Minister for Housing defends new Government rental measures
The Minister for Housing has defended new measures in relation to the rental market, saying they strike a balance between protecting tenants and supporting investment.
Speaking in Galway this morning, James Browne acknowledged "there were a few different moving parts" in the planned legislation, but he said these were necessary, given the scale of the accommodation issues the country was facing.
"There's always going to be a challenge around the complexity of doing anything like this, there's no one size fits all to bring a solution to this kind of complex situation," he said.
He said a balance had to be struck between protecting tenants and ensuring that investors were willing to embark on building projects.
The Minister said the Government wanted to protect existing tenants as well as increasing the supply of available rental properties. He said "a massive step change" was needed in this regard but that he believed the measures announced this week would help that to happen.
He said investors needed certainty as to what the long term situation would be regarding tenants rights.
Minister Browne said the current situation with Rent Pressure Zones (RPZs), where rent increases are limited to two per cent, meant investors could make a loss, if inflation rose above that figure.
He said this was causing a "blockage" but that more needed to be done to address what he termed "a viability gap" for new builds.
He said the Government would be taking other measures to close this gap in the coming weeks and months.
The Minister added that a minimum security of tenure, of six years from next March, would protect renters entering into a new lease agreement, while allowing landlords to be able to reset rents "every so often". He said he felt the six year period struck the right balance in that regard.
But he said landlords couldn't take advantage of this to reset rents "to a mad number" and would have to charge market rates or lower. The Residential Tenancies Board would adjudicate on any disputes that arose in this regard, and would be provided with additional resources to do this.
Minister Browne made his comments after opening a new office for the Threshold housing charity in Galway, where the twin issues of housing affordability and supply are having a huge impact on the lives of thousands of people.
He said he had secured cabinet approval to tackle the impact caused by short-term holiday lets on the wider rental market.
"We're in a housing crisis, where there is an issue with supply, we have to take priority decisions, and the priority has to be for people to have homes over short term lets" he said.
The Government has already proposed passing legislation to outlaw short term lets, in the absence of planning permission, in towns with a population of 10,000 or more.
The Minister acknowledged that this would have some impact on those dependent on such income but said the wider need for housing had to be given precedence.
He said there had been a lack of enforcement of existing legislation around short term lets, but said "it should come to an end now".
Mr Browne said planned legislation would give "really strong enforcement powers to ban the advertisement of short term lets".
He said he would also be open to giving more powers to local authorities in terms of enforcement.
The Minister has a series of engagements in the area today, including a meeting with campaigners in Conamara, who say the number of planning approvals for new homes in Gaeltacht areas is impacting the chance Irish speakers have to live in their own communities.
He is also due to open the first cost rental housing scheme in Galway city this afternoon.
Hashtags
Try Our AI Features
Explore what Daily8 AI can do for you:
Comments
No comments yet...
Related Articles
Irish Times
an hour ago
- Irish Times
More smaller apartments and studios could be built under plans being considered by Government
Moves which could mean greater numbers of smaller apartments, including studio apartments, built are being considered by Government and are likely to be finalised in the coming weeks. The proposals, being discussed at the highest level of the Coalition, are among efforts to make building apartments more attractive for investors and developers in a bid to increase the supply in urban areas, according to several people familiar with the discussions. Rules governing size, insulation, requirements for dual aspect in many apartments, corridor lengths, high-spec finishes and the need to have balconies are all cited as reasons for runaway cost inflation in the price of apartments, and all are likely to be examined. [ Dublin studio flats 27% smaller than current limit get go-ahead Opens in new window ] There is agreement among senior Government figures that design standards for apartments have risen so high that they have driven costs of construction to a level that has made them unaffordable. READ MORE In addition, the mix of apartments required in developments is being discussed, with Government figures understood to favour allowing more and smaller apartments, including more studio apartments, and fewer large apartments. Government sources were adamant that things like energy ratings, disability access and fire safety would not be affected under any package of changes that could be agreed, but outlined a range of other apartment design stipulations which the industry has protested add cost to development. [ 'I grew up in an apartment in another country. I bought an apartment in Dublin and had to get out after a year' Opens in new window ] Sources stress that they are not talking about building standards – these are produced by technical experts in construction and cover things like fire safety. Instead, they are discussing possible changes in apartment standards, which are set by planners. 'We need to change the viability equation for them,' said a Coalition source. Will rent reform make building apartments viable? Listen | 40:12 Some Government officials say that while balconies in a one-bedroom apartment are a useful amenity, they can also drive up the cost of construction and contribute to affordability issues for first-time buyers, leaving them unable to access the housing market. Tánaiste Simon Harris previously signalled an openness to the idea of revisiting apartment design standards, and it is understood that he again indicated they would be considered during a meeting of the Fine Gael parliamentary party last week, alongside plans to overhaul the remit of the Land Development Agency. [ Has Fingal County Council found a solution to our housing crisis? Opens in new window ] However, any move to revisit standards is likely to face some criticism. Orla Hegarty, assistant professor at the UCD School of Architecture, said that previous efforts to address affordability through changing design standards had proven unsuccessful. She said there was a risk of 'poorer quality housing for the very long term, for a very short-term balancing of the books'. It comes off the back of moves last week to overhaul the rental sector, including expanding rent pressure zones nationally, allowing more frequent resetting of rents, and improving some tenant protections.
Irish Times
an hour ago
- Irish Times
Quarter of Irish ‘EU presidency' meetings to be held outside Dublin
Most of the big political events hosted in the State during Ireland's time holding the presidency of the council of the European Union next year will take place in Dublin. Ireland is due to take over the important deal-making role within the EU for the second half of next year, which will see Government ministers become responsible for pushing EU policy forward. Ministers and senior diplomats will chair a large number of meetings, in Brussels and Ireland, where they will be expected to steer the other 26 national governments towards compromise agreements on various decisions and pieces of legislation. Tánaiste and Minister for Foreign Affairs Simon Harris is expected to brief Cabinet next week about the ongoing preparations for the influential EU role. READ MORE It is understood that 22 meetings of ministers from all EU states will be hosted in Ireland, along with a big summit of European leaders, which will be a huge logistical undertaking. [ Irish officials step up plans for rotating EU presidency, which will cost more than €150m Opens in new window ] About a quarter of the Cabinet-level meetings will be held outside Dublin, Mr Harris is expected to tell Cabinet colleagues next week. The estimated cost of hosting the EU presidency has yet to be finalised, but it is likely to be about €170 million, according to two sources. The Government is keen to make sure there is some regional spread of events across the country. Work to refurbish State-owned venues that will be used to host high-level meetings, such as Dublin Castle, is already under way. Several other venues have been block-booked for the six-month period. A meeting of all EU finance ministers at Dublin Castle was the largest event during Ireland's last stint running the council presidency in 2013. This time around the biggest event will be a summit of nearly 50 European heads of state and government, a relatively new forum known as the European Political Community. It will be held back to back with a separate meeting of the 27 EU leaders. The venue for the summit has not been confirmed. Hosting the summit of European leaders, as well as more regular meetings of EU ministers, will pose an unprecedented security and planning challenge for the State, according to an internal Government briefing. The briefing, seen by The Irish Times, said An Garda Síochána and the Department of Justice were still working out the likely costs of securing the high-profile political events during the EU presidency. A changed security landscape and the more complex nature of potential threats would be a feature of the planning, the briefing said. Irish Ministers have begun to travel to Brussels more regularly for meetings, to build up closer working relationships with their counterparts from other EU states. A rota is to be drawn up so that at least one Irish Minister will also attend the monthly voting sessions of the European Parliament from September onwards, to develop contacts with senior figures in the parliament. Running a successful EU council presidency will be 'essential for Ireland's position, influence and reputation' in the union, a separate Department of An Taoiseach briefing stated. The briefing, dated March 27th and released under the Freedom of Information Act, said Ireland would be expected to play an 'honest broker' role during EU policy debates. Topics that would likely be high on the agenda included defence, migration, climate, economic competitiveness, CAP reform and negotiations to decide the size of the next EU budget, the briefing said. Work is ongoing to map out what policy areas the Government will prioritise during the six-month window where it holds the EU council presidency next year.
Irish Times
an hour ago
- Irish Times
Rent reforms will pull up the drawbridge on future renters
The Government came to power with an urgent mandate to resolve the housing crisis . It's had an inauspicious start. There were fewer than 6,000 new home completions in the first three months of the year, according to Department of Housing figures published last month. While that's up 2 per cent on the year, it leaves a mountain to climb for the Government to hit its target of growing output by more than a third to 41,000 this year – and ratcheting up incrementally to 60,000 in 2030. Recent developments suggest this administration is as short-sighted and flighty as every other in recent times when it comes to housing. Take the plan to set up a housing activation office – one of the better ideas to come from the Department of Housing of late – aimed at getting a crack team of officials to move quickly on addressing barriers to the delivery of critical infrastructure to boost housing development. READ MORE [ John McManus: Government had to choose tenants over investors Opens in new window ] Minister for Housing James Browne's planned appointment of National Asset Management Agency (Nama) chief executive Brendan McDonagh as housing tsar descended into political farce when the Government baulked at Opposition criticism that he would retain his Nama salary of some €430,000. McDonagh, a very credible figure whose bond to public service isn't questioned even by his sharpest critics, had little option but to pull his name on May 1st when Tánaiste Simon Harris let it be known that he was peeved about not being kept in the loop. Appearing on The Late Late Show the following evening, Harris told middle Ireland that he did not think such a salary was a fair one. An effective housing tsar would be worth multiples of the controversial figure. Either way, McDonagh remains an employee of the State on that package. He's due to return to the National Treasury Management Agency (NTMA) once Nama – to which he is seconded – is wound down at the end of this year. Further evidence of political expedience remaining the order of the day is to be found, too, in the fresh stab this week at rent reforms. Currently, rent increases in rent pressure zones (RPZ), which covers about half the land area of the State, cannot be greater than the rate of inflation or 2 per cent – whichever is lower. A planned new nationwide control system – set to fully kick in from March 2026 – would also see rent increases for tenancies capped in most cases by inflation or a maximum cap of 2 per cent. However, landlords would be able to reset rents at the going market rate when a tenant leaves. Smaller landlords with three or fewer units will have to offer rolling six-year tenancies, while large ones will not be able to evict a tenant who has complied with their obligations except in very limited circumstances. [ Rent changes: How will tenants be impacted by the plans for Ireland's rental market? Opens in new window ] Rent control for new apartments constructed following enactment of the legislation would be linked to inflation. This, the Government said, should 'provide certainty, clarity, and encourage investment'. If only. There's a body of academic studies that point to rent controls in general affecting construction. Konstantin Kholodilin, a senior researcher with the German Institute for Economic Research in Berlin, last year reviewed 122 empirical published studies on rent controls internationally, spanning 1967-2023. Two-thirds of those studies that assessed the impact of rent caps on new residential development found they depressed construction, he said. Irish private-rental-sector construction was booming during the phase of RPZ rent controls between 2016 and mid-2021. But that was at a time when increases were limited to 4 per cent and interest rates globally were at ultra-low levels. Since then we have seen the maximum rent cap cut by half, construction costs spiral, and global interest rates spike (though they have since come off their highs). Construction in the private rental sector has all but evaporated. Although Approved Housing Bodies and the Land Development Agency have stepped in to address part of the gap in apartment building, they are focused on social and affordable accommodation. Construction and finance industry figures say uncertainty caused by ever-shifting housing policy is more off-putting for investors than individual tweaks in themselves. With the latest rules delayed until next March, can investors willing to consider new schemes even commit before then? Add in at least another three years before any new supply comes on stream, and you're talking about the end of the decade at the earliest for those brave enough to deliver. There is nothing in the plan that would curtail an ongoing trend of small landlords exiting the market, further tightening supply. Sherry FitzGerald, the largest estate agent in the country, estimates that landlords fleeing the rental market accounted for 30 per cent of all home sales in the first quarter of the year. Allowing owners new builds to link rents to inflation – a volatile index – compounds uncertainty for investors. Consumer price inflation is running at 1.7 per cent. The incoming measures may serve existing tenants well, but effectively pull up the drawbridge on future renters. People are likely to stay put for longer. This, along with a dearth of new builds, will further depress available stock and – all else being equal – push up what are already some the highest open market rental costs in Europe.
