Trump targets racial preferences in college admissions but leaves legacy and donor advantages untouched
Yet, while race is under intense scrutiny, legacy admissions and donor-based advantages remain untouched, preserving a system that favors wealth and inherited privilege.
Legacy admissions: The hidden advantage
Legacy preferences, sometimes described as 'affirmative action for the wealthy,' grant children of alumni or major donors a significant edge in admissions. Despite efforts to remove racial factors from evaluations, hereditary advantages continue to disproportionately benefit affluent and predominantly white students, leaving meritocracy incomplete.
Political and legislative momentum
Lawmakers argue that focusing solely on race does not fully address inequities in higher education. Several states, including Virginia, Colorado, and California, have banned legacy admissions at public institutions. Yet elite private universities, including all Ivy League schools, continue to uphold the practice. Stanford University recently announced it would maintain legacy preferences, even withdrawing from California's state financial aid program rather than abandoning the policy.
by Taboola
by Taboola
Sponsored Links
Sponsored Links
Promoted Links
Promoted Links
You May Like
American Investor Warren Buffett Recommends: 5 Books For Turning Your Life Around
Blinkist: Warren Buffett's Reading List
Undo
Merit over race, wealth intact
Trump's executive actions and Justice Department guidance aim to enforce compliance with the Supreme Court's 2023 ruling against affirmative action, requiring universities to provide detailed admissions data. While the policies prohibit racial consideration, they make no mention of legacy or donor advantages. Critics argue this selective focus undermines the notion of merit, allowing inherited privilege to continue shaping opportunity.
Public opinion and university practices
Most Americans oppose legacy and donor preferences, according to a 2023 AP-NORC poll. Universities defend the practice as a means of building community and securing donations. Transparency, however, remains limited. While institutions report whether they consider legacy status, few disclose its impact on admissions. Among the nation's most selective universities, very few reveal how many students are admitted under legacy or donor preference policies.
Meritocracy under scrutiny
Trump positions his actions as essential to maintaining meritocracy and ensuring colleges recruit capable future professionals. However, experts caution that targeting race alone may have unintended consequences, potentially prompting institutions to limit minority enrollment to avoid government scrutiny. The reform campaign raises fundamental questions about fairness in admissions when wealth and ancestry continue to hold sway.
The road ahead
Trump's admissions initiative exposes the tension between merit, diversity, and tradition in higher education. By addressing racial considerations while leaving legacy privileges untouched, the policies challenge universities to reconcile fairness with entrenched advantages. Whether true meritocracy can flourish amid enduring wealth-based benefits remains uncertain, highlighting the complexity of reforming an institution long shaped by privilege.
Ready to navigate global policies? Secure your overseas future. Get expert guidance now!
Try Our AI Features
Explore what Daily8 AI can do for you:
Comments
No comments yet...
Related Articles
Indian Express
17 minutes ago
- Indian Express
Trump says Xi assured him China won't invade Taiwan during his presidency
US President Donald Trump has said Chinese President Xi Jinping personally assured him that Beijing would not attempt to invade Taiwan while Trump remains in office. Speaking in an interview with Fox News on Saturday, Trump recalled: 'He told me, 'I will never do it as long as you're president'. President Xi told me that and I said, 'Well, I appreciate that'. But he also said, 'I am very patient and China is very patient'.' The remarks came ahead of Trump's planned talks with Russian President Vladimir Putin over Moscow's invasion of Ukraine. According to Reuters, the Chinese embassy in Washington did not immediately respond to a request for comment following Trump's statements. The two leaders held their first confirmed call of Trump's second term in June, and Trump had earlier said in April that Xi had reached out to him by phone, though he did not specify the timing of that call. China considers Taiwan a breakaway province and has repeatedly vowed to achieve 'reunification' with the island, by force if necessary. Taiwan, a self-governing democracy, rejects Beijing's sovereignty claims. China has increased its military presence around Taiwan, with frequent warship and aircraft maneuvers, and regular violations of Taiwan's air defense zone. US officials have previously warned that China could quickly shift to a military blockade or assault if it chose. Although Washington is Taiwan's main security partner and arms supplier, the United States, like most countries, does not maintain formal diplomatic ties with Taipei. (With inputs from Reuters)
&w=3840&q=100)
Business Standard
17 minutes ago
- Business Standard
EU push to protect digital rules holds up trade statement with US: Report
The European Union is trying to prevent the United States from targeting the bloc's digital rules as both sides work through the final details of a delayed statement to formalise a trade deal reached last month, the Financial Times reported on Sunday. EU officials said disagreements over language relating to "non-tariff barriers", which the US said include the digital rules, are among the reasons for the hold-up of the statement, the newspaper said. Reuters could not immediately verify the report. The European Union, the White House and the State Department did not immediately respond to a request for comment. President Donald Trump, according to FT. The July deal imposed a 15 per cent import tariff on most EU goods - half the initially threatened rate - and helped avert a broader trade war between the two allies, who together account for nearly a third of global trade. The US wanted to keep the door open for possible concessions on the EU's Digital Services Act (DSA), which Washington says stifles free speech and imposes costs on US tech companies, according to FT, which added that the commission has said that relaxing these rules is a red line. The EU's DSA is a landmark law meant to make the online environment safer and fairer by compelling tech giants to do more to tackle illegal content, including hate speech and child sexual abuse material. The commission had anticipated that Trump would sign an executive order by August 15 to cut tariffs on EU car exports to the US from 27.5 per cent to 15 per cent. However, a US official signaled that this would be delayed until the joint statement was finalised, according to FT.
Time of India
17 minutes ago
- Time of India
'Secret US State Dept Papers' On Trump-Putin Summit Found In Alaska Hotel Printer
Sensitive U.S. State Department papers on the Trump-Putin summit were discovered in an Alaskan hotel. The 8-page document revealed meeting times, locations, and staff contacts, alongside details of a planned ceremonial lunch. Experts warn of a major security lapse, though the White House dismissed the documents as a 'multi-page lunch menu.' The State Department has declined comment, leaving questions over the seriousness of the breach. Watch Read More
