
Hashtags
Try Our AI Features
Explore what Daily8 AI can do for you:
Comments
No comments yet...
Related Articles
Arab Times
12 hours ago
- Arab Times
IAF Chief Talks Aftermath of Precision Strikes on Terror Camps
NEW DELHI, Aug 9: Indian Air Force (IAF) Chief Marshal Amar Preet Singh revealed on Saturday that following India's precision strikes under Operation Sindoor on terror camps in Pakistan and Pakistan-occupied Kashmir, many close to him expressed that the strikes could have been even more extensive. 'On that night, we were really on a roll. I've heard from many people, and although I hesitate to say this, those very close to me said, 'aur maarna tha' — meaning 'you should have hit them more,'' Singh said during the 16th Air Chief Marshal LM Katre Memorial Lecture in Bengaluru on August 9. He also disclosed that the IAF shot down five Pakistani fighter jets along with a large aircraft, marking India's largest-ever recorded surface-to-air kill. 'We have confirmation of at least one AWACS (Airborne Warning and Control System) in the hangar, along with several F-16s undergoing maintenance. At least five fighters were confirmed shot down, as well as one large aircraft — either an aircraft or AWACS — at a distance of approximately 300 kilometers. This is the largest surface-to-air kill ever recorded by India,' he stated. The operation also resulted in several unmanned aerial vehicles (UAVs), drones, and some missiles falling within Indian territory. Based on precise intelligence, Singh said the IAF targeted the airfield, striking the main building where planning was conducted, which also served as a civilian terminal at times. 'At the Sukkur airbase, we hit the UAV hangar and radar site,' he added. Singh commended National Security Advisor Ajit Doval for effectively coordinating various agencies and forces during Operation Sindoor. Highlighting the thorough preparation, he noted that military leaders planned for all possible scenarios and responses. Reflecting on a key lesson from the operation, Singh said, 'The biggest takeaway is the primacy of air warfare. It has once again become clear that air power is the first responder for any country, capable of swift, precise deep strikes to achieve objectives without collateral damage.'
Kuwait Times
13 hours ago
- Kuwait Times
India pauses plans to buy US arms after Trump tariffs
Defense minister cancels planned trip to Washington NEW DELHI: New Delhi has put on hold its plans to procure new US weapons and aircraft, according to three Indian officials familiar with the matter, in India's first concrete sign of discontent after tariffs imposed on its exports by President Donald Trump dragged ties to their lowest level in decades. India had been planning to send Defense Minister Rajnath Singh to Washington in the coming weeks for an announcement on some of the purchases, but that trip has been cancelled, two of the people said. Trump on Aug 6 imposed an additional 25 percent tariff on Indian goods as punishment for Delhi's purchases of Russian oil, which he said meant the country was funding Russia's invasion of Ukraine. That raised the total duty on Indian exports to 50 percent - among the highest of any US trading partner. The president has a history of rapidly reversing himself on tariffs and India has said it remains actively engaged in discussions with Washington. One of the people said the defense purchases could go ahead once India had clarity on tariffs and the direction of bilateral ties, but 'just not as soon as they were expected to.' Written instructions had not been given to pause the purchases, another official said, indicating that Delhi had the option to quickly reverse course, though there was 'no forward movement at least for now.' Post publication of this story, India's government issued a statement it attributed to a Ministry of Defense source describing news reports of a pause in the talks as 'false and fabricated.' The statement also said procurement was progressing as per 'extant procedures.' Delhi, which has forged a close partnership with America in recent years, has said it is being unfairly targeted and that Washington and its European allies continue to trade with Moscow when it is in their interest. Reuters is reporting for the first time that discussions on India's purchases of Stryker combat vehicles made by General Dynamics Land Systems and Javelin anti-tank missiles developed by Raytheon and Lockheed Martin have been paused due to the tariffs. Trump and Indian Prime Minister Narendra Modi had in February announced plans to pursue procurement and joint production of those items. Singh had also been planning to announce the purchase of six Boeing P8I reconnaissance aircraft and support systems for the Indian Navy during his now-cancelled trip, two of the people said. Talks over procuring the aircraft in a proposed $3.6 billion deal were at an advanced stage, according to the officials. Boeing, Lockheed Martin and General Dynamics referred queries to the Indian and US governments. Raytheon did not return a request for comment. India's deepening security relationship with the US, which is fuelled by their shared strategic rivalry with China, was heralded by many US analysts as one of the key areas of foreign-policy progress in the first Trump administration. Delhi is the world's second-largest arms importer and Russia has traditionally been its top supplier. India has in recent years however, shifted to importing from Western powers like France, Zionist entity and the US, according to the Stockholm International Peace Research Institute think-tank. The shift in suppliers was driven partly by constraints on Russia's ability to export arms, which it is utilizing heavily in its invasion of Ukraine. Some Russian weapons have also performed poorly in the battlefield, according to Western analysts. The broader US-India defense partnership, which includes intelligence sharing and joint military exercises, continues without hiccups, one of the Indian officials said. India also remains open to scaling back on oil imports from Russia and is open to making deals elsewhere, including the US, if it can get similar prices, according to two other Indian sources. Trump's threats and rising anti-US nationalism in India have 'made it politically difficult for Modi to make the shift from Russia to the US,' one of the people said. Nonetheless, discounts on the landing cost of Russian oil have shrunk to the lowest since 2022. India's petroleum ministry did not immediately respond to a request for comment. While the rupture in US-India ties was abrupt, there have been strains in the relationship. Delhi has repeatedly rebutted Trump's claim that the US brokered a ceasefire between India and Pakistan after four days of fighting between the nuclear-armed neighbors in May. Trump also hosted Pakistan's army chief at the White House in the weeks following the conflict. In recent months, Moscow has been actively pitching Delhi on buying new defense technologies like its S-500 surface-to-air missile system, according to one of the Indian officials, as well as a Russian source familiar with the talks. India currently does not see a need for new arms purchases from Moscow, two Indian officials said. But Delhi is unlikely to wean itself off Russian weapons entirely as the decades-long partnership between the two powers means Indian military systems will continue to require Moscow's support, one of the officials said. The Russian embassy in Delhi did not immediately respond to a request for comment. – Reuters
Kuwait Times
14 hours ago
- Kuwait Times
Argentines grill up more beef in H1 as wages soar
BUENOS AIRES: A woman buys beef at a supermarket in Buenos Aires on August 8, 2025. -- AFP BUENOS AIRES: Argentines are once again chewing down on beef, as an economic turnaround has allowed them to fork over more for steaks, a report from the Rosario exchange said on Friday. The domestic beef market has logged an uptick as wages soar past inflation, the exchange said. Average salaries for registered workers jumped 62.5 percent in the year to May 2025. Consumer inflation was contained at 39 percent, although beef prices rose at a steeper 59 percent over the past 12 months. While still a strain, the inflation rate is a significant drop from the triple-digit annual price increases of the recent past. Austerity policies of libertarian President Javier Milei's have helped cool inflation. The bump in purchasing power went directly to the dinner table, according to the exchange. Consumers in the South American country went from eating an average of 47.6 kg (104.9 lb) of beef in the first six months of last year to 50.2 kg (110.7 lb) in the same period of 2025. 'As inflation begins to ease and allows the consumer's pocket to loosen up, albeit slowly ... beef consumption tends to recover the place of preference it has historically occupied within the local consumer's shopping basket,' said the study. The increased domestic beef consumption so far this year absorbed a supply glut, as exports fell 19 percent by volume, hurt by a volatile exchange rate, the report said. 'The question going forward is how long (local) consumers will be willing to accept the increased supply without a price adjustment,' the exchange said. The country is famed for its beef-eating culture, with steakhouses and asado barbecues a frequent dining option. Argentines had tightened their belts last year due to the high inflation, a recession and rising poverty and unemployment, turning from beef to cheaper meats. — Reuters
