Did the Coalition's pledged cuts to migration backfire?
A pledge to cut migration levels could be one of the key issues to haunt the Coalition as it reels from its . Part of the Coalition's pitch to voters was a proposed 100,000-place cut to net overseas migration (the difference between the number of people entering and leaving Australia). While it said the bulk of the cuts would focus on skilled migration , the lack of detail around which visa streams would be targeted was repeatedly scrutinised in the final weeks of the campaign. Redbridge Group director Simon Welsh told SBS News the Coalition's immigration stance "absolutely" backfired.
"Where the electorate was wanting hope and a positive plan, they were offering negativity," Welsh said. "Whether that was on immigration, , [or] whether that was on public servants."
Outgoing Liberal leader Peter Dutton linked record levels of migration — which peaked at 536,000 in 2022-23, but which Treasury estimates will return to 260,000 next year — with exacerbating demand on housing supply and pushing up prices. Welsh argued that in diverse communities, this rhetoric turned voters away from the Coalition. He said there are two distinct voting blocs — established migrant communities and those in the "growth phase", which are experiencing higher levels of migration to Australia. Among the latter, which includes the Chinese and Indian diaspora, Welsh said the Coalition's immigration policies "really were a negative".
"For families that are thinking about wanting to bring family over, because those communities are in this growth phase, that Liberal stuff was definitely a drag to them," he said. This was evident in the results across Sydney and Melbourne. Labor retained Hawke, Gorton and Chisholm in Victoria, and Parramatta and Reid in NSW, despite early polling showing these highly diverse seats were contestable.
The Asylum Seeker Resource Centre said voters had rejected the politics of fear and division. "Voters have acted with compassion and it's time for our elected representatives and political leaders to reflect this in the incoming parliament," Deputy CEO Jane Favero said in a statement.
In a March working paper, emeritus professor Peter McDonald and professor Alan Gamlen of the ANU Migration Hub argued that migration numbers were being "weaponised" to "elicit panic and sway voters". They outlined several reasons for the record migration levels during 2022-23. These included an influx of students, backpackers and temporary workers unable to travel during the pandemic, as well as several visa extensions under the Morrison and Albanese governments. However, with student levels on the decline and many of these extensions set to expire, they predict migration levels will sharply drop in three to four years. "From about 2027, as the number of departures expands considerably, net overseas migration is likely to plummet," they said. Visit the to access articles, podcasts and videos from SBS News, NITV and our teams covering more than 60 languages.
Try Our AI Features
Explore what Daily8 AI can do for you:
Comments
No comments yet...
Related Articles
Sydney Morning Herald
2 hours ago
- Sydney Morning Herald
Trump says trade deal with China ‘in very good shape' after call with Xi
Washington: US President Donald Trump said a trade deal with China was in good shape and accepted an invitation to visit Beijing after a 'very good phone call' with President Xi Jinping – their first since Trump returned to power in January. Trump said the call straightened out 'complexities' that remained from the preliminary agreement to lower tariffs struck during talks in Switzerland last month, including trade in rare earth minerals. 'I think we're in very good shape with China and the trade deal,' he said in the Oval Office shortly after the phone call. 'We've got a deal, we're just going to make sure that everybody understands what the deal is.' US Treasury Secretary Scott Bessent, Commerce Secretary Howard Lutnick and Trade Representative Jamieson Greer will lead a delegation to meet top Chinese officials and finalise details of the agreement, Trump said. He said the call lasted about an hour and a half and focused almost exclusively on trade, without canvassing the war in Ukraine or concerns Iran's nuclear technology. Trump said Xi had 'graciously' invited him and First Lady Melania Trump to visit China, and he reciprocated with an invitation for Xi to visit Washington. 'As Presidents of two Great Nations, this is something that we both look forward to doing,' Trump wrote on his social media platform TruthSocial. No dates were set for the visits. The Chinese foreign ministry said Trump initiated the call between the leaders of the world's two biggest economies.
The Age
2 hours ago
- The Age
Trump says trade deal with China ‘in very good shape' after call with Xi
Washington: US President Donald Trump said a trade deal with China was in good shape and accepted an invitation to visit Beijing after a 'very good phone call' with President Xi Jinping – their first since Trump returned to power in January. Trump said the call straightened out 'complexities' that remained from the preliminary agreement to lower tariffs struck during talks in Switzerland last month, including trade in rare earth minerals. 'I think we're in very good shape with China and the trade deal,' he said in the Oval Office shortly after the phone call. 'We've got a deal, we're just going to make sure that everybody understands what the deal is.' US Treasury Secretary Scott Bessent, Commerce Secretary Howard Lutnick and Trade Representative Jamieson Greer will lead a delegation to meet top Chinese officials and finalise details of the agreement, Trump said. He said the call lasted about an hour and a half and focused almost exclusively on trade, without canvassing the war in Ukraine or concerns Iran's nuclear technology. Trump said Xi had 'graciously' invited him and First Lady Melania Trump to visit China, and he reciprocated with an invitation for Xi to visit Washington. 'As Presidents of two Great Nations, this is something that we both look forward to doing,' Trump wrote on his social media platform TruthSocial. No dates were set for the visits. The Chinese foreign ministry said Trump initiated the call between the leaders of the world's two biggest economies.
The Advertiser
3 hours ago
- The Advertiser
Wall Street dips as investors focus on US jobs data
US stocks have dipped, dragged down by Tesla's shares, while investors looked ahead to the monthly jobs report to gauge the health of the labour market amid concerns of an economic slowdown. Chinese President Xi Jinping held talks with US President Donald Trump by phone, China's state-run news agency Xinhua reported, as bilateral relations have been strained by trade disputes. The call comes amid accusations between the US and China in recent weeks over critical minerals in a dispute that threatens to tear up a fragile truce in the trade war between the governments of the two biggest economies. Weaker-than-expected US private payrolls and services sector data on Wednesday raised concerns about the effects of Trump's erratic trade policies, with investors focusing squarely on Friday's non-farm payrolls report. Initial jobless claims data showed people in the US filing new applications for unemployment benefits last week rose for a second straight week. "I don't think it's some sort of big warning sign right now but it speaks to the fact that the labour market has been softening more and just getting gradually weaker," said Kevin Gordon, senior investment strategist at Charles Schwab. The jobs report comes ahead of the Federal Reserve's policy decision later this month, where policy makers are widely expected to hold interest rates. Despite continued calls from Trump to slash interest rates, Fed chair Jerome Powell has opted to stand pat so far, awaiting further data to help dictate the policy decision as tariff volatility prevails. US equities rallied sharply in May, with investors boosting the S&P 500 index and the tech-heavy Nasdaq to their biggest monthly percentage gain since November 2023, thanks to a softening of Trump's harsh trade stance and upbeat earnings reports. The S&P 500 remains nearly 3.0 per cent below record highs touched in February. US central bank officials including Fed Board governor Adriana Kugler, Fed Kansas City president Jeffrey Schmid and Fed Philadelphia president Patrick Harker are scheduled to speak later in the day. In early trading on Thursday, the Dow Jones Industrial Average fell 126.69 points, or 0.30 per cent, to 42,301.05, the S&P 500 lost 12.71 points, or 0.21 per cent, to 5,958.10 and the Nasdaq Composite lost 31.13 points, or 0.16 per cent, to 19,429.36. Eight of the 11 major S&P 500 sub-sectors fell, with consumer staples declining the most with an about 1.0 per cent fall. Brown-Forman fell 14.9 per cent, the most on the S&P 500, after the Jack Daniel's maker forecast a decline in annual revenue and profit. Procter & Gamble said it will cut 7000 jobs, or about 6.0 per cent of its workforce, over the next two years, as part of a restructuring. Shares of the consumer goods bellwether fell 1.3 per cent. Tesla fell 4.5 per cent, touching an over three-week low. The car maker's sales dropped for the fifth straight month in several European markets, data early this week has showed. Declining issues outnumbered advancers by a 1.08-to-1 ratio on the NYSE and by a 1.46-to-1 ratio on the Nasdaq. The S&P 500 posted 12 new 52-week highs and three new lows while the Nasdaq Composite recorded 37 new highs and 16 new lows. US stocks have dipped, dragged down by Tesla's shares, while investors looked ahead to the monthly jobs report to gauge the health of the labour market amid concerns of an economic slowdown. Chinese President Xi Jinping held talks with US President Donald Trump by phone, China's state-run news agency Xinhua reported, as bilateral relations have been strained by trade disputes. The call comes amid accusations between the US and China in recent weeks over critical minerals in a dispute that threatens to tear up a fragile truce in the trade war between the governments of the two biggest economies. Weaker-than-expected US private payrolls and services sector data on Wednesday raised concerns about the effects of Trump's erratic trade policies, with investors focusing squarely on Friday's non-farm payrolls report. Initial jobless claims data showed people in the US filing new applications for unemployment benefits last week rose for a second straight week. "I don't think it's some sort of big warning sign right now but it speaks to the fact that the labour market has been softening more and just getting gradually weaker," said Kevin Gordon, senior investment strategist at Charles Schwab. The jobs report comes ahead of the Federal Reserve's policy decision later this month, where policy makers are widely expected to hold interest rates. Despite continued calls from Trump to slash interest rates, Fed chair Jerome Powell has opted to stand pat so far, awaiting further data to help dictate the policy decision as tariff volatility prevails. US equities rallied sharply in May, with investors boosting the S&P 500 index and the tech-heavy Nasdaq to their biggest monthly percentage gain since November 2023, thanks to a softening of Trump's harsh trade stance and upbeat earnings reports. The S&P 500 remains nearly 3.0 per cent below record highs touched in February. US central bank officials including Fed Board governor Adriana Kugler, Fed Kansas City president Jeffrey Schmid and Fed Philadelphia president Patrick Harker are scheduled to speak later in the day. In early trading on Thursday, the Dow Jones Industrial Average fell 126.69 points, or 0.30 per cent, to 42,301.05, the S&P 500 lost 12.71 points, or 0.21 per cent, to 5,958.10 and the Nasdaq Composite lost 31.13 points, or 0.16 per cent, to 19,429.36. Eight of the 11 major S&P 500 sub-sectors fell, with consumer staples declining the most with an about 1.0 per cent fall. Brown-Forman fell 14.9 per cent, the most on the S&P 500, after the Jack Daniel's maker forecast a decline in annual revenue and profit. Procter & Gamble said it will cut 7000 jobs, or about 6.0 per cent of its workforce, over the next two years, as part of a restructuring. Shares of the consumer goods bellwether fell 1.3 per cent. Tesla fell 4.5 per cent, touching an over three-week low. The car maker's sales dropped for the fifth straight month in several European markets, data early this week has showed. Declining issues outnumbered advancers by a 1.08-to-1 ratio on the NYSE and by a 1.46-to-1 ratio on the Nasdaq. The S&P 500 posted 12 new 52-week highs and three new lows while the Nasdaq Composite recorded 37 new highs and 16 new lows. US stocks have dipped, dragged down by Tesla's shares, while investors looked ahead to the monthly jobs report to gauge the health of the labour market amid concerns of an economic slowdown. Chinese President Xi Jinping held talks with US President Donald Trump by phone, China's state-run news agency Xinhua reported, as bilateral relations have been strained by trade disputes. The call comes amid accusations between the US and China in recent weeks over critical minerals in a dispute that threatens to tear up a fragile truce in the trade war between the governments of the two biggest economies. Weaker-than-expected US private payrolls and services sector data on Wednesday raised concerns about the effects of Trump's erratic trade policies, with investors focusing squarely on Friday's non-farm payrolls report. Initial jobless claims data showed people in the US filing new applications for unemployment benefits last week rose for a second straight week. "I don't think it's some sort of big warning sign right now but it speaks to the fact that the labour market has been softening more and just getting gradually weaker," said Kevin Gordon, senior investment strategist at Charles Schwab. The jobs report comes ahead of the Federal Reserve's policy decision later this month, where policy makers are widely expected to hold interest rates. Despite continued calls from Trump to slash interest rates, Fed chair Jerome Powell has opted to stand pat so far, awaiting further data to help dictate the policy decision as tariff volatility prevails. US equities rallied sharply in May, with investors boosting the S&P 500 index and the tech-heavy Nasdaq to their biggest monthly percentage gain since November 2023, thanks to a softening of Trump's harsh trade stance and upbeat earnings reports. The S&P 500 remains nearly 3.0 per cent below record highs touched in February. US central bank officials including Fed Board governor Adriana Kugler, Fed Kansas City president Jeffrey Schmid and Fed Philadelphia president Patrick Harker are scheduled to speak later in the day. In early trading on Thursday, the Dow Jones Industrial Average fell 126.69 points, or 0.30 per cent, to 42,301.05, the S&P 500 lost 12.71 points, or 0.21 per cent, to 5,958.10 and the Nasdaq Composite lost 31.13 points, or 0.16 per cent, to 19,429.36. Eight of the 11 major S&P 500 sub-sectors fell, with consumer staples declining the most with an about 1.0 per cent fall. Brown-Forman fell 14.9 per cent, the most on the S&P 500, after the Jack Daniel's maker forecast a decline in annual revenue and profit. Procter & Gamble said it will cut 7000 jobs, or about 6.0 per cent of its workforce, over the next two years, as part of a restructuring. Shares of the consumer goods bellwether fell 1.3 per cent. Tesla fell 4.5 per cent, touching an over three-week low. The car maker's sales dropped for the fifth straight month in several European markets, data early this week has showed. Declining issues outnumbered advancers by a 1.08-to-1 ratio on the NYSE and by a 1.46-to-1 ratio on the Nasdaq. The S&P 500 posted 12 new 52-week highs and three new lows while the Nasdaq Composite recorded 37 new highs and 16 new lows. US stocks have dipped, dragged down by Tesla's shares, while investors looked ahead to the monthly jobs report to gauge the health of the labour market amid concerns of an economic slowdown. Chinese President Xi Jinping held talks with US President Donald Trump by phone, China's state-run news agency Xinhua reported, as bilateral relations have been strained by trade disputes. The call comes amid accusations between the US and China in recent weeks over critical minerals in a dispute that threatens to tear up a fragile truce in the trade war between the governments of the two biggest economies. Weaker-than-expected US private payrolls and services sector data on Wednesday raised concerns about the effects of Trump's erratic trade policies, with investors focusing squarely on Friday's non-farm payrolls report. Initial jobless claims data showed people in the US filing new applications for unemployment benefits last week rose for a second straight week. "I don't think it's some sort of big warning sign right now but it speaks to the fact that the labour market has been softening more and just getting gradually weaker," said Kevin Gordon, senior investment strategist at Charles Schwab. The jobs report comes ahead of the Federal Reserve's policy decision later this month, where policy makers are widely expected to hold interest rates. Despite continued calls from Trump to slash interest rates, Fed chair Jerome Powell has opted to stand pat so far, awaiting further data to help dictate the policy decision as tariff volatility prevails. US equities rallied sharply in May, with investors boosting the S&P 500 index and the tech-heavy Nasdaq to their biggest monthly percentage gain since November 2023, thanks to a softening of Trump's harsh trade stance and upbeat earnings reports. The S&P 500 remains nearly 3.0 per cent below record highs touched in February. US central bank officials including Fed Board governor Adriana Kugler, Fed Kansas City president Jeffrey Schmid and Fed Philadelphia president Patrick Harker are scheduled to speak later in the day. In early trading on Thursday, the Dow Jones Industrial Average fell 126.69 points, or 0.30 per cent, to 42,301.05, the S&P 500 lost 12.71 points, or 0.21 per cent, to 5,958.10 and the Nasdaq Composite lost 31.13 points, or 0.16 per cent, to 19,429.36. Eight of the 11 major S&P 500 sub-sectors fell, with consumer staples declining the most with an about 1.0 per cent fall. Brown-Forman fell 14.9 per cent, the most on the S&P 500, after the Jack Daniel's maker forecast a decline in annual revenue and profit. Procter & Gamble said it will cut 7000 jobs, or about 6.0 per cent of its workforce, over the next two years, as part of a restructuring. Shares of the consumer goods bellwether fell 1.3 per cent. Tesla fell 4.5 per cent, touching an over three-week low. The car maker's sales dropped for the fifth straight month in several European markets, data early this week has showed. Declining issues outnumbered advancers by a 1.08-to-1 ratio on the NYSE and by a 1.46-to-1 ratio on the Nasdaq. The S&P 500 posted 12 new 52-week highs and three new lows while the Nasdaq Composite recorded 37 new highs and 16 new lows.
