Official documents are quietly disappearing from departmental websites. Why?
George Orwell's
1984, Winston's job is making awkward documents and reports disappear down the 'memory hole': 'Day by day and almost minute by minute, the past was brought up to date. In this way every prediction made by the Party could be shown by documentary evidence to have been correct…'
The Irish Civil Service appears to be implementing the suitably Orwellian practice of 'unpublishing'. The past is being 'brought up to date' through the disappearance – deliberate or otherwise – of official documents from departmental websites.
Why? Could it be because they provide information that could be used to hold those departments (and their political masters) to account for failing to deliver their plans?
Last week, when writing here about the figures that show shocking numbers of Irish children going to bed hungry, I was looking for the research on food poverty commissioned by the Department of Social Protection in 2024. Under '
The Action Plan on Food Poverty and the associated research report are available
', the site said 'Item was unpublished or removed'.
READ MORE
That column was published last Tuesday. In the afternoon, I checked the site again and, remarkably the 'unpublished' bit had itself disappeared. The documents had been, to venture further into Newspeak, un-unpublished – in effect, restored.
This tells us that the availability or otherwise of public policy and research documents can be deliberately manipulated.
Shining a dim torch down the memory hole, here is a sample of purposefully disappeared evidence.
1. In 2017, the then minister for housing published a crucial online map showing, as the press release headlined, 'Over 2,000 hectares of land suitable for housing in State/semi-State ownership' with 'potential for up to 50,000 new-build homes on these lands'. The link now goes merely to the home page of the Housing for All website. There is no map of these sites.
2. That map was part of Rebuilding Ireland, the grand housing strategy published by the government in 2016. The redoubtable housing policy analyst Lorcan Sirr tells me: 'It looks like nearly all the Rebuilding Ireland policy information and documents have been taken down from the Department of Housing's website.'
3. The Department of Health's link to the
Project Ireland 2040
infrastructure plan, launched with great fanfare in 2019, now reads: '
Item was unpublished or removed
is the government's overarching policy initiative to make Ireland a better country for all of us, a country that reflects the best of who we are and what we aspire to be.'
Screenshot of the text which now greets readers.
4. The Department of Public Expenditure's announcement of updates to the same plan now reads: 'The Minister for Public Expenditure and Reform,
Michael McGrath
TD, has today launched an updated
Item was unpublished or removed
… This suite of material underlines the steady progress being made in the implementation of
Item was unpublished or removed
.'
Screenshot of the website text as now presented to the public.
5. The unveiling of the 2022 white paper on the transition to a decarbonised economy now tells us that the relevant ministers 'have launched the
Item was unpublished or removed
which was approved by Government today'.
6. The plug has been pulled on the Government's policy statement 'to ensure security of electricity supply to 2.4 million homes and businesses throughout Ireland', issued by Eamon Ryan in 2021. 'The Policy Statement can be accessed/viewed
Item was unpublished or removed'
.
7. The announcement of the then government's plan on artificial intelligence now says: 'The Minister for Trade Promotion, Digital and Company Regulation Dara Calleary today published the
Item was unpublished or removed
… A number of key achievements have been delivered so far including: delivering the
Item was unpublished or removed
in October 2022'.
8. The Department of Education's link to the Report of the Expert Group on Student Participation, launched by Norma Foley just last year, now reads: 'The full report and detail can be found at
Item was unpublished or removed'.
9. The announcement in 2021 of the Department of Health's plan to 'reduce levels of salt, sugar, saturated fats and calories in processed foods' was accompanied by a roadmap for implementation. It is now an announcement that the minister 'today launched
Item was unpublished or removed'.
10. The Department of the Environment's plan on cutting pollution from solid fuels now boasts that 'to reduce its effects, we introduced the
Item was unpublished or removed
in October 2022'.
11. The 'vision to make Shannon Estuary Region a renewable energy powerhouse', published by the Taoiseach and Tánaiste in 2022, has been washed away on the 'unpublished or removed' tide.
12. The name of the financial industry's lobby group that meets regularly with the Government to discuss its plans for the sector has been deleted. The lobby now meets 'on a quarterly basis with the
Item was unpublished or removed"
.
13. The public submissions on the implementation of the Lobbying Act in 2020 have gone down the memory hole: 'These submissions have been published and can be viewed at
Item was unpublished or removed
.'
14. The bioeconomy strategy on 'the production of renewable biological resources' has been un-published on the Department of Climate, Energy and Environment site.
15. As a piece de resistance, the public consultation on the review of the Freedom of Information (FOI) Act now informs us that 'For more details on the review process, the review roadmap is available at the following link:
Item was unpublished or removed'.
The range of departments engaged in this disappearing act strongly suggests it is not accidental. These documents are not secret. They could, presumably, all be accessed by using FOI – if you know exactly what you're looking for and can wait for weeks or months. Some can be found elsewhere online. And bear in mind that they represent thousands of hours of work by public servants themselves.
The function of the memory hole is to make it harder for citizens, civil society organisations, opposition politicians and journalists to hold ministers and senior civil servants to account for what they have and have not done. Every prediction made by the Party can be shown to have been correct.
Hashtags
Try Our AI Features
Explore what Daily8 AI can do for you:
Comments
No comments yet...
Related Articles
Irish Times
a minute ago
- Irish Times
Rose Conway-Walsh confirms Sinn Féin colleagues approached her on presidential run
Sinn Féin TD Rose Conway-Walsh has said the next president should be 'really up for the job' of reunifying the island of Ireland, adding that she was 'absolutely' that kind of person. Ms Conway-Walsh, who represents the Mayo constituency, confirmed she has been approached by people within her party, as reported by The Irish Times on Tuesday. She said it is an 'honour for anyone to be considered to be president of our country'. However, she declined to say whether she is willing to seek a nomination. Ms Conway-Walsh said she is very busy in her role as the party's spokeswoman on enterprise, tourism and employment. READ MORE In an interview with RTÉ's Drivetime, she declined to say whether she would consider running in the election . [ Sinn Féin mulls support for Catherine Connolly as it considers options for presidential election Opens in new window ] Outlining what qualities her party would seek, Ms Conway-Walsh said anyone Sinn Féin backs for the Áras must be a 'united Ireland' candidate. 'We have our own process going on. I don't think it's about individuals. [Sinn Féin] has done an extensive consultation within the party.' She said she sees the presidential role as 'absolutely key' and an important soft power. 'We are facing constitutional change in this country. We also need the voting franchise, presidential voting rights, to be extended to our citizens in the North. 'There is a serious role for a president here, and that's why we are giving it so much consideration within the party, and we will make the right decision at the end of the day.' [ The Irish Times view on the presidential race: contortions and expediency Opens in new window ] Ms Conway-Walsh said the person needs to be 'really up for the job of reunifying our country'. Asked whether she is that type of person, she said: 'Absolutely I am. I will always be that, whether I'm inside or outside politics.' 'I believe we should be in charge of our own affairs. I believe now the time is right for that. We saw the impacts of Brexit. We have seen the instability in the world. 'We have a wonderful island with wonderful people. We can be doing so much better. And I have a vision, regardless of what I do or in the future – I have a vision that we can make that happen to people, to make sure nobody is left behind.'
Irish Times
6 hours ago
- Irish Times
Ireland will be relieved at Trump's tariff cap on vital pharma sector
The publication of a joint agreed statement between the EU and US on the recent trade deal agreed in Scotland will be greeted with some relief in Dublin. It ties down some details of what was a woolly, political agreement – and for Ireland it gives a firm commitment to cap pharma tariffs at 15 per cent, while some parts of the sector may be excluded altogether. This removes the risk, for now at least, that US president Donald Trump would impose higher tariffs on pharma in the weeks ahead, or threaten them in future. This statement had been expected to issue a few days after the handshake between Trump and Ursula von der Leyen more than three weeks ago. The delay had led to fears of disagreement and details not being tied down. Now both sides have at least put things down on paper, even if there will be many months of negotiations ahead on various issues. The paragraphs on the pharma sector are important for Ireland, as it is a big employer, taxpayer and exporter. The EU had said after the deal was struck that its understanding was that pharma tariffs would be capped at 15 per cent, and that this included any that would be applied as part of a separate study being conducted by the US administration. READ MORE This is the so-called Section 232 study looking at national security issues in relation to pharma and also semiconductors. But comments by Trump that this study could lead to much higher tariffs on pharma in time raised fears that everyone was not on the one page. [ US agrees to cap tariffs on pharmaceuticals imports from EU at 15% Opens in new window ] Now the joint statement says that, taking into account this study, tariffs on pharma – and semiconductors – will not 'exceed 15 per cent'. At the moment pharma tariffs are zero and we will have to see when he publishes his Section 232 report whether Trump intends to apply the full 15 per cent rate to pharma coming from the EU immediately, or at some time in the future. A 15 per cent tariff is still high enough, if that is what emerges – but it is one which industry sources believe the sector can work with, albeit at a cost, given the high margin nature of much of its production. It will cause problems but not chaos. There is also another hopeful mention in the statement that generic drugs and their inputs and some chemicals may stay at a zero tariff – which would be a boost for parts of the industry here. The details of this have not been laid out in full and will be important. Beyond that, the section 232 process and Trump's attempts to push down drug prices in the US and persuade firms to move plans back to the US all have other potential implications for the sector here and for Ireland's efforts to attract pharma. The goal will be to remain as a trusted and safe supplier in US supply chains. In other sectors, the statement confirms the 15 per cent tariffs now in place and said the two sides will continue to talk about possible 'carveouts' – areas that will be excluded. Lobbies in sectors like spirits will continue to make their case. Tariffs at this levels will be a burden in general on exporters, though at least they know what they are dealing with. Whether the deal can now bed down remains a question – as does whether Trump will stick to it in the longer term. He has already torn up or ignored some previous deals in his trail of tariffs. But a joint agreed statement is a step in the right direction.
Irish Times
14 hours ago
- Irish Times
CIÉ group pensioners to get increase after 17 years
With unions in the CIÉ transport companies having this week backed long-discussed pension reforms in the group, it is now up to the Government to put in place measures that will allow retired workers to receive their first increase in about 17 years. Minister for Transport Darragh O'Brien on Monday welcomed the announcement by the CIÉ unions – the NBRU, Siptu, Connect, Unite and the TSSA – that members had backed changes, which had been negotiated with the company in May. There are two defined benefit schemes in the CIÉ group – the Regular Wages Scheme (RWS) and the 1951 Superannuation scheme. Members of the RWS backed the reforms by 74 per cent to 26 per cent. The result in the ballot of members of the 1951 scheme was tighter, with the changes being supported by 53 per cent to 47 per cent. READ MORE O'Brien said the decision 'prioritises the collective goal of bringing the CIÉ pensions schemes on to a more sustainable footing and provides for overdue increases for CIÉ pensioners'. However, the reforms will have to be backed by O'Brien as Minister for Transport and by Jack Chambers as Minister for Public Expenditure. O'Brien had earlier told CIÉ chief executive Lorcan O'Connor in a letter in July that if the deal was agreed then he would 'support and actively progress the process for the preparation and consideration of statutory instruments that are required to effect amendments to both schemes'. Unions are now likely to press ministers to introduce the necessary measures to allow the reforms come into effect within the next few months. There are about 6,400 retired CIÉ transport workers and they have been campaigning for years for a pension increase, citing the rising cost of living. However, the schemes' actuary did not believe that rises were affordable given deficits of about €370 million. The changes would see the existing two defined-benefit schemes closed to new members, who would be covered by a defined-contribution arrangement. Under the new proposals former staff who retired on or before December 31st, 2020, would receive a 5 per cent pension increase, with those who retired in 2021 getting 4 per cent, while those who retired in 2022 are in line for a 3 per cent rise. The deal would also allow staff covered by the 1951 scheme opt to cease paying contributions to the defined-benefit scheme once they reached maximum service and contribute instead to the new defined-contribution scheme. However, Chambers told Ged Nash of the Labour Party in a parliamentary answer in May that he did not intend to put in place similar arrangements for staff in the public service. 'There is no plan to amend the pre-existing public service pension scheme rules to allow for cessation of scheme membership and/or provision of a defined-contribution scheme for members who have attained 40 years' reckonable service', he said.
