Man lost 2 decades of life in prison due to GA cops faking evidence, suit says
Joseph 'Joey' Watkins lost two decades of his life in the Georgia prison system because police faked evidence against him and teamed up with two Georgia Bureau of Investigation employees to convince jurors he was guilty of murder, according to a federal lawsuit he filed.
When Watkins' murder conviction was thrown out by a September 2023 court order that affirmed his innocence, he 'had lived more than half his life in prison for a crime he did not commit,' his lawsuit filed May 30 says.
His exoneration was secured after Watkins, his parents and the Georgia Innocence Project fought to overturn his conviction for years.
Though Watkins had first been ruled out as a suspect in the killing of 20-year-old Isaac Dawkins, who was shot in the head while driving on a highway in Rome in 2000, he was pursued by Floyd County police and investigators with the Georgia Bureau of Investigation, according to his complaint. Rome is about a 70-mile drive northwest from Atlanta.
Officers from both agencies collaborated to hide evidence that would've shown Watkins was innocent and gave false testimonies at trial, the filing says.
The complaint includes Watkins' post-conviction statement to the court on July 1, 2001, when he declared: 'I am not a murderer. … I will be back in court because I am not guilty of this.'
'They can send me to prison, but I just want the family to know that justice has not been done,' Watkins said. 'I had nothing to do with this, and I will say it till the day I die.'
Now living freely in Floyd County, Watkins is suing over his wrongful imprisonment on five federal causes of action, including 14th Amendment violations. His lawsuit names Floyd County, three county police officers, the estate of a fourth officer who died in 2023, and two GBI employees, a special agent and a forensic analyst.
The county and its police chief, Mark Wallace, didn't return McClatchy News' requests for comment June 5.
GBI's public affairs director, Nelly Miles, declined McClatchy News' request for comment because of the pending litigation.
Watkins is represented by attorneys with Pfeiffer Rudolf, a Charlotte, North Carolina-based law firm that specializes in wrongful conviction cases, and attorney Henry C. Debardeleben, of Weinberg, Wheeler, Hudgins, Gunn & Dial LLC in Atlanta.
Attorney Sonya Pfeiffer, of Pfeiffer Rudolf, said in a statement to McClatchy News that 'since his release, and as recently as the past two months, Joey Watkins has been publicly and unjustly attacked despite his innocence.'
'The citizens of Floyd County, including the family of Isaac Dawkins, deserve to know the truth,' Pfeiffer said, adding that they intend to prove all facts made by the complaint.
Watkins' constitutional claims against the defendants include:
Concealment of exculpatory evidence Knowing and/or reckless use of false evidenceUnreasonable seizure and malicious prosecutionA municipal liability claimClaim for suppression of exculpatory evidence and deprivation of effective access to courts in violation of the First and Fourteenth amendments
'Worst prisons in Georgia'
After Watkins' conviction, he sought a hearing to argue his innocence, but Floyd County police and GBI investigators continued to hide the truth, preventing his claim from being heard, the complaint says.
He was then sentenced to life in prison, according to the complaint.
Watkins, who was 20 years old at sentencing, told The Associated Press in September 2023 after his exoneration that he 'cried like a baby … just knowing that it was finally finished, finally over.'
The efforts to hold Watkins responsible in Dawkins' killing, despite data from his cellphone that showed he wasn't in the area, led to his incarceration 'at some of the worst prisons in Georgia,' the complaint says.
A group of inmates trying to steal from him broke Watkins' nose and front tooth in 2002 at Phillips State Prison 'when he resisted,' according to the filing.
Throughout his incarceration, he faced further violence from inmates, resulting in a 'severe hernia in late 2005,' the complaint says.
The medical care available in prison was lacking, according to the filing, which says Watkins 'had to live with the excruciating pain and persistent discomfort from that hernia until he was finally allowed to have surgery in 2016.'
Watkins' wrongful imprisonment ended when he was released on bond in January 2023, before the case against him was dismissed months later,, according to the complaint.
'By the time he was set free, Watkins's parents were shells of their former selves,' the complaint says. 'Both were and remain in declining health and are broken financially after years of championing their son's cause and paying tens of thousands of dollars in attorneys' fees in efforts to prove their son's innocence and wrongful conviction.'
Watkins demands a jury trial and seeks an unspecified amount in compensatory and punitive damages.
He's asking the court for punitive damages that will 'deter such conduct by Defendants and other officials and law enforcement officers in the future,' the complaint says.
Try Our AI Features
Explore what Daily8 AI can do for you:
Comments
No comments yet...
Related Articles
American Military News
6 hours ago
- American Military News
Soldier killed pregnant wife with machete, dismembered her in HI, officials say
A soldier stationed in Hawaii admitted to killing and dismembering his pregnant wife in July 2024, Army officials said. Pfc. Dewayne Arthur Johnson II pleaded guilty during a court-martial in Hawaii to voluntary manslaughter and other charges in connection with the deaths of his wife, Mischa Johnson, and unborn child, according to a June 5 news release from the Army. Pfc. Johnson was ordered by a military judge to serve 23 years behind bars, which is the maximum, officials said. The 29-year-old also is to be reduced in rank and dishonorably discharged, according to officials. Mischa Johnson was six months pregnant when she was reported missing last summer from Oahu's Schofield Barracks, McClatchy News previously reported. In February, the Army Office of Special Trial Counsel referred several charges and specifications against Pfc. Johnson, according to a news release at the time. That meant he was headed toward a military trial. Under his plea agreement, the cavalry scout 'admitted to killing his wife and unborn child in the heat of passion by striking (his wife) in the head with a machete,' officials said. The couple had been fighting, 'and then things escalated to violence,' according to officials. Pfc. Johnson 'also provided specific details of his actions following their deaths, to include dismembering the bodies with a chainsaw and then using his car to transport the remains to a dumpster on Schofield Barracks,' according to officials. The remains 'have never been found and are presumed to have been transported to the island's trash incinerator,' officials said. Pfc. Johnson reported his wife missing about two weeks after he killed her, officials said, 'and (he) even participated with community search parties that spanned the island to look for her.' He was linked to the killing through DNA, blood and other evidence in their home, according to officials. Pfc. Johnson apologized during court proceedings, saying, 'My wife didn't deserve that. She wasn't trash,' Hawaii News Now reported. He also said that, 'I failed as a husband. I failed as a father and I failed as a man. … I'll forever be sorry,' per the outlet. Pfc. Johnson will serve his prison time at the U.S. Disciplinary Barracks at Fort Leavenworth in Kansas, officials said. ___ © 2025 The Olympian Distributed by Tribune Content Agency, LLC.
Miami Herald
6 hours ago
- Miami Herald
Mom and kids abducted by man working for cartel, feds say. He's convicted in MT
A man accused of trafficking drugs for a Mexican cartel was convicted of federal kidnapping charges after prosecutors said he abducted a mother and her two daughters, taking them to several U.S. states before Mexico, where he 'locked them in' a home and abused them. Roughly six years later, in 2023, Adolfo Vargas Lepe kidnapped another woman he knew for years from her Wyoming home and took her to Montana, where he used to live, according to the U.S. Attorney's Office for the District of Montana. Now, a federal jury in Billings has found Lepe guilty of three counts of kidnapping and one count of making an interstate threat after a three-day trial, the U.S. Attorney's Office said in a June 5 news release. 'Lepe traumatized his kidnapping victims, including physically and sexually assaulting them, shooting one of them, and transporting them around the United States and into Mexico,' U.S. Attorney Kurt Alme said in a statement. 'While engaged in that conduct, he also distributed methamphetamine, fentanyl, and cocaine in communities in Montana and elsewhere,' Alme added. Attorneys appointed by the court to represent Lepe, who used to live in Roberts, didn't immediately return McClatchy News' request for comment June 6. Roberts is about a 220-mile drive southeast from Helena, Montana's capital. On June 4, Lepe's trial ended with the jury finding him not guilty of kidnapping the mother of the two girls, but guilty of kidnapping her daughters, one of whom he's accused of sexually assaulting, and the other woman, court records show. Lepe began dating the mother of the two girls in 2017, before Lepe revealed 'he transported drugs for the cartel' after she found 'a significant amount of methamphetamine,' prosecutors wrote in court filings. Afterward, prosecutors said he kidnapped the family, took them to multiple states, then confined them to a Mexico residence. Lepe wouldn't let the woman 'leave his sight because of her knowledge of his drug trafficking,' according to prosecutors, who said he 'threatened to kill her and have cartel members kill her family.' The woman was repeatedly beaten and threatened with a gun by Lepe, the U.S. Attorney's Office said. The other woman he kidnapped in 2023 was also beaten and abused, including by Lepe pistol-whipping her and shooting her in the legs, according to prosecutors. He also 'imprisoned her in a dog kennel for hours on end' and 'beat her with bats and metal bars,' prosecutors wrote in court filings. The woman managed to escape Lepe by fleeing his home, to a local bar to alert the police, according to prosecutors. Before making it to the bar, prosecutors said she hid for hours in dirt located behind bushes. He was spotted driving two days later by Carbon County Sheriff's deputies, who were led on a 'high-speed chase' by Lepe until his truck rolled over and he was taken into custody, according to the U.S. Attorney's Office. Later, an investigation resulted in authorities finding narcotics linked to Lepe, including 'one pound of cocaine and two pounds of meth' and '12.5 pounds of meth and roughly 10,000 fentanyl pills,' prosecutors said. Lepe, who's facing life in prison, is scheduled to be sentenced on Oct. 2, according to the U.S. Attorney's Office.
Miami Herald
9 hours ago
- Miami Herald
Boss told cops to ‘keep an eye on' Muslim worker during prayer, MN suit says
A former employee of a Minnesota transportation agency said religious discrimination and retaliation forced him to leave his job, according to a lawsuit. The complaint — filed June 3 on behalf of Jihad Hamoud, a practicing Muslim — accuses regional planning agency Met Council of disciplining and humiliating him. It says that came after he reported faith-based discrimination, including one occasion where a supervisor directed police to 'keep an eye on' him while he prayed. A spokesperson for Met Council in Saint Paul told McClatchy News in a June 6 email they do not comment on ongoing litigation. 'With its power and resources, Met Council should be setting the standard for what an inclusive and respectful workplace looks like,' Naomi Martin, Hamoud's attorney, said in a June 5 news release. 'That starts with ensuring discrimination and retaliation have no place in its operations — especially by those in supervisory roles.' The lawsuit comes as the state of Minnesota continues to see increases in instances of anti-Muslim hate, attorneys said. Religious discrimination experiences According to the complaint, Hamoud was hired as a bus operator at the agency in 2010 and then transferred to facilities maintenance in 2019. He began recording his experiences after attorneys said he watched a Muslim co-worker experience retaliation by his supervisor. A supervisor made a negative comment directed at Muslim workers, blaming them for making a bathroom dirty during their prayer time, according to the complaint. When Hamoud told his supervisor Muslims are not allowed to pray in restrooms, he didn't apologize or correct his assumption, the complaint said. Hamoud also recorded multiple instances of discrimination with one janitor, according to the complaint. After reporting his experiences, Hamoud was placed on administrative leave, but the janitor continued working, attorneys said. Then, his managers told him to avoid the janitor when he got back to work, according to the complaint. But when Hamoud passed the janitor in a vehicle driven by another worker, his managers accused him of trying to intimidate the janitor, the complaint said. He was then told in a meeting with managers he would be placed on unpaid leave for five days, attorneys said. When he asked why he was being placed on leave, the managers did not say, according to the complaint. Hamoud was then escorted out of the office building by police, according to the complaint. 'This caused Hamoud great emotional distress, including feeling fearful, embarrassed, degraded, humiliated, disrespected, vilified, and discriminated against,' attorneys said. Despite ongoing emails to Met Council leadership after returning to work and continuing to experience religious discrimination, the agency didn't do anything to address it, according to the complaint. Hamoud resigned in May 2022 and filed a discrimination charge against the agency with the Minnesota Department of Human Rights, according to the complaint. The commissioner concluded there was probable cause of retaliation and discrimination against Hamoud twice, in November and January, attorneys said. The complaint asks for monetary compensation for 'lost earnings and benefits, emotional distress, embarrassment, humiliation, and other compensatory damages.' Anti-Muslim discrimination in Minnesota For the past three years, Minnesota has led the country in reported attacks against mosques, according to a report by the Council on American-Islamic Relations. There were 15 recorded incidents targeting mosques in the state in 2024, three times higher than the next highest state for reported attacks, according to the report. Several acts of vandalism, intimidation and discrimination were also reported in the state, the report said.
