Vape bans in Malaysia risk fuelling black market, resurgence in smoking, experts warn
Published on: Tue, Aug 05, 2025 Text Size: As Malaysia continues to refine its tobacco control strategy, the message from experts is clear - good intentions should not override evidence and experience. - Bernama pic for illustration only. Kota Kinabalu: Experts have warned that ramping up restrictions on vaping, especially moves tantamount to a ban, could trigger unintended and potentially harmful consequences, even as more states move in that direction. States like Johor and Kelantan, which have banned the sale of vape products since 2016 and 2015, respectively, continue to record high user numbers, with more than 150,000 users in Johor and over 30,000 in Kelantan. The availability of illicit vape products in the two states has raised concerns not only because they point to ineffective enforcement, but also the health issues that come with illicit product use, including the possibility of drug abuse. Malaysia is not alone in facing issues related to illicit vape use. A similar pattern has been observed in neighbouring Singapore, the country renowned for strict enforcement, but also where a complete ban on vaping has failed to curb its usage. A survey by Milieu Insight found vape usage among Singaporeans rose from 3.9 per cent to 5.2 per cent between late 2021 and 2023. For context, the island republic's vape ban has been in place since 2018.
Advertisement Back in Malaysia, several states, namely Terengganu, Perlis, Pahang, and Kedah, have implemented bans or stopped issuing new licenses for vape businesses. A health expert and economist say the trend of illicit vape use illustrates a core weakness in prohibitionist approaches: they often do not reduce demand, but instead shift it to illegal and unregulated channels. In a perfect world, a complete ban is ideal. But realistically, it has several repercussions,' said Professor Dr Sharifa Ezat Wan Puteh, a lecturer at Universiti Kebangsaan Malaysia. 'We're already seeing a rise in black market tobacco and vape products. These are untaxed and unregulated, making them more dangerous to users.' Sharifa said that in countries burdened by high smoking rates and low success with traditional nicotine replacement therapies (NRT), there may be a role for tobacco harm reduction (THR) products such as e-cigarettes, heated tobacco products (HTPs), and oral nicotine pouches. She said some recalcitrant smokers who find it hard to quit with traditional NRT may benefit from alternatives, though the effectiveness depends on product quality and enforcement capabilities. She cited countries like Sweden and Norway, which use snus and nicotine pouches and are projected to reduce tobacco smoking rates below 5 per cent in the coming years. These nations also have among the lowest rates of lung cancer and cardiovascular disease in the EU. In Japan and South Korea, the use of HTPs has coincided with a decline in smoking prevalence. In contrast, Australia's tightly regulated medical-vaping model is struggling. Under rules introduced in October 2024, vapes can only be sold via pharmacies with a prescription. But data from The Daily Telegraph revealed that just one in every 1,686 vape sales occurred through legal channels. Meanwhile, major suppliers, including Philip Morris, have exited the market, citing unsustainable regulatory burdens. The stricter controls have had a paradoxical impact. A month later, the same daily reported that more than one-in-10 of Australians aged 18 to 24 are now smoking cigarettes, a 36 per cent surge in less than a year. 'Policies don't always produce the desired results,' said Dr Carmelo Ferlito, chief executive of the Centre for Market Education. 'We've seen this in prohibition-era America and communist countries. Restrictions shift consumption underground rather than eliminate it.' Ferlito argues that heavy-handed bans fail to account for economic realities and consumer behaviour. He said that when in-demand products are banned, people would just find a way to procure them from illegal sources, and this was why 'good intentions' were not enough when it came to policy-making. 'Often, policies are designed as wishlists, ignoring the 'laws' of economics. 'For example, I could proclaim that I could fly and jump out a window. But if I do so, ignoring the laws of gravity, I could jump out of the window, but I won't be able to fly. That's the reality.' Ferlito said he believes regulation should facilitate reputable suppliers to bring in products legally, lowering the risk of counterfeit products. This should be accompanied by education and awareness on the trade-offs involved in the consumption of alternatives to cigarettes or stopping altogether. Sharifa said two Cochrane reviews, which are internationally recognised as the highest standard in evidence-based health care, have shown the benefits of THR in smoking cessation. 'Vaping was never intended for youth use, but weak regulation, lax enforcement, and irresponsible vendors have enabled widespread abuse. 'The situation has been further compounded by black market imports from abroad.' As Malaysia continues to refine its tobacco control strategy, the message from experts is clear - good intentions should not override evidence and experience. * Follow us on our official WhatsApp channel and Telegram for breaking news alerts and key updates! * Do you have access to the Daily Express e-paper and online exclusive news? Check out subscription plans available.
Stay up-to-date by following Daily Express's Telegram channel. Daily Express Malaysia
Hashtags
Try Our AI Features
Explore what Daily8 AI can do for you:
Comments
No comments yet...
Related Articles
Free Malaysia Today
19 hours ago
- Free Malaysia Today
Matcha latte: healthy beverage or calorie bomb?
Favoured the world over, the health benefits of a matcha latte depends on how the beverage is prepared and how much of it is consumed. (Envato Elements pic) KUALA LUMPUR : It's a guilty pleasure among foodies all over the world – matcha latte, the soft green-hued beverage made from finely ground Japanese green tea powder and combined with milk. Its vibrant, photogenic presentation makes it a hit on social media, and its association with an active and 'healthier' lifestyle makes it appear to be the preferred choice for many over coffee. But just how beneficial is this beverage, whose base ingredient hails from the Land of the Rising Sun and is currently facing global shortages? According to dietitian Nur Adilah Muhammadun Basar, the finely ground powder made from high-quality green-tea leaves may contain plenty of antioxidants, but its effects still depend on how the beverage is prepared and how much of it is consumed. 'Matcha is indeed rich in antioxidants compared to regular green tea, but when it's made into a latte with sweetened milk, syrups and whipped cream, it reduces the health benefits. 'In fact, it could even encourage unhealthy eating habits and higher calorie intake,' she told Bernama. Nur Adilah Muhammadun Basar. She said a glass of latte without added sweeteners contains 90 to 200 calories depending on the type of milk used. Loaded with syrups and flavourings such as caramel drizzle, this can easily spike to about 400 calories – the equivalent of about 1.5 bowls of white rice. As such, regular consumption could lead to health issues such as obesity, diabetes, heart problems and fatigue. These, of course, go against the very benefits matcha is supposed to offer, such as increased energy and mental focus, and support for the immune and metabolic systems. Nur Adilah also pointed out that a cup of matcha latte is estimated to contain more than twice the caffeine content of regular green tea, reaching up to 70mg. This is still less than the 120mg of caffeine found in a serving of coffee. Nevertheless, the combination of L-theanine and caffeine in matcha makes it a more suitable option for those who wish to stay focused without the jitters or post-caffeine crash associated with drinking coffee. 'The type of milk used in matcha lattes also plays a role. Cow's milk, for instance, can interfere with the absorption of antioxidants, compared with plant-based milks like soy, oat or almond, which are more matcha-friendly,' Nur Adilah added. Real, high-grade matcha has a unique identity – a subtle umami taste, slightly bitter but refreshing, with an earthy aroma. (Andrea Rhiannon Edmonds @ FMT Lifestyle) Meanwhile, academic Hairi Jalis agrees that the use of sugary syrups and additional flavourings not only drowns out the benefits of matcha but can also ruin its authentic taste. 'Real, high-grade matcha has its own unique identity: a subtle umami taste, slightly bitter but refreshing, with a naturally earthy aroma. 'In Malaysia, however, our palates tend to favour sweetness, especially among those who are accustomed to drinks like teh tarik, frappés and boba desserts,' said the senior lecturer from UiTM's department of gastronomy and culinary arts, . He noted that oat milk goes well with matcha lattes owing to its natural sweetness and texture: it doesn't overpower the taste of the green tea and makes it easier to create latte foam 'art', resulting in more visually appealing presentations. Hairi added that the challenge in preparing the beverage lies in ensuring it is neither too bitter nor too flat, which depends on the quality of the matcha powder and proper mixing techniques. 'The ideal water temperature must be between 70°C and 80°C, and the milk should not be too hot to preserve its natural sweetness. It's best to use a bamboo whisk, or chasen, to achieve a smooth mixture without clumps,' he concluded.
The Star
21 hours ago
- The Star
Health Ministry mulls grades for food nutrition
Health blitz: Dzulkefly posing for a group photo after attending the Nutrition event at the parliament building in Kuala Lumpur. — Bernama IN response to alarming findings on the nutritional habits of Malaysians, the Health Ministry is stepping up efforts to promote healthy eating, including working with food influencers and introducing new policies to encourage healthier choices. Health Minister Datuk Seri Dr Dzulkefly Ahmad said social media influencers, or key opinion leaders, can play a crucial role in shaping public behaviour, and the ministry intends to leverage their influence to spread awareness of healthy lifestyles. 'We want our influencers to uphold the most important agenda, which is to promote healthy eating and lifestyles,' he told reporters yesterday, after moderating a dialogue on the National Health and Morbidity Survey (Nutrition) 2024 findings. The report revealed serious deficiencies in the population's dietary habits. Only 12.8% of adolescents and 17.1% of adults meet the minimum recommended intake of fruits and vegetables, while dairy consumption is extremely low, at just 2.9% among adolescents and a mere 0.7% among adults. At the same time, sugar consumption is excessive, with 63.1% of adolescents and 47.0% of adults exceeding the recommended intake, mainly due to sweetened beverages. Fat consumption also surpasses the advised 30% of daily energy intake across all age groups, and 75.9% of adults consume more salt than recommended. Dzulkefly said the government will begin with policies focused on food literacy and nutrition awareness and highlighted the importance of addressing supply-side issues to make healthy food more accessible. 'Ultimately, it's about ensuring that food suppliers, particularly manufacturers, help promote the idea that healthy food does not need to be expensive,' he said. Dzulkefly also revealed that the ministry is considering the introduction of a nutri-grade system, which would classify food items by nutritional value. 'When we introduce nutri-grade, we will know the category of food, from A, the best, to B, and so on, including those that cannot be advertised at all,' he said. He also suggested that products deemed unhealthy could be placed in special sections of supermarkets, similar to how non-halal items are currently separated, to increase consumer awareness.
New Straits Times
a day ago
- New Straits Times
Indonesia proposes to send nurses to Malaysia under strategic plan
JOHOR BARU: The Consulate General of the Republic of Indonesia (KJRI) in Johor Bahru has proposed a strategic collaboration with hospitals in Malaysia to enable nurses from Indonesia to work here, thus helping to overcome the issue of manpower shortage in the medical sector. Its Consul General, Sigit S. Widiyanto, said this would be a win-win situation since about 70 per cent of the international patients in Malaysia are from Indonesia. He is confident that this measure will be mutually beneficial because Malaysia is facing a manpower shortage in the health sector, including nurses, while Indonesia has an excess workforce in the field. "Perhaps, in Johor, Melaka, and then in Penang, Kuala Lumpur… almost 70 per cent of their patients are Indonesians. I was told that the situation is the same with several hospitals in Sabah. "As such, it will be a win-win situation if more of our nurses get to work here. Communication-wise, there will be no problem as we understand each other. Similarly, in terms of opportunities and culturally," he said in an interview with Bernama recently. Previously, Johor Menteri Besar Datuk Onn Hafiz Ghazi said major hospitals in Johor Bahru are currently facing a serious and critical shortage of healthcare manpower, with a nurse having to manage more than 10 to 14 patients per shift, compared to an ideal ratio of 1:6 or a maximum of 1:8 Sigit said the consulate has begun state-level collaboration with a hospital in Johor, including the process of nurse intake before presenting it to the authorities in Kuala Lumpur for approval. "This requires approval from the Ministry of Health (MOH), the Malaysian Nursing Board and other stakeholders. But, we are trying because this has never been done before," he said. He said the nurses from Indonesia are currently recognised in many countries, including Singapore, Saudi Arabia, the United Arab Emirates (UA), Japan, Australia and Germany - proving their capability to serve in Malaysia. "If Indonesian nurses can work in those countries, then they can surely work in Malaysia. Within ASEAN, member countries have already agreed that nursing is among the open professions that can move between countries. Of course, there needs to be skill adjustments and other requirements according to existing regulations, but that is not a big problem," he said. He said they also plan to focus on recruiting nurses from the Riau Islands and Riau as an initial effort to place health workers in Malaysian hospitals. This measure is taken due to geographical proximity and cultural similarities, in addition to many patients from this area seeking treatment in states like Johor and Melaka. "We do not need to go far, we can fulfil our own needs. If it can be implemented nationally, it would be better, but for now, we will focus on the Riau Islands first," he said. He said Tanjung Pinang in the Riau Islands has a health education institution, namely the School of Health Sciences and the Health Polytechnic owned by the Indonesian Ministry of Health, which can be a major source of prospective nurses. "We have discussed with the health school here to create a 'sandwich' programme, whereby the curriculum will be combined to allow graduates in Indonesia to continue their studies for six months in Malaysia before serving here," he said. Sigit is confident that this method can produce nurses who are not only professionally qualified but also able to adapt to the local language and culture. The Johor Bahru KJRI has recorded that about 130,210 Indonesian citizens reside in its work area covering Johor, Melaka, Negeri Sembilan and Pahang. – BERNAMA
