Schools, roads in the spotlight amid talk of opening Sydney's Woollahra station
The Labor government is reportedly giving consideration to opening the 'ghost station' almost 50 years after work was halted and rezoning the area for housing towers.
While developers heralded the proposal, which the state government has not formally commented on, as a 'no-brainer', questions have been raised about its feasibility.
Woollahra is serviced by a single public school – Woollahra Public School – which has 701 children enrolled, according to the Department of Education.
Online documents provided by the school state the campus has a capacity of just 698 students, based on the number of permanent teacher spaces and class sizes.
An additional 1729 students are enrolled at nearby public schools, including Vaucluse Public School, which has just 232 students, according to most recent data.
Riverbank Public School, located in Sydney's northwestern growth area, by comparison has more than 2011 students enrolled from kindergarten to year 6.
Opposition education spokeswoman Sarah Mitchell accused the Minns Labor government of 'floating housing thought bubbles without doing the homework'.
'Even now, the community is crying out for another co-ed high school – not based on future growth but the population that already lives here,' she said.
'Any serious housing proposal must come with serious investment in school infrastructure.
'But once again, Chris Minns and his ministers are putting the cart before the horse – promising rooftops without classrooms.'
Mr Minns is yet to make an announcement about the future of Woollahra station but has not denied designs for the so-called ghost station either.
It comes at a crucial time for the Premier after the sale of Rosehill Racecourse to make way for 25,000 homes was shot down by the Australian Turf Club.
The Labor government is focusing on housing initiatives closer to the Sydney CBD and is spearheading measures to overrule recalcitrant Sydney small councils.
Mr Minns said new guidelines announced this month would allow the state government to 'surpass many councils' ability to say no' to new housing planning proposals.
Many of the councils the state government has its eyes set on are in Sydney's affluent southeast and north shore, areas with a reputation for opposing new housing projects.
Woollahra Deputy Mayor Sean Carmichael has been one of many vocal sceptics of the Woollahra train station revival proposal.
Mr Carmichael said the proposal was 'an interesting idea' but urged for a 'planning scalpel' to balance any potential density opportunities with heritage issues.
He said he had suggested opening ticket boxes and escalators to activate the station many years ago.
'I still personally wouldn't mind if that were the case, but expectations for what this stop can actually achieve really need serious tempering,' he said.
'Aside from density and heritage concerns I've already raised, opening Woollahra station won't help young commuters very much.
'Woollahra Public (School) parents will still mostly prefer to drive their children for safety and family time, so the advantage there is also very limited.
'It could also slow students down too, by adding greater complexity to the line, and drive up delays.
'The steep valley below, with awkward roads like Attunga St, really dent the viability of making Woollahra station anything more than a hokey stop on an otherwise incredibly efficient line.'
Mr Carmichael warned that 'flattening' mid-century and other architecturally historic homes in the area would not create affordable homes.
'Quite the opposite, as new luxury units bursting with creature comforts are inevitably more expensive than older ones that, for instance, don't have ducted heating or sound proofing,' he said.
In a statement, a Woollahra Municipal Council spokesperson said the council had not received 'confirmation or any detail from the NSW government regarding revisiting and/or developing a train station in Woollahra'.
'Woollahra Mayor Sarah Swan has indicated that she is willing to discuss this idea with the government within the context of ongoing concerns regarding the impacts the government's low and mid-rise (LMR) housing changes will have on Woollahra.
'The LMR changes ignore well-founded community concerns regarding existing density, increased traffic congestion, a lack of public infrastructure and the need to protect local heritage.
'Council is committed to supporting housing growth, but delivery of additional housing should respect the existing character of our community and take into account the unique challenges of each location.
'The changes override council's carefully-developed strategic plans for additional housing at appropriate locations, including nearby Edgecliff, which would not sacrifice high standards of planning integrity and community benefits.'
Hashtags
Try Our AI Features
Explore what Daily8 AI can do for you:
Comments
No comments yet...
Related Articles
The Australian
an hour ago
- The Australian
StockTake: Redcastle Resources
Stockhead's Tylah Tully looks at the latest news from Redcastle Resources (ASX:RC1), who is fast tracking a pre-feasibility study at the Queen Alexandra gold project in Leonora. Redcastle released a scoping study released earlier this month which detailed the project as high-return, staged, open-pit concept. Watch the video to learn more. This video was developed in collaboration with Redcastle Resources, a Stockhead advertiser at the time of publishing. This video does not constitute financial product advice. You should consider obtaining independent advice before making any financial decisions.
SBS Australia
an hour ago
- SBS Australia
‘It's largely meaningless': Marco Rubio rebukes Australia's support of Palestinian Statehood
'It's largely meaningless': Marco Rubio rebukes Australia's support of Palestinian Statehood Published 13 August 2025, 9:32 am The Australian Government maintains Palestinian statehood will isolate Hamas, after Hamas praised the move to recognition. The Prime Minister is under pressure to explain how he will ensure the Palestinian Authority can deliver on its assurances to demilitarise and uphold democracy.
ABC News
an hour ago
- ABC News
Australia and Vanuatu agree to $500m deal, but details remain scarce
Senior ministers from Australia and Vanuatu have trooped to the top of an active volcano on the island of Tanna for a ceremony to celebrate a major new pact between the two countries. Foreign Minister Penny Wong, Deputy Prime Minister Richard Marles and Pacific Minister Pat Conroy joined their counterparts from Vanuatu on the top of Mount Yasur to "initial" the landmark Nakamal Agreement ahead of formal signature by prime ministers next month. Australia is set to funnel some $500 million into Vanuatu over a decade under the pact, which will supplant a bilateral security agreement that was effectively scrapped by the Pacific nation after it was signed in 2022. While most of the details in the agreement are not yet public, Australia has labelled it "transformational", and Mr Marles said it reflected the two nations had a "shared destiny". "What this agreement really does is, for the first time, acknowledge what has always been the truth, and that is that as two nations, we are family, and that our future is very much bound together," Mr Marles said. The Prime Minister of Vanuatu Jotham Napat declared the deal a "win-win" for both countries. "The agreement that has entered today will transpire into a lot of great benefits between the two countries, whether it be the security agreement, economic transformation, with some specific focus on the mobile labour mobility and financial support," Mr Napat told journalists in Tanna. Under the agreement, Australia is expected to funnel funding into a host of areas, including climate resilience, key infrastructure, security support, labour mobility and budget support. There were some last-minute negotiations to secure an in-principle agreement ahead of the ministers' arrival, with officials from Vanuatu telling the ABC that both sides had to make some late concessions in order to secure the pact. Mr Marles would not be drawn on exactly what financial commitments Australia had made, but said the Nakamal Agreement "acknowledges our shared economic connection". He added it "makes clear that it is core business for Australia to be engaged in the human development of Vanuatu". It is also not clear if the arrangement will make it easier for Ni-Vanuatu to travel to Australia. Ahead of the agreement, Mr Napat declared he would not sign unless Australia agreed to introduce "visa-free" travel for his country's citizens, an arrangement which Australia has never introduced for any Pacific island nations. When asked whether Australia had offered any concessions on this front, Mr Napat said there would be an "agenda item" on visa-free travel in the Nakamal Agreement, but also suggested the subject was still being discussed — saying Australia "would get back to us on that". While Australia has not outlined its position publicly, the ABC has been told that while a "visa free" arrangement was not on the table, the government was willing to discuss liberalising broader travel requirements for citizens of Vanuatu. Griffith Asia Institute Adjunct Associate Professor Tess Newton Cain said the question around travel was a "real issue for the Vanuatu government and for the prime minister personally". "He has said that this is a 'must have' as far as he is concerned and he knows that if it doesn't transpire, it will reflect badly on him," Dr Cain told the ABC. She also said other Pacific nations would be watching the discussions between Vanuatu and Australia closely. "If, and it's a big if, Australia does grant some degree of visa-free access, for example, for Vanuatu officials, it will be very significant because we would expect to see pressure from other Pacific island countries for the same," she said. The agreement comes as Australia pushes back against China's efforts to embed itself as a major commercial and security partner for Vanuatu. Vanuatu has leaned heavily on Chinese institutions to fund major infrastructure projects and Beijing recently gifted it a sprawling new presidential palace, which was estimated to cost $31 million. China's police training teams have also been playing an increasingly visible role in the Pacific island nation. Vanuatu is not expected to hand Australia any "veto" rights over security partnerships with outside countries under the Nakamal Agreement, as both Nauru and Tuvalu have done in their strategic pacts with Canberra. But federal government officials nonetheless hope the substantial commitments on security within the pact will help enshrine Australia's position as Vanuatu's top security partner. Dr Cain suggested the Nakamal Agreement would likely have greater staying power than the 2022 bilateral security agreement signed by former Prime Minister Ishmael Kalsakau, which first stalled in parliament before being effectively dumped by Mr Napat. "The process is the main difference — this has been signed off by both the National Security Council and the Council of Ministers, which did not happen in 2022," she said. "It also is being designated as much broader than simply a security agreement with commitments made across several domains, including climate resilience, economic development and budget support."
