The Android Auto And Apple CarPlay Debate
I was having a conversation with Yuri Tereshyn, from The Straight Pipes YouTube channel, about projection-based infotainment systems versus native interfaces. He argued that Apple CarPlay is what splits the difference between a good user experience and an awful one, while I was trying to explain to him why, in the case of electric vehicles (EVs), you're better off with a native infotainment system.
This was all happening during the first drive launch event of the 2025 Chevrolet Blazer EV SS, a vehicle which, just like all of GM's latest EVs, makes do with a fully native setup. It was a relevant debate, because one week prior, I was also speaking with Lucid's lead software integration engineer about the decisions automakers currently have to make regarding projection apps. Turns out the very conversation Yuri and I were having is also ongoing behind closed doors. So, what's better? A projection-based system that allows you to use Android Auto and Apple CarPlay? Or a native infotainment system that allows you to download your apps directly to your car?
Related
Chevy's first-ever all-electric SS model packs plenty of straight-line firepower, but it's also a fantastic handler.
Projection-Based Systems Are Currently The Most Popular
Before we dig deeper in search of answers, perhaps it's best if we begin by defining what projection-based systems are and why they are different to a native, subscriber-based system. As I write this, projection-based systems are the most widespread type of infotainment interface.
Its name comes from the fact that it allows you to project the contents of your phone directly into the car's infotainment system through apps like Android Auto and Apple CarPlay. The projection can either be done by physically connecting your phone to the car using a USB cable, or, as is becoming more and more the case, wirelessly through Bluetooth and Wi-Fi technology.
Honda
The obvious benefit of such technology is that it allows you to have access to your most useful phone apps on the car's main screen, like your contacts, text messages, calendars, music apps like Spotify or Apple Music, as well as your favorite navigation app like Google Maps, or Waze. Both Apple and Google have perfected these apps over time to streamline their operation, as well as closely working with automakers to have them better integrate the cars.
But these apps remain a projection of your phone, meaning they're not part of your car's infotainment system. If, for instance, the automaker releases an update for your car's music player, neither Android Auto nor Apple CarPlay will notice. There's also a lot of data collection going on, allowing both Apple and Google to have access to your driving-related habits and behaviors. Finally, in the case of EVs, since projection apps are not part of the car's default system, they cannot predict your available range, correlate it with their navigation apps, nor can they make suggestions for public charging on the go. Yes, Google Maps can show you where public chargers are located on the map, but it pretty much ends there.
Native infotainment systems, rather, do without Android Auto and Apple CarPlay. That's because the system itself allows you to create a user profile and download your favorite apps directly to your car. While still relatively new in the industry, this sort of system has been used by Tesla since the very first Model S came out in the early 2010s, making it the pioneer of the genre. Today, other automakers like General Motors, Volvo, and Rivian have attempted to go down that path as well, using their own proprietary, Google-based interface.
The benefits of this technology are to allow your car to handle all of your connectivity features, and never have to look at your phone again while driving. Since your profile is already set up with your favorite navigation and audio apps downloaded, and since most new cars already come with mobile apps in which you can sync a driver profile and its preferences, each time you enter your car, everything is right there in your reach.
William Clavey | TopSpeed
Native infotainment systems effectively transform your car into a giant device, which is the natural evolution of things in a world where we're all connected to a device in one way or another. The system also allows you to download additional features you simply can't get with projection apps, like YouTube, games, or streaming services like Netflix.
Related
GM's recently updated ICE models all get essentially the same Google-based infotainment system as its EVs. Yet, Apple CarPlay remains. Why?
Finally, for EVs, since native infotainment systems are actually part of your car, they can predict how much range you've got left based on your navigation settings and how much you'll have left when you arrive at your destination, suggest public fast charging stops, recommend how long to stay at that charger, and automatically precondition the car's battery before initiating the charge cycle. Projection apps cannot do this, at least not yet.
But What About The Data?
William Clavey | TopSpeed
And what about data collection? If Apple and Google aren't taking it anymore, then does it mean it's going straight to the carmaker? Yes, which brought Yuri and me to the root of our argument. The core reason more and more automakers are contemplating taking control of the entire connectivity aspect of their cars is to avoid third-party companies like Apple and Google from leaving with the data. Automakers would much rather keep all of that data for themselves.
At the moment of writing this story, automakers are restricted by strict regulations about selling or sharing your data. The information collected, automakers say, serves solely to improve their vehicles through over-the-air (OTA) updates. But what about cybersecurity risks?
'Would you rather trust Apple, or any other automaker to safeguard your data? I choose Apple. Plus, CarPlay is like a buffer between my phone and my car. I don't need to log into my car on top of that. Maybe it's a false sense of security, but if I don't have to, I'd rather not give my information to an automaker at all!'
– Yuri Tereshyn, The Straight Pipes
William Clavey | TopSpeed
Yuri's got a good point. Some users may not want to go with a native infotainment system simply because of the hassle of having to log into that system. Sure, dealerships take care of much of that pain point when you purchase a new car through pre-dealer inspections, and once you're all set up, you technically never need to fiddle with it again. In GM's case, an existing Google account is all it takes.
But there's another element surrounding native systems that could prove to be a turn-off to users: subscriptions. GM currently sells its new vehicles with free OnStar and connectivity during the first few years of ownership, but once all of that expires, you'll need to pay in order to keep these features going.
Related
Even if it's not a 'real' Honda, the 2025 Prologue manages to hold its own.
Yuri and I agreed that the best of both worlds would be a vehicle that offers both the possibility of logging directly into the car's system, but that also preserves the possibility to project apps like Android Auto and Apple CarPlay. The Honda Prologue is one such vehicle. Built as the result of a joint venture between General Motors and Honda, it's essentially a rebadged Chevrolet Equinox EV equipped with a native infotainment system. Yet, Honda chose to leave Android Auto and Apple CarPlay connectivity for those who don't yet feel comfortable logging into the system.
William Clavey | TopSpeed
Of course, consumer reaction and demand will dictate which system will prevail. But GM is currently dealing with a lot of backlash regarding its decision, and has increased its dealer and in-car education surrounding its system. A recent update has added a prompt in GM EVs to remind the driver to set up their profile in the system, followed by a rather easy step-by-step procedure including a QR code. I have personally logged into all the GM EVs that I have tested and have no issue with the system. And I personally am not intimidated by the idea of an automaker collecting my data. But for people like Yuri who don't yet trust the auto industry's data-collecting practices and the cybersecurity that surrounds it, projection apps remain the clear way to go.
Hashtags
Try Our AI Features
Explore what Daily8 AI can do for you:
Comments
No comments yet...
Related Articles
Yahoo
37 minutes ago
- Yahoo
7 of the most exciting new iOS 26 features coming to your iPhone
If you purchase an independently reviewed product or service through a link on our website, BGR may receive an affiliate commission. Apple will open WWDC 2025 on Monday with its annual introductory keynote, where it will demo the tentpole features of its various operating systems. This will be a media event to remember for several reasons. First, Apple has to address the Apple Intelligence elephant in the room. iOS 18 failed to deliver Apple's AI promises, with the biggest Apple Intelligence feature still vaporware (for now). Today's Top Deals Best deals: Tech, laptops, TVs, and more sales Best Ring Video Doorbell deals Memorial Day security camera deals: Reolink's unbeatable sale has prices from $29.98 Second, Apple will introduce a new design language for all its operating systems, which will help unify the software experiences across its products. It's already very easy to move from an iPhone to an iPad or Mac, but the new visuals should make that experience seamless. Finally, this is the year when Apple also changes the naming structure for all its operating systems. There's no iOS 19. Instead, we're getting iOS 26, a moniker that probably means '2026.' All other operating systems will get the same '26' designator. With all that in mind, iOS 26 will be the most interesting thing coming out of WWDC 2025 for me. I'm a longtime iPhone user, and I'm already looking forward to the iOS 26 beta releases. Many iOS 26 design details and features have leaked in the past few months, so I'll give you a list of my priorities for the upcoming operating system. I won't make the same mistake as last year. I won't get excited about big Apple Intelligence features, like a SiriGPT experience that could rival ChatGPT. Instead, I'll take the smaller AI wins that Apple can deliver and wait to be surprised down the road. Also, I'll say that I'm deeply entrenched in Apple's ecosystem of products. Some of the iOS 26 features below will need other products to work, like the Apple Watch and AirPods. I've been running iOS betas almost exclusively since Apple started making them available. I probably skipped just one release, and it's been a great ride. Even early developer betas have been better than expected. I expect bugs from beta software. But unfortunately, bugs also show up in commercial iOS releases that most people use. With iOS 26, Apple is rumored to focus on improving stability. I hope that's true and iOS will really 'just work.' If that happens, then beta releases should also be smoother. I can't say I have issues with the current iOS design. Apple has added lots of customization options in recent years, from the Lock Screen to the Home Screen. But I wouldn't mind more cohesion between the various operating systems, especially since I'm dreaming of buying Apple foldables down the road. Those devices will need to offer UI experiences that transition between iPhone and iPad or iPad and Mac. iOS 26 will start that design revolution. All the operating systems Apple is about to unveil will feature visionOS-inspired design. We expect lots of translucency, more nimble menus that don't block content from view, and maybe new app icon designs. iOS 26 might feel like a fresh start, which every OS needs every few years. All apps will benefit from the new iOS 26 design, especially Apple's iPhone apps. The Camera app is one I use the most, and I'm looking forward to seeing a simpler interface that lets me focus on what I'm shooting. We'll supposedly get separate menus for photos and videos instead of several options crowding the screen. The menus will have the same glass-like look as the rest of iOS. Again, it should resemble the visionOS UI from the spatial computer. I run a lot, so I use the Apple Watch and the Health and Fitness apps to track all my health data. I haven't been happy with the bugs that have impacted my Apple Watch Series 10 this year, and I hope iOS 26 will fix many of them. But I'm excited about Apple bringing AI features to the Health and Fitness apps. Rumors say Apple will include a health coach in iOS 26. The AI coach should offer advice based on the health data collected by the iPhone and Apple Watch. Also interesting is the idea of a new food-tracking feature in iOS 26. The Health app has one, but I'd love a more intuitive version. AI can help in other areas, not just with lifestyle and exercise. Rumors say Apple will use artificial intelligence to improve battery life. Specifically, Apple's AI might analyze how I use my iPhone and find ways to improve efficiency and save battery. This iOS 26 feature probably won't be available on a phone like my iPhone 14 Pro, which I'm using after downgrading from the iPhone 16 Pro Max. But it might be great for the ultra-thin iPhone 17 Air coming this fall, which is the device I'll upgrade to long before I pick a foldable Apple phone. Not all the new features in iOS 26 have to be flashy. Sometimes, small tweaks can make a big difference. One rumored feature is better support for public Wi-Fi that requires signing into a 'captive' network, like those in hotels or airports. I usually avoid public Wi-Fi and use cellular data and VPNs for privacy and security. But sometimes public Wi-Fi is necessary. A captive-portal Wi-Fi where you sign in is still better than an open one. But you usually have to sign in on each device. iOS 26 will fix that by ensuring that all Apple devices using the same Apple ID connect once one of them does. Other iOS 26 features might be nice-to-have tricks that won't get much use. The rumored live translation support for AirPods is one of them. This is likely an Apple Intelligence feature, and several Apple rivals offer similar tools. Having AirPods translate what's being said around you in another language could be a great tool when traveling to places where communication is more difficult. iOS and Android are very mature platforms. It's tough for Apple and Google to surprise fans with major new features, especially with AI dominating tech conversations lately. I could use iOS 18 for another year and not expect much beyond Apple Intelligence finally working as intended. But iOS 26 could still be exciting thanks to the new design and a better overall experience. Add in a few smart tweaks and the iPhone can be an even better tool. That's all I really want from the computer I use the most. Don't Miss: Today's deals: Nintendo Switch games, $5 smart plugs, $150 Vizio soundbar, $100 Beats Pill speaker, more More Top Deals Amazon gift card deals, offers & coupons 2025: Get $2,000+ free See the
CNET
an hour ago
- CNET
Why Using Rice to Save Your Wet Phone Is a Horrible Idea
Summer is full of beach vacations and lounging near the pool. But if you drop your phone in some water, it could result in an expensive trip to a phone store. While many smartphones are water-resistant, that doesn't mean they're waterproof so it's still important to dry out your phone. Here are a few ways to get your phone dry after dropping it in water or getting it dirty, and hopefully these tips can help save you from having to buy a new phone. None of these methods are guaranteed to work, however, and while there's a lot of anecdotal evidence, there are very few scientific studies on the subject. The most recent study we could find was from 2014 by Gazelle, a company that buys and sells used and broken phones. According to that study, the make and model of phone were found to influence whether a phone could return to working order, with Android phones typically faring better than iPhones. Phone manufacturers agree that removing your phone from water as quickly as possible helps to minimize how much water comes into contact with your device. That means you have a better chance of saving your phone but don't put your phone in rice after removing it from water because that could damage it. Here's what you should do if you drop your phone in water. If you follow these instructions and your phone won't turn on, or it turns on and has some issues, you should take it to an associated phone shop to see if they can help. What Apple and Samsung recommend The two biggest phone manufacturers have some tips in case you drop your phone in water. Apple says that many iPhones are splash, water and dust resistant when tested in controlled lab environments, but these resistances aren't permanent. If your iPhone gets wet, it might display a warning that there's water in your phone's charging port. If you see this warning, or your iPhone comes into contact with water, lotions, soap or other potentially hazardous material, here's what Apple says to do: 1. After removing your iPhone from the material, turn it off and dry it with a soft, lint-free cloth. 2. Tap your phone gently with the charging port facing down to get excess water out of the port. 3. Place your iPhone in a dry area with good circulation and wait at least five hours. Pointing a fan at your iPhone's charging port might help the process. After five hours, try turning your iPhone back on and plugging it back in. If you're still having issues, you can try the other methods mentioned in this article, or you can take your phone to an Apple store for further assistance. Apple also says don't put your iPhone in rice. "Doing so could allow small particles of rice to damage your iPhone," the company writes online. Drop your smartphone in water? Don't has similar instructions for drying your phone: 1. Remove your phone from the water, turn it off and dry it off with a dry towel or a clean cloth. 2. Place your phone in a well-ventilated area or in the shade with cool air from a fan. Samsung doesn't specify a length of time to wait, though. Samsung says even after you've followed these steps that there might still be water inside your phone so you should bring it to a Samsung Electronics Service Center. Both manufacturers also say if you drop your phone in a liquid other than clean water -- like soda or pool water -- you should quickly rinse your phone using tap water before drying with a towel and then air drying. Apple and Samsung say to never use a heating source, like a blow dryer or oven, to dry off your phone. The heat could damage it. Silica gel beads could help You could also try silica gel. According to Gazelle, silica gel beads are a good option to absorb moisture out of phones. Silica gel beads can be found in those white packs labeled "Do not eat" that many products come packed with. You can save these packs from packages you've received, or buy packs through online stores like Amazon or companies like Dry & Dry. Once you have your silica, here's what to do after dropping your phone in water: 1. Get your phone out of the water and turn it off. 2. Dry the outside of your phone with a lint-free towel. 3. Place your phone in a large container. 4. Fill the container with your silica gel beads and seal the container. 5. Gazelle recommends waiting 72 hours to let your phone dry. 6. Remove your phone from the container and try turning it back on. Other household items might help If you don't have silica gel beads on hand, you could try other household items. Gazelle found couscous and instant rice both work well as drying agents. Follow the steps in the above section, but replace the silica beads with either of these, wait for the same amount of time and then try restarting your device. Gazelle also tested conventional cat litter, oats, chia seeds and uncooked white rice but doesn't recommend these products because they leave behind debris that could damage your phone. For more tips, check out how low-frequency sounds can get rid of water from your phone's speakers, how to get two days out of a single iPhone charge and how to easily manage your Android permissions.
Android Authority
an hour ago
- Android Authority
5 AI tools I rely on more than ChatGPT
Kaitlyn Cimino / Android Authority ChatGPT is usually the first tool that comes to everyone's mind when you start talking about AI. It sure is versatile and capable of doing a lot — often better than others in many ways. Its memory feature helps it learn about you and fine-tune responses, making it more personalized than many other (even paid) alternatives. It's also the one to open the floodgates for a wave of AI tools designed for very specific tasks — the kind that even ChatGPT can't handle well. And that's exactly where the broader world of AI tools comes in. I've tried quite a few of these AI tools, and here are the ones that have truly embedded themselves into my daily workflow. I can't imagine getting through the day without them anymore. What's your go-to AI tool (besides ChatGPT)? 0 votes Gemini NaN % Perplexity NaN % Claude NaN % Something else (comment below!) NaN % Gemini Ryan Haines / Android Authority Gemini is similar to ChatGPT in many ways — and no, I don't use it to unload my life problems. But I do end up using it quite a lot, and the simple reason is its presence. Since I rely on Google products both personally and professionally, Gemini is always just there — sometimes in the sidebar, sometimes just a wake word away. On my Workspace for Business account, I often use it to check grammar, tighten language, or tweak the tone of emails. But I've also had it read contracts in Docs and point out anything working against me or take notes during Meet calls and summarize the meeting within minutes of it ending. It even handles different accents in a single meeting quite well. Perplexity Calvin Wankhede / Android Authority If I've developed muscle memory for using ChatGPT, Perplexity has quietly replaced Google Search for most of my web lookups — especially on desktop. I use it heavily for research. Instead of browsing ten websites, scrubbing YouTube videos, or combing through forums for one specific detail — like what the most popular desktop OS in Europe was in the early 2010s — I just ask Perplexity. And much like appending 'Reddit' to a search to get real user opinions instead of content written for SEO, Perplexity does that for you. It gives you a concise gist, which is handy when I'm looking for general sentiment, say, around viral news. While it saves me the search legwork, I still verify what it gives me just to make sure I'm delivering accurate information with the necessary human oversight. NotebookLM Andy Walker / Android Authority For the longest time, I avoided NotebookLM. It felt like a niche product good for only a few tasks — but that's exactly where its strength lies. And honestly, what a tool Google has made! You can create multiple notebooks and upload source documents, even on the free plan. It analyzes long documents and can surface different perspectives, themes, and patterns — like a real brainstorming partner. That's not what I personally use it for, though. NotebookLM is a true example of AI's potential — I just hope it doesn't land in the Google graveyard anytime soon. What I love is its ability to switch tone easily between 'Guide' and 'Analyst' modes, especially when I need a more conversational or direct approach. But my favorite feature is its podcast-style audio summaries. Those have helped me digest jargon-heavy, never-ending documents while driving or cooking — and suddenly, it doesn't feel like work! NotebookLM is a true example of AI's potential — I just hope it doesn't land in the Google graveyard anytime soon. Notion AI Dhruv Bhutani / Android Authority Some AI tools become part of your routine without you even realizing it — and Notion AI is one of those for me. I initially dismissed it as something Notion was forcing on its users, but I've ended up using it more than I expected. I use Notion for almost all my long-form personal writing — blog posts, short stories, you name it. One thing that's always frustrated me is the lack of autocorrect. When I'm in vomit-draft mode, I don't care about typos or grammar and cleaning them up later was always a pain. With Notion AI, I can fix all that with just a couple of clicks. I can also throw in unformatted lists (groceries, travel packing, etc.) and just ask AI to clean them up. I even use it to brainstorm multiple angles for blog ideas, helping me avoid getting stuck on one track. It's like the second set of eyes I have always wanted for my blogs. The free plan gives me limited prompts, but since I only use Notion once or twice a day, I get by just fine. Ideogram An image generation tool has been eerily missing from this list — that's because I saved the best for the last! Ideogram has been my preferred tool for that because of one big reason. It is one of the only free tools that lets you customize and control a lot of aspects of your generated images, including their size and ratio. Most AI tools generate square images that are terrible for online use as feature images or on social media. Ideogram gets you a few free credits per week and creates some fantastic AI images using its latest-generation model with whatever customization you want. And it also has something called magic prompt that uses AI to create an elaborate prompt on your behalf. We all tend to underexplain AI the exact scene we want, but Ideogram covers you for that. Specialized AI tools are far more useful companions than a chatbot that behaves like an over-eager intern who always needs direction. AI beyond ChatGPT We've had AI around us for years — from Gboard's smart suggestions to Google Assistant — but it wasn't until ChatGPT became a buzzword that we really started noticing generative AI in our everyday lives. It's honestly hard to believe it's just been a couple of years since its arrival. A lot of AI tools have emerged in such a short span, and many of them have surely become an indispensable part of my life. But most importantly, I get to use them to be more productive without fearing about AI dimming my creative spark. They are far more useful companions than a chatbot that behaves like an over-eager intern who always needs direction.
