‘Cruel' criminalisation of women over abortion must end, says MP ahead of vote
She said the UK's 'Victorian' abortion law is 'increasingly used against vulnerable women and girls' and that her amendment is the 'right change at the right time' and a 'once-in-a-generation' opportunity to bring change.
Abortion in England and Wales remains a criminal offence but is legal with an authorised provider up to 24 weeks, with very limited circumstances allowing one after this time, such as when the mother's life is at risk or the child would be born with a severe disability.
It is also legal to take prescribed medication at home if a woman is less than 10 weeks pregnant.
Efforts to change the law to protect women from prosecution follow repeated calls to repeal sections of the 19th-century law, the 1861 Offences Against the Person Act, after abortion was decriminalised in Northern Ireland in 2019.
Ms Antoniazzi said her proposed 'narrow, targeted' measure does not change how abortion services are provided or the rules under the 1967 Abortion Act.
She said: 'This piece of legislation will only take women out of the criminal justice system because they are vulnerable and they need our help. As I have said it before, and I will say it again, just what public interest is this serving? This is not justice, it is cruelty and it has got to end.'
She added that her amendment is backed by 180 MPs from across the Commons and 50 organisations including the Royal College of Obstetricians and Gynaecologists (RCOG).
The MP assured her colleagues the current 24-week limit would remain, abortions would still require the approval and signatures of two doctors, and that healthcare professionals 'acting outside the law and abusive partners using violence or poisoning to end a pregnancy would still be criminalised, as they are now'.
A separate amendment has also been put forward by Labour MP Stella Creasy and goes further by not only decriminalising abortion, but also seeks to 'lock in' the right of someone to have one and protect those who help them.
Ms Creasy's amendment will also be debated but 'will fall' if Ms Antoniazzi's is passed by MPs, the Commons heard.
Referring to Ms Creasy's amendment, Ms Antoniazzi said while she agreed 'more comprehensive reform of abortion law is needed', such change of that scale should take place through a future separate piece of legislation.
Conservative MP and Father of the House Sir Edward Leigh, speaking against both amendments, described them as 'not pro-woman' and argued they 'would introduce sex-selective abortion'.
DUP MP Carla Lockhart insisted 'both lives matter', saying the proposed amendments 'would be bad for both women and unborn children'.
Justice Secretary Shabana Mahmood, who is not present for Tuesday's vote, outlined her opposition to both amendments in a letter to constituents, saying while she believes safe and legal abortions are part of female healthcare, the amendments 'unnecessary' and 'dangerous'.
The issue of women investigated by police over suspected illegal abortions has come to the fore in recent times with prominent cases such as those of Nicola Packer and Carla Foster.
Ms Packer was cleared by a jury last month after taking prescribed abortion medicine when she was around 26 weeks pregnant, beyond the legal limit of 10 weeks for taking such medication at home.
She told jurors during her trial, which came after more than four years of police investigation, that she did not realise she had been pregnant for more than 10 weeks.
The case of Ms Foster, jailed in 2023 for illegally obtaining abortion tablets to end her pregnancy when she was between 32 and 34 weeks pregnant, eventually saw her sentence reduced by the Court of Appeal and suspended, with senior judges saying that sending women to prison for abortion-related offences is 'unlikely' to be a 'just outcome'.
MPs had previously been due to debate similar amendments removing the threat of prosecution against women who act in relation to their own pregnancy at any stage, but these did not take place as Parliament was dissolved last summer for the general election.
The Society for the Protection of Unborn Children (SPUC) has urged MPs to vote against both amendments, saying they would bring about 'the biggest expansion of abortion since 1967″.
Alithea Williams, the organisation's public policy manager, said: 'Unborn babies will have any remaining protection stripped away, and women will be left at the mercy of abusers.
'Both amendments would allow abortion up to birth, for any reason.
A separate amendment, tabled by Conservative MP Caroline Johnson proposes mandatory in-person consultations for women seeking an abortion before being prescribed at-home medication to terminate a pregnancy.
She said her amendment aims to make sure women and girls are safe when they access abortion services.
She told the Commons: 'I'm not trying to limit people's access to what is clinically legally available. I'm trying to make sure that people are safe when they do so.'
She said the change she has proposed would be to protect women who have been trafficked and forced into sex work or those who have been sexually abused and where a perpetrator is attempting to cover up their crimes by causing a termination.
But Ms Antoniazzi said remote access to abortion care was 'safe, effective and reduces waiting times', and that such a change would 'devastate abortion access in this country'.
The changes being debated this week would not cover Scotland, where a group is currently undertaking work to review the law as it stands north of the border.
On issues such as abortion, MPs usually have free votes, meaning they take their own view rather than deciding along party lines.
The Government has previously said it is neutral on decriminalisation and that it is an issue for Parliament to decide upon.
Hashtags
Try Our AI Features
Explore what Daily8 AI can do for you:
Comments
No comments yet...
Related Articles
Daily Mail
a minute ago
- Daily Mail
Every EV model that qualifies for the Electric Car Grant
After a three-year hiatus, ministers have reintroduced taxpayer-funded discounts on electric cars in a bid to accelerate Britain's transition to EVs. Labour announced its new Electric Car Grant (ECG) on 14 July, with Transport Secretary Heidi Alexander hailing it as the scheme to 'unlock' the nation's 'transition to zero emission vehicles' with promises of reducing prices by as much as £3,750. Its arrival comes in the wake of a slump in private EV sales and a chorus of industry players and car manufacturers demanding a wave of purchase incentives to help them to achieve binding zero emission vehicle sales targets set out by the ZEV mandate. The Electric Car Grant forms part of the UK's Plan for Change, and replaces the Conservative's scrapped Plug-In Car Grant which ended in 2022. But it's not as easy as walking into a showrooms and expecting to see the cost of a new EV slashed. Only models up to £37,000 are eligible and manufacturers need to adhere to certain sustainability criteria. And car makers have to apply for grants, which has resulted in huge delays announcing qualifying cars as Government bean counters determine which models will be subsidised. Here's a full list of every electric car that's qualified for the grant to date... What is the electric car grant? The ECG is backed by a £650million scheme that's due to run until 2028-29. It offers buyers money off new all-electric models that are sustainably manufactured and priced at – or under – £37,000. But the grant differs to the previous scheme under Tory leadership from 2011 to 2022 - one because it only supports the greenest EVs. Once the Department for Transport deems if a vehicle qualifies at all, it then has to determine the band based on the car's 'sustainability criteria'. This includes the emissions produced during the battery's manufacturing, the vehicle's assembly, and the carbon intensity of the electric grids in the countries where the car is made. A certain threshold (which has not been confirmed by the DfT) needs to be met to qualify as a 'Band 1' model and the full £3,750 subsidy. Models failing to meet this benchmark will be deemed 'Band 2' and only receive a £1,500 discount. Which models qualify for the Electric Car Grant? Due to the prolonged application and review process, the Government has in recent weeks been releasing details of which EV models are eligible in drips and drabs. It says it is doing so 'as fast as it can'. This, however, has created a lot of waiting, uncertainty and frustration. It took over three weeks for the first four eligible models from Citroen to be announced , but the numbers have continued to rise since. Below is the list of every manufacturer and model that's been given the green light for the ECG. Alpine Models eligible: Band 2 £1,500: A290 French performance brand Alpine has just one model in the Government's ECG list; the A290 electric hot hatch. The sporty city car has qualified for the £1,500 grant, meaning the compact EV now starts from £32,000. Despite being listed under 'Renault Alpine' in the Government's list, Alpine is a separate brand to Renault, although it is owned by the French car making giant. It serves as the Group's performance and motorsport brand, and develops its own technologies. Citroen Models eligible: Band 2 £1,500: e-C3 and e-C3 Aircross, e-C4 and e-C4 X, e-C5 Aircross, e-Berlingo Citroen was the first manufacturer to be awarded the grant, with four models passing the lower band (2): The e-C3, e-C4, e-C5 and e-Berlingo van all have £1,500 discounted from their OTR. With the £1,500 ECG applied, the new e-C3 is now available from £20,595, the new e-C3 Aircross starts at £21,595, and the New e-C5 Aircross can be acquired from £32,565. The e-Berlingo (M versions only) van will now cost from £29,740. Cupra Nissan Models eligible: Band 2 £1,500: Ariya, Micra Struggling Japanese manufacturer Nissan has two EV models that now receive the £1,500 ECG: the Ariya and the Micra. The Micra is the more exciting model to have the saving applied because it is one of three new cars Nissan is launching this year and brings back the iconic nameplate in electric form. It goes on sale in September, and the discount will already be applied – it will cost from £21,495. The Ariya now starts from £33,500 thanks to the ECG. Peugeot Renault Models eligible: Band 2 £1,500: Renault 4, Renault 5 , Renault Megane, Renault Scenic Renault's Alpine A290, Megane, Scenic, R4 and R5 EVs all receive the £1,500 discount, bringing the R5 down to £21,495 for the entry-level version and £25,495 for the R4 entry-level. The Megane costs from £30,995 and the Scenic E-Tech from £35,495. Renault has confirmed that the new ECG will be applied to all orders taken from 16 July, backdating the discount to customers who bought any of the eligible models from that date. Vauxhall Models eligible: Band 2 £1,500: Astra Electric, Combo Life Electric, Corsa Electric, Frontera Electric, Grandland Electric, Mokka Electric Vauxhall has had its whole electric range confirmed for Band 2, which sees the Corsa Electric, Combo Life Electric, Astra Electric, Mokka Electric, Frontera Electric and Grandland Electric all reduced by £1,500. The Vauxhall's Frontera Electric family SUV starts from £22,495 OTR, while the popular Corsa Electric is available from £26,005. The Mokka Electric starts from £31,005, while the Astra Electric and Astra Sports Tourer now start from £33,505 and £34,705, respectively. The Grandland Electric is the most expensive with the grant applied costing £35,455. Volkswagen Models eligible: Band 2 £1,500: ID.3 Volkswagen's smallest electric car, the ID.3, is the first VW EVs now eligible for the Government scheme. With the £1,500 discount the ID.3 range is available from £29,360 for the ID.3 Pure Essential. Which brands are offering their own electric car grants? Chinese brands are unlikely to be included in the Electric Car Grant on manufacturing –related emissions ground, due to the coal use for energy creation in the East Asian country. So most Chinese manufacturers have decided to take matters into their own hands and offer grant-style savings of their own - some matching the Government's maximum subsidy of £3,750. But non-Chinese brands have also released their own grants while they wait to hear if they pass the Government's application process. We've compiled a full list of all the car makers that are offering their own manufacturer electric car grants – from £1,500 to £3,750 – so it's worth checking to see if the model you want is discounted by the car maker even if it's not part of the official ECG. How do you get the ECG discount? The Electric Car Grant discounts will automatically be applied to recommended retail prices of vehicles that qualify. Once the Government has approved a model, the manufacturer will discount the price online, in showrooms and dealerships. There's no paperwork for car buyers to complete to gain the discount on your new EV - it's all done for you. What is a sustainable EV? Why is the grant focusing on 'green' electric cars? While electric vehicles are lauded for their zero tailpipe emissions, the carbon emissions and environmental impact during production hinder them from being completely 'green'. Therefore, the Government is looking at the carbon emissions across the vehicle's entire lifetime, focusing on how sustainably each model is made, rewarding those that deliver zero driving emissions and low production emissions. Labour says it will grant the car makers with only the 'highest manufacturing sustainability standards' with discounts. To qualify manufacturers must hold a Science Based Target at minimum, verified by the independent Science Based Targets initiative, which aligns with the Paris Agreement goals. If it does not pass these checks it will not be eligible for the grant.
Spectator
30 minutes ago
- Spectator
Is the Blair-Cameron consensus on education over?
GCSE results day has brought a mixed picture; the pass rate has fallen, yet the regional gap has reduced and the gender gap is the narrowest it has ever been. Isabel Hardman and Sir Nick Gibb, former Conservative schools minister, join James Heale to discuss education policy, how changing cultural expectations may be helping the gender gap and why Labour seem determined to attack the Conservatives' record on education. In Nick's words, is Education Secretary Bridget Phillipson a 'more political figure than education figure'? Plus: how the recent High Court ruling over migrant hotels could spark a crisis for the government as more councils, including Labour-controlled ones, seek an end to the policy. Produced by Patrick Gibbons.
STV News
30 minutes ago
- STV News
How many asylum seekers are housed in hotels in Scotland?
A total of 1,573 asylum seekers are housed in hotels in Scotland, according to newly published data. The numbers have increased in recent months – mirroring a rise across the UK – but is lower than the peak reached in September 2023 under the Tories. The figures come just days after a court ruled that more than 100 asylum seekers currently staying at a hotel south of the border should be removed from the accommodation after a council brought a legal case. The High Court judgment has led to ministers bracing for further legal challenges from councils across the country and pressure on the Government as to where else they can house asylum seekers. Falkirk Council is among those considering the implications of the ruling. Data is not released on the number of hotels in use, but it is thought there were more than 400 asylum hotels open in summer 2023, which Labour said it had now reduced to fewer than 210. Asylum seekers and their families can be housed in temporary accommodation, known as contingency accommodation, if they are awaiting assessment of their claim or have had a claim approved and there is not enough longer-term accommodation available. Here is a full list of the latest available data showing the number of asylum seekers housed temporarily in hotels across Scotland, by local authority. Council Asylum Seekers in Hotels (June 30) Asylum Seekers in Hotels (March) Change (March to June) Aberdeen 364 300 +64 Aberdeenshire 312 250 +62 Angus 0 0 0 Argyll and Bute 0 0 0 Clackmannanshire 0 0 0 Dumfries and Galloway 103 69 +34 Dundee 0 0 0 East Ayrshire 0 0 0 East Dunbartonshire 0 0 0 East Lothian 0 0 0 East Renfrewshire 0 0 0 Edinburgh 162 153 +9 Falkirk 92 79 +13 Fife 0 0 0 Glasgow 0 0 0 Highland 0 0 0 Inverclyde 104 104 0 Midlothian 0 0 0 Moray 0 0 0 Na h-Eileanan Siar 0 0 0 North Ayrshire 0 0 0 North Lanarkshire 0 0 0 Orkney 0 0 0 Perth and Kinross 192 171 +21 Renfrewshire 66 61 +5 Scottish Borders 0 0 0 Shetland 0 0 0 South Ayrshire 0 0 0 South Lanarkshire 90 86 +4 Stirling 0 0 0 West Dunbartonshire 0 0 0 West Lothian 88 79 +9 Home Secretary Yvette Cooper insisted Labour's actions in the past year in increasing returns of failed asylum seekers, cutting asylum costs and the backlog, as well as plans to overhaul what she described as the 'failing' asylum appeal system, are all 'crucial steps to restoring order and putting an end to the chaotic use of asylum hotels that we inherited from the previous government'. But shadow home secretary Chris Philp accused Labour of having 'lost control of Britain's borders', claiming 'hotels would already be gone' if the Conservatives were still in power. The Refugee Council praised Labour for 'bringing the asylum system back from the brink of collapse', saying quicker asylum decisions 'means refugees can begin to rebuild their lives sooner, and the use of costly hotels can be ended faster'. Amid hotel protests, campaigners including Rape Crisis and Refuge have warned conversations about violence against women and girls are being 'hijacked by an anti-migrant agenda' which they argued fuels divisions and harms survivors. More than 100 women's organisations have written to ministers to say they 'have been alarmed in recent weeks by an increase in unfounded claims made by people in power, and repeated in the media, that hold particular groups as primarily responsible for sexual violence'. They added: 'This not only undermines genuine concerns about women's safety, but also reinforces the damaging myth that the greatest risk of gender-based violence comes from strangers.' Get all the latest news from around the country Follow STV News Scan the QR code on your mobile device for all the latest news from around the country
