
This Book on World War I Changed How I Think of Nonfiction
Paul Fussell, the historian and social critic, didn't think much of optimism — or optimists. Told to have a nice day, he'd respond: 'Thanks, but I have other plans.' He wasn't always such an ogre. But Fussell, who died in 2012, had what George Orwell called 'a power of facing unpleasant facts,' so much so that he took Orwell's phrase and, in a memorable 1988 essay, unpacked it like a baleful shaving kit:
Fussell did some of this killing himself. He served as a second lieutenant with the 103rd Infantry Division in France during World War II; at 20 he was gravely wounded and received a Bronze Star and a Purple Heart. His memoir about this experience, 'Doing Battle' (1996), is notably cleareyed and typically first-rate. Its subtitle — 'The Making of a Skeptic' — is crucial when considering anything this inimitable and lethally witty man ever wrote.
But the book that stands above the rest is Fussell's 'The Great War and Modern Memory' (1975), a bristling history of trench warfare on the Western Front during World War I, as seen through England's soldier-writers. It blends form and function to audacious effect, and is Fussell's greatest claim on posterity.
'The Great War and Modern Memory' turns 50 this year. It did not go unrecognized when it was published. It won a National Book Award and a National Book Critics Circle Award. In 1998, the Modern Library ranked it No. 75 on its list of the 100 best nonfiction books of the 20th century.
It now seems distressingly neglected. 'The Great War and Modern Memory' is worth a revisit, and a new generation of readers. I would slide it forward, like a runaway checkers stone, at least 30 places on the Modern Library's list, on writerly merit alone. It is filled with close and tragic perceptions, yet Fussell's sentences crunch like tanks snapping woodland into twigs.
I first read it when young, and it is one of two books — Jessica Mitford's 'The American Way of Death' was the other — that changed my idea of what nonfiction could be and ruined me for most other writers. If Fussell could write this intrepidly about war, and Mitford about death, topics that have lent themselves to more lugubrious prose than almost any others, I thought, why couldn't every nonfiction book — histories, biographies, memoirs — blend fact-finding with such high-stepping intellection, with such loathing for the bogus and with such literacy, glee and fury?
'Every war is ironic because every war is worse than expected,' Fussell writes. 'Every war constitutes an irony of situation because its means are so melodramatically disproportionate to its presumed ends.' He stretches mortal ironies until they shiver.
Robert Stone called the Vietnam War 'a mistake 10,000 miles long.' Fussell reminds us that the trenches dug by both sides during World War I stretched to about 25,000 miles, 'equal to a trench sufficient to circle the earth.' These furnaces of experience were 25,000 miles of muck and dung and blood.
Those back home, in the early years of the war, were assured that trenches were clean, well-lit and almost jolly places. Soldiers' subscriptions to newspapers, and to The Tatler and The Spectator, were not interrupted. The front lines were achingly close to London. An officer might breakfast in the trenches and, that evening, dine across the Channel at his club.
Even the fighting was made to feel matey — almost like a sporting match. Allied soldiers would sometimes dribble a soccer ball toward enemy lines, and preface their attacks with long, beautiful, arcing kicks.
'The Great War' is about the absolute loss of innocence that would follow. This war would be about squatting in filth, not about questing. First the corners were knocked off men's idealism, and then the foundations crumbled.
Fussell's book is humane because it pays such close attention to soldiers' experiences — to the more than eight million men who died because a single man, the Archduke Franz Ferdinand, had been shot. It is provocative because Fussell is such a determined foe of euphemism. Attentive people back home eventually learned, he writes, for example, that military reports of 'brisk fighting' or 'sharp retaliation' meant that 50 or more percent of a company had been killed or wounded.
Fussell singles out Thomas Hardy as the pioneer of modern English poetry because, in verse written before the war, he was 'the first to invite into poems the sound of ominous gunfire heard across the water.' He moves through the work of war poets, novelists and memoirists such as Siegfried Sassoon, Robert Graves and Edmund Blunden. Words meant more back then, before the arrival of cinema and television. Indeed, Fussell writes, 'Sometimes it is really hard to shake off the conviction that this war has been written by someone.'
He also takes in oral histories, newspaper headlines, letters and personal ads. 'The critic should read everything, all the time,' he wrote in a different book. He was an immense digester; he ate books alive; he was an intellectual who never sounded like an academic.
Modernism was still waiting in the wings. 'There was no 'Waste Land,' with its rats' alleys, dull canals and dead men who have lost their bones: It would take four years of trench warfare to being these to consciousness,' Fussell writes.
Fussell was born in Pasadena, Calif., in 1924. He was educated, before and after World War II, at Pomona College, and then Harvard. He married a fellow Pomona student, Betty Harper, who would become the perceptive food writer Betty Fussell. She wrote a classic memoir, 'My Kitchen Wars' (1999), about their lives together and, yikes, it was not altogether loving.
In 'The Great War and Modern Memory' Fussell analyzes how trench warfare led to widespread hysteria; he charts the spread of pernicious and long-lasting myths; he considers male beauty. Because low sun exposed troops by backlighting them, Fussell writes, in a typical observation: 'Dawn has never recovered from what the Great War did to it.'
Many fine books have been written about this war, including John Keegan's 'The First World War' and Barbara W. Tuchman's 'The Guns of August.' Fussell's book did not attempt to report on the entirety of the thing; he stuck to the trenches, to intense effect.
Eight million dead. Another horsefly of a writer, the art critic Robert Hughes, described some of the war's almost limitless damage this way: 'If you ask where is the Picasso of England or the Ezra Pound of France, there is only one probable answer: still in the trenches.'
Hashtags

Try Our AI Features
Explore what Daily8 AI can do for you:
Comments
No comments yet...
Related Articles


Chicago Tribune
10 hours ago
- Chicago Tribune
Today in History: James Earl Ray escapes from prison
Today is Tuesday, June 10, the 161st day of 2025. There are 204 days left in the year. Today in history: On June 10, 1977, James Earl Ray, the convicted assassin of civil rights leader Martin Luther King Jr., escaped from Brushy Mountain State Penitentiary in Tennessee with six others. He was recaptured three days later. Also on this date: In 1692, the first execution resulting from the Salem witch trials in Massachusetts took place as Bridget Bishop was hanged. In 1854, the U.S. Naval Academy held its first graduation ceremony. In 1940, Italian dictator Benito Mussolini declared war on France and Great Britain, formally entering Italy into World War II. In 1963, President John F. Kennedy signed into law the Equal Pay Act of 1963, aimed at eliminating wage disparities based on gender. In 1967, six days of war in the Mideast involving Israel, Syria, Egypt, Jordan and Iraq ended as Israel and Syria accepted a United Nations-mediated ceasefire. In 1978, racehorse Affirmed, ridden by Steve Cauthen, won the 110th Belmont Stakes to claim the 11th Triple Crown. Alydar, ridden by Jorge Velasquez, finished a close second in each of the Triple Crown races. In 1991, 11-year-old Jaycee Dugard of Meyers, California, was abducted by Phillip and Nancy Garrido; Dugard was held by the couple for 18 years before she was found by authorities. In 2018, the rover Opportunity sent its last message from the surface of Mars. Originally expected to serve a three-month mission, Opportunity functioned for over 14 years, traveling over 28 miles across Mars and unveiling critical discoveries about the planet's geology. In 2009, James von Brunn, an 88-year-old white supremacist, opened fire in the U.S. Holocaust Memorial Museum in Washington, D.C., killing security guard Stephen T. Johns. (Von Brunn died at a North Carolina hospital in January 2010 while awaiting trial.) In 2020, protesters pulled down a century-old statue of Confederate President Jefferson Davis in Richmond, Virginia, the former capital of the Confederacy. Today's Birthdays: Political commentator Jeff Greenfield is 82. Actor Frankie Faison is 76. Football Hall of Famer Dan Fouts is 74. Former Sen. John Edwards, D-N.C., is 72. Actor Gina Gershon is 63. Actor-model Elizabeth Hurley is 60. Comedian Bill Burr is 57. Alphabet CEO Sundar Pichai is 53. R&B singer Faith Evans is 52. Actor Hugh Dancy is 50. Country musician Lee Brice is 46. Actor Leelee Sobieski is 42. Olympic figure skating gold medalist Tara Lipinski is 43. Model Kate Upton is 33. Former first daughter Sasha Obama is 24.


Boston Globe
10 hours ago
- Boston Globe
Today in History: June 10, Opportunity rover sends last message from Mars
Advertisement In 1772, rebels in Rhode Island looted and set afire the HMS Gaspee in Narragansett Bay after the ship ran aground chasing smugglers. The defiant act was considered one of the sparks igniting the American Revolution. In 1775, 250 years ago, the Provincial Congress of Massachusetts set down guidelines for daily provisions for each soldier in the 'Massachusetts army.' Those include: 'One pound of bread : 2d. Half a pound of beef and half a pound of pork; and if pork cannot be had, one pound and a quarter of beef; and one day in seven they shall have one pound and one quarter of salt fish, instead of one day's allowance of meat : 3d. One pint of milk, or, if milk cannot be had, one gill of rice : 4th. One quart of good spruce or malt beer : 5th. One gill of peas or beans, or other sauce equivalent : 6th. Six ounces of good butter per week: 7th. One pound of good common soap for six men per week.' Advertisement In 1854, the Naval Academy held its first graduation ceremony. In 1906, the Mother Church of Christian Science was rededicated in Boston after an expansion tripled its seating capacity to 3,000. In 1940, Italian dictator Benito Mussolini declared war on France and Great Britain, formally entering Italy into World War II. In 1963, President John F. Kennedy signed into law the Equal Pay Act of 1963, aimed at eliminating wage disparities based on gender. In 1967, six days of war in the Mideast involving Israel, Syria, Egypt, Jordan, and Iraq ended as Israel and Syria accepted a United Nations-mediated cease-fire. In 1977, James Earl Ray, the convicted assassin of civil rights leader Martin Luther King Jr., escaped from Brushy Mountain State Penitentiary in Tennessee with six others. He was recaptured three days later. In 1978, racehorse Affirmed, ridden by Steve Cauthen, won the 110th Belmont Stakes to claim the 11th Triple Crown. Alydar, ridden by Jorge Velasquez, finished a close second in each of the Triple Crown races. In 1991, 11-year-old Jaycee Dugard of Meyers, Calif., was abducted by Phillip and Nancy Garrido; Dugard was held by the couple for 18 years before she was found by authorities. In 2009, James von Brunn, an 88-year-old white supremacist, opened fire in the US Holocaust Memorial Museum in Washington, D.C., killing security guard Stephen T. Johns. (Von Brunn died at a North Carolina hospital in January 2010 while awaiting trial.) Advertisement In 2018, the rover Opportunity sent its last message from the surface of Mars. Originally expected to serve a three-month mission, Opportunity functioned for over 14 years, traveling over 28 miles across Mars and unveiling critical discoveries about the planet's geology. In 2019, former Red Sox star David Ortiz flew to Boston for medical care; he'd undergone surgery in his native Dominican Republic after an ambush by a gunman at a bar. In 2020, protesters pulled down a century-old statue of Confederate President Jefferson Davis in Richmond, Va., the former capital of the Confederacy.
Yahoo
12 hours ago
- Yahoo
World War II veteran identified and buried 81 years after being killed in action
GRAVETTE, Ark. (KNWA/KFTA) — Eighty-one years after being killed in action during the D-Day Invasion of Normandy, Private Rodger Andrews was buried at Bethel Cemetery in his hometown of Gravette. Pvt. Andrews was in the 37th Engineer Combat Battalion during World War II. According to the Defense POW/MIA Accounting Agency, Andrews and the other engineers in the Battalion were tasked with clearing German defenses and setting up routes off the beach to allow the Allied soldiers to fight further inland in France. During the battle, Andrews died on Omaha Beach, although his exact cause of death is still uncertain. 'From what we understand, he made it out of the landing craft. He made it all the way across the beach,' said Chaplain Colonel Jeremy Miller, who presided over the memorial, 'He made it to the to the edge of the wall where his team was charged with breaching that wall so that thousands of Americans could follow through to really bring the allied forces ashore into France.' Bentonville Book Bus kicks off Summer Tour, encouraging students to read during the summer In June 2024, Pvt. Andrews' remains were identified with the help of a cheek swab submitted by his nephew, Russ Yates, a few years prior. Yates also said that the military and his family had been in contact for years, trying to find Pvt. Andrews. 'The military, I want to commend them. One hundred percent,' said Yates, 'Like the chaplain said, no one goes missing. We work until we find them.' Yates said when the U.S. military asked where he wanted Pvt. Andrews to be buried, he chose Bethel Cemetery, where Andrews' parents and sister are also buried. Community members from Gravette gathered for Pvt. Andrews' memorial. Both Yates and Col. Miller said they were happy to see the turnout. 'There were so many people from not only the community, there were a lot of people who traveled in for this and it wasn't so that they could be seen. It was so that they could pay respects, so that they could bring honor,' said Col. Miller, 'That's what makes me proud to be an American, when we get to see things like that.' Copyright 2025 Nexstar Media, Inc. All rights reserved. This material may not be published, broadcast, rewritten, or redistributed.