Teachers union politicizes classrooms with its challenge to antisemitism definition
The IHRA definition, however, is neither partisan nor novel. It has been endorsed by dozens of democratic governments around the world as well as many states, including
Advertisement
The MTA's resolution does not stop at opposing IHRA. In its official rationale, the resolution suggests the United States is facing a 'fundamental crisis of democracy' driven by a 'white supremacist curriculum' and warns of attempts to 'erase not only Palestinians and Palestine, but also all marginalized groups of oppressed people.' This language, while emotionally powerful, risks blurring the line between advocacy and indoctrination, especially when issued by a public-sector union representing K–12 educators.
Advertisement
Public school teachers do not operate in the same academic environment as tenured university faculty. They are employees of public institutions, entrusted with delivering state-approved curricula shaped by democratic processes. That includes the responsibility to teach complex global issues, such as the Israeli-Palestinian conflict, in a balanced, age-appropriate, and pedagogically sound way.
By positioning one narrative as morally urgent and others as harmful or even oppressive, the MTA risks politicizing the classroom. The resolution's most charged phrases, including 'genocide,' 'repression,' and 'terrorize us all into submission,' do little to foster constructive dialogue. Instead, they may stigmatize educators, parents, or students who hold different views or who believe that multiple perspectives should be explored.
This shift matters not just for educators but for all Massachusetts residents. The MTA's tax-exempt status exists to support its work on behalf of teachers' working conditions, not to fund political campaigns or promote foreign policy positions. When a publicly subsidized organization adopts a stance that seeks to delegitimize mainstream definitions of antisemitism and frame opposition as morally suspect, it raises legitimate concerns about accountability and mission creep.
Supporting teachers does not require turning classrooms into political battlegrounds. At a time when trust in public institutions is already strained, the MTA should recommit to the values that first earned it the public's confidence: educational excellence, professional integrity, and pluralism of thought.
Advertisement
Hashtags
Try Our AI Features
Explore what Daily8 AI can do for you:
Comments
No comments yet...
Related Articles
NBC News
12 minutes ago
- NBC News
Trump administration revoked more than 6,000 student visas, State Department says
WASHINGTON — The administration of President Donald Trump has revoked more than 6,000 student visas for overstays and breaking the law, including a small minority for 'support for terrorism,' a State Department official said Monday. The move, first reported by Fox Digital, comes as the Trump administration has adopted a particularly hard-line approach toward student visas as part of its immigration crackdown, tightening social media vetting and expanding screening. Directives from the State Department this year have ordered U.S. diplomats abroad to be vigilant against any applicants whom Washington may see as hostile to the United States and with a history of political activism. Around 4,000 visas were canceled because the visitors broke the law, with the vast majority being assault, the official said. Driving under the influence of alcohol and drugs and burglary were other offenses, the official added. About 200 to 300 visas were revoked for terrorism, the official said, citing a rule about visa ineligibility under the State Department's Foreign Affairs Manual. The rule identifies ineligibility grounds generally as 'engaging in terrorist activities' and 'having certain links to terrorist organizations.' The official did not say which groups the students whose visas have been revoked were in support of. Trump has clashed with several top-level U.S. universities, accusing them of becoming bastions of antisemitism following large-scale student protests advocating Palestinian rights amid the Gaza war. In his clash with Harvard, Trump has frozen funding for investigations and threatened to remove the university's tax-exempt status, prompting several European nations to increase research grants to attract talent. Secretary of State Marco Rubio has said he has revoked the visas of hundreds, perhaps thousands of people, including students, because they got involved in activities that he said went against U.S. foreign policy priorities. Trump administration officials have said that student visa and green card holders are subject to deportation over their support for Palestinians and criticism of Israel's conduct in the war in Gaza, calling their actions a threat to U.S. foreign policy and accusing them of being pro-Hamas. A Tufts University student from Turkey was held for over six weeks in an immigration detention center in Louisiana after co-writing an opinion piece criticizing her school's response to Israel's war in Gaza. She was released from custody after a federal judge granted her bail.
CBS News
5 hours ago
- CBS News
Lox & Loaded gun club aims for self-defense for Jewish community amid antisemitism threat
Lox & Loaded — it's the catchy name behind a new gun club formed in Chicago. The gun club is aimed at giving Jews and allies the tools to defend themselves with antisemitism at historic levels in the U.S. On a recent Saturday morning, Gayle Pearlstein was not observing the Jewish sabbath in the traditional sense. She was instead leading a weekly ritual of a different kind — in the form of target practice at Article II Range in Lombard. "It's never been easy being Jewish, but it's feeling harder and harder," said Lox & Loaded Member Jeffrey Sumber. "I think people that were in liberal households, or weren't accustomed to firearms, are realizing that the police cannot be at every street corner and every event," added Pearlstein. Most pulling the trigger at the Lombard gun range are inexperienced shooters — like retired psychologist Dr. Marla Friedman. "I do not want to shoot anybody, but I don't want to be unprepared," Friedman said. Others in the class said they have never had an interest in guns until recently. "I never thought that I would own guns or shoot guns as a hobby," said Lox & Loaded member Josh Weiner. "We aren't big Second Amendment gun people, but we love our identity, and we will do anything to preserve it," said Daniel Schwartz, president of the Chicago Jewish Alliance, "and if that means defending it, we will." Pearlstein, a firearms instructor with Lucky Star Tactical, started Lox & Loaded. "Lox & Loaded is a shooting club for people of Jewish heritage and their allies," she said. "We are 100% inclusive." The Lox & Loaded chapter that practices at the Article II range is just one of several chapters that meets regularly in the Chicago suburbs and a handful of other states. Pearlstein said since launching Lox & Loaded in March, more than 200 people have signed up. Since Oct. 7, 2023, Pearlstein said sales for firearm instruction have jumped some 60%. "You are your first defender," she said, "and that's where we come in. That's where we're training you safely." FBI data from last year showed that anti-Jewish hate crimes made up nearly 70% of all religion-based hate crimes. According to the State of Antisemitism in America report published in February, 33% of American Jews say they personally have been targets of antisemitism in person or online once this past year. In June, a man was arrested for throwing Molotov cocktails at a group of demonstrators in Boulder, Colorado, who supported the Israeli hostages taken by Hamas in October 2023. Weeks earlier, a Chicago man was arrested in a shooting that killed two Israeli embassy staffers outside the Capital Jewish Museum in Washington, D.C. Hate crime and terrorism charges were also announced late last year after a Jewish man was shot while walking to synagogue in West Rogers Park — though the suspect in that case later died in custody. Back at the range in Lombard, members of Lox & Loaded said they were drawn to the class due to the increase in antisemitic incidents and rhetoric. "It's a cause I really believe in," Sumber said. "I'm super concerned about the state of things in the world right now." "This is an opportunity for the Jewish community and our allies to really learn how to, you know, use the Second Amendment effectively and defensively," added Schwartz. While Pearlstein teaches her students to avoid violent or confrontational situations, some say they want the skills to protect themselves just in case. "I want to see every able-bodied Jew to have a gun," said Friedman.
USA Today
8 hours ago
- USA Today
Black suit and diplomacy: Zelenskyy dressed to impress in Oval Office do-over
Ukrainian President Volodymyr Zelenskyy came dressed for diplomacy. The last time Zelenskyy met with President Donald Trump in the Oval Office in February - an acrimonious meeting that ended abruptly - he said he'd wear a suit after the Russian war on his country had ended. The declaration came after a reporter asked Zelenskyy, who was wearing a black sweatshirt, black slacks and boots, why he was not wearing a suit while visiting the 'highest level' office in the country. I'll 'wear the costume after the war is finished," he replied. Kostium is the Ukrainian word for suit. This time, his sartorial choice as well as his choice of words seemed carefully designed to insulate him from another unceremonious exit from the Oval Office. But perhaps his willingness to don a suit to the meeting, three days after Trump's meeting with Russian President Vladimir Putin, also revealed that peace could possibly be within reach. No suit, no lunch, no respect: Zelenskyy-Trump feud started with a fashion dig As Zelenskyy emerged from his limousine at the White House outfitted in a monochromatic look with a black shirt, slacks and jacket, Trump gave him a once-over while flashing a big smile, clearly pleased at his guest's style. Minutes later, he seconded a reporter – the same reporter who had been critical of Zelenskyy's casual clothing choice in February - who was now paying him a compliment. 'You look fabulous in that suit,' Brian Glenn, White House correspondent for the pro-Trump network Real America's Voice told Zelenskyy. 'I said the same thing,' said Trump. Zelenskyy also came prepared to heap praise on Trump for his efforts to bring an end to the war. During the February visit, Vice President JD Vance, berated him for not expressing his gratitude for the support of the U.S. and to Trump. 'Have you said thank you once?' Vance said at the time. 'Offer some words of appreciation for the United States of America and the president who is trying to save your country.' During the Aug. 18 meeting, Zelenskyy peppered his opening with four thank you's in the first two sentences – expressing his gratitude for the invitation, Trump's personal efforts to end the war and to First lady Melania Trump for the letter she wrote to Putin generally advocating for children. It did not mention Ukraine. Zelenskyy had another weapon in his arsenal, a mirroring technique, known to elicit positive reactions: He came bearing a letter from his wife, Olena Zelenska, for the First lady Melania Trump, just like the one she had sent for Putin with her husband. Zelenskyy's efforts, and the fact that he was joined by a European delegation, seemed help keep discussions on the right track. Trump did not rule out U.S. support for Ukraine if diplomatic efforts didn't pan out, even though he has repeatedly called for concessions by Ukraine. 'We will give them very good protection — very good security. That's part of it,' he said. Swapna Venugopal Ramaswamy is a White House correspondent for USA TODAY. You can follow her on X @SwapnaVenugopal
