logo
What we know about the secret Afghan relocation scheme

What we know about the secret Afghan relocation scheme

The Guardian15-07-2025
Details have emerged for the first time of an enormous accidental data breach by a British official in 2022 that put 100,000 Afghans at risk of torture and death, and the huge efforts by successive governments to keep the blunder secret, citing the risk of Taliban reprisals.
Thousands of Afghan people – some of whom had worked with British forces in the country – have been secretly relocated to the UK as a direct result of the leak, at an additional cost of more than £850m.
The breach has been subject to a superinjunction since August 2023, meaning journalists were banned from disclosing anything about it – or even the fact that an injunction existed.
The superinjunction, which is the first ever requested by a British government and the longest in history, was lifted by the high court on Tuesday, which is why details of the leak and response can now be revealed.
The leak in February 2022 was the result of an error by a defence official, who had been tasked with verifying applications to the Afghanistan Resettlement and Assistance Policy (Arap) resettlement scheme, designed for Afghans who had worked for British forces in the country.
Working outside authorised government systems, he contacted a number of Afghans in the UK, believing he was sending a list of 150 names. Instead, he had emailed a copy of the entire list of applicants, from where it was passed on to others in Afghanistan.
The Times reported the official was a British soldier based at Regent's Park barracks, the headquarters of the UK special forces.
The leaked dataset contained the personal details of 18,800 individuals who were applying for resettlement along with their family members, including their phone numbers and in some cases addresses, amounting to 33,000 lines of data. Some emails of British government officials were also disclosed.
It was discovered in August 2023 by an activist who was helping Afghans who had worked for UK forces. One of her contacts alerted her in alarm saying that an anonymous member of a Facebook group had said he had the database and was threatening to post it in full.
She immediately contacted the MoD, saying: 'The Taliban may now have a 33,000-long kill list – essentially provided to them by the British government. If any of these families are murdered, the government will be liable.' The discovery was 'simply bone-chilling', she wrote.
The realisation sparked panic in Whitehall, and an immediate hunt for the source of the leak. At the same time, UK officials contacted 1,800 Arap applicants in Pakistan warning them that they might be in danger.
The MoD asked Facebook to remove the post, citing the 'risk of physical harm'. It then launched a top secret initiative, named Operation Rubific, to secretly evacuate to the UK those deemed most at risk of Taliban assassination – although tens of thousands would be left behind.
After a number of journalists became aware of the leak within days of its disclosure to the MoD, Ben Wallace, then the defence secretary, asked the high court for an order banning any mention of the breach.
On 1 September 2023 the judge Mr Justice Knowles granted a three-month
superinjunction 'against the world', rather than named individuals, the first of its kind. Another judge extended it the following February, saying there was a 'real possibility that it is serving to protect' those named in the leaked database.
However he cautioned: 'What is clear is that the government has decided to offer help to only a very small proportion of those whose lives have been endangered by the data incident and that the decisions in this regard are being taken without any opportunity for scrutiny through the media or in parliament.'
The injuction was later extended further, despite challenges from four media organisations. The government cited concerns of retribution from the Taliban against those named.
In December 2023 a covert new scheme called the Afghanistan Response Route (ARR), was set up to evacuate to the UK some individuals on the list who were ineligible for Arap. Though it was initially set up to resettle around 200 'principals' and their families, to date 900 individuals and 3,600 family members have been brought to Britain or are in transit via ARR, at a cost of £400m.
Taking into account the wider schemes, other official figures show that so far the government has relocated 35,245 Afghans to Britain, of whom 16,156 were among those affected by the data leak.
The present defence minister, John Healey, had been briefed on the leak while in opposition, but said on Tuesday that other cabinet members had only become aware of the situation after Labour was elected to government in July 2024.
On taking office he 'began straightway to take a hard look at the policy complexities, costs, risks, court hearings and the range of Afghan relocation schemes being run across government', he told parliament on Tuesday.
In January, he commissioned a former senior civil servant, Paul Rimmer, to conduct an independent review. He concluded that, nearly four years into Taliban rule of Afghanistan, the leaked data 'may not have spread nearly as widely as initially feared', and 'there is little evidence of intent by the Taliban to conduct a campaign of retribution' against those on the leaked list.
The review concluded that the ARR scheme 'may now be disproportionate to the actual impact of the data loss'.
As a result, the government told the high court on Tuesday that the superinjunction should be discontinued. In his ruling, Mr Justice Chamberlain described the cost of the plans as amounting to 'the sort of money which makes a material difference to government spending plans and is normally the stuff of political debate'.
The ARR has now closed, Healey told MPs, although he said 600 'invitations' that had already been granted to individuals and their families would be honoured. 'When this nation makes a promise, we should keep it,' he said.
He also offered 'a sincere apology on behalf of the British government', which was echoed by the Conservative shadow defence minister, James Cartlidge.
MoD figures published on Tuesday show that across several Afghan resettlement schemes, the numbers of those who have already come to the UK and those who have not yet travelled total 56,100 people, including family members.
The estimated total cost of all resettlement schemes is now £5.5-6bn. The covert ARR scheme set up specifically in response to the leak is expected to cost £850m.
Orange background

Try Our AI Features

Explore what Daily8 AI can do for you:

Comments

No comments yet...

Related Articles

Coatbridge political titan Sir Tom Clarke pulls no punches with reflective autobiography
Coatbridge political titan Sir Tom Clarke pulls no punches with reflective autobiography

Daily Record

timea minute ago

  • Daily Record

Coatbridge political titan Sir Tom Clarke pulls no punches with reflective autobiography

Memoir 'To Be Honest... Tom Clarke: The Story of My Life' follows Sir Tom's journey from young lad born in Coatbridge to his more than three decades in politics. In typically selfless fashion Sir Tom Clarke says he "will leave it up to the readers to decide" on the impact of his much-anticipated autobiography as the former Coatbridge political titan looks back on his remarkable life. ‌ The 84-year-old has unveiled his memoir To Be Honest... Tom Clarke: The Story of My Life - and pulls no punches when reflecting on his time in politics.. ‌ Sir Tom, who was a Member of Parliament from 1982 until 2015, pays repeated tributes to his home town throughout the book, beginning with a page devoted to the line "To the people of Coatbridge - the town that forged me and that I love so well". ‌ The autobiography's infancy came when then-MP Sir Tom lost his Coatbridge, Bellshill & Chryston seat in the May 2015 general election - a difficult moment he doesn't shy away from in the book. Sir Tom explained: "The book was suggested to me the day after the 2015 election and a couple of weeks later I was in Italy, where I wrote out an agenda and planned what to write. ‌ "But I was then plagued by several knee operations - eight in total - for several years which delayed the book's publication. "I've worked hard the past few years to get it written and teamed up with editor Neil Baxter. "Neil was well know in architectural circles and is a very good writer who has penned several books. ‌ "I often saw him on TV and heard him on radio and knew he was extremely gifted. "It's not easy to get a Scottish publisher so I was blessed by teaming up with Neil because as well as being an editor, he is part of the Baxter Jardine publishing company." Sir Tom added: "The book was all originally written by me and I adapted parts with Neil. ‌ "When I finished the first draft we discussed changes which ended up improving the book and it was ready for publication in June. "The presentation is lovely and everyone involved did a brilliant job putting the book together. "I am happy with the finished product but I will leave it up to the readers to decide what they think of it." ‌ Coatbridge comic-book and movie mogul Mark Millar wrote one of the book's two prefaces - with broadcaster Bernard Ponsonby penning the other. To Be Honest... Tom Clarke: The Story of My Life follows Sir Tom's journey from young lad born in Coatbridge to his more than three decades in politics, which included championing the rights of disabled people, visiting Iran to negotiate the release of British and Irish hostages and becoming Minister of State for Film and Tourism. ‌ He also doesn't hold anything back while criticising ex-Prime Minister Tony Blair, who he once called his "best friend", and former Scottish first minister Donald Dewar. Sir Tom, who was also honoured as a Papal Knight by Pope Francis in 2016, told Lanarkshire Live: "I was best friends with Tony Blair for the first 10 years in Parliament and I expected to be in his first Cabinet when he became Prime Minister. "The book goes into my thoughts on how things played out and how I felt Tony let me down badly. ‌ "But it was also important to me to reflect on things like my time as the Minister of State for Film and with the Scottish Film Council as I have always been passionate about film, which not everyone may be aware of. Sir Tom, knighted in the Queen's new year honours list in late 2020 for "public and political service"., went on to explain the choice of title for his autobiography: "I often listen to the radio in the morning and heard lots of people saying 'to be honest'. ‌ "I thought, 'why are they saying that?' Maybe they are thinking 'people won't expect me to say that'. "That's when it struck me to go with that as the title and put things on record as honestly as I can recall them. "It's also a hint at questioning the honesty of others I've had to deal with. ‌ "In the book I have said where I think I got things wrong; I've not been perfect by any means. "It's sometimes interesting to reflect back on things, and your judgement of people becomes very important." Sir Tom has worked with several charities and local organisations and made the kind-hearted decision to donate all proceeds from To Be Honest... Tom Clarke: The Story of My Life to the Moira Anderson Foundation and Coatbridge Citizens Advice Bureau (CAB). ‌ He added: "After the election defeat in 2015 I was approached by the outgoing chair of Coatbridge CAB to take on the role, which I did, for six years. "I saw first hand how a lot of the bureau's manager's time was spent fundraising and when I stepped down as chair, I told them half of the profits from my book would go to them. ‌ "I planted a tree at the Moira Anderson Foundation earlier this year to mark the charity's 25th anniversary. "I told the Foundation's founder, Sandra Brown, about my book and we had a very interesting conversation as she has also written a book - and what a wonderful book it is. "It's a charity that does invaluable work and it is my pleasure to donate half of the book's proceeds to the Foundation team."

Moment Brit comedian 'accidentally shoplifts' seen on CCTV before she's arrested
Moment Brit comedian 'accidentally shoplifts' seen on CCTV before she's arrested

Daily Mirror

timea minute ago

  • Daily Mirror

Moment Brit comedian 'accidentally shoplifts' seen on CCTV before she's arrested

Cerys Nelmes, a stand-up comic from Bristol, claims that she accidentally walked out of a Zara shop in Turkey without paying for her items - but quickly returned after realising her error This is the moment a British comedian leaves a Zara shop without paying - before she's arrested. ‌ Cerys Nelmes is facing three years behind bars after being accused of stealing clothes from a branch of Zara in Istanbul, Turkey on July 22. Mum-of-one Cerys, from Bristol, has been banned from leaving the country while police investigate the store's claims. ‌ Footage shows Cerys wearing a blue dress as she browses around the shop with an armful of clothes on hangers and other items in her backpack. Later footage shows her leaving the store clearly distracted by her phone and, according to her, forgetting that there were items in her white backpack she hadn't paid for. ‌ She is then seen standing just outside the shop, still on her phone, as a Zara staff member walks over and asks her and another woman to go back inside before the police were called, NewsX report. Cerys says she returned to the store without argument over the forgotten 6,000 lira (£110)-worth of clothing still in her backpack. But she told her social media followers she was then detained and locked in a room for hours with no explanation. ‌ From there, she was taken to a police station and said she was pressured to sign documents in a language she could not read. She was released on probation by a judge after 24 hours in a holding cell, allegedly with no food, water or loo. She has since been released but has been forbidden from leaving the country and is being put up by a local family as she does not have the money for an extended stay. The police investigation is ongoing. "I was told they didn't understand me," said Nelmes. The next day, she was brought before a judge who released her but banned her from leaving the country. She now faces a potential three-year sentence as the case proceeds. ‌ Ms Nelmes says she is stranded in Turkey, unable to afford accommodation and missing out on work back home, putting her and her son at risk of losing their UK home. She said: "I'm ok and have been taken in by a Turkish family who gave me food and a bed. I don't deserve all the kind words from people but I am very grateful." On her website it states of her career: "Cerys has worked very hard to forge a strong career in the comedy industry. She is a leading mc on the comedy circuit, working for major UK clubs and UK charity events. Cerys has a fantastic stage presence and her audience interaction is flawless." ‌ Recounting what happened, she said that she had left the store with several items of clothing before realising her error. Despite returning to the store, claiming she had returned the items and wanted to pay, Nelmes was seized for shoplifting. The stand-up, explained the incident in a social media post saying: "On Tuesday I left a Zara store in Istanbul without paying for items. "I returned straight away and handed the items to staff. I was asked to pay and I said I would and the manager accepted this. To cut a long story short I was then taken to a locked room where hours later after no communication from anyone I was taken away by police and held in a police station and was asked to sign things I couldn't read. "I was put in a prison cell for 24 hours with no food or toilet facilities. When I asked for water, I was told they didn't understand me. I was handcuffed and taken for fingerprints and mugshots at 3am. I was handcuffed and taken to court the following day and put in a cell. "I appeared before the judge and was told by a translator that I was released, but unable to leave Turkey for an undetermined amount of time. He said I was lucky to not be put in prison but I currently face up to three years. I have to report to a local police station every Monday. "I am lucky I have good friends in Turkey who are currently looking after me, and trying to translate the paperwork. I have no money, no earnings coming in from home, and I am running out of important medication. I will lose my home which I share with my son, and livelihood. "I am not looking for sympathy. I made a mistake which I tried to immediately rectify. I am embarrassed for my friends, my family, and I have made my 78-year-old mum unwell. I will never forgive myself for what I have done."

Starmer convenes Cabinet for urgent meeting on Gaza
Starmer convenes Cabinet for urgent meeting on Gaza

South Wales Guardian

time30 minutes ago

  • South Wales Guardian

Starmer convenes Cabinet for urgent meeting on Gaza

It comes as the Prime Minister faces renewed pressure to recognise Palestine as a state immediately and after he held an emergency call with France and Germany at the weekend. The Prime Minister is focusing on securing aid for those on the ground and a 'sustainable route' to a two-state solution, Downing Street has said, and emphasised that the UK recognising Palestine was a matter of 'when, not if'. Sir Keir has started working with France and Germany on a process to 'bring about a lasting peace' in the Middle East and shared the plans with US President Donald Trump when they met in Scotland on Monday. He is expected to share details with Arab states and other key allies in the coming days. The Cabinet meeting, which some ministers are attending in person and others virtually, comes after Parliament broke for its summer recess last week. Pro-Palestine protesters gathered outside Downing Street as the meeting took place. Four people wearing white headdresses posed solemnly above what appeared to be a model shrouded corpse and crowd of people gathered banging pans with spoons, many of them wearing keffiyehs and carrying Palestinian flags. A metres-long banner was held in front of the black gates in Whitehall reading 'genocide in Gaza' and 'death from famine and disease'. Speaking on Tuesday morning, Technology Secretary Peter Kyle said he would not 'pre-empt' the meeting, but added it was 'right' to 'assess what Britain can do' to ease the situation in Gaza. He also said the Palestinian people should be 'rewarded for what they've been through' and given the tools 'to move them towards the kind of peace, stability and dignity that every citizen in every country is owed'. Amid international alarm over starvation in Gaza, Israel announced at the weekend that it would suspend fighting in three areas for 10 hours a day and open secure routes for aid delivery. The UK confirmed it was taking part in airdrops of aid into the territory. Aid agencies have welcomed the new measures but said they were not enough to counter the rising hunger in the Palestinian territory. Sir Keir said that the British public is 'revolted' at the scenes of desperation in Gaza as he appeared alongside Mr Trump at his Turnberry golf course on Monday. The US president hinted at sticking points in US-led negotiations over a peace deal, saying Palestinian militant group Hamas had become 'very difficult to deal with' in recent weeks. He suggested this was because they held only a small remaining number of Israeli hostages. Sir Keir's official spokesman said on Monday: 'This week, the Prime Minister is focused on a pathway to peace to ensure immediate relief for those on the ground, and a sustainable route to a two-state solution. 'We are clear that the recognition of the Palestinian state is a matter of when, not if, but it must be one of the steps on the path to a two-state solution as part of a wider plan that delivers lasting security for both Palestinians and Israelis.' Sir Keir has likened the plan he is working on with France and Germany to the coalition of the willing, the international effort to support Ukraine towards a lasting peace. His spokesman said the plan would build 'on the collaboration to date that paves the way to a long-term solution on security in the region'. Sir Keir is meanwhile facing calls from a growing number of MPs to recognise a Palestinian state immediately. More than 250 cross-party MPs have now signed a letter calling for ministers to take the step, up from 221 on Friday. Business Secretary Jonathan Reynolds on Monday dismissed the idea that there is a split at the top of Government over when to recognise a Palestinian state, saying 'we all want it to happen'. Health Secretary Wes Streeting is among those to have signalled a desire for hastened action, calling for recognition 'while there's still a state of Palestine left to recognise', while Justice Secretary Shabana Mahmood said the Government wants to recognise a Palestinian state 'in contribution to a peace process'.

DOWNLOAD THE APP

Get Started Now: Download the App

Ready to dive into a world of global content with local flavor? Download Daily8 app today from your preferred app store and start exploring.
app-storeplay-store