Court throws out damages case brought over wheelbarrow injury
A High Court judge has thrown out a case brought by a former stablehand who wanted damages for hurting his back while emptying a wheelbarrow.
Mark Lawless brought proceedings over a March 9th, 2016 incident at Rossmore Cottage Stables in The Curragh, Co Kildare, where he was employed by racehorse trainer Adrian Keatley.
Advertisement
Mr Lawless, who now works as an auctioneer, sought compensation from Mr Keatley for injury he allegedly sustained to his back when he emptied soiled hay from a wheelbarrow.
In a judgment, Mr Justice Michael Twomey said this incident was an 'everyday misfortunate mishap' for which Mr Keatley was not liable, and dismissed Mr Lawless' case.
Mr Lawless left his job as a stable hand after about 6 to 8 weeks of work at Mr Keatley's stables, and currently works as an auctioneer.
The judge noted that the Supreme Court previously ruled that courts should approach personal injury claims with 'common sense' and 'some degree of scepticism'.
Advertisement
In this vein, the judge said it was his view that if the wheelbarrow incident occurred in Mr Lawless' own garden, it would be regarded as an 'accident', with no one to blame.
This approach is also relevant in considering the evidence of expert witnesses called during the hearing. 'A court does not require an engineer to tell it that one should empty a wheelbarrow on the flat, and not try to empty a wheelbarrow on an upward incline, since this is basic common sense,' the judge said.
The judge also said it was his view that Mr Lawless was mistaken in the recollection of the incident: on the balance of probabilities, he emptied the wheelbarrow on a flat surface, rather than – as Mr Lawless said during the hearing of the case – an incline.
Ireland
Boy who claimed he broke his arm on astro turf pit...
Read More
Emptying the wheelbarrow on an incline is 'unorthodox', the judge said. 'If he had done so, in this court's view, he would have made that claim in his pleadings.'
Advertisement
Even if Mr Lawless' recollection was correct, the judge said, he was not entitled to make that claim at the hearing. He also said Mr Lawless had a responsibility to ensure the surface he was emptying the wheelbarrow on was flat.
'If he failed to do so and then decided to roll a wheelbarrow up an incline and seek to empty it on that incline, any injury to his back is not the responsibility of his employer,' the judge said.
The judge said it was his preliminary view that the costs of the proceedings at both the High Court and the Circuit Court should be awarded against Mr Lawless. The case had been before the court as an appeal from the Circuit Court.
Hashtags
Try Our AI Features
Explore what Daily8 AI can do for you:
Comments
No comments yet...
Related Articles
The Independent
24 minutes ago
- The Independent
Tampa Bay Rays' Wander Franco found guilty in sex abuse case, receives 2-year suspended sentence
Wander Franco, the suspended Tampa Bay Rays shortstop facing sexual abuse charges, was found guilty on Thursday but received a two-year suspended sentence. Franco was arrested last year after being accused of having a four-month relationship with a girl who was 14 at the time, and of transferring thousands of dollars to her mother to consent to the illegal relationship. Franco, now 24, also faced charges of sexual and commercial exploitation against a minor, and human trafficking. Prosecutors had requested a five-year prison sentence against Franco and a 10-year sentence against the girl's mother, who was found guilty and would serve the full sentence. Before the three judges issued their unanimous ruling, the main judge orally reviewed the copious amount of evidence that prosecutors presented during trial, including testimony from 31 witnesses. 'This is a somewhat complex process,' said Judge Jakayra Veras García. More than an hour into her presentation, Veras said: 'The court has understood that this minor was manipulated.' As the judge continued her review, Franco looked ahead expressionless, leaning forward at times. Franco, who was once the team's star shortstop, had signed a $182 million, 11-year contract through 2032 in November 2021 but saw his career abruptly halted in August 2023 after authorities in the Dominican Republic announced they were investigating him for an alleged relationship with a minor. Franco was 22 at the time. In January 2024, authorities arrested Franco in the Dominican Republic. Six months later, Tampa Bay placed him on the restricted list, which cut off the pay he had been receiving while on administrative leave. He was placed on that list because he has not been able to report to the team and would need a new U.S. visa to do so. While Franco awaited trial on conditional release, he was arrested again in November last year following what Dominican authorities called an altercation over a woman's attention. He was charged with illegally carrying a semiautomatic Glock 19 that police said was registered to his uncle. That case is still pending in court.
BreakingNews.ie
an hour ago
- BreakingNews.ie
Garda seeks restraining order against superior for harassment and bullying
A garda and his wife are using anti-stalking laws to secure a civil restraining order against a high-ranking superior officer claiming harassment and bullying. They lodged an application at Dublin District Court, which came before Judge Aine Clancy on Thursday. Advertisement The proceedings are being held in camera, meaning the public cannot attend, and parties involved cannot be identified due to reporting restrictions. Brian Gageby BL, instructed by the Chief State Solicitor's Office, acted for the respondent, and the judge noted that they had filed a 63-page affidavit. Counsel described it as an unusual case where the applicants have alleged bullying and harassment; however, the senior officer's case was that he was acting in the course of his duty. The couple are representing themselves. Advertisement The garda's wife said the respondent's affidavit amounted to misinformation, which she described as horrendous. Her husband also contended that the manner in which the documents were served on him "has caused severe distress and personal alarm to me and my family." He added that in future, he was agreeable to collecting any further material from a Garda premises, and he raised concerns that at an earlier stage in the proceedings, other gardaí were in court as part of a police plan allegedly at the request of the respondent. The couple have summoned six other officers to give evidence, and the respondent has already given a personal assurance to stay away from the couple, their home, children and pets. Ireland Woman tells court of sexual abuse by her mother, u... Read More Mr Gageby said that there was no difficulty with that continuing. Advertisement Judge Clancy ordered the officer and his wife to file responding affidavits by July 30, and the case will be listed for mention the following day. She set aside a whole day for the hearing of the action in early October. The civil restraining orders were introduced in the Criminal Justice (Miscellaneous Provisions) Act 2023 as a measure for people seeking protection. The District Court may issue an order to prevent the respondent from violence or threats, stalking, harassing or approaching the applicant's home, work, or school. It can run for up to five years but may be shorter. Breaking it could mean jail for up to a year and a maximum of €4,000 fine.
BreakingNews.ie
an hour ago
- BreakingNews.ie
Dublin man (20) had gun hidden under bullet proof vest in taxi, court hears
A 20-year-old man was caught in a taxi in Dublin with a loaded handgun after it fell out of his 'body armour' vest on Tuesday night, a court has heard. Craig McKeever of Dromard Road, Drimnagh, Dublin, was charged with an offence under the Firearms Act for unlawful possession of the .22 calibre handgun on June 24th at Turvey Road, Inchicore. Advertisement He appeared before Judge Susan Fay at Dublin District Court on Thursday and was denied bail. In evidence, Garda Niall White said that the accused made no reply to the charge. He objected to bail and alleged that Mr McKeever was caught red-handed. He said the accused and another male got into a taxi, which gardaí approached, noticing a strong smell of cannabis. Advertisement The court heard that during a search, the accused was found in the back seat wearing a body armour ballistics vest, and out of which fell an army green .22 calibre pistol. 'One round of ammunition was discovered loaded in the firearm,' Garda White said. The court heard the gun was seized, along with the single round, a magazine storage holder, the body armour vest and €550 cash allegedly in Mr McKeever's possession. The second male fled but was later granted bail, the court heard. Garda White voiced concerns that the seizure of the gun was related to an ongoing feud. The contested bail hearing was told the young man's house was burned down last year, rebuilt and later petrol bombed. Advertisement He said the Garda ballistics section had also examined the gun. The offence can carry a maximum 14-year sentence. The accused did not address the court or indicate a plea, but the bail hearing was told that the case was likely to be transferred to the Circuit Court, which has greater sentencing powers. Ireland Billionaire JP McManus fights back tears in meetin... Read More His barrister, Kevin McCrave, stressed he had the presumption of innocence and bail, that the weapon has to be tested by experts for the defence, and that his client could spend a year in custody on remand awaiting trial. Case law states that the court could consider bail where it might otherwise not due to lack of a speedy trial, he asserted. Counsel said his client had family in court who could support him, stand bail, and ensure he attended court. He argued that the court had a myriad of conditions it could apply to Mr McKeever, who would obey strict conditions similar to house arrest, which would be like having a Garda searchlight on him. Judge Fay said she considered the submissions but denied bail and remanded Mr McKeever in custody to appear at Cloverhill District Court on July 3rd.
