Manipulated chart misleads on migration rate in Canada
The image spread online throughout June on Facebook, Instagram, YouTube and X, where it was shared by controversial influencer Mario Nawfal and news aggregator Visegrád 24, which frequently posts misinformation.
As anxiety heightened in recent years over housing shortages and employment opportunities, Canada's years-long pro-immigration consensus broke as some argued welcoming more newcomers contributed to scarcity.
While certain analysts say employers are exploiting the temporary foreign worker program and immigration officials warned that Canada is bringing in more immigrants than it can house, AFP still regularly debunks rumors misleadingly claiming the system helps new arrivals take jobs, food assistance and social benefits from citizens.
These concerns were accompanied by a documented increase in the rate of new arrivals to the country, but the chart seen in the social media posts exaggerates the phenomenon.
Text claims the graph in the image was sourced from the Statistics Canada dataset "Estimates of the components of international migration, quarterly" (archived here).
But the government statistics agency told AFP the chart does not align with its data.
"The figure is not an accurate picture of Canada's migration patterns," said Statistics Canada spokeswoman Jasmine Emond in a June 27 email.
The graph circulating in June was credited to the account "@FinanceLancelot" (archived here), which shared the chart with the striking increase to X on May 31. Following the thread of that post leads to another graphic, this time credited to "@AlymerTH" (archived here), depicting a slightly less extreme increase going up to 2023 posted on October 8, 2024.
Emond said Statistics Canada was uncertain about the source of the numbers in the chart but @AlymerTH claimed in a post they used a code to scrape the "components of international migration" dataset and create the chart.
Statistics Canada's dataset is broken down into departures and arrival categories such as emigrants, immigrants -- or permanent residents -- and inflows and outflows of non-permanent residents, which includes anyone coming in on a work or study permit. @AlymerTH's code appears to take the sum of categories that denote departures and subtracts them from all the arrival categories.
However, Emond said an equation calculating recent net migration should have used the "net non-permanent residents" category over a subtraction of outflows from inflows. The data breaking down non-permanent residents' comings and goings is only available from the end of 2021.
Comparing @AlymerTH's formula and the one suggested by Statistics Canada produces similar results for high net international migration in 2023, but the X user's equation also leads to an increase in 2020. The formulation from the government agency showed a decrease that year when many left during the coronavirus pandemic (archived here).
Statistics Canada consolidates data from the "components of international migration" set into its own graphic, broken down by quarters, which again shows the net decrease in 2020 and increases between 2021 and 2023 (archived here).
Unlike the June social media posts, which show net international migration supposedly taking off to over 2.5 million people per year by 2025, Statistics Canada's representation of its most recent immigration data actually shows a decrease in the category after a peak in the third quarter of 2023.
The chart with the steep increase appears to show a 2.5 million data point tacked on to @AlymerTH's graph in reaction to the recently elected Canadian government's proposed immigration targets.
Canada's latest Immigration Levels Plan (archived here), says the government intends to allow the entry of around 2.8 million people, but this is over the course of multiple years between 2025 and 2027 as opposed to just within 2025.
Net migration levels will likely be further decreased by the number of non-permanent residents who leave when their permits expire -- a number not yet known or reflected in the chart on social media.
The Canadian government announced reductions to its immigration targets in late 2024.
According to Statistics Canada data, the country saw its lowest net migration levels since 2021 in the last quarter of 2024 and first quarter of 2025 (archived here).
Read more of AFP's reporting on misinformation in Canada here.
Hashtags
Try Our AI Features
Explore what Daily8 AI can do for you:
Comments
No comments yet...
Related Articles
Bloomberg
42 minutes ago
- Bloomberg
Fringe Party Vows to Put ‘Japan First' to Erode LDP Power
Updated on Save Japan's Liberal Democratic Party has dominated the country for the last 70 years, losing control of the government only twice. A five-year-old party cobbled together on social media during the pandemic is trying to weaken that grip on power by tapping into voter frustrations and anti-foreigner sentiment. The party, Sanseito, is gaining traction in the polls and is focused on peeling away current LDP voters in the upper house election on July 20. Led by Sohei Kamiya, a former high school teacher, it advocates for restrictions on immigration as well as laws against foreigners buying Japanese companies or land. Sanseito promises to cut taxes, protect rice farmers, boost the country's birth rate and curb the use of pesticides.
Yahoo
2 hours ago
- Yahoo
Immigration agents demand tenant information from landlords, stirring questions and confusion
ATLANTA (AP) — Immigration authorities are demanding that landlords turn over leases, rental applications, forwarding addresses, identification cards and other information on their tenants, a sign that the Trump administration is targeting them to assist in its drive for mass deportations. Eric Teusink, an Atlanta-area real estate attorney, said several clients recently received subpoenas asking for entire files on tenants. A rental application can include work history, marital status and family relationships. The two-page 'information enforcement subpoena,' which Teusink shared exclusively with The Associated Press, also asks for information on other people who lived with the tenant. One, dated May 1, is signed by an officer for U.S. Citizenship and Immigration Services ' anti-fraud unit. However, it is not signed by a judge. It is unclear how widely the subpoenas were issued, but they could signal a new front in the administration's efforts to locate people who are in the country illegally, many of whom were required to give authorities their U.S. addresses as a condition for initially entering the country without a visa. President Donald Trump largely ended temporary status for people who were allowed in the country under his predecessor, Joe Biden. Experts question whether landlords need to comply Some legal experts and property managers say the demands pose serious legal questions because they are not signed by a judge and that, if landlords comply, they might risk violating the Fair Housing Act, which prohibits discrimination on the basis of race, color or national origin. Critics also say landlords are likely to feel intimidated into complying with something that a judge hasn't ordered, all while the person whose information is being requested may never know that their private records are in the hands of immigration authorities. 'The danger here is overcompliance," said Stacy Seicshnaydre, a Tulane University law professor who studies housing law. "Just because a landlord gets a subpoena, doesn't mean it's a legitimate request.' ICE officers have long used subpoenas signed by an agency supervisor to try to enter homes. Advocacy groups have mounted 'Know Your Rights' campaign urging people to refuse entry if they are not signed by a judge. The subpoena reviewed by the AP is from USCIS' fraud detection and national security directorate, which, like ICE, is part of The Department of Homeland Security. Although it isn't signed by a judge, it threatens that a judge may hold a landlord in contempt of court for failure to comply. Tricia McLaughlin, a Homeland Security spokeswoman, defended the use of subpoenas against landlords without confirming if they are being issued. 'We are not going to comment on law enforcement's tactics surrounding ongoing investigations," McLaughlin said. 'However, it is false to say that subpoenas from ICE can simply be ignored. ICE is authorized to obtain records or testimony through specific administrative subpoena authorities. Failure to comply with an ICE-issued administrative subpoena may result in serious legal penalties. The media needs to stop spreading these lies.' These requests are new to many landlords Teusink said many of his clients oversee multifamily properties and are used to getting subpoenas for other reasons, such as requests to hand over surveillance footage or give local police access to a property as part of an investigation. But, he said, those requests are signed by a judge. Teusink said his clients were confused by the latest subpoenas. After consulting with immigration attorneys, he concluded that compliance is optional. Unless signed by a judge, the letters are essentially just an officer making a request. 'It seemed like they were on a fishing expedition,' Teusink said. Boston real estate attorney Jordana Roubicek Greenman said a landlord client of his received a vague voicemail from an ICE official last month requesting information about a tenant. Other local attorneys told her that their clients had received similar messages. She told her client not to call back. Anthony Luna, the CEO of Coastline Equity, a commercial and multifamily property management company that oversees about 1,000 units in the Los Angeles area, said property managers started contacting him a few weeks ago about concerns from tenants who heard rumors about the ICE subpoenas. Most do not plan to comply if they receive them. 'If they're going after criminals, why aren't they going through court documents?' Luna said. 'Why do they need housing provider files?' ICE subpoenas preceded Trump's first term in office, though they saw a significant uptick under him, according to Lindsay Nash, a law professor at Yeshiva University's Cardozo School of Law in New York who has spent years tracking them. Landlords rarely got them, though. State and local police were the most common recipients. ICE can enforce the subpoenas, but it would first have to file a lawsuit in federal court and get a judge to sign off on its enforcement — a step that would allow the subpoena's recipient to push back, Nash said. She said recipients often comply without telling the person whose records are being divulged. "Many people see these subpoenas, think that they look official, think that some of the language in them sounds threatening, and therefore respond, even when, from what I can tell, it looks like some of these subpoenas have been overbroad,' she said.
Washington Post
3 hours ago
- Washington Post
Immigration agents demand tenant information from landlords, stirring questions and confusion
ATLANTA — Immigration authorities are demanding that landlords turn over leases, rental applications, forwarding addresses, identification cards and other information on their tenants, a sign that the Trump administration is targeting them to assist in its drive for mass deportations . Eric Teusink, an Atlanta-area real estate attorney, said several clients recently received subpoenas asking for entire files on tenants. A rental application can include work history, marital status and family relationships.
